I am concerned if I choose boeing company for my project then how will I compare it with its competitor airbus as the currency for both companies are different
Topic 8 Period 35 onwards
Hi Trephena
Thanks a lot for your reply. I'll take note of the points you mentioned.
I forgot to mention that my main company X is a subsidiary of another bigger company Y. Can I use strictly company X as my main company because the parent company Y deals in other sectors. To be noted that I have the detailed financial reports of company X separately.
Thanks
Should be ok as the more you are comparing like with like the better and more valid the comparisons. So if by using X you are managing to eliminate the property sales business this makes the two companies more on an equal footing in terms of market and subsequent analysis.
Possibly though one of its strengths may be as part of the bigger group as it probably makes borrowing capital cheaper and there may be some benefits in terms of favourable intercompany cash flows it can call on if required.
Hi Trephena
Thank you for your valuable answer. I would be most grateful if you could clarify the following:
Question 1.
My main company deals in several countries in the world but reports in pounds. The issue is I have comparative figures both in CONSTANT currency and REPORTED currency. Under CONSTANT currency, they made a reduction in profit and under REPORTED currency (due to depreciation of the pound), they have an increase in profit.
Do I need to submit ratios for both figures? if yes do i need to make a dual analysis? One for CONSTANT currency and another for REPORTED currency? (Note that the absolute figures are different under each of them). I'm worried especially for key ratios like profit, and REVPAR figures.
On the other hand, I searched for a simpler company ( food sector this time) which deals only in one country, but i have a problem with it;s competitor.
My competitor's annual report 2016 is 01 Jan 2016 - 31 Dec 2016, however the 2015 report is 01 july 2015 - 31 dec 2015 (6 months only!) because it changed its year end. However, it also includes comparative figures for 01 july 2014 -30 june 2015.
Question 2.
Do I need to pro-rate 01 Jan 2015 - 30 june 2015 in the comparative figures (6 months) and then add in the given figures in the report 01 july 2015 - 31 dec 2015 so that i then have a full year 01 Jan 2015 - 31 dec 2015 ?
Question 3.
Is it compulsory to show a 3 year analysis for our competitor, or does the latest financial statements (competitor) suffice for evaluation of the main company?
Thank you very much
So you guys think I can compare AIRBUS with BOEING for November submissions? Plus, what if I compare different years of AIRBUS and BOEING and compare its performance? I am sorry that I am posting this again but its important.
@Salman - sorry for not answering your query. Yes Boeing and Airbus would be suitable comparators. Don't worry about the different currencies as using ratios obviates the need to translate currencies (which are not a good idea in the case of drawing comparisons as it introduces an artificial dimension that is not controllable by a company as currency fluctuations are dependent on international currency demands and complicated economic factors. Currency differences may influence company strategies but that is a separate issue to drawing comparisons)
@nzeadall - I'll answer your detailed query with respect to (1) when I have a spare moment. I have addressed (2) elsewhere on the forum - so please see the query from Chenjerai towards the top of Page 2 and my reply further down.
With (3) if you only do 1 year's worth of comparisons you are unlikely to get a grade higher than a C. The main company must always be 3 years
Hi Trephena
Thank you very much for question 2. If I understood correctly your reply, then i think my proposal sounds reasonable.
Regarding Question 3, i meant one year comparison for the competitor only. For my main company, I'll certainly do 3 years analysis. What i meant is evaluating main company A
Yr 1, Yr 2 and Yr 3 versus competitor B, yr 3 only or should it be main company A
Yr 1, Yr 2 and Yr 3 versus competitor B, Yr 1, Yr 2 and Yr 3.
For Question 1, I'll wait for your response.
Once again thanks a lot for your precious assistance.
In Part 2 of RAP, I'll be mentioning ratio analysis under accounting techniques used.
There are various categories of ratios such as profitability ratios, liquidity ratios, etc and each category has got many kinds of rations such as profit margin, ROCE, etc.
Which ratios do I choose, to briefly comment on?
Also when stating limitations, do I mention them in general for Ratio Analysis or specifically for each ratio?
Please note I've chosen the Hotel Industry.
@nzeadall - if the annual report is in GBP use those figures. Trying to deal with differences in currency treatment would (a) over complicate things and (b) mean that you are focusing too much on figures and percentages. What you need to do is look at the bigger picture.
By this I mean spend time doing a good PEST and SWOT. Go over the CEO and directors' reports for all 3 years and also the year before your analysis period starts. See what major decisions and policies have been implemented and how these relate to PEST and SWOT factors. This should enable you to do a better analysis.
