I am concerned if I choose boeing company for my project then how will I compare it with its competitor airbus as the currency for both companies are different
Topic 8 Period 35 onwards
@aynskyfighter - PepsiCo produces some snack foods and so do Nestle. However Nestle is more associated with chocolate and confectionery so is probably best paired with another company producing chocolate and sweets.
@ishika - as I think I explained to someone else, you need to see who the target market is, geographical spread and number of hotels. There is never going to be a perfect match so you explain this in the limitations and when discussing the results
Hi trephena,
Still waiting for a reply on my question on Woolworths.
Marks and Specer is a food retailer and although they sell food under their brand name they do not manufacture this. I think Woolworths in S.A. is the same I.e. a food retailer not a manufacturer. Can you find some biscuit or confectionery manufacturers instead?
Im choosing food industry, can i choose candy company? Like tootsie roll corp
Possibly, however as I have pointed out I am not familiar with the operations of every company. You need to look at their markets and products and ensure both they and the comparator manufacture the products (as opposed to just marketing or selling them) and there is sufficient to consider them and match them together as competitors. There is unlikely to be a perfect match so you discuss this in the limitations section and where appropriate in your analysis.
@Chenjerai -
Yes this is a bit of a problem. It may depend upon why they have charged their year end - were they recently taken over by another company? If so this might make it unsuitable.
However otherwise you could adjust the financial statements to make this last year 12 months by dividing the income statement by 12/15 which would give you an approximation of Jan to Dec 2015. This also would mean going back to the previous year end Sept 2014(?) and taking 9/12 representing Jan to Sep and adding 3/15 of Oct 2014 to Dec 2015 as this would represent Oct to Dec 2014 so that you ended up with an approximate year Jan to Dec 2014. Similarly you would need to take 9/12 of year end 2013 and add 3/12 of 2014 to get the full figures representing Jan to Dec 2014. Fortunately you could probably use the Balance sheet figures as they are (unless there was a share issue between Oct to Dec 2015).
This all sounds complicated but with a spreadsheet is not as bad as it sounds.
Alternatively choose a different company!
Yes this is a bit of a problem. It may depend upon why they have charged their year end – were they recently taken over by another company? If so this might make it unsuitable.
However otherwise you could adjust the financial statements to make this last year 12 months by dividing the income statement by 12/15 which would give you an approximation of Jan to Dec 2015. This also would mean going back to the previous year end Sept 2014(?) and taking 9/12 representing Jan to Sep and adding 3/15 of Oct 2014 to Dec 2015 as this would represent Oct to Dec 2014 so that you ended up with an approximate year Jan to Dec 2014. Similarly you would need to take 9/12 of year end 2013 and add 3/12 of 2014 to get the full figures representing Jan to Dec 2014. Fortunately you could probably use the Balance sheet figures as they are (unless there was a share issue between Oct to Dec 2015).
This all sounds complicated but with a spreadsheet is not as bad as it sounds.
Alternatively choose a different company!
It is difficult for me to advise particular companies as I am not familiar with a lot of overseas companies and really have few ideas about food manufacturers. Most food manufacturers though would produce more than one product and have several products in their portfolio unless you were looking at a specialist company in something more like the luxury end of the market e.g. in the UK there is Hotel Chocolat who as the name suggests are chocolatiers. However even they are pushing the boundaries of what cocoa can go in, as they produce cocoa flavoured gin (not to my liking! :-( ) and even I believe cocoa pasta - again not something that would appeal to me but might to others.
@Obianuju -sorry I missed your query but I have been busy in the day job.
Hotel specific ratios will depend to a certain extent on the hotel size whether it is a chain and whether it is in a group. Room occupancy rate is a key one, average stay per guest, average spend per guest stay (or possibly per day/night) , profit per employee. If information is available there might be others as restaurant and bars will be regarded as business units and there might also be other forms of segmentation e.g. conference and events.
Where the hotel is a chain read through the annual report written section to discover what info is available . With a group where hotels are just part of the overall activities it may be harder to make comparisons as some of the detail may be 'lost' in total figures but again read through the written reports (CEO /directors reports to shareholders).
