Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** ACCA P3 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin9y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P3 September 2017 Exam

*** ACCA P3 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P3 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA P3 exam below (comments will open after 5pm UK)
EEddie9y ago#61
@eagledave said: Well, Appendix A and B make the case study about 3.5 pages including the questions. I had not seen one like that in the past papers.
Check out 6/13, 6/12, 6/11, 6/10 6/15 its similar in lenght or slightly longer
EEd9y ago#62
@adeoluomosanya said: did Q1 tell us to choose if we were for or against the radical change proposal by TCA for FMC? I dont think I chose a side...
No, it didn’t but the CEO would like to understand the implication of the proposed change and wants to have holistic view of this.. We therefore have to look at the current situation based from the case, the proposed change, and then the impact. So by explaining all this, you have to somehow express your opinion by critical analysis and also we are allowed to disagree and then justify why.
Mmelissa9y ago#63
Time management was also the issue for me. I did 2 , 4 and 1. Think I failed tho.
EEd9y ago#64
@eddienel said: Check out 6/13, 6/12, 6/11, 6/10 6/15 its similar in lenght or slightly longer
It is longer than those plus the topics (although easy to understand) don't usually come up, not in a long case study, cause we usually practise Pestel, 5 forces, etc, or other usual areas which makes it harder I guess. This one is particularly tougher to get into - just my personal opinion of course.
RRana9y ago#65
Dude looking at your answers now i'm pretty sure you passed hahaha I did not think twice about subtracting the costs didn't even occur to me they gave us the contribution figure ugh looking back now i feel like i didn't do well at all. aw well, we can only hope for the best!
@dt1988 said: For Q1 I feel unsure about. For contextual features I always feel a bit unsure, for example, the time element I found hard to relate as I couldn't seem to see any info regarding time constraints! Preservation was also hard as the suggested change was such a major overhaul I couldn't think of what to preserve although just now it occured to me I should have mentioned the quality assurance team perhaps. I also found it difficult to relate financial ratios so tried to throw numbers in with an apendix showing their current performance. Part C of Q1 threw me a bit. I wasn't sure if it wanted me to advise actions to take as well as identify. I started off trying to suggest solutions but in the end gave up and just stated the apparent barriers and how important they were. My biggest fear of Q1 is that I didn't relate it enough to the scenario. Q4 I think was the easiest of all of them. It essentially gave you all the answers without having to think about it. I did the decision tree Q3. I actually drew the whole thing very quickly on the blank page of the question paper, very messy and then re-did this on my paper. I did not subtract the $1.5m costs as we were provided with the contribution figure so all three results resulted in a positive with option 3 being the best. (I also did check if I subtracted this and both option 1 & 2 provided losses which to me didn't make sense). In limitations I questions how predictable and reliable these probabilities and figures were. I also obviously mentioned that they has used an inappropriate model for static growth as this represented the industry as a whole and not themselves. I also mentioned that option 3 had the most amount of estimation and runs the risk of being less profitable if the forementioned occupancy and contribution amounts were less than predicted, although I did not calculate any figures for this. For sources of finance, I was unsure. I literally just mentioned all three, internal funds, debt capital and equity capital and that realistically only equity capital seemed their best option, with risks mentioned about some shareholders gaining too much power.
KKarl9y ago#66
@taftan said: how did you find the exam guys; for me time management was a nightmare!
time management was the undoing of me in the exam I feel. It's a shame as nothing was too difficult, concept wise...but way too much detail in Q1. I couldn't answer part C of Q1. and I missed out on part (b) of Q4 - so dropped nearly 30 marks. Hopefully I got enough out of the rest of the paper! best of luck for you
KKarl9y ago#67
@bjshoko said: I think the ACCA wants the new paper Strategic Business Leader to catch up with us. At this rate we will forfeit our P1s. The paper was tough. Time management hectic. Q1 disaster.
you are not wrong. On my 2nd sitting of P3 amd this one was even harder to pass...despite the very straightforward content. Impossible to pass everything in the time alloted
KKarl9y ago#68
@dt1988 said: I believe it was 4 marks for professional standard. Even without the report format I would imagine that you would gain most marks if your work was structured well and flowed well. How an earth they think that we have the time to do this though. I wonder if most people just do the To/From bit with some headings and then lose all thought process about structure as they try to gain as many marks as possible from the content required.
Haha! That sounds like exactly what I did
KKarl9y ago#69
@eagledave said: Exactly, I was writing so fast and my hands were literally trembling, and half of my mind says, go on you can do it, and the other half saying, you wasted all this time and missed these marks, tsk tsk.. If ACCA wasn't that important to me, I would have just said, oh well, better luck next time, but I realllllyyy prepared for it and was following all techniques and memorised the models..then today happened :) Well, I really hope for a kinder and more flexible marker!
eagle dave your experiences sound exactly like the way my exam went. Uncannily! Just out of interest how many marks do you think you dropped? I was unable to answer part c of Q1 and part b of Q4. I think I must have spent about 25-30 mins just reading and planning Q1. Over shot the runway massively and only had 1 hour and 15 mins left for Q2 and Q4. So disappointing.