Yes I understood you meant one year only of analysis for the competitor -hence my comment "if you only do 1 year’s worth of comparisons you are unlikely to get a grade higher than a C". If you hope to get a higher grade then more analytical depth is required including comparing the performances (as opposed to just financial results) for the 2 companies over a full 3 years
@accastudentofoman - This is quite basic stuff and I would have thought that if you had a decent mentor this would have been discussed between you??
You need to consider the most important ratios: gross profit and net/operating profit being key and you also along with some liquidity ratios need to look at gearing. There should also be some discussion of investors returns and ratios. I have however always stressed the work is not just about calculating figures and percentages - it is also about explaining what has driven performance (so see the answer immediately above). For the hotel trade you should also consider room occupancy rates,and other KPIs used in the industry. Read the written part of the annual report that precedes the financial statements to find these
Thanks a ton for your guidance!
Hello Trephena,
My friend is doing the project. And he has chosen to go for the dairy industry. The company's core products are dairy but it also produces juices.The problem is the bsc info pack clearly states no beverages. Is it fine to go ahead with this company ??
Since finding a company solely of dairy products is difficult.
Please can you help ??
hi i just wanted to ask on how to get the list of verified mentors for the oxford brookes rap project ?
@nada000 - as long as it produces mainly food (yoghurt, cheese, chocolate for example) then some beverages as part of the product portfolio would be acceptable. Just milk and juices would not.
@kamlesh - register as a mentee on the OBU mentoring website and there should be a list showing the names and where the mentor is based. In the first instance you can contact anyone on the list via the website to enquire about potential mentoring
Hello trephena,
Thank you for your help. I wanted to ask if hotel chocolat and Ferero spa for topic 8 would be good ???
Although Ferero spa is bigger than hotel. chocolat but they both are into chocolate.
For topic 8 should companies be listed on the stock exchange ??
Can you recommend companies which produces biscuits or snacks ??
Hi,
Must say I've found this forum very helpful and thank you for your assistance and guidance.
I hope you can clarify a few things for me.
For my submission period, sectors are Aerospace, Food products & Hotels. I've looked at the ICB and looks like these are sub sectors of a sector. I've decided to choose Aerospace (2713).
My only concern is that organisations are now much more diverse and have different income source and can be involved in different sub sectors. So, how strict do we need to be in choosing a sector specific organisation? For. e.g. I've picked Rolls Royce PLC primarily sells aircraft engines but also supplies to defence sector (2717) and is involved with marine & nuclear activiites. Should I choose organsiatons that are strictly sector specific as provided by OBU? However this is going to be a challenge as we all know that the publicly available financial statements are group consolidated and segregating it will be a real challenge. Also, comparing it with its competitors will be a real challenge too as their figures will be diluted as well. Most of the organisations involved in aerospace sector will be involved in defence and other sectors for generating income. Not just aerospace, most of these organisations with publicly available financials will one way or another will have diverse income sources and a real challenge to be sub-sector specific.
I've emailed ACCA OBU to seek clarifications as well but no response yet.
Can you shed some light on this and assist?
Many thanks
Nash
Note from Trephena: I am away from home staying in a part of the country with very limited internet access. If your query is not answered this issue in most cases lies behind the reason for not answering it right now.
I would like to know the ideas of what are the specific ratios for Aerospace industry? Anyone any idea what ratios are industry specific? Please share 2 or more. Thank you. Boeing
You will need to read through the written pages of their annual reports and visit the investor relations sections of their websites. You should also read around the business and get a feel for the industry before attempting the analysis as most of these companies operate very differently from companies in other sectors.
Companies in this sector spend huge amounts on design and R&D and therefore an analysis of this would be very relevant. Looking at things like inventory in a textbook manner is probably a waste of time (and demonstrates a lack of understanding of the business): for example Boeing makes planes to order (although possibly some specialist spare parts would be carried as stock and sold).
However WIP valuations would need to be looked at instead as significant amounts of capital are tied up in planes that may take months (if not years) to assemble and they are not all completed on the last day of the financial year!!! Customers pay deposits up front with order and stage payments during construction and some profit taken on the potential sale at various points throughout manufacture. Order book figures would therefore be crucial to maintaining a smooth running operation and all aspects of planning particularly cash flow and capital.
