Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** P2 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 P2 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** P2 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results


Please note: Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening.
Former userFormer user13y ago#31
Question 1 - D shaped group + acquisition of associate (effective holding 70%,56% and 30% associate) - How did you guys calculate the goodwill impairment? for Bower and Heeny??
Q3 i desperately attempted it :) There was IAS 17 in the truck bought for Blackcutt but otherwise the question is tooooo vague....Q4 a ok - was about IFRS 13 impairment and expected losses and Level 1,2,3 got it right..didnt attempt question 4b..No time!!!
I think the examiner is too hard and don't like us to pass..!!
Ffidget13y ago#32
@lsoltobaeva said:
1) I didn't get the impairment part. Per my calculation assets weren't impaired.



I had to do that calculation again. The first time there was no impairment per my caluculation either, but the tone of the note was suggesting that there was, and reading it again, it mentioned the given recoverable amounts not including total liabilities for either of them, so I did the calculation again taking the total liabilities for bower & heeny off the given recoverable amounts, leaving me with a $50m impairment for heeny, which sounded good, so I went with that. Whether it's right or not remains to be seen. lol!
Former userFormer user13y ago#33
deceptively hard paper, seemed easy by glancing but looking at it in more detail was tricky it seems exams are all being theory based, very little calc nowadays. was expecting cash flows too and financial instruments didnt come up. missed oppprtunity for me im afraid, ran out of time.
Former userFormer user13y ago#34
hi admin....
is it necessary to mention the IAS number or name for the treatment in the exams... Or u think by treating the scenario appropriately with the regulations of the International Standards without mentioning say, IAS 17 or IFRS 5, is acceptable??
Ttopoftherock13y ago#35
@stuartkelly took the words out of my mouth
Former userFormer user13y ago#36
@emz168 said:
I got 50 impairment also and none on bower but I think I has goodwill of 190..
How did you treat the impairment?
What about question 3 I got confused and part b of q4 wasn't sure of decommissioning...


I have got 190 goodwill for D and 8 goodwill for the other.

50 impairment attributable to :

35m intangible asset
15m Goodwill.
Former userFormer user13y ago#37
@taofinal said:
I have got 190 goodwill for D and 8 goodwill for the other.

50 impairment attributable to :

35m intangible asset
15m Goodwill.


exactly what i did too...

i though i double entried everything but still ended up with a difference...

my goodwills are the same as yours too...
Llsoltobaeva13y ago#38
Q1 - the structure of the group wasn't D shaped! The parent (M) didn't have direct holdings in heeny.
Jjay1413y ago#39
since everyone is on here..pls remind me how they award marks to workings shown...
Ffidget13y ago#40
@emz168 said:
I got 50 impairment also and none on bower but I think I has goodwill of 190..
How did you treat the impairment?
What about question 3 I got confused and part b of q4 wasn't sure of decommissioning...


190 sounds familiar as well for goodwill in Bower. I allocated the impairment 56% group (taking it off group retained earnings), and 44% deducted off NCI.

I didn't do question 3. The only bit I might've had a chance with was the vehicle lease. So I went for Q2 instead. Q4 I did, and part (a) was fine. Wasn't really sure what to do with part b), so did a random calculation using the unit volume and selling price to show a full fair value of each sector - excluding the transaction costs, then advised that the valuation to be used would need to be the australasian one since it's where the company did all its buying and selling. Excluding the transaction costs was the right thing to do I think.. the rest was a stab in the dark.

Similarly with the decommisioning. I based a calculation on the labour cost, overheads, inflation and industry mark-up, and said the rest wasn't allowed in the calculation. Again, a stab in the dark as I didn't know.

Still.. part a) was worth 13 marks I think, so if I get another couple of marks for the rest of it, I'd be happy! :)
Bbenitez13y ago#41
How many marks do you reckon the impairment calcs were worth in Q1
Former userFormer user13y ago#42
@fidget said:
190 sounds familiar as well for goodwill in Bower. I allocated the impairment 56% group (taking it off group retained earnings), and 44% deducted off NCI.

I didn't do question 3. The only bit I might've had a chance with was the vehicle lease. So I went for Q2 instead. Q4 I did, and part (a) was fine. Wasn't really sure what to do with part b), so did a random calculation using the unit volume and selling price to show a full fair value of each sector - excluding the transaction costs, then advised that the valuation to be used would need to be the australasian one since it's where the company did all its buying and selling. Excluding the transaction costs was the right thing to do I think.. the rest was a stab in the dark.

