FR*** F7 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
i know exams was crazy even i messed up with contract figures both revenue n cost recognised plus amount due frm customer other that that i hope will be enough to pass.
why $1.2m while they says $500000 pa times 4yrs is 2000000,so from 1 april to 31 march we only recognised $500,000 n remain figure will be deferred liabilities n account entry is debit sales revenue n credity liability ie non current of $1000,000 n current $500,000 .would be easy to discount it but there wa no discount factor ,so how did you get 1.2 as deferred income?
@kelvin469 said: why $1.2m while they says $500000 pa times 4yrs is 2000000,so from 1 april to 31 march we only recognised $500,000 n remain figure will be deferred liabilities n account entry is debit sales revenue n credity liability ie non current of $1000,000 n current $500,000 .would be easy to discount it but there wa no discount factor ,so how did you get 1.2 as deferred income?Because the usual sale price of the product + 4 years servicing was 20m but the sale was made for 16m which means a 20% discount was given on the sale so discount product by 20% (18,000,000 x 80% = 14,400,000) and discount service revenue (500,000 x 80% x 4 = 1,600,000) so totalling 16,000,000 per the question
@accastudent1986 said: Because the usual sale price of the product + 4 years servicing was 20m but the sale was made for 16m which means a 20% discount was given on the sale so discount product by 20% (18,000,000 x 80% = 14,400,000) and discount service revenue (500,000 x 80% x 4 = 1,600,000) so totalling 16,000,000 per the questionOnce again, no. These are separate performance obligations. One is a point of time, one is over some period. So, you are incorrect
Accastudent1986, i think u totally misunderstood this question
@accastudent1986 said: The deferred tax i probably should have offset from current year's tax charge rather than putting in OCI but regarding the deferred income my comment above applies, deferred income would be 1.2m not 1.5m otherwise you are saying that the 4m discount was given on the product and not the servicing element which the question does not confirm. But yes i messed up the question as i misread it but now i fully understand what is being asked. I put deferred tax as non current liability in the exam if i remember rightly but messed it up earlier when i attempted the hybrid paper :(You still dont underdtand the question. It is not a bundle
@christa316 said: But the acquisition revals will not be included in OCI only post evaluations. The reval of the financial instruments would have gone through p&lChrista, what are you writing? :D
I think the revenue should decrease with the 1500, and add back the contract REvenue (30000*0,625)
Where is the Opentuition F7 tutor?:) He would help us:)
Haha you are making yourself look foolish
Ok genius the sale was made for 16m, how much of the 16m was in relation to the product and how much in relation to the servicing?
Watch your words, buddy! I didn't insult you!
Wasn't talking to you Adam
@accastudent1986 said: Wasn't talking to you AdamThen, sorry! :)
Here's what the study text says;
"In relation to a bundled sale, any discount should generally be allocated across each component in the transaction. A discount should only be allocated to a specific component of the transaction if that component is regularly sold separately at a discount."
Here's what the question says;
"Revenue includes an amount of $16 million for a sale made on 1 April 2015. The sale relates to a single product
and includes ongoing servicing from Downing Co for four years. The normal selling price of the product and the
servicing would be $18 million and $500,000 per annum ($2 million in total) respectively"
So without question the scenario described is a 'bundle' sold at a discount (as in sold for less than the usual sale price)
exam was kind of oka. i think i scored well in sectionB. but lost it in mcq. ii wish i clear it. dont wanna go through the full cycle again.
@gavin23 said: Don't see how middle one gives controlRevisit IFRS 10
@emo777 said: Yeah bro, in goodwill calculation, what was your pre acquisition? They had opening retained earnings of 8600 and 3000 loss for the yearI can't remember now i forget the other information in the question but i think it ended up that 1,500 of the loss occurred after acquisition and there were no other adjustments? so 8600-1500
@accastudent1986 said: Remind me what the question said about the deferred tax asset/liability?
@accastudent1986 said: Remind me what the question said about the deferred tax asset/liability?She means q1
@emo777 said: No, there is no such a requirement.
@accastudent1986 said: No that's right it was the correct answer as parent can be exempt from preparing consolidated statements if the subsidiary is held for resale (regarded as investment property effectively). I selected that, the parent produces and the shares not publicly tradedRead this chapter in BPP book, this has been excluded
@emo777 said: Read this chapter in BPP book, this has been excludedI've already conceded on that point we are discussing revenue recognition from Q3
No it is not. . That only pertains to revaluation Increase with a deferred tax consequence. In this case we were asked to ignore. It would have been a credit in the pnl
I am getting confused since it seems people are jumping between 1 n 3 so fast..someone mentioned the increase in the fv instruments for the parent went to oci. Then the revaluations at acquisition also went to oci. I was saying only post acq revaluations go to oci.. But even if... Based on the question the financial instrument was fv through Pn L
Same here..i got a lot of bs
Guys, does someone remember there was one mcq and the forst option there was that gain on revaluation is recognized at the disposal of asset or smth like that. I chose it to be incorrect, who remembers?
@emo777 said: Guys, does someone remember there was one mcq and the forst option there was that gain on revaluation is recognized at the disposal of asset or smth like that. I chose it to be incorrect, who remembers?Was that the one about a previously revalued asset?
@accastudent1986 said: Was that the one about a previously revalued asset?I dont remember exaxtly, but this statemrnt was in option A of that mcq, and i chose it wrong. There were four in toral and i chose two correct options
@christa316 said: I am getting confused since it seems people are jumping between 1 n 3 so fast..someone mentioned the increase in the fv instruments for the parent went to oci. Then the revaluations at acquisition also went to oci. I was saying only post acq revaluations go to oci.. But even if... Based on the question the financial instrument was fv through Pn LSurley someone know the best approach for question 2. I think the points being argued for Q 1 and 3 would make only a mark or 2 different? But theres a 15 mark question not yet discussed
MCQs were hard and confusing. There was even one on absorption costing :S
@yvans said: MCQs were hard and confusing. There was even one on absorption costing :S600000/100000=6 per unit and then multiply by 3000 units
I think the 30 mark question should be faced out from f3.
The 30 mark question should be removed from f7

