FR*** F7 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Hello there, anyone could help pls? It would be great to see asap the official solutions for the question before the next exam session...
So when and where will these solutions be available? Thanks
Lets discuss question 2 for who did it.
First question for 3 marks .
I did pbit + ( equity + non current - 9 million) for both 2015 n 2016. *ROCE
I continued on with gpm opm asset turnover. Didn't get to do a 4th. I attempted this in the last 10 min
I analysed from the roce question and noted the differences. Mentioned revenue declined slightly when comparing the periods. I think I also mentioned that this fall was due to the disc op . Since those assets generated revenue. Commented on the differences.I wonder how much marks was allocated to the ratios alone
hahaha. its called passion.
@alanjp101 said: For the contract asset you had to recognize revenue and cost of sale based on the amount of cost incurred to date over the total experience expected cost. The difference being the profit would then be added to the 5000 for contract asset in the sofpIt should not have been added from what I recall
@alanjp101 said: Yeah. I did that and the gain of 3750 is added to the asset in the sofpJonathon is correct - contract asset at reporting date = $8.75m
2 friends who sat the F7 paper said they also got negative goodwill and panicked as a result. Looking at peoples comments here it appears many got negative goodwill so that may be the correct answer.
@zubairakhtar said: 2 friends who sat the F7 paper said they also got negative goodwill and panicked as a result. Looking at peoples comments here it appears many got negative goodwill so that may be the correct answer.Its positive.
Contract asset: 15000 costs to date plus 3750 profit minus 10000 invoiced = 8750 contract asset
Anyone got 3.25 million as grant balance in mcq?
354000 as fonsolidated revenue?
93400 as profit to parent shareholders in consolidation?
51600 as value of inventory?
Seriously, that paper was messed up.Question 3 adjustments threw me off a bit and l calculated Convertible loan note on 300k instead of 30 k only noticed my mistake after failing to balance off and realising the unusually big difference, trying to go back to make corrections was a nightmare l messed up, not sure the marker will see anything clearly. l was not expecting Q1 to be extracts. The deferred Tax asset l think is part of the Subsidiary Net assets at acquisition and at reporting date. My Goodwill was positive.
That paper was just difficult
@brenda112 said: Seriously, that paper was messed up.Question 3 adjustments threw me off a bit and l calculated Convertible loan note on 300k instead of 30 k only noticed my mistake after failing to balance off and realising the unusually big difference, trying to go back to make corrections was a nightmare l messed up, not sure the marker will see anything clearly. l was not expecting Q1 to be extracts. The deferred Tax asset l think is part of the Subsidiary Net assets at acquisition and at reporting date. My Goodwill was positive. That paper was just difficult300k or 30k makes no difference as long as your method is correct
@christa316 said: Lets discuss question 2 for who did it. First question for 3 marks . I did pbit + ( equity + non current - 9 million) for both 2015 n 2016. *ROCE I continued on with gpm opm asset turnover. Didn't get to do a 4th. I attempted this in the last 10 min I analysed from the roce question and noted the differences. Mentioned revenue declined slightly when comparing the periods. I think I also mentioned that this fall was due to the disc op . Since those assets generated revenue. Commented on the differences.I wonder how much marks was allocated to the ratios aloneI calculated the Roce: PBIT/ (Total asset-Current liabilities)
@cene89 said: I calculated the Roce: PBIT/ (Total asset-Current liabilities)I think different methods are acceptable. My calc was; operating profit/(equity + long-term debt)
But I didn't deduct with 9000.
@cene89 said: But I didn't deduct with 9000.I didnt either. But even if we had to, in vase you wrote the formula and calculated other figures correct (besides 9000) i think we should get partial credits
I second your comment. I did not like it at all.
What's the 9000 people are referring to for Q2 .. I used PBIT over NCA less CL and wrote out the formula I was using .. Think you had to add back int to get PBIT.
The gave four ratio's:
Profit Margin - showed it with and without the Dis Op and commented.
ROE - dropped because of lower profits.
Gearing - was up. Think there was a new loan note. Commented that this was prob used to restructure and seen as a better option than issue shares and diluting shareholding.
Current ratio - showed the effects of holding the "assets held for sale"
Concluded by saying that company looking to rectify the situation and possibly taking in the hits this year .. Would need a longer term view blah blah.
Was last question so was fighting the clock.
Thought the paper was okay initially but starting to doubt myself on a lot of the MCQ's. How do people remember their MCQ selections? Do they write them in attendance docket?
lol mike little has already done the workings and goodwill is positive.
The total cost is 24, not 39, first I was confused as well but after reading it again, I realized that it said "total expected cost", not "expected cost to complete."
I also added 2.5 to revenue and increased AR by same amount... additionally, I added the profit from the contract and put a note that I have included the profit in the Revenue since there was no clear direction on where to add it (I mean, we could have added the whole contract revenue to Revenue and then add the whole contract cost to Cost of Sales- to still arrive at the same effect of the profit from the contract...) My statement of financial position was balanced as well, tho' that does not mean I treated all the notes as expected.
Got a positive goodwill of 1.4m or so in Q1... the revaluation loss in the asset reduced the net assets by 2.5m (I have heard quite a good number of students saying they increased the net assets with this value).
Q2... used current ratio, net profit margin and expenses/revenue ratio. I think I did not use gross profit margin as I couldn't link it to the discontinued operations...
