PM*** ACCA F5 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@anastassiya777 said: same here...absolutely understand you with feelings after exam.i left room totally squeezed.I had same feelings and was thinking was that really a F5 paper lol ? The expressions on the faces of other students were same and were saying the same I sat on afternoon session 2pm pakistani time.
No it wasn't just the morning. I had rolling budget case Q and i did the 2pm sitting
Yes, i also got 25$. I spent about 5 minutes on that question (((
I'm looking to fit F5 in June, can someone tell me how much the CBE exam differs to the paper exam please? As people are scaring me about the CBE version!
@oc10 said: I'm looking to fit F5 in June, can someone tell me how much the CBE exam differs to the paper exam please? As people are scaring me about the CBE version!i don't think that the version is the biggest problem here... Just this time the questions were very tricky and unusual.... The paper is hard enough to pass when its straightforward and the unusual questions in this session made like mission impossible... Don't get scared of the CBE, there are many things that are much better with it, plus this is the future apparently.. sooner or later all exams will be computer based... I sat F7 on Tuesday on CBE and found it brilliant, especially for the long q's. The spread sheet makes thing way easier and it's functionality helps a lot when you have to work fast. That saves a lot of time as you can copy/paste or to link the cells, and can also save you from making silly mistakes with the calculations, or if you have to change smthg, it gets recalculated everywhere... of course, there is that other side, when you have technology, you always have the possibility of it to stop working in the middle of the exam... and then you start to waste time....
@tcrngdr said: Hi, A question for all those candidates that sat the paper with Section C questions on the 3Es and the hotel. Did anyone else have trouble seeing the whole hotel question on their screen? I'm aware that you had to scroll up and down but I also had to scroll left and right which made analysing the graph and picking out the relevant information quite difficult. It was so time consuming!!! Not what I needed on my last question :(Yea, I had the same issue! :((
Failed the paper exam in december and got 48%, absolute no chance Im getting higher the CBE was a disaster. Good that Im not alone here, thought my professional paper was easier than this dumb paper. ACCA are raking in the money with this exam, pass rate will be going down again
Yes me too! I got 51% for section A C/S ratio qn.
I had 60 tables for that
@rai175 said: I got 51Yes i got 51% too,no matter how i calculate it
@gurtgreen said: Did anybody have a question that was so confusing something like 60% of 30% and 70% of 30% I’m sure it was a probability question took me a little while to get around that onemy answer was 2000 something, option B, don't know if it's right
@odean20 said: If i remember correctly i thought the question ask how many chair should be produced. It was only one scare resources material and unlimited labour so you are correct it is a limited factor. First you would have to rank the product based on return per scares resource. Chair was rank second, therfore table would be first. I dont remember how many unit but i remember that only 12 meter was available for chair only and each chair use 0.2 meter Therfore 60 chair should be produced 12÷0.2 = 60I think they asked for how many tables.. not chairs
It was really hard paper. I do not even understand what is the reason behind preparing this kind of paper.
@rachelxi said: I had 60 tables for thatDo you remember how you got 60 tables?
can u tel me about long question on which topic ?
Well at least I wasn't the only one who found this exam very difficult The questions took a while to complete in section A. In Section C I struggled to get my head around the transfer pricing question - understand the theory but applying it to the question was difficult. So disappointing.
@vgs1 said: Well at least I wasn't the only one who found this exam very difficult The questions took a while to complete in section A. In Section C I struggled to get my head around the transfer pricing question - understand the theory but applying it to the question was difficult. So disappointing.for me section a was more or less ok but b and c with this transfer pricing nightmare.
it wasn't only you to find it difficult, thats for sure
i found the section A q's very detailed, so much information to process for only two points, it took forever to read and reread it and to come up with an answer... its impossible to fit that in 3.6 minutes...
i didn't like how the big q's were split into three separate q's, i had to go back and forth so i can use the info from the previous one...
I received a survey from ACCA asking about my experiences of the March exam sitting. I gave precise details about how bad the CBE software is. Would encourage all who receive one to reply so ACCA can make needed changes.
@cate said: It was a very hard paper.it was very difficult paper to pass through, i was giving the exam first time and i did so much practice but i couldn't find any of the similar questions. every question was unique. i was thinking that ACCA has made CBE compulsory from March-18 so it will be a bit easy paper than before but i was wrong. does anyone feel the same? it was disaster....
I got 51% for the contribution/sales ratio
What was the bottlneck resource- variants was like wood materials, labour hours, demand.I chose demand
lucky you with the paper based exams...
there is always an issue with the computers... we were all together 4 people yesterday, two of us had problems. My computer froze in the middle and i had to move stations... it's not a big deal in normal circumstances but at the exam this hard was very distracting, it took me forever to be able to concentrate again... but ACCA are all about time management and stuff... it's hard to manage your time when you get distracted all the time...
The girl next to me had earplugs... how come i never thought about that....
Yeah i chose demand too! Thats why other resources were greater than what would be needed for covering total demands.
@chrisi04 said: It's all about money by making it hard on purpose. One of the main reasons why they don't publish the full past papers so no one can contradict them. Should we do a petition to these people that think that they passed their exams and now they have the power to stop other from having a decent exam like they had in their time. Very unfair exams and unfair examiner. This is my 4th attempt to sit for F5. Honestly this is the hardest exam ever. They should lower the pass rate. I have done all the sacrifices and worked less hours and invested such time to study for a too much nonsense detailed exam. Should we create a petition to lower the pass rate? Speak up people because they are stealing money from our pockets.I completely agree with you.we should do something about it.
Happy to sign the petition!
It was my 7th CBE and I thoroughly prepare for each paper. F5 Mar exam was nonsense, the number of complex question was out of proportion. Scenarios of sections B and C questions were way too long and not always clear to understand quickly under time pressure.
I am sure that all prepared students could come up with correct solutions if time allows.
It wasn't fair test of knowledge.
@thiago said:I'm too in.... How to make sure that our concerns & pEtitions reach the acca head office?
Very time pressured, had to guess about 5 mcq at the end as I ran out of time. Section can was very difficult.
I too agree that this exam was nothing like the practice questions. I have a Kaplan exam kit and a BPP one too and I was doing well with the questions and my timing. I put so much time and effort in to this as it was my 2nd attempt and the exam was totally unfair with questions that I have not had to deal with in such detail before and the questions that were meant to be taking under 4 mins were taking me 10 mins!! Not to mention the added pressure of being made to do it on a computer! I have given some very negative feedback to ACCA about this and I hope everyone else does too. They need to mark this paper in view of it being so hard. Make your voice heard people!!!! Don't rely on others to do it for you!
yes. I got demand.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

