Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** P3 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 P3 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll

*** P3 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Rrohailamjad210315y ago#31
i did with Diamond ...was it wrong?
Former userFormer user15y ago#32
paper is fair but the time is crucial. reading time for all 3 questions are about 45min... omg ~
Former userFormer user15y ago#33
my last paper, i hope i pass this and thats it i am done, ready to apply for membership .
Former userFormer user15y ago#34
i can't understand why the examiner can't give us shorter scenario's, it takes so much time analysing it all, and on top the person is already time pressurised. spending 20 mins or more in reading the optional questions is suicidal. EVERY MARK COUNTS and the person is wasting time just reading the lengthy scenario.
Former userFormer user15y ago#35
Hey, in the first question i used only PESTEL because i had no time! I think i referred to both macro and industry environment. Is that wrong?
Former userFormer user15y ago#36
all the examiners articles - people & strategy, pricing strategy (econimic & non economic factors), the strategic use of IT, forecasting (trend analysis), and project mangement. . . . . barely anything came up only the financial and non financial benefits of the project and benefits realisation. very annnoying to study these inside out and the minimal amount comes up in the exam. im very disappointed after putting in so much effort for nothing. q1 part a) i put in pestel and then did the 7m's model as i taught this best fitted the "market/industry" requirement. the porters diamond is used when expanding abroad & the porters 5 forces is in relation to "competition". the question didnt ask for competition of wasnt a foreign expansion so what do ye think???? was i wrong using the m's model????? time pressure also was unreal. didnt get to finish question 4 and didnt really relate it back to the case study, just explained the i's and gave a real life example. overall, disappointing
Jjpalis15y ago#37
I used PESTEL and M model as well in Q1a, thought M model was more about industry environment. Was I wrong?
Former userFormer user15y ago#38
I did pestel and five forces in Q1. I don't know about others but i think there were enough things in the scenario that were pointing towards these models. but other models can also be used as well provided they answer the question set.
Former userFormer user15y ago#39
9 M's model is to assess internal strength and weaknesses, and the q1 didnt ask for that...therefore I dont think that was the right choice.
Former userFormer user15y ago#40
ruined this paper...pray hard!
Pplatinumkp15y ago#41
Yeah i just bombed that beast...

In reality - strategy is about long term and we would all have more time to carefully make good suggestions.

In exam world - we are super people.
Aaurianne0415y ago#42
Lord, i just need 50%, no award winning prize please. JUST 50%
HOW MUCH LONGER AM I GOING TO CARRY ON FEEDING ACCA WITH MY EXAM FEES...I need return
Former userFormer user15y ago#43
@aurianne04 said:
Lord, i just need 50%, no award winning prize please. JUST 50%
HOW MUCH LONGER AM I GOING TO CARRY ON FEEDING ACCA WITH MY EXAM FEES...I need return


Ya Lord, please help us, I m requesting for the same too~ ^^
Ppuiyee9015y ago#44
@richieoctober said:
all the examiners articles - people & strategy, pricing strategy (econimic & non economic factors), the strategic use of IT, forecasting (trend analysis), and project mangement. . . . . barely anything came up only the financial and non financial benefits of the project and benefits realisation. very annnoying to study these inside out and the minimal amount comes up in the exam. im very disappointed after putting in so much effort for nothing. q1 part a) i put in pestel and then did the 7m's model as i taught this best fitted the "market/industry" requirement. the porters diamond is used when expanding abroad & the porters 5 forces is in relation to "competition". the question didnt ask for competition of wasnt a foreign expansion so what do ye think???? was i wrong using the m's model????? time pressure also was unreal. didnt get to finish question 4 and didnt really relate it back to the case study, just explained the i's and gave a real life example. overall, disappointing


actually those articles are not written by examiner, most of them are written by Ken Garrett, he is a freelance lecturer and author. my situation same like you, i spent time carefully read all the articles. revise the whole class notes and revision notes, but when i saw the questions, my mind really went blank, what i studied before really time wasted, i might as well dont revise, at least i won't be panic that what i studied was totally irrelevant
Former userFormer user15y ago#45
It was way too lenghty paper... had consumed time reading the scenario and plotting the answers.

Q1 i use Pester and 5 forces and make or buy decision for outsourcing. 3 weakness not really sure just wrote some crap :)

Chose Q2 & Q4, Q2 was mostly like F9 with org matrix.
Q4 6I's and E procurement - scenario application (havent use anything just justify its usefullness and relevance to the scenario.

it was supposed to be an OK paper should they made it 4hours instead of 3hr paper. Answers are just at the back of the mind, you just cannot concentrate because of the time pressure :)