And yea the MCQs, kinda came easy (at least, way easier than F8)... buh there was that question of computing NCI or so, which I don't understand where the options came from...lol
Well, I thank God for seeing me through this paper.
Yea, Billy, you're right on the contract asset note... total cost was 24 while revenue was 30
@ gavin23, I have also wondered how people remember their MCQ selections... they probably look through & memorise towards the end of d exam & write out thereafter or as u said, they probably scribble it on the exam docket... #justpondering
@michael01 said: I also added 2.5 to revenue and increased AR by same amount... additionally, I added the profit from the contract and put a note that I have included the profit in the Revenue since there was no clear direction on where to add it (I mean, we could have added the whole contract revenue to Revenue and then add the whole contract cost to Cost of Sales- to still arrive at the same effect of the profit from the contract...) My statement of financial position was balanced as well, tho' that does not mean I treated all the notes as expected. Got a positive goodwill of 1.4m or so in Q1... the revaluation loss in the asset reduced the net assets by 2.5m (I have heard quite a good number of students saying they increased the net assets with this value). Q2... used current ratio, net profit margin and expenses/revenue ratio. I think I did not use gross profit margin as I couldn't link it to the discontinued operations... And yea the MCQs, kinda came easy (at least, way easier than F8)... buh there was that question of computing NCI or so, which I don't understand where the options came from...lol Well, I thank God for seeing me through this paper.I added 2.5 to revenue too but in this caw you should have 500 in current deferred income and 1000 as non current
@michael01 said: I also added 2.5 to revenue and increased AR by same amount... additionally, I added the profit from the contract and put a note that I have included the profit in the Revenue since there was no clear direction on where to add it (I mean, we could have added the whole contract revenue to Revenue and then add the whole contract cost to Cost of Sales- to still arrive at the same effect of the profit from the contract...) My statement of financial position was balanced as well, tho' that does not mean I treated all the notes as expected. Got a positive goodwill of 1.4m or so in Q1... the revaluation loss in the asset reduced the net assets by 2.5m (I have heard quite a good number of students saying they increased the net assets with this value). Q2... used current ratio, net profit margin and expenses/revenue ratio. I think I did not use gross profit margin as I couldn't link it to the discontinued operations... And yea the MCQs, kinda came easy (at least, way easier than F8)... buh there was that question of computing NCI or so, which I don't understand where the options came from...lol Well, I thank God for seeing me through this paper.Remember any of mcqs to discuss?
@emo777 said: Remember any of mcqs to discuss?@ Gvtftf, my assumption was that the customer had only paid 16m, that's why I increased AR with the 2.5m... and then, if the customers are yet to pay, there won't be any deferred revenue... we would only recognise an asset (AR) in subsequent periods as we earn them... I ain't too certain if my assumption is right tho' Earnestly, I can't clearly remember any of them MCQs... trying hard to recollect buh they all seem to be lost in foreverland...lol
@michael01 said: Yea, Billy, you're right on the contract asset note... total cost was 24 while revenue was 30 @ gavin23, I have also wondered how people remember their MCQ selections... they probably look through & memorise towards the end of d exam & write out thereafter or as u said, they probably scribble it on the exam docket... #justponderingIirc, they were asking for the Nci share of profit, so that was working the Nci share in the bottom of the consolidated statement of profit or loss. I.e. Total profit - equity parents share
@samirrules said: Iirc, they were asking for the Nci share of profit, so that was working the Nci share in the bottom of the consolidated statement of profit or loss. I.e. Total profit - equity parents shareDo you mesn the last question number 20??
They asked for value to be added to nci, it was not about profit and loss, it was about getting posr-
@michael01 said: @ Gvtftf, my assumption was that the customer had only paid 16m, that's why I increased AR with the 2.5m... and then, if the customers are yet to pay, there won't be any deferred revenue... we would only recognise an asset (AR) in subsequent periods as we earn them... I ain't too certain if my assumption is right tho' Earnestly, I can't clearly remember any of them MCQs... trying hard to recollect buh they all seem to be lost in foreverland...lolMichael, if u deal with this kind of question, i assumed that 2 million is already included in 16
@michael01 said: @ Gvtftf, my assumption was that the customer had only paid 16m, that's why I increased AR with the 2.5m... and then, if the customers are yet to pay, there won't be any deferred revenue... we would only recognise an asset (AR) in subsequent periods as we earn them... I ain't too certain if my assumption is right tho' Earnestly, I can't clearly remember any of them MCQs... trying hard to recollect buh they all seem to be lost in foreverland...lolRevenue includes an amount of $16 million for a sale made on 1 April 2015. The sale relates to a single product and includes ongoing servicing from Downing Co for four years. The normal selling price of the product and the servicing would be $18 million and $500,000 per annum ($2 million in total) respectively. So, it means that 2 is already included in 16
This is my second F7 attempt, first one got 47, and had some more confidence while working last time rather than this one. This one seemed different from the moment you read through the questions. Compared to previous attempts, MCQs were quite Ok this time; but not Section B. I would like to Highlight one fact, that we spent most of our precious revision time on Cons SOFP, SOCI, Associate and their adjustments; but was quite sad that we didn't get enough questions this time, else it would have been a scoring paper. Quite disappointed with this paper. Question 3 was so different from what we actually practised. To end, I just hope I get my 50%.

