AAA*** ACCA P7 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
It was hard. More to write but ran outta time.
This exam just driving crazy with time pressure....a lot to write but no time !!. min additional 30 minutes need to complete the exam.
What were the questions this time?
OMG! I found the questions manageable but couldn't do justice thanks to lack of time :(((
Reading takes like 15min so no point in makin the exam 3h15min IMO.
The first question took me like 1.5h and i had like 1.5 hours for the rest . I just messed up quesn 5 as I didn't have time :( Feeling terrible cos it was an easy one on a few accounting standards.
Quesn 1- Business risk & Risk of Matl Misstatement of an airline group company with 4segments . (10*2) , Additional info to evaluate Internal control-4marks & Ethics-7 Marks
Quesn 2- there were 3 cases and we had to evaluate the sufficiency & approp of Audit evidence, list out other procedures to collect evidence and also report on deficiencies of internal control to TCWG.
Quesn3- something on forecasts of cashflow (Left it)
Quesn 4- Had a group audit in which a subsidiary was having going concern issues + disagreement between subsidiary auditor&grp auditor/mgt on modified report (14 marks) + Professional scepticism (6marks)
quesn 5- KAM (8marks) & 3 cases involving possible accounting misstatements (one goodwill impairment, court litigation provision & cant remember the third) - 12marks
(Messed this big time cos of lack of time :( )
Hope to get 50 ! Lets see !
Does anyone know exactly what the additional info was for Q1 c)? I talked about importance of understanding the industry and doing tests of control in inventory but not sure that was the answer!?
I can only agree, time pressure was too bad, I wasn't able to finish the exam, but I think it should still be enough to pass. Q1 was probably too much packed into one question.
time pressure was an issue and 1 was obvious but to pick ethical was had but it was about forensic auditing which had self review, advocacy, independence and conflict of interest.
5 was about recent article KAM
@Guy- Oops that didnt strike me at all. I jus wrote about assessing the competence of internal auditor & reviewing his report and then getting more management representations + board meeting minutes, Inventory control systems etc.. too bad I cant remember much !
Are you allowed provide a forensic investigation for an audit client if they are listed?
@gavin23 said: Are you allowed provide a forensic investigation for an audit client if they are listed?I wrote about the threats, safeguards and how for listed cos Tax&legal services are prohibited etc.. I also said that it'd be better to avoid taking it up to avoid the threats and that in some countries like India(where im from) it is expressly prohibited which means the auditor shd check such regulations also before deciding. My final conclusion was that it'd be recommended to not accept the forensic investigation.
I didn't go into all the threats .. just explained it was a forensic investigation and that our independence would be compromised therefore there was no suitable safeguard. Also wrote that Auditor was prohibited from entering into such an engagement would a listed company .. thought I read that somewhere.
It was a fair paper but time sure was a killer.
Anyone remember the bit about Landing rights in Q1 ... had the company acquired inappropriately - as in not going through the relevant regulatory authority?
Too much going on in Q1 - was very hard to construct a fluent answer in the time. It should have been a 50 marker.
How did you answer question 5 b? Seems like all the treatment was correct. Were they trying to ask us about how this matter should be reflected in KAM and EOM etc?
I think the paper was fair. i have done at least 5 past papers under exam condition so had no issue with the time management. But the result will tell...just hope for the best but left the exam with a feeling that I have done my best and should pass. failed to prepare prepare to fail!
the material risk were landing rights, inventory, loan and derivatives but you see business risks political, ban, internal control, profitability of one company had loss, going concern due government restrictions, derivatives risk, liquidity risk, safely, fuel, reliance of one supplier of air line asset and customer preferences risk
What's about question 4
For the 4 material misstatement risks I put NCA (IAS 16), Borrowing Costs (IAS23), Fin Inst (Hedging) (IFRS 9) and Inventory (IAS 2). Anyone else get anything similar??
for risk of Material mistatment i went with loan,derivatives,landing rights and goodwill(since the government has changed landing slot timings) and revenue of the low cost airlines was decling...:P
i forgot to write about derivatives in business risk
i did mention about self advocacy threat..self review and self interest threat(as it was non-audit assignment) but forgot to mention about forensic investigation
Q5 was bit confusing
@divy32 said: For the 4 material misstatement risks I put NCA (IAS 16), Borrowing Costs (IAS23), Fin Inst (Hedging) (IFRS 9) and Inventory (IAS 2). Anyone else get anything similar??So glad someone else put borrowing costs in. I thought it was a stab in the dark. I also put in about brand names because it said they were operating under three brands so I said they shouldn't have capitalised if internally generated but I was really clutching at straws with that one. I found this exam quite difficult. All the practice questions and mocks I've done have been fine but today i struggled to get enough info out of the scenarios for the marks available.
