Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

PM*** ACCA F5 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin8y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the ACCA F5 March 2018 Exam

*** ACCA F5 March 2018 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results Post your comments about the ACCA F5 exam below (comments will open after 5pm UK)
VVinxi8y ago#91
Even when division A had external demand it didn't sell those units at 14 to be. As far as I remember n that was the point I notes that after fixed cost addition there was a too high price charged for transfer which couldn't be acceptible when there's no external demand also it cannot be considered as minimum too even it was more than divi b could get from external. But still rule is to add cost incurred when no external market n that includes fixed cost . That's what is bothering me..God knows what was the correct minimum transfer price. Ppr was hell bad for me overall.
VVinxi8y ago#92
I went for something like 3.75 allthogh I strongly beleive it wasn't corect but incouldnt find a way to get cor re ct answers for tp question it was tricky .
VVinxi8y ago#93
It was canning. Are u sure of 2500 n did u get that question of variance which m talking about? It was somethin foe quarter 2 I beleive there were no actual figures given we had to calculate variance from other variances I couldn't find a way to get to the answer. But I knew m bad at guessing even on 50% prob :(
Vviscera8y ago#94
#all I just want to say one thing.. Acca are getting unfair with the question asking style, their provide us with very few information's and expects us to answer these question us making the right asumptions... How can that even be possible... in the Transfer pricing question part (b) they were asking that how much to sell internally and externally with the optimum benefit to the company and then in the question it was clearly written that Div B wants 150,000 of adaptors because it wasn't utilizing its full production capacity, even with the demand of battery be like 180,000... Div A had 200,000 external demand as the question was taking me ... it was clearly showing that Div A is full filling both Div B demand and External demand completely.. The i ask from the acca whats the point of asking this kind of question, are u guys trying to confuse us, or u guys dont have any other thing left to ask
VVinxi8y ago#95
I agree mate that's the point I was thinking. The question on transfer thing was the lamest ever question on this topic they were not even clarifying things in question with words like full capacity stuff just to miss guide the purpose was not testing knowledge coz it cannot be tested on such stuff. Whole ppr was a peice of sh*t for me. Transfrr thing eas very confusing not even fullfilling the purpose of transfer pricing with no post contributions and stuff. Tooo lame. Acca should stop putting such stuff on our heads atleast go with ur standard Acca plz
Ddamity8y ago#96
This paper was just too horrible.... I read and understood f5 just to be clueless during exams especially question 31/32 .
BBella8y ago#97
@vinxi said: Even when division A had external demand it didn't sell those units at 14 to be. As far as I remember n that was the point I notes that after fixed cost addition there was a too high price charged for transfer which couldn't be acceptible when there's no external demand also it cannot be considered as minimum too even it was more than divi b could get from external. But still rule is to add cost incurred when no external market n that includes fixed cost . That's what is bothering me..God knows what was the correct minimum transfer price. Ppr was hell bad for me overall.
Div A had always had external damand-200 000 units. They were selling at fool to it and only what they had extra up to their max capacity (350000)they were selling to div b. That was the problem- div b wanted more, bcs they were able to sell more and they were making bigger profit. Thats why they had external supplier at the same price. Q was if there was no such supplier, what would be min transfer price, but i think they meant fair for both div's... you know- goal congruence, wats best for the company as a whole...
VVinxi8y ago#98
Maybe u re right. I don't know why I put on seven. I was just thinking if it sells at 14 that would be way to more even it would be same as previous price when it had external market . And now when there is no external market it would prefer to sell at minimum price of 7 not at price which covers everything otherwise it will have all of the stock turn waste. As its getting any contribution outside it would be willing to get this marginal contribution at minimum. I went on with this assumption. But now it think its wrong
VVinxi8y ago#99
Way too errors in spell m sorry hope h have understood my reason :D well goodluck for result.
