Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** ACCA P2 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin9y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA P2 December 2016 Exam.

*** ACCA P2 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** ACCA P2 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results

Post your comments about the ACCA P2 exam below

AAimee9y ago#31
@paulbongiovanni said: I said that Minor was Dollar - I think that I went along the lines of 'even though the facts appear to show that Minor's functional currency is Euro, the subsidiary is not autonomous and provides monthly dividends to the parent - effective acting as a branch.' I found 3B and 3C tough and I only had around 15-20 minutes to write them, so I felt the time pressure and didn't have greatest structure in my answer. 3B - I think i mentioned how market conditions, cash flows, PV etc are incorporated into the FV of assets whereas the replacement cost does not and how that would affect the 'gain' that the director put down to their negotiation influence based on their liquidity position. 3C - I really ran out of time here, but identified an IAS36 impairment issue? The director said the licence wasn't impaired as the PV of future cash flows was > carrying value - however the future cashflows were contingent on a possible change in law/regulations. I don't know if they're the greatest of answers but I had to write something XD
I did the same as you, on all parts!
Former userFormer user9y ago#32
how did anyone apportion PL of Ginny upon disposal? got confused in the exam ( x9/12?
Former userFormer user9y ago#33
and I had a gain on disposal, $24...
AAimee9y ago#34
@kerimova1808 said: how did anyone apportion PL of Ginny upon disposal? got confused in the exam ( x9/12?
Yup, did 9/12 income for Ginny. -!; 3/12 for income from associate
Nneilsolaris9y ago#35
@kerimova1808 said: how did anyone apportion PL of Ginny upon disposal? got confused in the exam ( x9/12?
I did exactly that! Then (was it?) 40% of 3/12 for the associate. Then entered what I calculated as a group loss on disposal of the 20%(?).
Aaamir3009y ago#36
Yes Gunny 9/12 & other 100%
Former userFormer user9y ago#37
yes, me too, took 40%x3/12 for associate
Eeoin9y ago#38
Was Ginny the company in the middle of the P/L in the question does anyone know? I took 9/12 of the one that was furthest right I think that was Boo I'm guessing a gud few marks gone there already!
Nneilsolaris9y ago#39
I think between us we've got about a 150% pass mark already!
Aaamir3009y ago#40
I think no. Because order was 10,000 units. He has delivered 6,000 units with fault. The point you need to remember that both parties agreeed to adjust credit note in future payments. It means they will not adjust in sale al ready been made. So next 7,000 units cross the limit of order. Then 1st 4,000 x (1,000-40) & next 3,000 x (1,000-40-50) assume that the customer has ordered more even fault in product.
Ssh9y ago#41
How di they mark us? How many points do we loose for not giving the sales the discount? As I read it that they hadn't ordered the amount that qualified for the discount :( Also I didn't treat the investment property correctly. I depreciated it and put a gain to oci in error. Also the goodwill impairment I based it on the $28 not the revised amount. I put the remeasuremt as a gain to oci but was it a gain? I also Inc the oci for ginny to profit but don't know if I should have ignored that. I was stuck on part B. Part course I said it was self interest threat and could miss lead potential investors and then zippy could get a bad reputation they should seek professional advice on classification. Maybe they were doing it to get a better bonus. Don't know if I went off track from the q. I did questions 2 and 3 but don't remember them that we'll. Can someone give me a breakdown of 2 a B and 3 a B c. I think it was 3c I didn't have a clue just made it up about the loan that was guaranteed by the director or something. Thanks
AArsalan9y ago#42
@aamir300 said: I think no. Because order was 10,000 units. He has delivered 6,000 units with fault. The point you need to remember that both parties agreeed to adjust credit note in future payments. It means they will not adjust in sale al ready been made. So next 7,000 units cross the limit of order. Then 1st 4,000 x (1,000-40) & next 3,000 x (1,000-40-50) assume that the customer has ordered more even fault in product.
Yeah, I did exactly the same thing.
