PM*** ACCA F5 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Section C suing ABC what is the cost to nursing?
Procedure B Nurse per patients per day = 30 ?? how can there be 30hours in a day?
Most tough CBE ever. MCQ one question takes more than 5 min. too many question in one MCQ. hate it
I calculated the 31 questions variances
like that...
original budget * std rate
400* 1 = 400 * I don't remember
planning variance
revised budget * std rate
400 *85%=340*1 * I don't remember
operational variance
actual budget * std rate
320 *
@suay said: Section C suing ABC what is the cost to nursing? Procedure B Nurse per patients per day = 30 ?? how can there be 30hours in a day?it will option C I guess... yea same here how will be 30 hours. but we all know the 24hour= 1 days I think its innovation of ACCA should report the #NASA ????
I think the q32 c) minimum transfer price should be $14, because division A has an existing market for it's adapters i.e. 30,000, but irrespective of that it is being transferred to division B, hence the opportunity cost i.e. the sales lost - any reduction in sales due to it being an internal transfer. Hence, selling price i.e $15 less Variable selling cost to external market $1 equals $14.
And nursing hours per patient per day can be 30 hours, what gives the notion that it's a single nurse which attends a patient, it could be 3 nurses working 10 hour shifts, taking care of single patient.
Please do correct me if I am wrong. thank you.
@stoner7 said: I think the q32 c) minimum transfer price should be $14, because division A has an existing market for it's adapters i.e. 30,000, but irrespective of that it is being transferred to division B, hence the opportunity cost i.e. the sales lost - any reduction in sales due to it being an internal transfer. Hence, selling price i.e $15 less Variable selling cost to external market $1 equals $14. And nursing hours per patient per day can be 30 hours, what gives the notion that it's a single nurse which attends a patient, it could be 3 nurses working 10 hour shifts, taking care of single patient. Please do correct me if I am wrong. thank you.I agree, the nurse hours- it's a procedure in a hospital, there might be 5 nurces at this surgery or 10... about the transfer price also agree, only i said 15 not 14 as i forgot about the 1 dollar extra... To be fair div a should earn as much as if it's external... and div b has no choice as there is no other supplier....
I found this exam very hard. I had taken F4 and got a pass of 84%. I feel I have definitely failed F5 since I guessed about 5 questions and didn't answer much of section C.
f4notes - yes, 10m
saruccia - yes, I got one on the bank. I didnt know where to start...1000 customers each year, 500 leave in y1 500 in y2 etc etc.
Saif - do you know how you worked out $25?
vinxi - yes. I had been revising material variances not sales :(( so I didn't have a clue on a lot of them.
suay - 30 hrs a day is possible with for instance more then 1 nurse i,e 2 nurses provide a patient 15 hrs of care a day.
It was horible paper, i had CBE and my computer froze in the middle of it and i had to change stations, so distracting....
100% agree with you.
And in the mcq section, q were so complex that i had to read it two or three times, just to understan what they're asking....
There was one q so random, i swear it was like from different paper, must have been one if the seeded q's....
Did anyone had that problem?
Hate MCQs, there use to be 1 out 4 possible answer. now select 2 or 3 out of 4, 5 or 6.
if you get 1 wrong=0 marks.
Past papers and RK did not help this time at all. i was hoping that few questions may repeat from RK or Past papers but i saw nothing.
What do you get for the actual learning rate and c which month it ceases
Absolutely agree, task so long to read it just takes up most of your time. Does anyone remember in ABC which cost were going to increase when switching to ABC from absorption costing?
Learning rate is 90% for the actual performance, it stops in November i.e last seen effect of learning rate is in November. No effect of LR from December onward.
If it's with respect to the hospital procedures, then procedure 1 increases and procedure 2 decreases.
I got 90% And after 3 months so November. Very different paper to what expected. Spent ages revising budget types, expected values, maximax etc to have nothing on it
@stoner7 said: Learning rate is 90% for the actual performance, it stops in November i.e last seen effect of learning rate is in November. No effect of LR from December onward. If it's with respect to the hospital procedures, then procedure 1 increases and procedure 2 decreases.I thought it ceased in December onward. I got 90 as well
The planning and operational variance was tricky thought. I got adverse for both
The economy,efficiency and effectiveness questions was straight forward
I applied the learning curve to the first 4 units then rest at steady rate to give revised hours for the output. Then compared actual to revised for operational and revised to original for planning. No idea if right
Can anyone write answers sequentially? I got a lot of B variant
Operational adverse planning favourable
I got operational and planning both favorable, I took the original budget worked without any LR involved as the director's concern with the preparation of the budget by the trainee was that he did not consider the LR effect while preparing the budget.
Found this paper a little easier to do to time than paper based have sat this paper 3 times 48% each time have actually had enough of f5 now
However the section A felt like it was never going to end ... transfer price not to bad but q32 learning curves I just struggled to grasp what I was doing this is where a little extra time would have helped
The fact we had extra questions as well that we do not get any marks for frustrated me I bet these were the easy ones haha !!
Sections B found not to bad anybody else think they did ok section b ?
In section b throughput what was the bottleneck resources.
I put canning ?and 2500 could be wrong
I don't get it - some of your comments here are scaring me - I didn't see a single learning rate questions, nor transfer price question. Only one question in Section A re: ROI and RI.
Was the learning rate and transfer price questions hidden somewhere?
Or do we have different exams? I took mine in London 2pm GMT
Section b - chairs and tables, teachers and books and flexible budgeting- found B good!
Yes, 90 is right. I guess. Also I remember that on operating statement of Div A in section C I got profit 100 for Div A, and something like 7890 for the group.
I didn't have transfer pricing either 2pm
I sat mine Brighton 2pm has transfer pricing and learning curve both section c
They are talking about section C
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