Good luck to us getting 50%
OSOlga Sosnovska15y ago#46
Well, quite a disaster... After all, I do not understand why we should again learn the cases from F9, P5 ect.?? This paper is a business analysis, and why we should calculate IRR and other things which we have done before? Disappointing is that all the revision kit examples (except Pilot Paper 2011) do not reflect the new exam style of the new examinator. Therefore, wasted efford and time... Just hope that I "matched" the correct models and my common sence explaination will be useful for 50 marks... :(((
Former userFormer user15y ago#47
@alancong Sorry I can't really answer your question. I can't remember what Q1 part c was and in Q2 I don't think there was an 'intangible and tangilbe part'. You'd have to elaborate what you mean.
Former userFormer user15y ago#48
@ahmed1986 If you included good points on the industry within a PESTEL analysis then I'm sure you'll still score points for it. Strictly speaking though PESTEL is for macro or general environment. There were only 4 professional points for use of models so you can't loose much for it.
Former userFormer user15y ago#49
the thing with irr and npv question was you dont have to calculate anything , you just have to tell that he dont know what he was saying , as the discount rate he gave you were totally wrong which included only inflation effect so calculating irr with it would also be wrong , the thing was the company was having financing issues payback is usually suitable for that companies that are having financial issues as a initial screening tool , later on management can set irr as a benchmark that should be achived , also npv was quite worng , as he gave "employee moral" and "quality of info" which were intangible benifits , the only thing he was right about was business case , which you have to define what it was
Former userFormer user15y ago#50
In question 1a, I used the PESTEL for the macro-environment analysis and I used the Industry Life cycle for the market/industry analysis.

Is it right?
Former userFormer user15y ago#51
@jeanp786 said:
In question 1a, I used the PESTEL for the macro-environment analysis and I used the Industry Life cycle for the market/industry analysis.

Is it right?



as examiner does not stated any specific models , use any that fits the scenario
Former userFormer user15y ago#52
@connectt For the process redesign I made some minor suggestions cutting out some stages that weren't necessary. Then I wrote a longer suggestion on the whole system going web based rather than by email - benefit of automation would be less errors, faster, less need for admin staff.
Former userFormer user15y ago#53
alancong.. 3 weakness part was all general things.. number 1 deals with need to coordinate n communicate budgets n monitor them.. tentions arose for not doing do.. number 2 was abt lack of succession planning.. plus employee commitment n morale new graduates were hire a facilitative leadership would be approporiate or anyother you think fine... number 3 was very straight.. Ecocar was being victim of Red tapism.. they js used to discuss risk bt never taken any action.. so recommending TARA framework or 4Ts i think would have been a good answer
Former userFormer user15y ago#54
bytecode./.. exactly i did the same thing.. all you have to do is to criticize the appraisal there were OBSERVABLE benefits which may not be correctly quantified,,, even those shouldnt be included... well those 15 marks were a piece of cake seriously:D n specially for P4 students.. it seemed as if m doing t10 or f9... thnks to p3 examiner:D
Former userFormer user15y ago#56
Do anyone remember whether there was any relevant, mainly financial info, in Weakness 1 - description related to Q1, b, - outsourcing? I am afraid i skipped important info. Forgot to get back to this description due to time pressure:((
Thanks.
Former userFormer user15y ago#57
@richieoctober said:
all the examiners articles - people & strategy, pricing strategy (econimic & non economic factors), the strategic use of IT, forecasting (trend analysis), and project mangement. . . . . barely anything came up only the financial and non financial benefits of the project and benefits realisation. very annnoying to study these inside out and the minimal amount comes up in the exam. im very disappointed after putting in so much effort for nothing. q1 part a) i put in pestel and then did the 7m's model as i taught this best fitted the "market/industry" requirement. the porters diamond is used when expanding abroad & the porters 5 forces is in relation to "competition". the question didnt ask for competition of wasnt a foreign expansion so what do ye think???? was i wrong using the m's model????? time pressure also was unreal. didnt get to finish question 4 and didnt really relate it back to the case study, just explained the i's and gave a real life example. overall, disappointing


may be you sit for exam just wanna get 50% thats all, please dun spot question as the examiner always warn us. be prepared and you wont get panic,
you use M model instead of Porter 5 forces, you still can earn marks as the question state any relevent model(s), but you wanna get higher marks, you shud stick the the question that ask for 5 forces, ur can use M model to relate the company position in that industry.
Mmuneebnawaz9015y ago#58
well Outsourcing part required some calculation for discussing financial part
cost if outsourced ( 3500 x 6 ) + ( 250 x 6 ) - 1250 ( decrease in overhead ) = 21250 and if manufacture in house it will cost 4500 x 6 = 27000 . so financially beneficial but also discussed that make sure there might be some other cost which may make it financial not good. discussed quality issues and reliability in non financial part . attemted complete paper alhamdulilah . Hoping for good marks :)
Former userFormer user15y ago#59
Nobody on earth can read all the questions in 15 mins and make comprehensive approach to questions. Opentuition lecturer recommended approach helped. Questions were not strange but no time to seriously organise oneself.
Rrafay_ali15y ago#60
who used Harmon's process start matrix for quest 3 part a..

I totally screwed up on the last part I defined the 4 elements and picked up points from the passage what may have been vaguely related but I think It was fine...also left the financial aspect of outsourcing in quest 1..

rest was goood