PM*** F5 September 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
The target costing question was fairly okay, however the last question threw me off, i didnt have enough time to analyse and re-draft the operating statement. So i just calculated the variance & discussed the performance based on that. Mcq's were long! Cvp analysis was okay too, i was hoping it would to come out as opposed to linear programming since its been 3 yrs it was last examined. This sitting had more discursive questions. Which you would expect for a management accounting paper. Overall it was okay.
Quite agree with everyone about the MCQ's, they seemed really tough this time and took forever, written questions seemed fairer than June 2015 however the minimax question was just horrendous!!
I remember getting £1.12 as well for ABC. Can't believe I made such a silly mistake with relevant costing £110. Lost easy 2 marks. hope they don't prove to be costly :(
@barryhastings said: Quite agree with everyone about the MCQ's, they seemed really tough this time and took forever, written questions seemed fairer than June 2015 however the minimax question was just horrendous!!I'm glad I'm not the only one who didn't get the minimax regret question. I've got a degree in maths, for what it's worth!
what answer did you get for relevant costing? i had 40. i dont know if its correct
so was this a 94 marks exams am i right?
Hey can I know how you get the 5.8 - 1.6 as your contribution? I did it the same way with you but I remember my contribution was 3 point something. Do you remember any figure like this? I use selling price minus the cost of production.
@hoangduchung1903 said: Yes, I got 600 with a regret of $180Can you remember what's your contribution?
Dear God, I need miracle. Please give me 51%.
can anyone tell exactly what topics were tested in the paper? plz
@yuemin said: Can you remember what's your contribution?Contribution per unit sold : $5.20 - $1.80 = $3.40 First I set up a payoff table for each possible daily demand and each possible daily supply For example : If supply is 500 and demand is 500 : contribution = (5.20 - 1.80) x 500 = $1,700 This amount is the same for demands of 550, 600, 650 If supply is 550 and demand is 500 : contribution = 5.20 x 500 - 550 x 1.80 = $1,610 And so on for other combinations of supply and demand.....After that I set up a regret table based on the payoff table
On the selling price I got $20. 35-0,01(1500). Not so sure though. This sitting gave me headache
Unbelievably hard Acca understand the situation differently, that is very bad reputation for AccA, section B in second I thought I'm not in F5
I think it too. The price is 40. Lost contribution is opportunity cost
can anyone tell exactly which topics were tested in the paper? plz
@gawcram said: Anyone got 650 for the minimax question?I got 500 but I think my calculations were incorrect, struggled with the question.
@goddey90 said: what answer did you get for relevant costing? i had 40. i dont know if its correctYes I did to, as lost contribution. hope it's right as need every mark possible.
I got 40 too(10hrs*$4 lost control)
I agree with you all, F5 paper focused on cringe topics would you agree?
10 marks on TVM (3 E's) like not being funny but this was not covered with college provider. Section A and B were alot trickier than past sitting and specimen paper.
Definitely think I be retaking in December which is not ideal.
If anyone sat the exam at Tottenham Hotspurs why were students allowed to eat chocolates during the exam, it strictly said NO FOOD IN EXAM HALL !!
Good luck to everyone.
@yuemin said: Can you remember what's your contribution?Hi, This question was terrible. It made no sense to me but my contribution was £3.20 or £3.40 I can quite remember anymore but I had picked 600!
Looks like pass rates for ACCA are falling because ACCA are experimenting too much and making exams harder to pass, perhaps they need more retake fees. No wonder a lot more people are choosing CIMA now in UK. At my work place CIMA/ACCA split is like 75/25, and this is surprising because I work in a bank in London. We regularly get CIMA reps coming in giving presentations and nearly all new starters at my work are choosing CIMA.
can anyone tell exactly which topics were tested in the paper? plz tell me....
Target costing, sales variances, value for money, cvp, risk n uncertainty .... Forgot others
were you guys provided with graph sheets. In Ghana there were no graph sheets.
thanks a lot...lisaiita
You are welcome
For the variances question, what sort of answers did we have for part b? The performance of the company and sales manager?
I completely rushed this as I ran out of time.
My answer included planning being somewhat uncontrollable, operational being controllable.
I related it to part a) but my part a answers were wrong :(. Think I lost a lot of marks here.
@jimbob1212 said: For the variances question, what sort of answers did we have for part b? The performance of the company and sales manager? I completely rushed this as I ran out of time. My answer included planning being somewhat uncontrollable, operational being controllable. I related it to part a) but my part a answers were wrong :(. Think I lost a lot of marks here.I did a bit of basic maths percentages and concluded that the sales manager had done a very good job and the company as a whole was quite good. Very woolly.
Hi All,
I believe exam was a hard one and definitely examiner had a slightly different approach comparing to previous exams. MCQ- I was not sure about 5 questions including advantages of direct vs indirect input? Some mcq there really hard and took long time to get the answer.
