Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** P2 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 P2 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** P2 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results


Please note: Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening.
Former userFormer user13y ago#1
question 4 : how to calculate fair value?
Former userFormer user13y ago#2
Oh my goodness, so much writing!
Former userFormer user13y ago#3
Q1. Statment of financial position( Complex Group) with IFRS 5 and Ethics..
i was relying on main stream standards of p2....cant believe no Question on finanical instruemnt or sharebased employe benefit.....:( :(
Theres always next time..cheers
Llsoltobaeva13y ago#4
How could they make sofp again? I wasn't morally prepared to this idea. :)

What a stupid question regarding green certificates? Which standard was implied here?
Former userFormer user13y ago#5
for the green certificates i write about grant :D lol desperate answer :)
Former userFormer user13y ago#6
i also wrote Govt grant for green certificate....hope its right :(
Former userFormer user13y ago#7
I didn't do the impairement test properly which meant I didn't impair neither bower nor heeny and I forgot to measure the line of business held for sale at the lower of C.A and F.V less CTS, included it in the SOFP in current assets and current liabilities at carrying amount :( I hope these 2 mistakes won't cost me a lot of marks.
Aathey8313y ago#8
P2 Dec12 = train wreck :(
Think I may have done well on q1 and q4 part a not sure about part b. Picked q2 and basically just clutched at straws al the way through. Likened green certificates to derivatives, and didn't includes cash equivalents not in presentation al currency in the cash flow??
Decided subsidiary was now an associate based on test of control but explanation felt rushed

Over all I didn like it, though it tested too many nitty gritty areas of the syllabus for a lot of marks and wasn't as specific with requirements as past papers.
Former userFormer user13y ago#9
@skull said:
i also wrote Govt grant for green certificate....hope its right :(


any idea if it was ias 18 coz that was his main source of income? Sort of him selling the certificates and electricity?
Former userFormer user13y ago#10
Amazingly Easy paper. Managed well ... Lengthy but was fairly manageable. Balance sheet Tally first time in my life. ... Almost was a distinction if fair value calculation in Q 4 could have asked for something else... :).... Cheersss....
Former userFormer user13y ago#11
I though cash flow gonna come.. But the other round... Too bad
Former userFormer user13y ago#12
@hamzahmoazzam said:
Amazingly Easy paper. Managed well ... Lengthy but was fairly manageable. Balance sheet Tally first time in my life. ... Almost was a distinction if fair value calculation in Q 4 could have asked for something else... :).... Cheersss....


Well done
Former userFormer user13y ago#13
@lsoltobaeva said:
How could they make sofp again? I wasn't morally prepared to this idea. :)

What a stupid question regarding green certificates? Which standard was implied here?


Hi there, I also didn't expect SOFP was out again, had been working very hard on Consol. cash flow but ended up.... T_T

Next sitting, I'm coming~
Jjay1413y ago#14
mixed views here..funny but totally blanked out in question 1...not from not knowing it..but from confusion.....just hope my workings gain me some marks!
Former userFormer user13y ago#15
hamzahmoazzam said 9 minutes ago:
Amazingly Easy paper. Managed well … Lengthy but was fairly manageable. Balance sheet Tally first time in my life. … Almost was a distinction if fair value calculation in Q 4 could have asked for something else… …. Cheersss….

Quote | #


What did it tally at if you remember please?
Former userFormer user13y ago#16
Not as bad a paper as I though even though I was hoping for cash flows!

Q1) Was ok but I miss read the question and treated the two subs as as subs of parent rather ran 1 sub and one sub sub. Any thoughts on how many marks I will lose for than and follow up marks?

Q2) A few odd bits- I treated the green cetificates as assets and gov grants ie Dr asset Cr Gov grant (deferred income).
Finance lease for the vehicles
Sub should be equity accounted as JV as didnt actually have control
Tax adjustments- not sure

Q3
Didnt think this was too bad at all.

All in all not too bad- just gutted I didnt read the question and get the sub sub!
Ffaizan13y ago#17
question one was about SOFP with standard goodwill and 4 adjustments with B being about IFRS 5 mainly why held for sale needs to meet crtieria tht sale is highly probable and sale in present condition? C dont remember

2 was good green certificates I wrote about IAS 18 and contingent asset then there was about a foreign currency question relating to loss and how it should be treated in financial statement.

3 was about the samething in question 2 but different IAS there was one about lease where the company outsourced the waste disposal who bought trucks and it would be treated as lease as they would work for the company their whole life and if the outsourced company ceased trading it would go to blackcutt (yes i remember the name :P)

Over all only one question with calculations Q1 and the rest all theory. I'm 50/50 on it as i might not score high plus my BS didnt balance :(
Eeoglasain13y ago#18
I did not do well at all.
Question one looked so easy and short but there was serious detail in there.
Question 2 was tough and then I wrote only a little for a third question. Knew it wasnt my day from the off.

That was such a Theory paper. Everything said ''Discuss''

Will be focusing almost completely on theory next time.

