Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** P2 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin13y ago
Post your comments about June 2013 P2 exam. How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams? Vote in our Instant Poll *** P2 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments *** poll results
Former userFormer user13y ago#31
<cite>@vladimir87 said:</cite> I believe that you forgot to gross up the goodwill. The goodwill is calculated as proportionate share and when testing CGU you should gross it up to include notional goodwill. I think that as at 31 May 2013 net asset of park were 2.220 + fair value adjustment 35 (I think) + notional goodwill 80/0,6= 133. This equals 2.388 and recoverable amount was 2.088. Park was impaired for 300.
However, even if you did not do so, you got the same result. Since part of grossed up goodwill is not recognized anywhere, impairment to PPE is 167. This approach is only relevant to decide whether there is any impairment, afterwards the result is the same. Sorry if I frighten you :)
Mmarky12313y ago#32
I thought the exam was pretty tough although (and I'm not looking for the sympathy vote lol!) I was very unprepared due to personal circumstances. I'd brushed up on financial instruments and investment properties so hopefully can pick up a few marks there. A pass for me will be fantastic - I attempted everything that was asked in each question, but if not I will treat this as a practice run ready for December. Best of luck to all of us :)
Oolasunmola13y ago#33
honestly, i totally flunked the csfp...i prepared for cashflow. i answered the remaining 3 questions but didn't really link them with the standards well....i got the name of the standards discussed them..did question 4 well.. in fact i did all four questions to compensate for a terrible question 1?... ANY LUCK?
Jjennietrang9113y ago#34
<cite>@vladimir87 said:</cite> However, even if you did not do so, you got the same result. Since part of grossed up goodwill is not recognized anywhere, impairment to PPE is 167. This approach is only relevant to decide whether there is any impairment, afterwards the result is the same. Sorry if I frighten you :)
Oh.. Now I know I did not put 35 of FV adjustment when do the impairment review. I did not manage time wel, spent too much time on Q1. And I have to agree that the 3-year loan is a tricky one... I seriously dont think I will pass.. When will ACCA post the marking scheme?
Aazramalik13y ago#35
Was the 1st question D shaped group?
Aansi13y ago#36
@karmuks, thanks :)) but every student deserved it and only few will pass :D joking :) 50% will pass :) I can't tell you much about Lease. When i was reading the question , i started feeling that the examiner wants us to think that it's a financial lease while in fact it's the operating one. It is one of those cases when it is not easy to decide and easy to manipulate , hence the troubles with underlying IAS. But i only had some time for part B of the question and didn't even have time to read part a well :) So can't tell you more :) we'll see. Don't think of it much now. Congratulations , p2 is over ....till december ;)
Mmichael765613y ago#37
Q1 wasn't too bad. I ended up with $180m impairment. $80m to goodwill and $100m to PPE. No impairment to NCI as its the proportionate share basis so all to RE. The examiner put in a lot of red herrings by showing the FV of NA and equity balances from the acquisition in 2011. The parent acquired in 2012 so I used these figures. Overall, not a bad paper although didn't expect the SOFP. Have to wait until august and see!
Former userFormer user13y ago#38
Did anyone else think the lease in Q3 was actually a Hire Purchase? Did anyone else think in Q2 it was ok that they combined operating segment (i) and (ii) ?
Kkishan13y ago#39
question 1 was a D shaped group. Trailer had 14% equity share in C. and Park had 70% share in C. Both of these were at june 2011. then in June 2012 Trailer bought 60% of park. so everything basically happens on june 2012! Both ended up being subsidiarys i think with the effective interest in C being 14%+(60%x70%)= 56%. Therefore NCI on C was 44%. i messed up the goodwill working completely and came out with like £1400 goodwill on C or something and just ended up using that figure so you would still get follow through marks even if you have the wrong figures. Question 2 was multi standard, - Operating segments - Provisions - Revenue Recognition on service contract. Question 4 was 'bin the clutter article'. Definatley passable if you knew the basics becuase this was a gift of a paper compared to previous sittings i have seen! then again this is the first time i am sitting it so i could fail and be chewing my own words so who knows! overall i found it fair. MEssed up a load of workings but who doesnt under exam pressure?
Former userFormer user13y ago#40
It can not be a bad idea for the examiner to review the time we sit for this paper or to split the paper into 2. the idea behind too much work in a very little time is not right. I strongly think that even the 15 mins reading time should be part of the actual exam.