KKarl9y ago#70
@darlingboyuk25 said: Th CEO is high interest high power you forgot she has a lot to lose from the project the governing body obviously low interest bout high power and the employers high interest low power
I had it exactly the same
Aandy9y ago#71
Nah I'm fairly sure you're right. Contribution is revenue less variable costs hence why when you calculate break even it's FC÷ Contribution. You need to deduct fixed costs don't worry.
EEd9y ago#72
@kbourne said: eagle dave your experiences sound exactly like the way my exam went. Uncannily! Just out of interest how many marks do you think you dropped? I was unable to answer part c of Q1 and part b of Q4. I think I must have spent about 25-30 mins just reading and planning Q1. Over shot the runway massively and only had 1 hour and 15 mins left for Q2 and Q4. So disappointing.
Honestly? I'd be lucky to get 15 marks in Q1, I just had this sinking feeling as I was writing them but I had to try and push through...Q2 & Q4, although they were easy, I had an hour and 15 mins to attempt both, so you can imagine the quality of my answers and writing...so I wouldn't hope for too much either..:(
SMSTEPHANIE MICALLEF9y ago#73
Having passed all the Fundamental exams with flying colours, I am feeling completely disheartened with the professional exams. The exams are really unfair, all they're testing us is on our speed, not on our professional skills. Giving us at an extra half hour would make all the difference for us to apply the skills we have. P3 question 1 scenario was too long, & for me it wasn't clear as to whether the examiner wanted us to contest the consultants suggestion or otherwise comment about it; I ended up doing a bit of both. I studied really hard & worked a lot of past papers, but honestly left exam feeling really disappointed & angry.. this is just business not testing prospective accountants skills !!
EEd9y ago#74
@sgmic0107 said: Having passed all the Fundamental exams with flying colours, I am feeling completely disheartened with the professional exams. The exams are really unfair, all they're testing us is on our speed, not on our professional skills. Giving us at an extra half hour would make all the difference for us to apply the skills we have. P3 question 1 scenario was too long, & for me it wasn't clear as to whether the examiner wanted us to contest the consultants suggestion or otherwise comment about it; I ended up doing a bit of both. I studied really hard & worked a lot of past papers, but honestly left exam feeling really disappointed & angry.. this is just business not testing prospective accountants skills !!
Same feeling, I wish the examiner is reading all of our feedback and would take it into account when marking our papers.
Bbereank9y ago#75
Gutted! Gutted! Gutted! It was a fair paper but the time pressure was HORRENDOUS. It's a retake for me, I'm afraid. The question 1 scenario was so-o-o long. Felt so disheartened. When I got home I started looking at the ACCA website to see if the new Strategic Business Leader will be any easier. To be honest, I feel like calling it a day; after all I've got ACCA's Advanced Diploma in Accounting and Business ... Rant over :-) Maybe I'll feel better in the morning ...
TTTom Tom9y ago#76
Time pressure an issue for me too. Had to stop at 1:45 on Q1 in order to give sufficient time to do the others. Not happy with what I put but hopefully that with the other Qs will get the magic 50. Went for 3 and 4 - decision tree straightforward enough but messy in execution and SWOT/Ansoff I think was ok too...
Aandy9y ago#77
I did Q3 and Q4. Took one look at all the questions and these definitely seemed like the ones I would get the most minutes per Mark on. Started with Q3, drew up the decision free and only option 3 was profitable after deducting fixed costs which is necesaary as contribution only takes into account variable profits. Obvious problems to mention were: >Option 3 had the most estimation due to increased contribution > they had taken the economic forecast from an financial advisors website- why not government which is much more reliable than a bias advisor > doesn't take account of time value of money- project 3 had big initial costs and it's a 5 year project > decision trees represent a lot run average and bit suitable for one off projects + the outcome isn't a result that could actually happen On to part b) which was about finance and the risks of each > reatined earnings -unlikely to have as been making losses > may be able to obtain from the group as it's a global hotel chain > low risk and cost as the money is there > mention for option 2 wouldn't be a huge cost so more likely to have enough reserves + outflow would be over time Equity- may struggle with share issues due to poor results Dividends required to be paid to satisfy shareholders but this is more flexible than debt finance Debt finance- easiest to obtain > likely to have lots if assets to secure against making it cheaper as less risk to lender >requires fixed cash repayments increasing risk and gearing as these need to be met Anyone else put anything similar?
AACCALady9y ago#78
@hassanatcams said: Well actually for Q1 I did agree that a change was needed in that the co need to incorporate the online selling of products but I disagreed with the business analysts regarding the abandonment of the dealer network and completely moving to an online platform and that was because co was operating in a very niche market with majority of the customers being senior citizens so I disagreed that the dealer based model is scrapped altogether though I agreed that a change was needed but that should be by incorporating the online platform and not by scrapping the dealerships.
