Post your comments about June 2013 P2 exam.
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
Vote in our Instant Poll

SBR*** P2 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
<cite>@anamariachi said:</cite> I got the same figures. So it is either the same mistake, either the same good approach :)You had to gross up the proportionate goodwill before calculating any impairment loss...then consider only the group share of impaired goodwill amount...the rest to write-down PPE...even if in the end it falls down to the same amounts...the principle may be considered wrong...
I completely missed the step acquisiton. Anyone have any idea how many marks this will cost me.
<cite>@christinemackenzie said:</cite> I completely missed the step acquisiton. Anyone have any idea how many marks this will cost me.that is not a step acqusitions. but a D shape complex consolidation
<cite>@anamariachi said:</cite> I got the same figures. So it is either the same mistake, either the same good approach :)i got the same i remember thinking these were some odd figures .......so as said before either we all made the same mistake or we will crumble
Gain on step acquisition was obvious, but I might have forgotten not so sure....
Also, I have made a stupid choice between Q3 and Q4.
Let's hope that I will get the ponts...
the over all exam was ok.
In question-1 the goodwill of park was 80
the goodwill of caller was 398
& impairment of proportionate goodwill was 180. (because we had to calculate notional goodwill (80*100/60).
NCI was $959m.
<cite>@anamariachi said:</cite> I got the same figures. So it is either the same mistake, either the same good approach :)the impairment was 180. because we had to calculate notional goodwill first which was (80*100/60)
Dear friends could you help me?
Will I be given full marks for calculation under partial method of goodwil if I used the following proforma -
consideration paid
+ plus NCI share of net assets at acqusition date
- minus all net assets of subs at acquision date
I have found that in some answers the following proforma is given for partial method of goodwil
consideration paid
- minus parent share of subs net assets at acquision date
The answer will be the same but I am worring about the the proforma which I used
consideration paid
+ NCI share of net assets at acqusition date (NCI % multiplied by net assets at acqusition date)
- all net assets of subs at acquision date
Please, tell me what do you think?
<cite>@mohsinahmed said:</cite> the over all exam was ok. In question-1 the goodwill of park was 80 the goodwill of caller was 398 & impairment of proportionate goodwill was 180. (because we had to calculate notional goodwill (80*100/60).think we have the same ans but not for impairment though
<cite>@saiyan2005 said:</cite> think we have the same ans but not for impairment thoughDear friends could you help me? Will I be given full marks for calculation under partial method of goodwil if I used the following proforma – consideration paid + plus NCI share of net assets at acqusition date - minus all net assets of subs at acquision date I have found that in some answers the following proforma is given for partial method of goodwil consideration paid - minus parent share of subs net assets at acquision date The answer will be the same but I am worring about the the proforma which I used consideration paid + NCI share of net assets at acqusition date (NCI % multiplied by net assets at acqusition date) - all net assets of subs at acquision date Please, tell me what do you think?
Hi, Can I use the current lectures available online to begin study for the Dec 2013 exam? For Papers P2, P3, P4 an P7?
1st question was fair. Not too sure about the rest
The goodwill had to be grossed up 133 (80 + 53 for NCI)
Impairment of 300 to allocate 80 to sub and 53 to NCI the rest 167 to PPE
the total impairment was 300. from it we only needed parent,s share of goodwill which was (300*60%) = 180
from 180 figure 80 was to be allocated to goodwill. as a result goodwill was became 0.
the remaining 100 was to be written off from PPE.
thats how it should have done.
<cite>@fg2011 said:</cite> Dear friends could you help me? Will I be given full marks for calculation under partial method of goodwil if I used the following proforma – consideration paid + plus NCI share of net assets at acqusition date - minus all net assets of subs at acquision date I have found that in some answers the following proforma is given for partial method of goodwil consideration paid - minus parent share of subs net assets at acquision date The answer will be the same but I am worring about the the proforma which I used consideration paid + NCI share of net assets at acqusition date (NCI % multiplied by net assets at acqusition date) - all net assets of subs at acquision date Please, tell me what do you think?No bro you made a mistake. actual proforma is: FV of consideration at date of acquisition + FV of NCI - FV of net assets at acquisition date total goodwill
<cite>@mohsinahmed said:</cite> No bro you made a mistake. actual proforma is: FV of consideration at date of acquisition + FV of NCI - FV of net assets at acquisition date total goodwillyes, it is proforma for goodwill measured at FV But I am talking about partial goodwill method (which was used in part A of question 1) That is why i am asking - Will I be given full marks for calculation under Partial method of goodwil if I used the following proforma – consideration paid + plus NCI share of net assets at acqusition date - minus all net assets of subs at acquision date I have found that in some answers the following proforma is given for partial method of goodwil consideration paid - minus parent share of subs net assets at acquision date The answer will be the same but I am worring about the the proforma which I used for partial goowill metod THANK YOU!!!
i time badly. spend too much time on Q1, on calculating goodwill, park goodwill was easy 80, celler's goodwill was difficult,at the end i just put any number in and move on. I wish I have done that earlier. because I end up do not have enough time to finish Q3, which I could have answer and gain some points.. If I fail by few marks I will be so angry with myself.
