SBL*** ACCA P3 September 2017 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Me too. I keep on trying to tally up the marks in my head. Hoping for a possible 35 out of 50 for both option questions. I will be lucky to get 15 out of 50 for q1.
@darlingboyuk25 said: Th CEO is high interest high power you forgot she has a lot to lose from the project the governing body obviously low interest bout high power and the employers high interest low powerSame here, Project Sponsor - HP, HI OFCAST-HP, LI MBCE-LP,HI
Question 1. a. I don't remember what was the topic of the question, can any one just tell me what was it based on ?? Just to recollect it, Just have got blank about it. Can you also illustrate the given scenario of Q1 P3 Sep 2017
In Question 1. b. POPIT People Organisation Process & IT was for 14 marks, I could not guess what was POPIT in the exams, but just attempted in some way, cant remember much on what I have written on this.
Q. 2 Mendolow Matrix was fine - attempted OK
Q. 2 On Project Management and was also fine.
Q. 4 On SWOT and Ansoff analysis was also fine.
obviously the regulator is high and high - they have been concerned with many stuff and also have the power to lower the licenses - dunno i might be wrong but its the way one interpret it I guess
Can someone discuss about what u wrote in question 4 a??
Q1 was evaluating using contextual features such as time, scope and structure, capability, and preservation.
All of the questions were really ok, it's just finding the right and relevant context and points to put under each heading...as well as trying to be analytical
Well actually for Q1 I did agree that a change was needed in that the co need to incorporate the online selling of products but I disagreed with the business analysts regarding the abandonment of the dealer network and completely moving to an online platform and that was because co was operating in a very niche market with majority of the customers being senior citizens so I disagreed that the dealer based model is scrapped altogether though I agreed that a change was needed but that should be by incorporating the online platform and not by scrapping the dealerships.
did anyone suggest on the same lines
this is a very subjective paper and there are no right and wrong answers as long as you can back up your assertion with anything sensible
Damn right....i left like 35 marks out....never in my whole life....Only God may help me pass....if i did......bigggg IF ...that scenario was far too long.....what are they expecting from us ?!?!?
@hassanatcams said: Well actually for Q1 I did agree that a change was needed in that the co need to incorporate the online selling of products but I disagreed with the business analysts regarding the abandonment of the dealer network and completely moving to an online platform and that was because co was operating in a very niche market with majority of the customers being senior citizens so I disagreed that the dealer based model is scrapped altogether though I agreed that a change was needed but that should be by incorporating the online platform and not by scrapping the dealerships.plus change was supposed to be incremental not big bang
I think the scenario tried to assert time and again that the dealer shops served as a very important socialising part for modelers. moreover nowhere in the scenario was there any mention of the modelers being tired of purchasing from the shop or showing any preference for online purchases. the solely online purchasing assumption was solely made by the business analysts who could be wrong
On the sponsor/CEO and regulator topic. They are High interest, high power and low interest, high power respectively. There's a similar past question, think it was about a mobile industry regulator.
Question 1 I didn't enjoy at all. There was plenty to write, but a lot of it overlaps between the requirements of a and b and difficult to slot unique facts under the two points, especially with limited time, there's not enough time to plan and structure before starting to write. Dissapointed that the usual pestel, 5 forces, value chain didn't feature, it's a large part of the subject and usually features prominantly. Almost like the examiners took all the lesser examined topics and threw it into one paper.
Hopefully I did enough. If they want better structured answers, they really need to give another hour. Or make section one's case shorter. Although I do think it wasn't as long as some of the past papers.
yup
i thnk the regulator was hgh pwer high interest coz they hv high interest in wat th company provides to its customers.
@aminb001 said: I agreed with TMA in that it is a revolutionary change. Reason being that they should predominantly be an e-commerce business. Therefore the scope changed dramatically meaning a transformational change. The fact that they are there financial statements and profitability ratios were falling meant that the change needed to be quick and with simultaneous tasks as it a change in the entire process being online.if they apply big bang the board will be reluctant to change...
@eddienel said: Hopefully I did enough. If they want better structured answers, they really need to give another hour. Or make section one's case shorter. Although I do think it wasn't as long as some of the past papers.Well, Appendix A and B make the case study about 3.5 pages including the questions. I had not seen one like that in the past papers.
Q1 required to write a report.
For Q1 I feel unsure about.
For contextual features I always feel a bit unsure, for example, the time element I found hard to relate as I couldn't seem to see any info regarding time constraints!
Preservation was also hard as the suggested change was such a major overhaul I couldn't think of what to preserve although just now it occured to me I should have mentioned the quality assurance team perhaps.
I also found it difficult to relate financial ratios so tried to throw numbers in with an apendix showing their current performance.