Ssookrah8y ago#100
I totally agree. The questions in part C, was too far from revision past papers as well as from BPP and Kaplan revisions
Ggoodvibes8y ago#101
This articles has an example which is so similar to ques31 on learning rate part a. https://www.accaglobal.com/middle-east/en/student/exam-support-resources/fundamentals-exams-study-resources/f5/technical-articles/the-learning-rate-and-learning-effect.html
Ssookrah8y ago#102
Ya same for ans for the profits
JJK8y ago#103
Paper was very hard. Section C question on the value of money. It such a small section in the syllabus don't know why it was such a big question.
TTahir8y ago#104
@viscera said: #all I just want to say one thing.. Acca are getting unfair with the question asking style, their provide us with very few information's and expects us to answer these question us making the right asumptions... How can that even be possible... in the Transfer pricing question part (b) they were asking that how much to sell internally and externally with the optimum benefit to the company and then in the question it was clearly written that Div B wants 150,000 of adaptors because it wasn't utilizing its full production capacity, even with the demand of battery be like 180,000... Div A had 200,000 external demand as the question was taking me ... it was clearly showing that Div A is full filling both Div B demand and External demand completely.. The i ask from the acca whats the point of asking this kind of question, are u guys trying to confuse us, or u guys dont have any other thing left to ask
I absolutely agree with you.The ultimate objective should be the learning by testing concepts. Not confusing candidates to make mistakes. And confusing on things which are not part of the syllabus but based on a IQ level which varies from person to person.I was thinking as once told by my tutor such low quality questions can only be seen in BPP and Kaplan kits but now ACCA is also following the same path.
CChris8y ago#105
Did anyone have a question on tables and chairs in section B? One question was how many tables should be produced in quarter 1, limiting factor was 25m3 of oak each table used 5m3....however, 4 tables was not an option so I selected the maximum demand.
Oodean8y ago#106
@chrisj1 said: Did anyone have a question on tables and chairs in section B? One question was how many tables should be produced in quarter 1, limiting factor was 25m3 of oak each table used 5m3....however, 4 tables was not an option so I selected the maximum demand.
If i remember correctly i thought the question ask how many chair should be produced. It was only one scare resources material and unlimited labour so you are correct it is a limited factor. First you would have to rank the product based on return per scares resource. Chair was rank second, therfore table would be first. I dont remember how many unit but i remember that only 12 meter was available for chair only and each chair use 0.2 meter Therfore 60 chair should be produced 12÷0.2 = 60
NNatia8y ago#107
In question 31 I calculated learning rate 96% 400*32*r5=10368 r5=0.81 r=96% How did you get 90%?
HHarish8y ago#108
Exactly guys i agree with all of your comments regarding the transfer pricing question.... It's an unethical way to confuse the students.... First i multiplied with 150000 units only then i striked it out & changed it to 180000 units.... What is the correct answer? Do we have multiply by 150000units or 180000 units??
HHarish8y ago#109
@odean20 said: If i remember correctly i thought the question ask how many chair should be produced. It was only one scare resources material and unlimited labour so you are correct it is a limited factor. First you would have to rank the product based on return per scares resource. Chair was rank second, therfore table would be first. I dont remember how many unit but i remember that only 12 meter was available for chair only and each chair use 0.2 meter Therfore 60 chair should be produced 12÷0.2 = 60
Yes 60 chairs is the correct answer.....
Oodean8y ago#110
@natss said: In question 31 I calculated learning rate 96% 400*32*r5=10368 r5=0.81 r=96% How did you get 90%?
The second batch takes 360 hours The first batch takes 400 hours Therefore divide 360÷400 = 90% Or 1 batch take 400 hours 1 batch take 320 hours Add both batch and divide by 2. That is (400 +320)/2 = 360 hours An then divide by the 1 first batch 400. That is 360÷400 = 90%
Ddipta8y ago#111
@odean20 said: If i remember correctly i thought the question ask how many chair should be produced. It was only one scare resources material and unlimited labour so you are correct it is a limited factor. First you would have to rank the product based on return per scares resource. Chair was rank second, therfore table would be first. I dont remember how many unit but i remember that only 12 meter was available for chair only and each chair use 0.2 meter Therfore 60 chair should be produced 12÷0.2 = 60
yea right ans is 60
Ddipta8y ago#112
can anyone tell how u guys calculated the 31 question variance?
