SBL*** ACCA P3 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
how did you find the exam guys; for me time management was a nightmare!
Me too. Can not do all question. I have just left 30marks. Terrible!!!
How did you answer Q1?
Time was ok thankfully, question 2 and 4 were a godsend! Easy marks for theory and application on the mendelow matrix and similarly for the ansoff matrix... just hoping they will outweigh my question 1 ?
Yeah same. Found Question 1 really difficult with time management. Q4 was very easy. Q2 was easy but ran out of time to answer it with the best of my ability. So hoping that it balances out.
Time management was a huge issue for me. Did the mendelows matrix and the decision tree which I felt I answered quite well. Then tried question 1 and hit such a panic!
Hey, was it option 3 for decision tree?
Aaaa?
I started with a "yes attitude" reading the requirements and once I started going through Section A and then answering the questions, I got stuck there. It was a disaster!! never read such a long case study question as this one and so vague that I found it difficult to pick suitable points from it. I read the examiners report and I was avoiding copying texts from the scenario, instead I tried to state in my own words and explain my answers, which was hard work when you're under such pressure and stress and trying to make sure you are meeting professional writing standards.
So after about two hours of trying to fight through it, I only had an hour and 15 mins. left for the remaining questions. Luckily, I was confident with the requirements and the cases were easier to read and understand but the time I had left, meant I had to write as quickly as I could.
I was so gutted that after all the preparation and good score in my mock, I am still feeling like I have done nothing, so deflating really. I only hope that the marker is flexible enough to consider my answers and the effort of trying to analyse and not just copy the case.
Yes, question 1 was vague. POPIT and contextual features shouldn't be together really!
Decision tree anyone? I chose option 3. I drew Decision tree so horribly lol
I went for the decision tree as well, even though mid way i was skeptical abou the calculations as it's been so long lol but yeah i went with option 3
did you deduct the fixed costs and spendings from the expected value in your evaluation?
i did that and both options 1 and 2 generated losses for me...
Well, I rushed answering question 4, literally picked the points from the SWOT writing in full steam like a bullet train, terrible!! Anyway, Option 3 was the choice and we had to evaluate this decision using organic growth, M&A, and strategic alliance, I explained the speed, cost, cultural conflict impact of each of this. My conclusion was starting to adopt organic growth strategy considering the resources and capabilities that the company already has, and it is less costly and is faster to do compared with the other options.
I answered questions 1 2 and 4...really easy questions, so much to write in so little time though. I reckon a pass mark of 54 will do me :) ! Good luck to everyone, easy paper.
Anyone limit option 3 with 200 rooms?
@rana91 said: I went for the decision tree as well, even though mid way i was skeptical abou the calculations as it's been so long lol but yeah i went with option 3 did you deduct the fixed costs and spendings from the expected value in your evaluation? i did that and both options 1 and 2 generated losses for me...All options were positive for me though. Yes I did. Decsision tree was v easy. But due to time limitation couldn't put neatly.
@waterfall1509 said: Anyone limit option 3 with 200 rooms?Nope damn. Time pressure.
Luckily for me. I do q3 first. However, I can't do q1 b and c. :( a little hope. Q3.option 1 and 2 have negative results. Option 3, growing 160*2 higher than 200. So profit is only 400,000 usd
Lets hope for best
I honestly think that the P examiners need to revise the exam format into four 25 mark questions, as I don't think reading such a massive question gives us enough time to really understand and analyse the case. Smaller cases are easier to read and then students can think more critically and produce a more sensible and profound answer.
aaah i didn't pay attention to that part at all. used the 320 as it is.
hoping for the best cause question 1 was horrible for me the scenario was so long i couldn't do much
hoping for at least 50 ?
Totally agree with you thao67. Absolutely terrible to have such a long case study for such little time. And you can't skim read because almost every sentence is relevant somehow.
POPIT was very confusing for me also the ecommerce question - I'm hoping I got a 25 from Quest 1 Qus 2 & 4 were super fair! - Did you classify The CEO as low interest - high power? She really had low interest putting all her duties on the manager...
Very time pressured exam. Q1 was a nightmare!
@thao67 said: I totally agree with you eagledave. I was very annoyed coming out of that exam. That question 1 was just far too long to read and analyse properly. I really didn't have time to analyse or calculate the ratios properly. It was more of a test of speed reading rather than your understanding of the syllabus. We would never have to do that in real life, so what are they really testing us??? Same for all ACCA exams really. If only they give us a little more time to show your true understanding and analytical skills:((Totally spot on, that's exactly how I felt, the current format isn't really fit for purpose and value-adding. And also, based on the examiner's report, the expectation from us to produce an output of that high level of standard is unfair with the time available.
@fernandomer said: POPIT was very confusing for me also the ecommerce question - I'm hoping I got a 25 from Quest 1 Qus 2 & 4 were super fair! - Did you classify The CEO as low interest - high power? She really had low interest putting all her duties on the manager...Well, I did put her as high interest and high power and therefore, a key player considering she has an overall responsibility in the project's success, being a project sponsor, and this is crucial for the company she leads as a CEO. The implication on the project manager is that regular update on the status and progress of the project would be required in order to ensure a quick resolution of any issues i.e. budget constraints.
@fernandomer said: POPIT was very confusing for me also the ecommerce question - I'm hoping I got a 25 from Quest 1 Qus 2 & 4 were super fair! - Did you classify The CEO as low interest - high power? She really had low interest putting all her duties on the manager...I put her as high interest but low power towards the project itself, high interest because as a project sponsor she has the most to lose so she will be highly interested in how the project goes, low power because she delegated the full time day to day running of the project to the project manager and she cannot directly alter the course of the project. We could both be right, so long as we expressed ourselves properly and backed it up.
yeah i figured that our re pro management -But the CEO is working in the public sector and mostly are politically appointed and somehow the scenario gave me that impression that she had little interest in the job - also at one point she asked the project manager to handle stuff problem - a proper CEO, considering the issue , should handle them him self. But i also put the regulator as high power high interest especially since they can lower the licence fees etc.
Dunno maybe I'm wrong with my interpretation
I think the ACCA wants the new paper Strategic Business Leader to catch up with us. At this rate we will forfeit our P1s. The paper was tough. Time management hectic. Q1 disaster.
Th CEO is high interest high power you forgot she has a lot to lose from the project the governing body obviously low interest bout high power and the employers high interest low power
@thao67 said: I was also in the same boat as you eagledave ref question 4. It was such a nice question but I ran out ot time so literally wrote as fast as I could, picking some obvious points just to pick up a few more marks, that's if the marker can read my writing!Exactly, I was writing so fast and my hands were literally trembling, and half of my mind says, go on you can do it, and the other half saying, you wasted all this time and missed these marks, tsk tsk.. If ACCA wasn't that important to me, I would have just said, oh well, better luck next time, but I realllllyyy prepared for it and was following all techniques and memorised the models..then today happened :) Well, I really hope for a kinder and more flexible marker!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