AArsalan9y ago#43
@mynameisearl said: Also I didn't treat the investment property correctly. I depreciated it and put a gain to oci in error. I put the remeasuremt as a gain to oci but was it a gain? I also Inc the oci for ginny to profit but don't know if I should have ignored that.
Yeah, me too. I depreciated it and placed the gain to OCI. ): Seems quite a few students fell into this trap. Yeah, the re measurement gain was a gain as per the question. I just Cr it to OCI.
Ssh9y ago#44
What about 1b? I don't think I will get any marks for my answer as I just guessed why
Ssh9y ago#45
I feel really unclear on the revenue part as I know I probably misread it and worried about the points I will loose
Oolanrewaju9y ago#46
The question did say a total of 6,000 units were produced initially. Then 7,000 were subsequently produced even though there was a contract of 10,000 units. The threshold for recognizing a discount is 15,000 units. However, Zippy sold only 13,000 units in total to them. They did not earn the discount. Who else did question 4? it was a terrible question for me
Ssh9y ago#47
Thank you that's how I read it. But don't think I did the credit note correctly as I times by 6000 and deducted from revenue
AAmanda9y ago#48
Did Q1 state the policy for investment properties was fair value rather than cost model?
NNidhi9y ago#49
Too bad P2 was cancelled in my city as my state's chief minister passed away :( Anyway, I hope to get the refund soon!!
VVebem9y ago#50
Why a lot of people didn’t answer Q4, there was 18 free mak in part A & B(ii) Part A was from technical articles Please tell the name of technical articles if you can. Thanks
VVebem9y ago#51
@almoosawi4 said: Why a lot of people didn't answer Q4, there was 18 free mak in part A & B(ii) Part A was from technical articles
Please tell the name of article if you can. Thanks
Ssh9y ago#52
What did people put for 1b and 1c?
DDavid9y ago#53
@mynameisearl said: What did people put for 1b and 1c?
Just talked about the different kind of costs for pensions. Service costs, actuarial gains and losses , interest etc and where they were posted. 1 (c) I focused mostly on the ACCA code of ethics and how they were breached by attempting to make the bonus targets. Competence, integrity and behaviour were main 3. What about you?
Former userFormer user9y ago#54
@kelvinlengg said: Does anyone remember the standards apply for Question 3(c)? Was it the criteria for development cost to be capitalized under ias38??
I thought 3c was about how value in use should be calculated.
Former userFormer user9y ago#55
@mynameisearl said: Hi, Will the answers be available on this website? If so when? Q1 I had a profit on disposal which I included in my p&l. The fv adjustment I left the good will as it was originally (dont know if that was right) I added the fv depreciation to cost of sales. I was really unsure of the both investment properties. I reversed out the 3m provision. The pension seemed OK I thought the remeasurement was a gain. Sales I was a bit unsure of treatment. I didn't discount I took off the credit note and added the extra 7000 units at £1000.im sure I will find out that was wrong tho.
I didn't discount either as additional 5000 has not been purchased.
Former userFormer user9y ago#56
@mynameisearl said: Thank you that's how I read it. But don't think I did the credit note correctly as I times by 6000 and deducted from revenue
I deducted credit note as well from the revenue. It doesn't matter when they agreed to settle it, what matters is that revenue for 6000 units that was initially recognized, now is lower due to defects hence credit note should be taken into consideration. This is my view.
Aask2489y ago#57
I deducted the credit notes from revenue. 6,000 x $40 = $0.24M. The 13,000 units wasn't enough for a discount, so 13,000 x $1,000 is recognised in total, which is $13M.
AAli9y ago#58
@vebem said: Please tell the name of article if you can. Thanks
https://www.accaglobal.com/vn/en/student/exam-support-resources/professional-exams-study-resources/p2/technical-articles/impairment-of-financial-assets.html "Impairment of financial assets"
AAli9y ago#59
Just quick question, Q1 (b) it was asking about P&L vs OCI and recycling process. Or it was about types of pensions?
Ffaizan9y ago#60
I didn't consolidate the results of subsidiary that was disposed..only gain and income from associate how much will be effect on marking?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.