It is very hard to know at times if you have done well, I ran out of time and ended up writing lines of nonsense near the end, it really is tough to manage that aspect.
Q1 was ok, I found hunting out the business risks not so easy with this scenario.
Q2 quite liked that had seen most of the accounting issues to be audited before.
Q3 Best of the bunch in my opinion. Auditing a cash flow forecast and related party loan from the CEO.
Q4 Looked easy but was a PITA, professional sceptiscm and lack of audit evidence to substantiate going concern. So wish I'd done Q5 as I was red hot on KAM after the examiner article. Probably jeopardised a pass by choosing 4 and not 5
My biggest issue was feeling I hadn't really got into my flow and I knew I could write a lot better than that.
This paper was really different from his past year papers
@dd92 said: So glad someone else put borrowing costs in. I thought it was a stab in the dark. I also put in about brand names because it said they were operating under three brands so I said they shouldn't have capitalised if internally generated but I was really clutching at straws with that one. I found this exam quite difficult. All the practice questions and mocks I've done have been fine but today i struggled to get enough info out of the scenarios for the marks available.Woah! I missed all that. I wrote about segment reporting cos 4 segments were involved(is it right?) , commodity derivatives, Intangibles impairment, non cash transaction, possible material inventory frauds and also abt consolidation risk & loan. I wrote extra actually :/
@riteshgrg82 said: did no one find question number 2 difficult? i know the topic and question were simple, but i wasted 30 mins staring at question 2 trying to think what to write......that question tilted me and put me in time pressure. I found it puzzling not knowing how to start my answer. hated that questionHi5! I was wondering how the break up of marks wud be. shd we write all the 3 aspects to each scenario? I was a bit stuck too with that n then decided to address all the 3 requirements for each case. Such a time killer!!
On Material Mistatenent I got completely thrown off my the non disclosure note at bottom.
They took me away from looking at NCA's and Intangibles and unmentioned opening balances and parts of the consolidation process.
Did mention borrowing costs and Derivitives so may have pulled 2 or 3 marks from the 10. Would have been better leaving Q 1 to the end.
Hello all of.you
Anybofy write these audit risks
Listing issue directors manipulate the fs figures
Ifrs8
IAS 8 oprning balances
new audit client
30million understatment of liabilities and expenses
Business risk
One supplier
Regulations
Issue in buying new runways
Cargo services which effects reputation
Loss in revenue
The exam on a whole was as expected no surprise....but time pressure.... no matter how much you practice and find techniques this don't stand to the exams....question one was messed up....only on doing the other questions could I think of the correct answers......For the amount of things that is required to be written there are too many things to analyse.....Just thinking of how to answer the questions 1 & 2 was enough to throw off the stamina for the exam. I didn't even make use of the figures presented......i was just concentrating on trying to do some in each question before the time ran out.........to read and analyse the question one alone is already half of the time allocated for the entire questions. During the mock exams did well in question 1's but for this exams the Accounting standards used were....not my favorite, Question 2 I can barely remember what it was......Question 5 I think you did have to mention about KAM or EOM but I just mentioned whether or not it was correct and the impact on the audit..........
I agree would have been better off leaving question 1 for last....that was my intention but then didn't want to leave it for last and then ran out of time lol... Missed out completely on the borrowing costs.....and struggled so much for a 4th point for MM.......settled for the inventory theft....but I dont think it was Significant!!!
Way too time pressured, should be another 15 minutes added onto the exam.
Failed to attempt the 4th question, partially my own fault, partially the lack of time in the exam.
Agree with you 100% ... hard to prepare for the real thing & the most annoying thing is you could have aced that paper with a liitle more time as there was nothing difficult in it. That line about not mentioning MM risks that were disclosure related completely threw me off as I started to doubt every risk I came up with. That and trying to use the figures ate into a lot of my time. I had to read that paragraph on the Landing rights about 3 times before I grasp what was happening and I still wasn't sure. Messed up the ethical part too as I thought all non audit engagements are now prohibited for listed co's. I was well over my time at that stage so that was an easy 7 marks left behind. The rest of the paper was fine but only had ten mins on Q4.
Will definitely leave Q1 until last if I have to re-sit as the rest of the paper definitely triggers off more info in your head for Q1.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

