Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** P2 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 P2 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** P2 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results


Please note: Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening.
Former userFormer user13y ago#61
@chunky

I got negative goodwill of 30 for the sub-sub, which I then adjusted in reserves (retained earnings)
Former userFormer user13y ago#62
Never before come across a P2 past paper with two questions re. accounting treatments. Was strange to come across Q's 2 and 3 in the same paper. Big chunks of the syllabus were not included. Strange.

And no chance of question spotting. The examiner must have clocked on that 12/10 and 12/08 were Cash flows, so he didn't want to make this paper completely predictable.
Sseth113y ago#63
guysss!! impairment of 50 for the sub sub was indeed the case IF liabilities were deducted from Recov. Value.
This means that all of you have correctly calculated goodwill at the first place since NBV= Net assets (year end) + goodwill !!!
But, the thing is that in this case, impairment of 50 is greater that actual goodwill which cannot be true at any case.

Also, Recoverable value= higher of NRV (NSP) and Value in use. Where does the standard say that liabilities must be excluded from the calculation of Recoverable value?? I think this was just to cinfuse us.

This is why I didn;t impair either of the subs........................

Greeting to all (is my first post on this site)
Bbenitez13y ago#64
Good shout Funkus, I did think the same regarding the cash flows, also no income statement! Perhaps a SOFP again...predictions were off the mark.
Think there is a lesson there for us all.
Bbenitez13y ago#65
No impairment of subs is this the correct treatment??
Llewisbush13y ago#66
Can't believe the paper wasnt a cash flow or income statement so took me by suprise. On previous papers standard straight forward adjustments were on the sofp but not this one! :( I talked about revenue standard in the electric/government adjustment. I hope everyone passes and if you know you ve tried your best you cant do anymore! :-)good luck all! Fingers crossed :)
Former userFormer user13y ago#67
Question 1 - associate - moved dividend received into calculation
Goodwill also 190 - so glad I thought I had done it wrong !!
Didn't understand about the impairment so ignored that - thought it would only be a couple of marks
Q2-dreadful didn't know anything about certificates so didn't do this one
Q3- library impairment of £2.7m
Q4-fair value ok and markets but absolutely no idea about the decommissioning just guessed it as labour & materials plus overheads plus inflation ????
Sseth113y ago#68
impairment tests are intended to test!! if REc value < NBV , u never impair anything
Bbenitez13y ago#69
Thanks Seth, if this is correct I may have got lucky...
Bbenitez13y ago#70
Not sure of the treatment of the inv to associate.

I added the org cost (not FV) plus new consideration plus profits. Thinks the profits were 30% x 18m??
Former userFormer user13y ago#71
@seth1 said:
impairment tests are intended to test!! if REc value < NBV , u never impair anything
hi seth, is rec v < nbv or cv then you need to impair. impairment was required in q1, i would agree on the 50m. on its allocation is where the confusion arose, looking at each sub as a single CGU then first goodwill then proportionate to the rest of the remaining NCA and intangibles, however, some people seem to have taken it to intangibles for the remainder. i was doubtful at this point as to taking the entire impairment to total goodwill ( both subs). not sure on what the correct treatment is, however in any case the total RE calc of the parent would have been reduced by its share of the imp = 56, the remainder to nci
Sseth113y ago#72
no prob benitez.
Something else came on my mind now: in the last note of consolidation (Q1) we just had to de recognise PPE, Inventory and CL as given, or also run an impairment by taking as Recov amount the cash expected to receive (or already received I dont remember..)??????


I hope we will all pass. Indeed it was a relatively easy and straightforward paper compared to previous sittings
Former userFormer user13y ago#73
@benitez said:
Not sure of the treatment of the inv to associate.

I added the org cost (not FV) plus new consideration plus profits. Thinks the profits were 30% x 18m??

hi benitez, agreed on most, the existing initial holding at the remeasured fv on additional acquisition, then new consideration plus share of associate profits with time proportion of 6 months. finally to deduct the dividend paid as this was paid after the inv becomes associate.
Former userFormer user13y ago#74
Examiner likes playing tricks. He is a trickster.
If assessing learning is about playing tricks, l will have to get into his tricky mindset mode to convince him that l have learnt something in the last past 4 months.