Any specific KPIs may vary from company to company
@nada000 - I like the idea of Hotel Chocolat and Ferrero, however you need to have access to the financial statements which may sometimes be an issue with private limited companies. If you can get these for HC then go ahead. They have different marketing models and and philosophies so there will be some limitations in the comparisons you can make.
In fact I think HC would make a good subject for Topic 18.
Good day all, i require a clarification with regards a company to choose for topic 8, i intend using a food producer, a company that is into the manufacture of pasta, noodles, semolina, would this company be allowed as a food producer.
@nash1807 - apart from mentioning the diversity etc. in your limitations section and where appropriate in the analysis, I can give y out no real advice. It will be interesting if you get a detailed reply from the OBU Office, (which I doubt) but if you do please post it here.
I have made some comments and suggestions on the Aero space thread so you might l like to read those. I can't help feeling that the business analysis should be the main focus for this sector (marketing factors being particularly important e.g. customers [commercial companies or government] promotion [air shows, trade delegations] payment terms and product differentiation. In fact an Aero space company would probably a good subject for Topic 18.
Sorry I can't be much help but the sectors for T8 in P35 are quite difficult and none are really clear-cut.
@trephena - Thanks for your response. I've had no reply to my email yet, doubt I'd get one. If I do, I will post it here.
dhameelolar - that sounds appropriate as a food producer
Hi,
The results i am getting for Marriott are segregated quarter wise and as we are to analyse the whole year,how am I to project the quarterly reasons of increase/decriease in numbers to the whole year.
Should i just pick out the reason out of the 4 quarters that had the most impact or combine the reasons of the 4 quarters? but that would mean having to reference 4 pages for 1 para.
Best Regards.
I am thinking of submitting RAP in Period 35 on topic 8 and recently went through OBU Info Pack. I am really confused about choice of organization. The choice has been made unnecessarily difficult by limiting it to specific industry sub sector ( not even keeping it to a sector). I am really unable to understand that what is the point in narrowing down the choice of organization so much that it becomes a headache for students. For evaluating business and financial performance of an organization students obviously needs an organization of size large enough to be a topic of discussion in business reporting media platforms and for which financial and other business information is available through at least some sources. But organizations of such size rarely very rarely operate within a sub sector of an industry as large organizations have diverse product portfolios and mostly even industry sectors are not a boundary for their products. Even if one finds a company fulfilling the specifications, finding a suitable competitor is nearly impossible. ( According to my initial research on food product companies) As it adds another layer of specifications that is finding two companies operating in same target market with nearly similar product portfolios obviously otherwise their wont be a competition particularly at organizational level.
Whilst I agree that the industry sectors are fairly hard no-
one is forcing you to select Topic 8 if you don't l like the selection (or perhaps your mentor is?.) There are 18 other topics to choose from several of which do not require any primary data collection e.g. Topics 17, 18 and 20 where you can more or less choose a company (provided there is sufficient data) so why not broaden your horizons and do for something else as OBU is not going to change the industry sectors for at least another year.
hello trephena,
can you tell me united technologies with honeywell will go well for topic 8 ? Please could you guide ?
@trephena no mentor isnt forcing me to go for topic 8. I myself am much more confident about this one as compared to all other topics except the part of choosing the organization and so i placed my concerns over here with hope of some guidance and help instead of being remarked as ignorant :) its just that i was really upset as i have been trying to find a suitable organization for last three days which make me wrote my query in a complaining tone.
I was not implying ignorance on your part but know students (about 70% of them generally and about 95% in Pakistan) just never consider anything other than topic 8, (which followers of this forum will know is not a particular favourite topic of mine). However I try to overcome my bias by advising where I can for example I have produced an article on Evaluation and Analysis on our homepage which focuses mainly on this in relation to Topic 8 and also I created a special forum on Airlines for Topic 8 when they were the industry sector (which if you read the comments on P34 results students found invaluable).
Previously I had created a special forum for Topic 17 mainly because African students actually tend not to go for Topic 8 and were looking for a suitable topic that did not involve primary data collection. This forum for T17 has proved very popular and useful. Overall many students have commented that with my advice they have achieved B grades
In relation to the new industry sectors for Topics 8 and 15: they are so hard I genuinely think students would be better off considering alternative topics. I therefore wanted you to be aware that you stand a much better chance of passing if you broadened your horizons and looked elsewhere. ( I would in fact put money on the statistics for P35 backing me up on this - and I am not a gambling woman - that Topics 17, 18 and 20 will have higher pass rates than Topic 8).