MCQ
1-Got £1.02 ABC 0.12+direct cost of 0.90
-Relevant cost got £40 but should be £110 it’s in OT mcq chapter9 q5
-For the goods received notes question : Format check & sequence check
-For the level of information question : Both operational(Tactical should be long term over 5years)
-For motivation picked 2
-Accept both RI and ROI RI= profit 10K less 7.5 cost of investment=accept, ROI= was giving something like 13.3%
-For joint processing question: reject the first and reject the second
-which is MOST LIKELY” to be affected- Government
-On the selling price I got $20. 35-0,01(1500). Not so sure ever.
Part B:
Q1 Target Costing
A-Steps
B-Advantages and Disadvantages for cleaning company if adopted TC
Q2 Minimax regretion/Expected Value/Use of Probabilities
A)
Contribution per unit sold : $5.20 – $1.80 = $3.40
Construct payoff table for each possible daily demand and each possible daily supply
Demand- 500,550,600,650
Supplly
500
550
600
650
For example :
If supply is 500 and demand is 500 : contribution = (5.20 – 1.80) x 500 = $1,700
This amount is the same for demands of 550, 600, 650
Not sure but when supply is 600 and demand 500: 600*(5.20-1.80) less 100*1.80
B) Explanation of EV and adoption of probabilities by flower company
Q3
A- Overall satisfaction of bus company – no idea
B- Comments on directors view- made few points e.g. not enough info, just made up staff
C- Definition of Efficiency and effectiveness followed by one example
Q4
A- Weighted average contribution to sales ratio. Got 0.6092 or 60.92% I did exclude % of fixed labour when calculated contribution
B- Margin of safety in $
C- Draw a chart with not paper provided :)
D- Can’t remember Breakeven point?
Q5
A) Sales variances- redraft
Used two formulas
Sales Volume Variance (ASale – BSale)SProfit/unit
Sales Price Variance (APrice – SPrice)ASales
B) Assess companies and directors performance taking in to account what in country price decreased by 2% but market share increased by 5% and director has heavily invested in advertising.
I do not expect to pass F5 this time. ACCA is designed to be difficult and you should expect to be tested not only in the scenarios from revision kits but overall understanding of performance management, no blame to ACCA at all. This is why it’s well respected qualification.
@siknagudruole said: Hi All, I believe exam was a hard one and definitely examiner had a slightly different approach comparing to previous exams. MCQ- I was not sure about 5 questions including advantages of direct vs indirect input? Some mcq there really hard and took long time to get the answer. MCQ 1-Got £1.02 ABC 0.12+direct cost of 0.90 -Relevant cost got £40 but should be £110 it’s in OT mcq chapter9 q5 -For the goods received notes question : Format check & sequence check -For the level of information question : Both operational(Tactical should be long term over 5years) -For motivation picked 2 -Accept both RI and ROI RI= profit 10K less 7.5 cost of investment=accept, ROI= was giving something like 13.3% -For joint processing question: reject the first and reject the second -which is MOST LIKELY” to be affected- Government -On the selling price I got $20. 35-0,01(1500). Not so sure ever. Part B: Q1 Target Costing A-Steps B-Advantages and Disadvantages for cleaning company if adopted TC Q2 Minimax regretion/Expected Value/Use of Probabilities A) Contribution per unit sold : $5.20 – $1.80 = $3.40 Construct payoff table for each possible daily demand and each possible daily supply Demand- 500,550,600,650 Supplly 500 550 600 650 For example : If supply is 500 and demand is 500 : contribution = (5.20 – 1.80) x 500 = $1,700 This amount is the same for demands of 550, 600, 650 Not sure but when supply is 600 and demand 500: 600*(5.20-1.80) less 100*1.80 B) Explanation of EV and adoption of probabilities by flower company Q3 A- Overall satisfaction of bus company – no idea B- Comments on directors view- made few points e.g. not enough info, just made up staff C- Definition of Efficiency and effectiveness followed by one example Q4 A- Weighted average contribution to sales ratio. Got 0.6092 or 60.92% I did exclude % of fixed labour when calculated contribution B- Margin of safety in $ C- Draw a chart with not paper provided :) D- Can’t remember Breakeven point? Q5 A) Sales variances- redraft Used two formulas Sales Volume Variance (ASale – BSale)SProfit/unit Sales Price Variance (APrice – SPrice)ASales B) Assess companies and directors performance taking in to account what in country price decreased by 2% but market share increased by 5% and director has heavily invested in advertising. I do not expect to pass F5 this time. ACCA is designed to be difficult and you should expect to be tested not only in the scenarios from revision kits but overall understanding of performance management, no blame to ACCA at all. This is why it’s well respected qualification.awesome response, jogged my memory quite a bit. For MCQ I think I disagree with you on quite a few aspects. The ROI question meant that the ROI of the investment was LESS than the ROI of the division, therefore REJECT ROI, ACCEPT RI The tactical decision was regarding future budgeting, Tactical is regarding anything for future which provides support to senior management.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

