PM*** F5 September 2015 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
so difficult..why there is no graph paper provided for CVP?
Why is there no demand given for the Regret Table question? :/ So confused!!!
Why acca didnt provide graph? Or they forgot there is graph
This sitting is way harder than the sitting before. The style of the question change. In section A, there is many lengthy questions. This is not good.
I didn't understand the mimimax regret question as there was no indication of demand. I therefore compared 'no sales' to 'everything sold'. Was that correct?
Does anyone know if for the last question, sales price was used instead of contribution to work out the sales variance, would there be any credit at all or would it all be marked wrong?
Personally I think this sitting was harder than June 2015 and Dec 2014. The questions were generally more towards written and theory-based, less straightforward calculations ones. The scenarios given were also harder to understand thoroughly. Less specific details were given. Could get only 60-65 if I am lucky
Anyone else struggle with the question on weighted average for the percentages of overall satisfaction of the bus company? The question just baffled me for what was only a 2 mark question it was not worded very well and confusing. The problem is it led into the higher mark questions which were discursive based on your answer too this. In real life I would be able to ask for clarification on a requirement if I didn't understand, however here I can only hope that I understood and responded correctly. Maybe I just didn't understand the subject well enough, huh?
Anyone got 650 for the minimax question?
I think acca want to punish students for giving exam in September, this paper simply put was ridiculous. This was my third attempt and even then this seemed harder then all last 3 combined.
13 mcq required calculations which is simply not fair when scenario is half page. they have made it so hard to pass it is beyond belief.
i guess getting all exam fees repeatedly doesn't seem a bad idea for acca..bloddy awful paper
@acaqub said: I cannot remember exactly. I but think it should be 600.Yes, I got 600 with a regret of $180
Does anyone know if for the last question, sales price was used instead of contribution to work out the sales variance, would there be any credit at all or would it all be marked wrong??
Whether an expected value would help. I said no as no probabilities were given!
@acaqub said: It is not worked out in this way. If you assume nothing are sold or all are sold. There is no need to use minimax. You should draw a column for demand 500 550 600 650. You then have to draw a row for the supply 500 550 600 650. For instance, for the first situation: when demand is 500, for supply 500 (500 are sold), 550 (500 are sold and 50 are discarded, so the calculation is 500*(5.8-1.6 my be this figure to get the unit selling profit)- cost of each unit production*50). For the subsequent units, you will be able to calculate. Once you got all figures, for each level of supply, try to get the range.You will then be able to choose the smallest range relating the level of supply that you have toget.Is it like a 2 scenario? One with usual customers (5. 8 selling price) and one with public (7.4 or something selling price) Like normal demand with special contract. So we need to calculate total contribution of both of them I might be wrong
I fully agree with maulik.its a punishment to have taken exam in september.
What about the mcqs?
Is it 2 for the graph in McQ ?
And the tactical and operational question is it first one tactical, and the second one operational?
I have to say that F5 Sep 2015 was tough. Examiner has set MCQ to examin more than one topics within each question. That was very clever. However too long scenarios for MCQs worth 2 marks only made more difficult to manage the time.
Part B was crazy and It felt like questions are open to interpretation.
This exam costs £90 on average and not providing graph paper is just stingy.
What did everyone get for the shadow price one?
And also the selling price where demand is zero?
Revalant costing one, where some labour was refusing to work, for 10 hours?
For the weighted contribution, did we take out the % of fixed cost from labour?
All I know is I came out of the exam hall with a headache! still have them and at work :(
hope you are right because i got 35 too, although it seemed far too straight forward to be correct, so I ended up dwelling on it.
@abuzer said: Hi, to everyone where can I find the suggested answers for MCQ F5 September 2015?The ACCA will not be publishing the whole of the September exam, and not until after the December exam anyway. "With the introduction of the four exam sessions, we will continue to publish the same number of exams, two per year, and at the same times, after the December and June exam sessions. These exams will be compiled from questions selected by the examining team from the two preceding sessions. That is, they will not reflect the entire September or December exam, for example, but will contain questions most appropriate for students to practice. "
@johnmoffat said: The ACCA announced after the June exams that they will no longer be publishing either the exam questions or the answers. Without the questions we cannot provide suggested answers.Hi John Would you be able to answer my question earlier? I briefly mentioned that for sales price/volume variance analysis (for both operational and planning), i used the standard selling price instead of the standard contribution. Would I gain any credit here - it was a 8 mark question :( Thanks a lot!
@acaqub said: MR=35-Q/50 So P=35-Q/100 Set Q=0, P=35110 for relavant cost I think What is the answer for the graph budget difficulty or something is it 2?
@gawcram said: 110 for relavant cost I think What is the answer for the graph budget difficulty or something is it 2?I had 40 for relavant cost, I thought the 70$ was sunk as we would employ then anyway!
And the one about checking the numbers of good received note, the month
Is it range and sequence check?
I can't wait to see what the pass rate is. I'm guessing it will be less than June's 37%! If I don't make it this time (I do think I have probably just scraped through despite having messed up the minimax regret question), I'll give it more one try. If I don't pass then, I quit!
My second time taking this exam and I have to say after all the work I put in I was totally baffled by this paper? The MCQ questions were too long, and Section B was very confusing in parts. Very disappointed with this sitting.
@gawcram said: And the one about checking the numbers of good received note, the month Is it range and sequence check?That's what I picked. I hadn't heard of it, but it seemed the logical answer.
@jamesath said: I had 40 for relavant cost, I thought the 70$ was sunk as we would employ then anyway!Since the labours are on full capacity it is the opportunity cost lost contribution plus variable cost of labour
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

