FR*** F7 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@gawcram said: 16) I think how much profit attributable to equity holders Is it?Yeah, it was The last was profit for NCI and I got D
@emo777 said: Yeah, it was The last was profit for NCI and I got DYes, I remember it was D
@emo777 said: 1) Control question: choose three option, 45% with others 1% is also control 2) Consolidated revenue question: include parent and post acquisition subsidiary, ignore associate revenue 3) Going concern as adjusting event 4) Grant bakance of 1325 5) Shareholder wealth maximization and roce for profit organizations, non financial goals for non profit organizations 6) Inventory question: lower of cost and nrv, cost was 51600 or smth and it was lower 7) Lease question: overstated by 2000 8) Only acquired intangible asset recognized as intangible asset 9) Only warranty claims recognized an asset 10) the last question 20 answer was D 11) Impairment was straighforward 12 Comparability: disclosure of accounting policies and restatement of past figures 13) Ration question: only second option 14) Capital gesring measures debt structure and risk 15) Deferred tax should not be discounted 16) there was another question on consolidation, dont remember 17) Lower acid test ration in comparison with industry: it was D, buy materials using cashI agree with u on 2,3,5,6,7,10,11,12 Others I don't remember
@gawcram said: I agree with u on 2,3,5,6,7,10,11,12 Others I don't rememberThe first one and the obe with goung concern as adjusting are from IFRS and IAS
@ Christa
the cost was to the subsidiary not parent so u had to get unrealised profit as:
35/135*2.43m=630000
So does anyone else agree that the answer to question 1 should be;
Goodwill:
Consideration on acquisition (W1) 10,800
NCI at date of acquisition ((9,000*40%)*$1.50) 5,400
Sub-total 16,200
Less: Fair value of subsidiary's net assets at date of acquisition (W2) 13,600
Goodwill 2,600
Retained earnings:
Parent's retained earnings 17,200
Group share of post-acquisition earnings -720
Less: PURP on inventory -630
Group retained earnings 15,850
NCI:
NCI value at date of acquisition 5,400
NCI share of post-acquisition earnings -480
NCI at year-end 4,920
@accastudent1986 said: So does anyone else agree that the answer to question 1 should be; Goodwill: Consideration on acquisition (W1) 10,800 NCI at date of acquisition ((9,000*40%)*$1.50) 5,400 Sub-total 16,200 Less: Fair value of subsidiary's net assets at date of acquisition (W2) 13,600 Goodwill 2,600 Retained earnings: Parent's retained earnings 17,200 Group share of post-acquisition earnings -720 Less: PURP on inventory -630 Group retained earnings 15,850 NCI: NCI value at date of acquisition 5,400 NCI share of post-acquisition earnings -480 NCI at year-end 4,920I dont agree with you fv of net assets. It should be: 9000 plus 1200 tax asset minus 2500 fv value plus 8600-1500 as pre acquisition earnings. So, you have 14800 as fv of net assets
@accastudent1986 said: So does anyone else agree that the answer to question 1 should be; Goodwill: Consideration on acquisition (W1) 10,800 NCI at date of acquisition ((9,000*40%)*$1.50) 5,400 Sub-total 16,200 Less: Fair value of subsidiary's net assets at date of acquisition (W2) 13,600 Goodwill 2,600 Retained earnings: Parent's retained earnings 17,200 Group share of post-acquisition earnings -720 Less: PURP on inventory -630 Group retained earnings 15,850 NCI: NCI value at date of acquisition 5,400 NCI share of post-acquisition earnings -480 NCI at year-end 4,920Agree with you on nci, however, again disagree with parent retained earnings. You deducted purp, ok, you deducted 720, ok, u forgot to deduct 6/12 unwinding interest and add gain on equity asset revaluation. You found loss on equity asset revaluation as for subsidiary, thats how you got -1200, but why didnt u do the same for parent?
@emo777 said: I dont agree with you fv of net assets. It should be: 9000 plus 1200 tax asset minus 2500 fv value plus 8600-1500 as pre acquisition earnings. So, you have 14800 as fv of net assetsHere's how i calculated sub's net assets; Date of acquisition Year-end Post-acquisition Share capital 9,000 9,000 - Retained Earnings 7,100 5,600 -1,500 FV adj -2,500 -2,500 - FV depreciation adj -500 500 - FV adj financial asset - -200 -200 13,600 12,400 -1,200
Geshi, its for you. There was a mcq related to exemption from consolidation. I chose 3 options: ultimate parent publishes, shares are not traded and not in the process of issuing
@emo777 said: Geshi, its for you. There was a mcq related to exemption from consolidation. I chose 3 options: ultimate parent publishes, shares are not traded and not in the process of issuing] Can you recall what the 4th option was?