I had the same trouble as everybody with the Impairments and such. A real missed opportunity I think though
Former userFormer user13y ago#19
In question 1 for the inpairment. I got that only one sub was impaired - Heeny and inpaired intangible assets by 14. Anyone else get this?

Also treated the green certs as gov grant that are recognised as reducing the cost of the electricity as they are sold? thoughts?
Former userFormer user13y ago#20
didnt think it was too bad at all

1) small parts were confusing...
the associate didnt state whether profits accrued evenly so i just left it at 48m....reclassified the dividend to retained earnings...

i got a 50m impairment on the sub-subsidiary...

messed up the write down of assets held for sale as the liability confused....

2 and 3) we pretty similar just different ias/ifrs just wrote what i could for each one...the tax adjustment on the last part of 2 was a bit confusing...

there were lots of easy marks to be had though...think i may have done enough for a pass...

disappointing chunks of syllabus not tested at all....share based payment, employee benefits, financial instruments!!!, deferred tax, related parties, op segments,...very strange...

roll on feb hey
Bbenitez13y ago#21
Disaster! Q4 Trades in Australasian sector - what was expected here?

Also, the FV of a the decommissioning provision. Used gov bonds to discount but other %s ??
Rrk8513y ago#22
Wish I didn't follow any exam tips from anyone! I would have done Q1 better if I didn't!
CFCute Friend13y ago#23
Consolidated cash flow was xpected ..tricky n lengthy paper ....
atleast i wasnt xpected CSOFP this time from Holt..
i wasnt sure about the impairment in Q 1 but for B it was about 160 and for H it was about 9

and for Q 2 for green certs i applied IAS18 , i thought the certificate was for trade purpose and the main source of income as well .

i am hoping for the 50 marks .......
Former userFormer user13y ago#24
Paper was easy nd managable in given time....
Llsoltobaeva13y ago#25
1) I didn't get the impairment part. Per my calculation assets weren't impaired, hihi.
Assets held for sale (PPE+inventory-liabilities) vs recoverable amount of $30. The difference went to P/L, not sure if it's correct.
2) I linked green certificates to financial instruments and/or assets held for sale. I think it was stupid of me :)
Tax adjustment - linked to subsequent events after reporting date. I said that it was non-adjusting event bu should be disclosed. What do you think?
3) Blackcutt - vehicles should be owned by it and leased to Waste Co. Right?
Warehouse- contingent liabilities on clean up of land shoul be disclosed. No provision needed because the legal document didn't come to force as at the year end. Who else thinks so?
What about plots? I said they are investment property and valued at fair value. And those for sale as assets held for sale.
What about housing rental to low-income people? Did it imply some discounting?

What else was there?
Llsoltobaeva13y ago#26
By the way I am gonna write a negative review on exam room conditions. Almaty, KZ exam centre sucks at organization!!!! Rooms were hot ! No air conditioning! No water was supplied this time (was supplied in June). I was really uncomfortable sitting there.
And, hey, rest rooms were shared, I mean guys and girls to the same rest room. What a shame!!!!
Ffidget13y ago#27
@tajinder2222 said:




i got a 50m impairment on the sub-subsidiary.



So did I. So that's good to know somebody else got the same!
Former userFormer user13y ago#28
Q1: Whooaa,, amazing one, I managed to create the dbl entries of all the adjustments but still got a difference of exact 10m :D ... dunno where it wnt wrng, there was imparment resulting for Henney only. IFRS 5 required general discussion as to give details for the criteria of recording the asset under IFRS 5. Ethical issues and accounting implications for subsidiary selling property lower than the market vale to its parent ( I implemented IAS 24 here :P )
Q3: In my opinion, IAS 16 for letting property and collecting rents, IAS 40 for holding lands for capital appreciation, and IAS 2 (which was a pure blunder :() for buying and selling i.e. trading of properties. IAS 17 finance leases for vehicles used for carrying waste, that was provided by Waste Co. IAS 37, for disclosing the event in notes as there was no reliable estimate of wht is gng to be paid by buckcutt. IAS 16 for school and I guess the cost for converting in library will be expensed as there is no increase in the performance of the asset.
Q4: Principles relating valuing assets under IFRS 13. Hierarchy for levels under IFRS 13. I didnt understand the 2nd part at all , what were we supposed to do, what was specifically asked?? no hint to fair value all the markets or only australian,,, :D
Cheers.
Former userFormer user13y ago#29
@fidget said:
So did I. So that's good to know somebody else got the same!

I got 50 impairment also and none on bower but I think I has goodwill of 190..
How did you treat the impairment?
What about question 3 I got confused and part b of q4 wasn't sure of decommissioning...
Former userFormer user13y ago#30
I also treated green certificate incentive as grant goverment. Not have time to touch Q2 part d. I don't know how to calculate fair value for the decommission liability in question 4 also.
The exam was not really hard but I was not good at time management, wish that I could have more few minutes. Just cross fingers for 50 marks !!!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.