Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** P2 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin13y ago
Post your comments about June 2013 P2 exam. How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams? Vote in our Instant Poll *** P2 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments *** poll results
Former userFormer user13y ago#61
Well I definitely tried my best but as always there were a few bits which I was unsure about. What did everyone do with the following?...... 1. The loan at a reduced rate 2. The restructuring, did you provide for both plans (excluding training)? 3. Were the segments to be split in question 2a? 4. Did you disclose a contingent liability or not for the damage costs? Then a provision?
Former userFormer user13y ago#62
yh SOFP again, he will never do cash flow especially when everyone is saying cash flow this time. but again i didn't do well. forgot how to deal with that impairment thing, and few other adj, i got goodwill of park 80 too, but didn't know how to get the impairment (although i did the similar Q twice from exam kit, still kicking myself , but don't want to check it again now coz I can't ask for my paper back and change it , :P ) Although I didn't do well myself, i think the paper was fair , anyone who prepare well would pass easily. (but not when you start finding the note one week before exam , lol ) will have to wait and see the result , but might have to resit .. (the thought of it make me want to run away from ACCA ) For those of you who finish the exam , let's just be happy that it's over and celebrate :) And people who still have P1 tomorrow , good luck.
Former userFormer user13y ago#63
<cite>@faizan said:</cite> I used the 2012 figures for caller too as it become a subsidiary after the parent bought park. The impairement thing was 2220 - 2088 right? or you use 2088 (one guy used this) btw someone here said q3 was about provisions.. no it was not about provision but held for sale which was kept in that state for more than 12 months and the company wanted it to still be classified as held for sale even when it was transfering activities to the subsidiary.
I did 2220 + (non dep land from FV adj , 35 or 40 not remember) -2088 but so uncomfortable , feeling that I did the wrong thing ,
Kkarmuks13y ago#64
For me question one seemed very easy, usual stuff, goodwill impairment step acquisitions, deemed disposal of previous interest. Actually all parts were familiar. Only thing what I did not like is that it took a time to sort out what and when was acquired , all information seemed to be thrown in to different corners of question. Second thing employee benefits, I knew how to calculate it but the again different wording used wasted my time to sort out which is which. Examiner should make easier wording as there are lot of students who does not have English as first language. If not that wording I would finish that question 15 min earlier what I could spend better on other harder questions.
Former userFormer user13y ago#65
<cite>@anamariachi said:</cite> I got the same figures. So it is either the same mistake, either the same good approach :)
Yep, definitely correct. GW in Sub-sub not so simple, How should one work out the indirect (42%) consideration? Also, why was the investment of T in C $310 in the FS, when the notes indicated $260? Surely nothing to do with the charitable loan?
Nnevyana13y ago#66
The loan issue in Q1a, it had to be treated at amortised cost Ok? so 50+50*6%-50*3%= 51.5 ok? Currently we have 48.5, thus the diff = 51.5-48.5 = 3 shall be treated Dt RE/ Cr Loan payable =3 The thning is that based on the question this loan was a receivable because we granted the loan to a charity, if so then it would be: 50-50*6%+50*3% = 48.5 but the scenario explicitely said that the loan is presented net of the cash paid (if loan receivable, the cash would have been received) and the loan would be 51.5. So, I just assumed that it is payable and did it and then in the CSOFP presented it under payables. Did anyone else noted that or I was just too under time preassure?
Kkarmuks13y ago#67
:) Well it was okay. Way easier then F7 at least. I had such a big smile when i saw that SFP was examined again :))) Who expected it ? :) it looks like next time nobody will already expect anything else but sfp :) Time pressure was an issue only if u waste too much time in q1 . Otherwise i would not call it time pressured. At least not like i expected. My time allocation wasn't good as always, so i might fail ...but it's purely my fault :) All in all, fair exam , thanks to examiner and thanks OT :) Dont worry Ansi you should pass. I thought it will be statement of financial position,because i think examiner thinks that we all have well learned cash flows and income statement that there is no need anymore to examine it :D I confused about lease, was it operating or finance? After reading article I eventually decided it was an operating one? What others decided on lease?
