SBR*** ACCA P2 December 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
How was the exam
Question two is fairly easy
a functional currency similar to one of the past paper
s - dollars
Major - yen
Minor - dollars
B intangible assets
Impairment to 500000 and amortise over the remaining term
c related party disclosure
Question 3 is tough for me
Part a IFRS13 level one input should be used
Part b and c don't have enough time and can't think of anything though
Related party's question was hard. I found 2a functional currency OK.
How did you find the consolidation? I found it weird and can't tell if I scored OK in it or not.
The investment property threw me and I'm sure I did some other adjustments wrong in it. I had a loss on the 3rd company.
@kakahh said: Question two is fairly easy a functional currency similar to one of the past paper s - dollars Major - yen Minor - dollars B intangible assets Impairment to 500000 and amortise over the remaining term c related party disclosure Question 3 is tough for me Part a IFRS13 level one input should be used Part b and c don't have enough time and can't think of anything thoughCorrect me if I am wrong and I do not want to panic you but see below : The functional currency for Minor was Euro as they sold to the competitive market in Euro. this is the main criteria of 21. they only bought goods in dollars from the parent but converted to euro in Portugal. Also, ther was no Active market in the scenario so we can not use level1. We have to use Level 2 as they were all listed companies. The definition they had for an inactive market was wrong as well. Question 4 was tricky as I kept mixing up the fair value measurement criteria and also the financial instruments buckets! Lets forget it now we are done
Hi, I got confused with the impairment if trademark I think I should have changed the amortisation to reflect the the new life but instead I said to do that next year. I think I was wrong to do that????
For the property in question one I accounted for a tenth as PPE (i.e. with depreciation for the year), and the remainder as an investment property (no depreciation for the year). I don't know for sure if that's right.
I said dollar too not euro because it was a subsidiary and was not autonomous.
Is that wrong?
Why a lot of people didn't answer Q4, there was 18 free mak in part A & B(ii)
Part A was from technical articles
I think minor is not Euro
- not autonomous
- level of transactions with parents (dividend all the profit)
agree the income statement I have no idea. I misread the investment property question and just treated under IAS 16 :( Sarah, I could be wrong about the funtional currency but I they are consolidation they would be dollar but I am pretty certain it is euro.
@neilsolaris said: For the property in question one I accounted for a tenth as PPE (i.e. with depreciation for the year), and the remainder as an investment property (no depreciation for the year). I don't know for sure if that's right.PPE the floor to boo ? And one floor I forgot the issue
does anyone know anything about question 3 part B and C?
that was horrible
also, i ran out of time and didn't calculate the profit attributable to NCI, also didn't have time to actually do the statement and include the adjustments :( i did all the workings though except for working number 7. how bad does that sound? i really don't wanna fail ?
But there's no definitely right or wrong in this exam , marks will be scored for valid argument
So don't panic :)
Did anyone get a loss on the disposal in the income statement? of around 13mill?
@rana91 said: does anyone know anything about question 3 part B and C? that was horrible also, i ran out of time and didn't calculate the profit attributable to NCI, also didn't have time to actually do the statement and include the adjustments :( i did all the workings though except for working number 7. how bad does that sound? i really don't wanna fail ?Question 3 B C really horrible .. I don't know what to write even re read the questions for numerous time
Was there a question on impairments to assets in both questions 2 and 3? I wrote very similar answers to both.
I think I wrote 'higher of FVLCTS and VIU' and least 3 times in the exam.
same here! and the problem is i really didn't know much about impairment of financial instruments or anything for that matter that came in question 4, so i just had to do question 3. I'm still so confused as to what it was all about
@seanog91 said: Did anyone get a loss on the disposal in the income statement? of around 13mill?I got a group loss on the part disposal of the subsidiary. I got something like minus 4.8m, but I don't have much confidence in my calculations!
@seanog91 said: Did anyone get a loss on the disposal in the income statement? of around 13mill?it is gain 8m, by mistake I wrote it 8 loss XD
@seanog91 said: Did anyone get a loss on the disposal in the income statement? of around 13mill?I think I got 13.6 so I adjusted the figure they'd included already by 0.4
was the goodwill adjusted to reflect the actual fair value of net assets at acquisition? or did you leave it as 28?
also? i got a gain on disposal of 13.2
i had trouble remembering how to calculate the carrying value of NCI, but i think i didn't it correctly
Does anyone remember the standards apply for Question 3(c)?
Was it the criteria for development cost to be capitalized under ias38??
i was absolutely clueless regarding that question, but now that you've mentioned it i think that could've made sense
What the heck was part 1 b wanting? It was about the new rules for SMEs and to tell management about them. I found it frustrating as what limited knowledge I had of this the question already told you. 0/8 for me here.
What was the trick on the product sale bit in question 1)? As simple as take off the 6m already included in revene and replace with the discounted price Revenue for the 13m units, and then take off the money lost for thr defective goods?