@accastudent1986 said: Here's how i calculated sub's net assets; Date of acquisition Year-end Post-acquisition Share capital 9,000 9,000 - Retained Earnings 7,100 5,600 -1,500 FV adj -2,500 -2,500 - FV depreciation adj -500 500 - FV adj financial asset - -200 -200 13,600 12,400 -1,200The only difference between your 13600 and my 14800 is the fact that u missed deferred tax asset
@accastudent1986 said: ] Can you recall what the 4th option was?Something irrelevant. Like they buy subsidiary to sell it or smth
@emo777 said: Agree with you on nci, however, again disagree with parent retained earnings. You deducted purp, ok, you deducted 720, ok, u forgot to deduct 6/12 unwinding interest and add gain on equity asset revaluation. You found loss on equity asset revaluation as for subsidiary, thats how you got -1200, but why didnt u do the same for parent?Ahhh you're right i should have removed 108 from group retained earnings for the deferred consideration interest :( Regarding the tax asset, you're saying i should have increased the sub's reporting date and and date of acq position by 1,200?
still wondering if actually we needed to use deferred tax asset in the goodwill calculation????
@emo777 said: Something irrelevant. Like they buy subsidiary to sell it or smthNo that's right it was the correct answer as parent can be exempt from preparing consolidated statements if the subsidiary is held for resale (regarded as investment property effectively). I selected that, the parent produces and the shares not publicly traded
@accastudent1986 said: Ahhh you're right i should have removed 108 from group retained earnings for the deferred consideration interest :( Regarding the tax asset, you're saying i should have increased the sub's reporting date and and date of acq position by 1,200?Yes. It will be relieved, so recognize
@accastudent1986 said: No that's right it was the correct answer as parent can be exempt from preparing consolidated statements if the subsidiary is held for resale (regarded as investment property effectively). I selected that, the parent produces and the shares not publicly tradedNo, there is no such a requirement.
There was an MCQ question about consolidated revenue...I think..it was 93.400. What do you think?
@abatesi said: still wondering if actually we needed to use deferred tax asset in the goodwill calculation????Yes. Why not?
@cene89 said: There was an MCQ question about consolidated revenue...I think..it was 93.400. What do you think?Just added parent revenue and post acquisition subsidiary revenue
@emo777 said: No, there is no such a requirement.Just revisited the textbook and this one might be open for debate; "Subsidiary held for resale If on acquisition a subsidiary meets the criteria to be classified as ‘held for sale’ in accordance with IFRS 5, then it must still be included in the consolidation but accounted for in accordance with that standard. The parent's interest will be presented separately as a single figure on the face of the consolidated statement of financial position, rather than being consolidated like any other subsidiary."
Yes, it was 93.400..I think! There was some intra group balance..I think
@accastudent1986 said: Just revisited the textbook and this one might be open for debate; "Subsidiary held for resale If on acquisition a subsidiary meets the criteria to be classified as ‘held for sale’ in accordance with IFRS 5, then it must still be included in the consolidation but accounted for in accordance with that standard. The parent's interest will be presented separately as a single figure on the face of the consolidated statement of financial position, rather than being consolidated like any other subsidiary."They were exluded, then ifrs 5 removed this exlusion
@emo777 said: Just added parent revenue and post acquisition subsidiary revenueYes, it was 93.400..I think! There was some intra group balance..I think..but We should not have calculated with this amounts
@cene89 said: Yes, it was 93.400..I think! There was some intra group balance..I thinkYes, but it was pre acquisiton, so removed by multyplying subsidiary revenue by 6/12
@emo777 said: They were exluded, then ifrs 5 removed this exlusionDamn! I'm loosing more and more points every time i think about the answers i gave!
@accastudent1986 said: Damn! I'm loosing more and more points every time i think about the answers i gave!However, a parent need not present consolidated financial statements if it meets all of the following conditions: [IFRS 10:4(a)] it is a wholly-owned subsidiary or is a partially-owned subsidiary of another entity and its other owners, including those not otherwise entitled to vote, have been informed about, and do not object to, the parent not presenting consolidated financial statements its debt or equity instruments are not traded in a public market (a domestic or foreign stock exchange or an over-the-counter market, including local and regional markets) it did not file, nor is it in the process of filing, its financial statements with a securities commission or other regulatory organisation for the purpose of issuing any class of instruments in a public market, and its ultimate or any intermediate parent of the parent produces financial statements available for public use that comply with IFRSs, in which subsidiaries are consolidated or are measured at fair value through profit or loss in accordance with IFRS 10.*
So, as u van see, nothing related to held for sale
am saying that because i think the deferred tax asset was relating the parent and not the subsidiary,.......