Former userFormer user13y ago#68
i got an asset in the defined benefit obligation ???? i dunno of 4 or something ..... in revaluation of office building i js revalued the building till 84 ... which was the cv had there been no impairement .... i dunnu i did it right or not
Nnevyana13y ago#69
<cite>@d38ono said:</cite> Well I definitely tried my best but as always there were a few bits which I was unsure about. What did everyone do with the following?...... 1. The loan at a reduced rate 2. The restructuring, did you provide for both plans (excluding training)? 3. Were the segments to be split in question 2a? 4. Did you disclose a contingent liability or not for the damage costs? Then a provision?
The loan I discussed in my prior post I settled provision only for Plan A, because in Plan B there was not approval like to for Plan A where the two factories were identified by the management.
Former userFormer user13y ago#70
Well, think I did ok with SFP. Shame I knew none of the IAS!!!
Former userFormer user13y ago#71
i really crammed in the last month...it was a good exam not too difficult; the questions were not bad at all especially questions 2 and 3 which tested several IASs.Thought bin the clutter was coming but was too risky for me to study last minute and oh oh, question 1 really tested your understanding of when to recognize goodwill and along with a further acquisition..i could be wrong but did not caller became a member of the group when the Park acquired it. Originally it was just an investment at 14%. oh well i got totally confused at first and then settled my thoughts to come to certain realizations. I did not practice any past paper questions except for the chapter questions in kaplan but a question like this one really tested whether one understands the mechanics of group accounting.
AAAsad Ali Hussaini13y ago#72
Want some suggestions... I had done Q4 which was IFRS 12 - Disclosures but had applied P1 knowledge in Q4 a i & ii both (9 and 6 marks) .. was it right to do so?? Will I be giving marks for this??
Former userFormer user13y ago#73
Does anyone know what we should have done for the loan and the restructuring costs in q1??. Also, when is the marking scheme out?
Nnevyana13y ago#74
<cite>@melindamarchal said:</cite> Does anyone know what we should have done for the loan and the restructuring costs in q1??. Also, when is the marking scheme out?
For the restructuring I provided plan 1 only and with 14,000 because I excluded the training costs which are not directly related to the restructuring.
Former userFormer user13y ago#75
<cite>@nevyana said:</cite> For the restructuring I provided plan 1 only and with 14,000 because I excluded the training costs which are not directly related to the restructuring.
Me too
Former userFormer user13y ago#76
<cite>@katyancha87 said:</cite> Q3. part (c) of the question on IFRS 5 - Held for sale, isn't it? not IAS 37
Yes, it is. sorry I did not remember exactly
Former userFormer user13y ago#77
<cite>@1686844 said:</cite> Me too
I assumed the same, with a 14,000 provision but now I can't remember if I added the figure to the SOFP, I guess I will never know now! Do you get marks for the correct workings even if you forget to transfer to the SOFP? I discounted the loan and interest receivable using the 6% interest rate, then calculated interest at 6% less 3% paid but I'm still unsure what should have been done (as I ended up reducing the loan receivable).
Former userFormer user13y ago#78
A tough but fair exam.
Ffg201113y ago#79
Hello! friends, pls, help me! 1) Q1 -redundacy costs - I included in provision for plan 1 all expenses except for retraining; for year 2 I disounted the provision for 2 years (5% ategiven) and recorded as lontermprovision - is it OK? Will I begiven full marks for this part? 2) Q3 Leasing of land I classified land as operating lease -indefinite life of land -the owner has the right to adjust the amount of the rentals (5% to current value) - no control is pased ;risks and rewards and so on i listed 5 complete ideas and now I think that it was finance lease - will I be given marks if I classified land as operating lease in this question? Could you please help me/ Thank you!!!