Did anyone get a gain on disposal of subsidiary of 13M? So I said it was a gain the group of 13m and a loss to the now associate of 13m. Didn't know what to do here but so I took the 14M that it said had already been included away and replaced with the 13M for group revene and then included the 13m as a loss in the now in the now associate company who got 60% of the loss and then 40% of the loss came back to the group.
Was lucky for checking examiner articles on Ifrs 13 given half a chan was the only bit of exam I felt I knew the right answer for.
I said that Minor was Dollar - I think that I went along the lines of 'even though the facts appear to show that Minor's functional currency is Euro, the subsidiary is not autonomous and provides monthly dividends to the parent - effective acting as a branch.'
I found 3B and 3C tough and I only had around 15-20 minutes to write them, so I felt the time pressure and didn't have greatest structure in my answer.
3B - I think i mentioned how market conditions, cash flows, PV etc are incorporated into the FV of assets whereas the replacement cost does not and how that would affect the 'gain' that the director put down to their negotiation influence based on their liquidity position.
3C - I really ran out of time here, but identified an IAS36 impairment issue? The director said the licence wasn't impaired as the PV of future cash flows was > carrying value - however the future cashflows were contingent on a possible change in law/regulations.
I don't know if they're the greatest of answers but I had to write something XD
Hi,
Will the answers be available on this website? If so when?
Q1 I had a profit on disposal which I included in my p&l.
The fv adjustment I left the good will as it was originally (dont know if that was right) I added the fv depreciation to cost of sales.
I was really unsure of the both investment properties. I reversed out the 3m provision.
The pension seemed OK I thought the remeasurement was a gain.
Sales I was a bit unsure of treatment. I didn't discount I took off the credit note and added the extra 7000 units at £1000.im sure I will find out that was wrong tho.
@kevikraze said: What the heck was part 1 b wanting? It was about the new rules for SMEs and to tell management about them. I found it frustrating as what limited knowledge I had of this the question already told you. 0/8 for me here. What was the trick on the product sale bit in question 1)? As simple as take off the 6m already included in revene and replace with the discounted price Revenue for the 13m units, and then take off the money lost for thr defective goods? Did anyone get a gain on disposal of subsidiary of 13M? So I said it was a gain the group of 13m and a loss to the now associate of 13m. Didn't know what to do here but so I took the 14M that it said had already been included away and replaced with the 13M for group revene and then included the 13m as a loss in the now in the now associate company who got 60% of the loss and then 40% of the loss came back to the group. Was lucky for checking examiner articles on Ifrs 13 given half a chan was the only bit of exam I felt I knew the right answer for.Kevin dont take my word on any of these as I just realised I did every question and was wondering why my timing so so wrong. I hope they take pity on me here :( Part 1B was about Pensions and employee benefits so I just described the various Pensions and then gave a bit of FS treatment around this. I got about 6 points down max on this. The product sales I did the same as yourself and got something like 6.8 million revenue and .2 of the discount going to cost of sales. I misread the investment but and treated it as a normal property and jsut depreciated and sent the revaluation gain to the SPLOCI. the disposal I did the exact same thing. I got 57 as the Transfer in less the conderation price and got 13.
@mynameisearl said: Hi, Will the answers be available on this website? If so when? Q1 I had a profit on disposal which I included in my p&l. The fv adjustment I left the good will as it was originally (dont know if that was right) I added the fv depreciation to cost of sales. I was really unsure of the both investment properties. I reversed out the 3m provision. The pension seemed OK I thought the remeasurement was a gain. Sales I was a bit unsure of treatment. I didn't discount I took off the credit note and added the extra 7000 units at £1000.im sure I will find out that was wrong tho.I used the discounted charge as they had met the minimum criteria for the sales discount? Was 9 hundred and something. I also altered sales by the 240k for the credit note. Also reversed the 3m provision and talked about how the estimate isn't reliable and they might not do the repairs.
For the last working note in question 1. Am not sure I got it right but this is what I did. 7000 × 950=6650000
Less 50×6000=300000
Less 40× 6000=240000
=6110000 which I added to the revenue.
The 300000 been reduction in selling price if they purchase over 10000 units while 240000 represents reduction in selling price as a result of the defect.
@ogunnubi said: For the last working note in question 1. Am not sure I got it right but this is what I did. 7000 × 950=6650000 Less 50×6000=300000 Less 40× 6000=240000 =6110000 which I added to the revenue. The 300000 been reduction in selling price if they purchase over 10000 units while 240000 represents reduction in selling price as a result of the defect.I didn't give them the extra discount as I read it as they needed to buy 10,000 (contract) plus an extra 5,000 to get the discount. Made a little note to say not giving them it as it was not certain that the buyer would qualify and no end date for the purchases was given? Hopefully the examiner will feel sorry for me...
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