Otherwise, the paper looked daunting at 1st sight. I wrote something though.
Former userFormer user13y ago#75
Got confused by the details of the breaking down of Hinny NCI 20% fv 255 , other % s with values and impairment measurement. I could not deduce what that meant really.
Ccazza9913y ago#76
Hi All
I didn't impair the subs at all in q1. Got 190 & -22 for goodwill.
Q2 & Q3 advised to treat green certs as financial instruments per IFRS9 as active market.
Finance lease on the waste vehicles.
Spoke about joint arrangements, JV's, JO's and determined that it was a JO as control had been lost.
Tax adj-said it should have been disclosed in prior year that there was an issue and adj should not have been a prior year adj as no error or change of policy had occurred.
Foreign currency-brain dumped rules for translation and gain loss (!!)
Land-said one should be FV thru p&l or Oci.
Empty land held at FV thru Oci as not part of general ops
Land held as inventory to be re-classified and held at Am cost as revenue generating.
Environmental damage-said Cont Liability exists under old and new IAS/IFRS as stated almost certain that legislation would be passed, and company had begun clean up on other sites so created expectation. Need to assess cost and provide. Need to Disclose aswell.
School-$5m cost 12 years dep = $2.4 nbv. Need to impair down to $2.1m as value in use is unrealistic.

Hope I wrote enough. B/S didn't balance so def screwed something up there.
Was surprised as everyone about Cashflow and had just about nailed those in revision :(
Fingers crossed for everyone xx
Former userFormer user13y ago#77
Fingers crossed~ I picked Q3 and Q4. Q1 didn't do well in impariment and non-current asset held for sale....Q4, didn't do the calculation.
Former userFormer user13y ago#78
Overall i think the paper was a fair paper was expected a tougher one but i really messed it up....messed up quiet a bit for ques 1, balance sheet didnt tally by $501m, and yes i remember, just had a nightmare :)
-i got only bower impaired, cant remember by how much (however from what i remember directors believed intangibles were impaired, so I impaired the goodwill and then forgot to combine it together with the other intangibles on the face of SoFP) i also forget to compute goodwill on puttin associate..only computed the increase in investment, i messed up on IFRS5, didnt adjust to carrying value and i put it as two line on face of SoFP instead of one...was so looking forward for a SoCF, esp given its been several SoFP over the exam sittings. I didnt even know which 1s to add back...oh my god i really messed up.
b)Discussed criterias for IFRS5 and some make up reason why regulators would be skeptical
c)I discussed a little bit on ethics but really didnt knw how the accounting issues would arise

-i went over the hardcore standards for P2 such as IFRS2,IAS19,etc, just briefed through the other standards which came up, so i plainly got confused bout most accounting treatments which i attempted in q2 & q3

q2)Briefly described the standards without much consideration of accounting treatment:
-IAS 20-grants for the green certificate (but messed up on explaining the treatments)
-IAS21-foreign currency+treatment in cashflow
-left third one
-IAS 8-prior year errors not to be made (not sure bout that)

q3)also briefly discussed standards
-IAS40 for capital appreciation, got confused bout others and left it out
-IAS17-finance lease for lessor
-IAS37-provisions, i said no provision because i felt that there was no present obligation at year end, and no reasonable estimate of cashflow (but there are mixed views so really not sure)
-IAS36-impairment, I also got a little calculation to write down to $2.1m however, ran out of time to further explain
Ccardine13y ago#79
Quote:
The paper was very tricky!!!!!!!! I have calculated Goodwill, and there is a discount on purchase which I take to RE's immediately and the remaining to NCA's. Let me advice you ALL do not underestimete the depth of this paper; it was very details. We're to prepare for ACCA because they need cash, so the exam will never be walk-over!!! Get the facts in your head!!!!!!! Any way, I was able to attempt the required questions: 1, 3 and 4. I did not balance the SoCFS, but as a good accountant you open a suspense account and book the balance.
You must also note that due to the time pressure, you can mis-calculate, by imputting the wrong numbers in the calculater - that is the devil work. JEHOVAH prevail over his evil.
In everyting we do, please ask the heavenly father for his devine guidence, he his here for ALL of us.
Best wishes to those who will do P1 and great success in your results.

Merry Christmas everybody!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Llsoltobaeva13y ago#80
@cazza99 said:
Hi All
I didn't impair the subs at all in q1. Got 190 & -22 for goodwill.
Q2 & Q3 advised to treat green certs as financial instruments per IFRS9 as active market.
Finance lease on the waste vehicles.
Spoke about joint arrangements, JV's, JO's and determined that it was a JO as control had been lost.
Tax adj-said it should have been disclosed in prior year that there was an issue and adj should not have been a prior year adj as no error or change of policy had occurred.
Foreign currency-brain dumped rules for translation and gain loss (!!)
Land-said one should be FV thru p&l or Oci.
Empty land held at FV thru Oci as not part of general ops
Land held as inventory to be re-classified and held at Am cost as revenue generating.
Environmental damage-said Cont Liability exists under old and new IAS/IFRS as stated almost certain that legislation would be passed, and company had begun clean up on other sites so created expectation. Need to assess cost and provide. Need to Disclose aswell.
School-$5m cost 12 years dep = $2.4 nbv. Need to impair down to $2.1m as value in use is unrealistic.