Im so glad I read your comment, I thought I did well in the paper considering I analysed all parts of the paper and with the contexual features and popit model but then started to panick as I thoughts they paper wanted as to go against it as they said they wanted a balanced approach (so maybe go against what the consultancy company said) but I basicallt wrote the same answer as you
JAJoyceline ACCA, MSc9y ago#79
This exam was an absolute disaster for me. I am already so depressed, not sure I'll make it. How are we suppose to read through such a long q1? Makes no sense to me. I literally skimmed through the case just to beat time! With only two papers to go, P3 is arguably my most detested paper. Subject content is pretty vague and I find it extremely boring! I just hope I don't get to go through to rewrite this nightmare of a paper! Absolutely demotivated!?
EEddie9y ago#80
@eagledave said: It is longer than those plus the topics (although easy to understand) don't usually come up, not in a long case study, cause we usually practise Pestel, 5 forces, etc, or other usual areas which makes it harder I guess. This one is particularly tougher to get into - just my personal opinion of course.
I don't disagree, it was a bad combination of questions to use in my opinion. Maybe value chain internal appraisal or 5 forces industry analysis and effect of changes with popit might have been better.
JHJi Hwa9y ago#81
Anyone opt Strategic Alliance for Q4 c? Sharing of knowledge, knowhow in overseas market to overcome the lack of experience in overseas. As they hold patents of recipe, it is likely overseas alliance will work with Tramor, especially UTF as the main target market as of now. Cost and benefit are shared. Risk can be reduced and transfered or shared. Anyone reckons this? Thnks
Former userFormer user9y ago#82
7-Sept-2017 is my 9th attempt, and i will take 10th attempt. cheer!!!
JAJoyceline ACCA, MSc9y ago#83
Same here! That was my suggested option - strategic alliance
CChristopher9y ago#84
Yes, time management, but I only had a few marks remaining
Aandy9y ago#85
I went for acquisition for the following reasons; >they had experience of acquisitions >they had no exp overseas and this would effectively be buying it in >the shareholders demanded significant growth on dividends and share price fast -this is the fastest growth model > strategic alliance risks losing core competences >all the directors were approaching retirement and they had no succession planning -acquisition acquires additional directors and increases pool of talent to select new ones from > potential synergies >organic growth would have taken too long the directors wouldn't be there to oversee which ruled that out for me >can't remember the fourth option Essentially in making your choice I think you are supposed to be thinking about which option allows it to best overcome it's weaknesses / threats and use it's strengths
AAde9y ago#86
@angelamalta said: I am fully prepared for a resit for December. I ambitiously entered for P3 and P2 for September even though I only gave birth in May underestimating the effect of a lack of sleep on the old grey matter! POPIT model, I remembered correctly what one of the P's stood for and the IT but the other two could I remember! So plumped for objectives and the other P i now cannot remember! Me thinks that the markers of both my P2 and P3 will have a right good chuckle to themselves when correcting them. Lesson to oneself to attempt one paper at a time, I am not superwoman, and family and health come first! Good luck everyone! Smile!
PEOPLE, ORGANISATION, PROCESSES, IT
Aandy9y ago#87
I argued a merger would lead to cannibalizing our own sales and has strong cultural issues particularly as a different country
AAde9y ago#88
@andyt said: I argued a merger would lead to cannibalizing our own sales and has strong cultural issues particularly as a different country
I suggested a strategic alliance
NNidhi9y ago#89
Quesn 1 involved contextual features (5 features) for 20 marks and then POPIT for 14 marks and barriers to ecommerce for 12 marks. Quesn 2 on mendelow matrix and project mgmt .. Mapping 3 stakeholders - 15 marks and then describing the roles and responsibilities of sponsor and manager for 10 marks. Quesn 3 on decision tree analysis and alternative sources of finance Q4 on ansoff strategy based on the given swot analysis and why market dvpmt was favourable 15 marks and then diff between organic growth, m&a and alliances and to suggest the best one for client 10 marks Overall I was mighty disappointed with myself for the awful time management. The first question took a solid 2 hours . It looked easy at the outset but getting down to the nitty gritty made it hard especially since I Hadn't practised much. I was left with very little time for the other 2 easy questions which ultimately led me to mess up the easiest 4th question big time. God knows what I've managed to write in like 20 mins time. I just hope to scrape through. I really wish the ACCA board increases the exam duration of reduces the question size. I even wrote that in the feedback form which they gave after the exam. It really sucks to come out of the hall knowing it was an easy paper but you screwed it purely cos if time management .. I really am pissed with myself :(( Praying for a pass!!
NNidhi9y ago#90
@jihwalai said: Anyone opt Strategic Alliance for Q4 c? Sharing of knowledge, knowhow in overseas market to overcome the lack of experience in overseas. As they hold patents of recipe, it is likely overseas alliance will work with Tramor, especially UTF as the main target market as of now. Cost and benefit are shared. Risk can be reduced and transfered or shared. Anyone reckons this? Thnks
I wrote the same and I guess this is a totally acceptable answer. Fingers crossed!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.