JJennie8y ago#113
I got 60 too after ranking them on contribution per scarce resource
SShujuanSupporter8y ago#114
It was hard paper and I run out time for C
Oodean8y ago#115
@dipta3308 said: can anyone tell how u guys calculated the 31 question variance?
That was a trick question. First you would have to calculate the revised standard using the learning rate of 85% The question say after three month ( the 2 batch) the the product reach a steady state. My reason was that i should find the nth batch of the remaining 14 batch (16 batch - 2 batch) Y=400× 2 batch^0.234 Y=340.109 hours Total hours for 2 batch (340.109 × 2 batch) = 680. 22 hours Y= 400 × 1 bacth ^0.234 =400 hours Total hours for 1 batch (400 * 1) = 400 hours Therfore the nth batch is ( 680 - 4000) = 280.22 hours Batch 3 onward would take 280.22 hours Month 1-3 would take 680.22 hours Month 3-6 would take 3923.08 hours ( nth batch 280.22 × the remaining 14 batch) Total hours work 4603.3 hours Revise standard is 4603.3 hours × $16 = $73652.80 Original standard is 400 hours × 16 batch × $16 = $102400 Planning variance is $28747.2 F Revise standard is 4603.3 hours × $16 = $73652.80 Actuall hours worked is 5184 hours × 16 =$82944 Operational variance is $9291.20 A
TPTuấn Phạm8y ago#116
@odean20 said: That was a trick question. First you would have to calculate the revised standard using the learning rate of 85% The question say after three month ( the 2 batch) the the product reach a steady state. My reason was that i should find the nth batch of the remaining 14 batch (16 batch - 2 batch) Y=400× 2 batch^0.234 Y=340.109 hours Total hours for 2 batch (340.109 × 2 batch) = 680. 22 hours Y= 400 × 1 bacth ^0.234 =400 hours Total hours for 1 batch (400 * 1) = 400 hours Therfore the nth batch is ( 680 - 4000) = 280.22 hours Batch 3 onward would take 280.22 hours Month 1-3 would take 680.22 hours Month 3-6 would take 3923.08 hours ( nth batch 280.22 × the remaining 14 batch) Total hours work 4603.3 hours Revise standard is 4603.3 hours × $16 = $73652.80 Original standard is 400 hours × 16 batch × $16 = $102400 Planning variance is $28747.2 F Revise standard is 4603.3 hours × $16 = $73652.80 Actuall hours worked is 5184 hours × 16 =$82944 Operational variance is $9291.20 A
You are making me confused because isn't the number of batches is 32 and actual hours worked is 10,384? It's stated in the case
JJennie8y ago#117
I did on 32 as well
YYanru8y ago#118
I never take this kind of hard exam though my all life, it destroyed my confidence and i thought i know every topic and accumulator points in the book and revision of practice well, but the revision exam questions with exam question is totally different style, I have no idea, why examiner is very harsh for students. ACCA f5 exam this time is a extremely hard and tricky style for me. For me, Section A is super hard, and Section B half of questions don't know how to think and answer, Section C why 3E is big sections. I really want to know this season pass rate can over 40 or not? If it is lower than F8, that is so ridiculous. My heart broken after exam done.
Oodean8y ago#119
@tuanpm102 said: You are making me confused because isn't the number of batches is 32 and actual hours worked is 10,384? It's stated in the case
The question say for six month sept to February that would be 16 batch. I can be wrong
JJennie8y ago#120
I worked so hard and did so many mocks. That felt so different to everything I practised. Especially section A and the 3es question in section C. Def knocked my confidence
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.