Part C of Q1 threw me a bit. I wasn't sure if it wanted me to advise actions to take as well as identify. I started off trying to suggest solutions but in the end gave up and just stated the apparent barriers and how important they were.
My biggest fear of Q1 is that I didn't relate it enough to the scenario.
Q4 I think was the easiest of all of them. It essentially gave you all the answers without having to think about it.
I did the decision tree Q3. I actually drew the whole thing very quickly on the blank page of the question paper, very messy and then re-did this on my paper. I did not subtract the $1.5m costs as we were provided with the contribution figure so all three results resulted in a positive with option 3 being the best. (I also did check if I subtracted this and both option 1 & 2 provided losses which to me didn't make sense).
In limitations I questions how predictable and reliable these probabilities and figures were. I also obviously mentioned that they has used an inappropriate model for static growth as this represented the industry as a whole and not themselves. I also mentioned that option 3 had the most amount of estimation and runs the risk of being less profitable if the forementioned occupancy and contribution amounts were less than predicted, although I did not calculate any figures for this.
For sources of finance, I was unsure. I literally just mentioned all three, internal funds, debt capital and equity capital and that realistically only equity capital seemed their best option, with risks mentioned about some shareholders gaining too much power.
@aminb001 said: Did 1a ask for a particular format? OR was is just general professional marks? I can't remember if it said report format or not?Format is to write a report so I put the usual to, fro, subject and a brief intro...
@eagledave said: Well, Appendix A and B make the case study about 3.5 pages including the questions. I had not seen one like that in the past papers.no doubt this one got to be one of the lengthiest case studies to appear in P3 history
I think the socialising part of the dealership shops was a hint that the dealership should not be scrapped altogether otherwise we could loose customers
@hassanatcams said: I think the socialising part of the dealership shops was a hint that the dealership should not be scrapped altogether otherwise we could loose customersyep u ryt..... 20 marks was too much for qustion 1a and also those 14 for POPIT.... coz it was kinda hard to link to the scenario.
I believe it was 4 marks for professional standard. Even without the report format I would imagine that you would gain most marks if your work was structured well and flowed well.
How an earth they think that we have the time to do this though. I wonder if most people just do the To/From bit with some headings and then lose all thought process about structure as they try to gain as many marks as possible from the content required.
@hassanatcams said: Well actually for Q1 I did agree that a change was needed in that the co need to incorporate the online selling of products but I disagreed with the business analysts regarding the abandonment of the dealer network and completely moving to an online platform and that was because co was operating in a very niche market with majority of the customers being senior citizens so I disagreed that the dealer based model is scrapped altogether though I agreed that a change was needed but that should be by incorporating the online platform and not by scrapping the dealerships.Yes I put the advantages and disadvantages of changing from B2B to B2C model, there will be some training costs for sales and marketing for ordering processes that need to be communicated to the customers, finance department for online payment, and investment in reliable IT and website to address fraud and security issues. All of these entail cost. As a business analyst, I also looked at the future prospects of the new model given that TMC or TAC (can't remember) identified some benefits and that 90% of the people have broadband and use the internet in purchasing. The age group of customer which is also a concern for the directors over the acceptance of the new model. I then linked FMC supplies high quality products, which the company has to maintain and ensure the customer amidst the change. This age group are likely to stick with the products hence they may be willing learn the online ordering system and also this group has the capacity to pay for premium products. Through sales and marketing communication, the ease of use of the internet ordering should be emphasized to encourage customers to embrace the change.
well I think for the beginning and conclusion 2 marks seem sensible while other 2 would be for the content is the written part. things like professional terminology, structure, etc
@eagledave said: Yes I put the advantages and disadvantages of changing from B2B to B2C model, there will be some training costs for sales and marketing for ordering processes that need to be communicated to the customers, finance department for online payment, and investment in reliable IT and website to address fraud and security issues. All of these entail cost. As a business analyst, I also looked at the future prospects of the new model given that TMC or TAC (can't remember) identified some benefits and that 90% of the people have broadband and use the internet in purchasing. The age group of customer which is also a concern for the directors over the acceptance of the new model. I then linked FMC supplies high quality products, which the company has to maintain and ensure the customer amidst the change. This age group are likely to stick with the products hence they may be willing learn the online ordering system and also this group has the capacity to pay for premium products. Through sales and marketing communication, the ease of use of the internet ordering should be emphasized to encourage customers to embrace the change.well your points sound equally sensible to me.
@hassanatcams said: well I think for the beginning and conclusion 2 marks seem sensible while other 2 would be for the content is the written part. things like professional terminology, structure, etcI agree
however I mentioned that the co would have to build a proper IT Dept as they don't have one yet
did Q1 tell us to choose if we were for or against the radical change proposal by TCA for FMC? I dont think I chose a side...
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