Former userFormer user13y ago#41
Section B questions were quite nice compared with other years. I did Q2 and Q3 and was happy with them. Q1 was very tough and tricky.
Former userFormer user13y ago#42
Exam was easy in fact ... but I was not good enough. I really hope just to have my 50 marks. Question 1. The conso question was very straightforward - only SFP for D shape group with piecemeal acquisition element (part a). In part a was also included IAS 16 (revaluation of building), IAS 19 (defined benefit pension plan), IFRS 9 (financial assets - loan receivables), IAS 37 (restructuring provision). For part b (accounting NCI at fair value) and c (ethics) I had very few time and just wrote 2 or 3 things there :( Questions 2 and 3 were about IFRS 8 (discuss whether 2 segments are reportable or not), IFRS 5 (discuss whether a subsidiary meet the definition of held for sale in 2 consecutive years), IAS 18 (revenue recognition of services with present value element), IAS 17 (lease of land with many additional information, this one I did it in a wrong way), IAS 16 and IAS 20 in one question (building for museum), IFRS 9 and IAS 40 (discuss the different levels of inputs when determine the fair value of investments property), IAS 37 (damage, litigation - discuss whether it is provision or contingent liability). Questions 4- bla bla bla - I skipped it.
Former userFormer user13y ago#43
<cite>@vladimir87 said:</cite> I believe that you forgot to gross up the goodwill. The goodwill is calculated as proportionate share and when testing CGU you should gross it up to include notional goodwill. I think that as at 31 May 2013 net asset of park were 2.220 + fair value adjustment 35 (I think) + notional goodwill 80/0,6= 133. This equals 2.388 and recoverable amount was 2.088. Park was impaired for 300.
Yep, I realised that afterwards, but this will only impact with one mark. Nothing to worry for me.
Mmarkobeograd13y ago#44
Again same thing with ACCA, little time for very demanding tasks. I am aware that this is professional level, but examiners should to test our knowledge, and not our ability to write fast. I am of opinion that these exams should be at last 4 hour tested, in order to give time to candidates to think and express that. However q1 too much details and cut off dates. i am wondering what should be done with increases in value of Caller up to 310 from 280 after inclusion into the Group. For the first revaluation up to 280 from 260 I debited other components of equity and made transfer to group's retaind earnings, but for second I did not know what to do and where this surplus should be transfer or eliminated. Also tricky issue with loan with confusing figure of 48.5. I discounted 50 milion in three years time rate 6% - get 42and accounted interest for one year (6%) with deduction of already accounted interest of 1.5 (50*3%). However I did not know where to transfer difference of loan's carrying value and my computation beside of lowering of financial asset. Office space revaluation was also tricky as during my review of past exam papers I have noticed that revalution loss needs to be deducted for the amount of portion of annually depreciation. Probably in rush - I spent 2 hours for this question - deducted amount which relates to retained earnings instead to added it. Regarding impairment of goodwill I am wondering whethet only parent portion of 60% should be set agains goodwill and ppe, while rest is not group relevant. I deducted only 80 from Goodwill and rest 100 against ppe. Other questions were easy for me, but I did not have too much time so was enforced to briefly disscuss them. If there will be enough time other questions would not be problem for me. q2 - IFRS 8 operating segments, IAS 18 deferred revenue, IAS 37 provision together with IAS 10 events after reporting date and finally IAS 20 goverment assistance together with IAS 16 ppe q3 - IFRS 17 lease (issue with finance lease of land - despite of indefinite life), IFRS 5 with disposal of subsidiary, IFRS 40 investment property, rest of this question can't remember. Best regards.
Former userFormer user13y ago#45
For question 1: I did not read the question properly and thought it was a Vertical Group. will i get severely penalised i.e. 0 Mark for goodwill calculation and for part (b) used workings of part (a). Thanks
Ffaizan13y ago#46
The goodwill was not 80 i'm sure of it. I dont know the exact figure because I forgot to deduct something but it was no where near 80. Everything went well but due to the time pressure I made a basic mistake of entering the wrong figures of asset and liabilities during consolidation of subsidiary in the balance sheet :( Does anyone know how many marks you lose for that? other than that it was okay.