<cite>@fg2011 said:</cite> yes, it is proforma for goodwill measured at FV But I am talking about partial goodwill method (which was used in part A of question 1) That is why i am asking - Will I be given full marks for calculation under Partial method of goodwil if I used the following proforma – consideration paid + plus NCI share of net assets at acqusition date - minus all net assets of subs at acquision date I have found that in some answers the following proforma is given for partial method of goodwil consideration paid - minus parent share of subs net assets at acquision date The answer will be the same but I am worring about the the proforma which I used for partial goowill metod THANK YOU!!!dear bro you have mixed the 2 methods of goodwill. the method of full goodwill which i have learned form lsbf lectures is following: Goodwill (controling interest):- FV of consideration Less: FV of net assets ( CI% * FV of net assets) Subtotal Goodwill ( Non controling interest):- FV of NCI Less: FV of net assets ( NCI% * FV of net assets) Subtotal Full goodwill ( Goodwill CI + Goodwill NCI)
<cite>@saiyan2005 said:</cite> think we have the same ans but not for impairment thoughi think it's ok .. i did the same as well . because that's what the method used in kaplan.
<cite>@fg2011 said:</cite> Dear friends could you help me? Will I be given full marks for calculation under partial method of goodwil if I used the following proforma - consideration paid + plus NCI share of net assets at acqusition date - minus all net assets of subs at acquision date I have found that in some answers the following proforma is given for partial method of goodwil consideration paid - minus parent share of subs net assets at acquision date The answer will be the same but I am worring about the the proforma which I used consideration paid + NCI share of net assets at acqusition date (NCI % multiplied by net assets at acqusition date) - all net assets of subs at acquision date Please, tell me what do you think?it's not wrong. that's what i did too. because this is the method used in kaplan text books.
<cite>@sujawahab said:</cite> it's not wrong. that's what i did too. because this is the method used in kaplan text books.the partial goodwill method is;- FV of consideration Add: FV of NCI( FV of Net Assets * NCI%) Less: FV of Net Assets Partial Goodwill you can reconfirm it from any book.
the method of full goodwill which i have learned form lsbf lectures is following:
Goodwill (controling interest):-
FV of consideration
Less: FV of net assets ( CI% * FV of net assets)
Subtotal
Goodwill ( Non controling interest):-
FV of NCI
Less: FV of net assets ( NCI% * FV of net assets)
Subtotal
Full goodwill ( Goodwill CI + Goodwill NCI)
It was more towards ok side...... Thanks to the tutor..
hi i forgot to write the paper version will my paper be mark or will it go against me? Thanks
<cite>@stephencommey said:</cite> hi i forgot to write the paper version will my paper be mark or will it go against me? Thanksbro you need to phone the acca. and ask this issue. or write an email to acca.
<cite>@mohsinahmed said:</cite> the partial goodwill method is;- FV of consideration Add: FV of NCI( FV of Net Assets * NCI%) Less: FV of Net Assets Partial Goodwill you can reconfirm it from any book.proportional based goodwill (partial goodwill) consideration paid ADD:FV of NET ASSET owned by NCI(FV of Net asset at acquisition X NIC %) LESS: FV of net assets of subsidiary at Acqusition partial good will this is equal to what he wrote above that is consideration paid + plus NCI share of net assets at acqusition date - minus all net assets of subs at acquision date ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- full Goodwill Consideration paid ADD: FV of NCI (given in the question) less:FV of net assets of subsidiary at Acqusition full goodwill parent : goodwill X Parent % NCI: goodwill X NCI % ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- and your method also same as to what i wrote above. just the steps are different. i did just as you did in F7 when i went to classes. but p2 i self studied from kaplan book. and i addopted the above kaplan method for p2 .. but i know both methods are same but just different way of doing it
the only thing we need to do is to pray and keep fingers cross
Admin
Is there possibility that opentuition will show suggested answers for P2?)
Thanks
<cite>@surepass said:</cite> Examinees Do you know tat you can pass this silly exam by not attempting Q1 consol or even Section B and yet you still able to achieve a Pass. Trust me yes is true. I had friends did tat. Even mine was totally garbage and yet still Pass. My advice don’t bother too much time on this paper. Just answer 1.5 question and A sure guarantee pass. 3hrs to do 1.5 question is possible. Answers need not quality.You had a dream ? :p
Online Tuitor for P2 has cleared at one sitting