Similarly with the decommisioning. I based a calculation on the labour cost, overheads, inflation and industry mark-up, and said the rest wasn't allowed in the calculation. Again, a stab in the dark as I didn't know.

Still.. part a) was worth 13 marks I think, so if I get another couple of marks for the rest of it, I'd be happy! :)


I take the 35m impairement and split into nci and RE of parent but the 15m I give it totally to parent - full goodwill method? Am not sure :(
Llsoltobaeva13y ago#43
@benitez said:
How many marks do you reckon the impairment calcs were worth in Q1

Probably 6 marks.
Former userFormer user13y ago#44
I messed up in attributing impairment, I thought per ias 36 impairment had to go first to goodwill and then to assets pro rata woops hopefully will pick up some marks
My balance sheet was out. I think I did not account for ifrs 5 correct... I spoke about criteria for ifrs 5 in part b and c I wrote about related parties and I also mentioned the accoUnting policy change although not sure that was correct.
Ffidget13y ago#45
@jodukwe said:
since everyone is on here..pls remind me how they award marks to workings shown...


I think you'll need to wait til they publish the answers online. It's difficult to say how much marks they they've allocated to each working.
Bbenitez13y ago#46
@fidget said:
I think you'll need to wait til they publish the answers online. It's difficult to say how much marks they they've allocated to each working.
6 impairment
Aathey8313y ago#47
Did anyone else only get 23 for the goodwill of Sub subsid? As a consequence i only realised 23 of the impairment, did any one else end up in this situation?
Ffidget13y ago#48
@taofinal: hey, don't be doubting yourself! I just treated the impairment in the way I did because I thought that's what to do with it. Could be completely wrong! :)
Ffidget13y ago#49
@athey83 said:
Did anyone else only get 23 for the goodwill of Sub subsid? As a consequence i only realised 23 of the impairment, did any one else end up in this situation?


Yes, I got 23 for goodwill of the sub-sub as well. I wrote off the whole impairment of 50 though 56% group retained earnings and 44% NCI purely because the whole impairment came from the sub-sub. In hindsight, I'm thinking that's a bit too easy to be right. :)
Former userFormer user13y ago#50
I also got 23 for goodwill for sub subsidiary.then I added 595 (total assets) and the 23 and took away holding value of 604 giving me an impairment of 14 and I took that from intangible assets.anyone else??
Former userFormer user13y ago#51
will did my best i hope for 5o

thanks

all
Former userFormer user13y ago#52
when do they release the solution or even the exam paper, very hard to know how you got on in that exam, did anyone mention intangible assets for the green certs
Nnkhly13y ago#53
Feeling bad....cannot believe no Reconstruction, no Share based payment, no Employee benefits, no Financial Instruments....didn't manage to understand the impairment part of Q1......
Jjohnsnow13y ago#54
Does anyone know how marks are written?
For example if goodwill is 7 marks but I forgot the impairment will I get 0 marks or Will be I awarded some marks (2-3).
Or for example something is omitted from retained earning (full is 6 marks), will I receive marks proprtionally or zero?
Can anyone answer?

If 0, I am finished
Nnevyana13y ago#55
What about the 30m costs in Q1, related to the discontinued operations. I treated them as a restructuring provision as per IAS 37. Not sure if it satisfies all criteria.
Nnevyana13y ago#56
@johnsnow, about 2-3 points to be deducted from all 7, check prior exams marking scheme at the end of the answers on the website
Jjohnsnow13y ago#57
nevyana

thank you.
Former userFormer user13y ago#58
I calculated the goodwill re subsub as a bargain purchase/negative goodwill?! I cant see that anyone else got this....oops!!!

Q2 I didnt know what on earth to write about so I attempted Q3, wasnt sure on how to deal with the plots of land. Applied IAS 17 to the vehicles, and IAS 37 to the environmental issue. Also unsure about the school/library.

Any thoughts on plots and the school?
Former userFormer user13y ago#59
@nevyana said:
What about the 30m costs in Q1, related to the discontinued operations. I treated them as a restructuring provision as per IAS 37. Not sure if it satisfies all criteria.



Im pretty sure the question said they satisfied all the HFS criteria. so they had to be classied as such? As in revalued/no deprec and set as HFS assets and liabilities?
Former userFormer user13y ago#60
@chunky I found very similar to you! I got negative good will for the sun sub think around -22??? Also found similar re: qu 3 and qu 4!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.