Ffaizan13y ago#47
I used the 2012 figures for caller too as it become a subsidiary after the parent bought park. The impairement thing was 2220 - 2088 right? or you use 2088 (one guy used this) btw someone here said q3 was about provisions.. no it was not about provision but held for sale which was kept in that state for more than 12 months and the company wanted it to still be classified as held for sale even when it was transfering activities to the subsidiary.
Former userFormer user13y ago#48
Did anyone get 398 for goodwill on caller?
Former userFormer user13y ago#49
i also got 80 for park goodwill and i think i got around 350-400 for caller so possibly 398 but dont remember
Ppolldoll13y ago#50
I really let myself down! Whilst reasonably confident with most of what I did for Q1, I spent far too long over it, the rest was a gallop and I didn't finish. I think I may have got in a pickle in the impairment calculation. I grossed up the goodwill but I forgot the fair value adjustment and only impaired the PPE by the 60% proportion... I did Q2 in a rush (with limited success I expect). I certainly don't expect to get the professional marks! I came onto Q3 with very little time left and the leases seemed baffling to get my head around quickly so I did part (c) which was only worth 6 marks... I will be very lucky to pass with 19 marks left out and Q2 so rushed. Very disappointed in myself as I have all first time passes up to now.
Former userFormer user13y ago#51
what did people do for the pension in Q1? there was a lot of information given but i just worked out present value of obligations using actuarial value of obligations ad discount factor and deducted it from fair value of plan assets to give about 4m plan deficit :S
Ffidget13y ago#52
<cite>@jflan2 said:</cite> For question 1: I did not read the question properly and thought it was a Vertical Group. will i get severely penalised i.e. 0 Mark for goodwill calculation and for part (b) used workings of part (a). Thanks
It seems to be, if you have a look at the marking scheme for past papers, that despite there being quite a lot to do to get to the goodwill figure, it's hardly worth any marks anyway for the time and effort it takes to do it. You won't be penalised twice for it though, so if your calculation in part b is correct using your incorrect answer from part a, then you should get the marks for it.
Former userFormer user13y ago#53
Section A was normal BUT sec B was not easy, in ques 1 the impairment of CGU (PARK) was $300 ($2388 - $2088) and the entry is: Dr: Cons Reserves $180 ($300 x 0.6) Cr: Goodwill $80 (g/w attributable to Trailer) Cr: PPE $100 Am I right?? By the grace of almighty we had been compensated 30 minutes due to power failure. :p :D
Former userFormer user13y ago#54
<cite>@jazzold said:</cite> what did people do for the pension in Q1? there was a lot of information given but i just worked out present value of obligations using actuarial value of obligations ad discount factor and deducted it from fair value of plan assets to give about 4m plan deficit :S
I think you had to calculate: *interest on defined benefit obligation (DBO) and fair value of plan asset (FVPA) = 5% * opening balance *remeasurements (actuarial gains and losses) on DBO and FVPA = balancing figure between closing balance, opening balance and other changes mentioned (current service cost, contribution to the plan asset and payments to employee) Then take the accounting entries: dr P&L (current service cost + net interest cost) dr OCI (remeasurements) cr defined benefit liability
Former userFormer user13y ago#55
By the grace of almighty we had been compensated 30 minutes due to power failure. :p :D
Lucky guys!!!
Former userFormer user13y ago#56
but half of that stuff doesnt feature on the SFP?
Former userFormer user13y ago#57
<cite>@jazzold said:</cite> but half of that stuff doesnt feature on the SFP?
The entry for P&L reflects Retained earnings in SFP and OCI reflects Other components of equity (or again Retained earnings - I have seen both presentation)
Former userFormer user13y ago#58
makes sense i suppose
Former userFormer user13y ago#59
"Exam was ok, but I was not good", "Fair enough, but not enough time" - are you kidding? BE HONEST This was a disaster! Q1 part A was time and mind killer and then part B, based on that goodwill that was messed up in part A! I made only one fatal mistake - tried to do consolidation workings, should have skipped, maybe there would be any chance to pass then. See you next year!
Kkishan13y ago#60
Just rememberd question 1 on ethics. Absolute gift of a question. 6 marks on saying something like "this director believes that accountants do not need to study ethics. Also discuss if the misappropriation of profits is an ethical issue?" What a gift. I put down PIPCO ethical guidelines and said not statig correct profits is against 1. Directors fiduciary responsibility 2. His ethical guidelines spelt out by his relative body (PIPCO.) Hopefully I got full marks on that.