Hope I wrote enough. B/S didn't balance so def screwed something up there.
Was surprised as everyone about Cashflow and had just about nailed those in revision :(
Fingers crossed for everyone xx


Amazing! My answers are almost the same as yours! Lol! I thought I screwed up and now not sure I it is good that someone thinks like me, haha. Maybe I'll get some marks! Good luck!
Former userFormer user13y ago#81
Q1 would be my saviour;
I didn't impair my goodwill, wrote off the 50m impairment of sub-sub completely from intangible assets,separately disclosed the assets n liabilities as discontinued operations, expensed 9m intangible assets, wrote off 2m to other component of equity,
Q2 was tricky;
Discussed government grants,
Finance lease, etc
Just scribbled few sentences down
Q3 was better;
Investment property, inventory, impairment
I still have to pray hard to score atleast 50 to pass this dreadful paper.
Bbernardspyii13y ago#82
I had a terrible time cos I had morlar tooth decay and ached through the morning till almost exam over, even though after taking the medicine from pharmacy without prescription. Hell to me this exam is worst nightmare. Could not see or hear things clearly, and worst of blur and giddly headache, wondered why it was happened like that. Questions were tricky, but if not sick, I think I could still mmanage. Oh goosh! don't blame anything for it could not be saved. Try again.
next sitting.
Former userFormer user13y ago#83
I'm totally screwed. I'm sure coming back next year.
Former userFormer user13y ago#84
I feel the paper was quite OK compared with other recent p2 questions. Qs 3 and 4 were quite good for me. I had a strong hunch for IFRS 13, fair value - and I guessed right. Q1 on vertical group was loaded with adjustments. Had a go at most of the adjustments and showed my workings but could not complete the consolidated SFP. Q1 (b) and (c) on asset held for sale and discontinued operations/ ethical issues on a planned disposal were generally fair as well. Sure of a pass in this. Best wishes to everybody.
Eenigma2813y ago#85
Question 1
a) CSOFP: Went good, but couldn't calculate the impairment, left the whole adjustment though did 2 lines working but didn't include in the CSOFP. (examiner says to omit 1 entry, that costs only 2 marks0
b) IFRS 5: Had full command on the standard so went good.
c) Ethics, It went alright.

Question 2
---> I went totally blank on it so didn't even read it in full

Question 3
a) IAS 40, IAS 2, IAS 16
b) IAS 17 - Finance Lease
c) IAS 17 - Operating Lease
d) IAS 16
Overall went good.

Question 4
ai) I knew the standard definition in IFRS 13
aii) I knew the three level hierarchy, tried to explain
b) It went okay, but not too sure if it was right, hoping to score 5/10 for this part.

Over all it was OKAY, hoping to get a PASS!
Eenigma2813y ago#86
And oh, some IAS 37 was there too in Ques 2, c) and provision was for lessor.
Former userFormer user13y ago#87
Q3 The waste disopsal vehicle at first I thought it was a finance lease as the council can obtain title if the Outsource company went under but then thought it didnt give any other information i.e. who pays for repairs etc so I put Contingent Asset... Looking at everyone elses I should have gone with my original thought :(
Former userFormer user13y ago#88
easy paper as i think so
for q1: after finding out goodwill for both sub and sub subs, i calculated impairment for both subsidiary and sub subs as well, similarly calculated inivestment in associate by taking reseves at acq amount i,e deducting 18 from 21 and reserves at closing date and then multiplied by relevant holding percentage in order to get shares in post reserves and then added it in cost of investment of associate in order to obtain investment in associate;s amount. similarly calculated nci for both bower and henny as well. then move towards consolidated reserves for minny and then finally consolidated SOFP . it didnt telly by only 200 :D
Ppt13y ago#89
The paper is ready to donwload now.

https://www.accaglobal.com/en/student/qualification-resources/acca-qualification/acca-exams/p2-exams/exams-p21/int-stream.html
Mminiclaire13y ago#90
question 2 went really well for me, ias 2& 20 for the green certificates, qualify for grants ias 20 & certificates not sold by end of accounting period ias 2 inventories.
ias 7 translation of foreign exchange rates.ias 8 and ias 12, ajustments arising from tax audits, prior period error rather than as achange in estimate under ias 8, amount arising from impact of derecognising a deferred tax asset ,in respect of the release of corporation tax accrual from tax settlement represents tax expense separately disclosed with ias 12.
think the other bit was ias 27 control of subsidiary.
q1 attempted all but balnce sheet was out loads!!!!!!!!
q4 first part was fine ifrs 13, but second part was not good, hoping for apass!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.