Eemmalin7713y ago#80
I started off with Qs4 (which was a gift), then Qs2 (which was okay I suppose), then the essay/ethics on Qs 1b/c (also easy), leaving myself the full hour to do the SOPF last, which was horrendous. I think my exam technique was spot on, but not sure if got enough marks for 50...very borderline!!
Former userFormer user13y ago#81
Bin the clutter was a gift. Not a technically demanding paper but very long acca becoming a racing game, the one who writes fastest wins
Former userFormer user13y ago#82
U
Former userFormer user13y ago#83
too long .... i have left a point worth 10 marks ... i wish pass
Former userFormer user13y ago#84
Questions were not bad..but I messed up with no1 specially in the section of Caller...although it was straightforward but screwed up and ended the respective answer very badly..write some about 2 and 3 and hope it is in line with relevant IAS/IFRS..can I hope for a lucky 50?
Former userFormer user13y ago#85
<cite>@d38ono said:</cite> I assumed the same, with a 14,000 provision but now I can't remember if I added the figure to the SOFP, I guess I will never know now! Do you get marks for the correct workings even if you forget to transfer to the SOFP?
I think that you have to get points!
I discounted the loan and interest receivable using the 6% interest rate, then calculated interest at 6% less 3% paid but I'm still unsure what should have been done (as I ended up reducing the loan receivable).
I did the same but I accounted for the loss. 50 m minus PV with 6% = difference which I accounted as a loss in the current year. Then I calculated the new interest income (it was 1.8 I think) and I accounted for the difference between the interest already accrued (1.5) and 1.8. I am not sure whether this is correct??
Former userFormer user13y ago#86
<cite>@fg2011 said:</cite> 2) Q3 Leasing of land I classified land as operating lease -indefinite life of land -the owner has the right to adjust the amount of the rentals (5% to current value) - no control is pased ;risks and rewards and so on i listed 5 complete ideas and now I think that it was finance lease - will I be given marks if I classified land as operating lease in this question? Could you please help me/ Thank you!!!
This lease was the most difficult part in the exam I think. I wrote that it is a finance one. I mentioned the new change in IAS 17 whether there will not be anymore operating lease. That the rights to use the asset correspond to the definition of an asset in the Conceptual Framework. That the risk and rewards are transferred. Bla bla bla. But I am not sure at all and probably I am wrong. About these adjustments to the rent, I wrote that they should be accounted in the year they occur. Somebody wrote above that there is an article and according the article it should be an operating lease.
Former userFormer user13y ago#87
Did someone succeed to balance the SPF in Q1?
Former userFormer user13y ago#88
Q1: From the question: The FV of NA of Caller was 990 at 1 June 2011 (When 14% and 70% acquired). But share capital was 800, Retained earnings was 190 and OCE was 52. Total is 800+190+52=1,042. And FV of NA was less than per Calculation (990-1,042). So I decreased the share capital from 800 to 708 as balancing fugure: Share capital: 708 RE: 190 OCE: 52 FV of land: 40 TOTAL: 990 What did you do?
Nnevyana13y ago#89
<cite>@azenaghiyev said:</cite> Q1: From the question: The FV of NA of Caller was 990 at 1 June 2011 (When 14% and 70% acquired). But share capital was 800, Retained earnings was 190 and OCE was 52. Total is 800+190+52=1,042. And FV of NA was less than per Calculation (990-1,042). So I decreased the share capital from 800 to 708 as balancing fugure: Share capital: 708 RE: 190 OCE: 52 FV of land: 40 TOTAL: 990 What did you do?</blockquote I saw that also, but the diff was exactly 52, the amount of other components in equity. I just used 990 as per question. It is not likely that acca have mistaken this but i put down my assumption that i will use 990.
Former userFormer user13y ago#90
How foolish I was!! I use 1 Jun 2011 for calculate G/w for Caller.... Loss NCI and G/w? how much marks for these? so sad I would have been more hard working.......regret much