I am not entirely clear what you question is as it mainly comes over as a series of statements!
I have always suggested that SWOT and PESTLE are more appropriate for Topic 8 than Porter's 5 Forces (and this is even more evident when it comes to looking for a substitute for a hotel!!). SWOT and PESTLE are strategic tools and influence management decisions and impact on results. Good application of these models is vital for a pass and to link the business and financial analyses together. Looking at the CEO and directors' reports mean that their strategic decisions can be identified and subsequently analysed in the ratio section in terms of whether the financial results show these decisions to have been successful.
I have suggested some potential KPIs in a previous post above.
Note: I am not familiar with this hotel chain and therefore cannot really comment further - my expertise is on putting together a good RAP and not in choosing companies apart from offering general advice
Hi,
I wanted to ask i will be going for Hotel Industry so i have two options in my mind kindly guide me which one is better:
1. Marriott and its competitor Pearl Continental or
2. Marriott and its competitor Serena
Statements NOT questions: You got that right. Asking the right questions needs skill.
I'm more or less requiring assurance that I'm going on the right track. So I put a statement and a 'right?' at the end, to convey my thought process.
There are 38 Hotel PLC. What factors should we consider when choosing the appropriate one?
There is a particular(attractive) brand of hotel. I know under which parent company it is. But, I don't know under which of the 3 subsidiaries it's under. Where can I get the information, that which subsidiary owns the particular brand?
When a group of companies has 3 subsidiaries (all 3 of them Hotel PLC) how do we choose the most appropriate subsidiary?
Is it preferable to take the parent company annual reports or subsidiary?
Will I have to reference the news article (mentioning companies fighting for top 3 slots) when I bring in the comparator Hotel company?
I understand that there are no marks for choosing the company and its comparator but the research and analysis is going to be based on them. If down the line we realize that the company is not suitable, it might be too late to turn back.
(Although deliberation is good, it shouldn't result in paralysis by analysis.)
hi @trephena
my company has a year end of 31 mar 2017 and publishes their annual reports on 30 september 2017. as per the rules in the information pack, we should use the latest of annual reports until 31 july 2017 publishing date. however as i have said the company i chose is yet to publish their annual report on september although they have available financial statements for the year ended 31 mar 2017 but they are unaudited. should i use the 2016 Annual reports then?
thank you so much
The usual 'rule of thumb' for choosing organisations is like for like, that means either at a group level or individual level company level for both (not group for one and company level for the other). Normally companies have to be registered (by definition) and their ownership details can be found by looking at their registration details (significant shareholders / shareholdings information).
Regarding referencing -I have produced a whole article on our homepage explaining this topic called the 'Open Tuition Ultimate Guide to Referencing your RAP' -so please read that.
As I have said repeatedly I do not have any particular experience and expertise in the hotel sector so I can't really help anyone choose a particular hotel or group as their are literally millions of them out there worldwide!
Normally they must be audited so Mar 2016. Just ensure they weren't out by 31 July 2017 as that is the cut off date. The day after the date auditors sign the accounts is usually taken as the publishing date.
thank you, would apportion as you advised
Hi Trephena,
I'm thinking of choosing General Mills Inc.(main) and Conagra Brands Inc.(comparator), could you kindly confirm if these two are comparable as General mills is more focused on cereals and snacks and Conagra makes canned, frozen,preserved foods and bakery items.
Best Regards,
Furqan
Probably. I think it is always going to be difficult to find a perfect match within the same country as companies tend to have slightly different products to appeal to a different market as this is easier than competing head-to -head in the same market with another established company. So go for it and bring out the differences in their products and operations in the Limitations section and in your analysis and evaluation
Ok thanks,yes i was facing the same issue as in food producers no one is focusing on a single area and everyone has diversified into a lot of different markets
Hi,
Can I compare marriott international(the group) vs hilton worldwide(the group)?and will I be able to get sufficient data for hotels?I'm worried that the hotels industry might not have sufficient research material available.
Best Regards.
Marriott and Hilton were discussed on the first page of this thread so refer to that. As to whether their is sufficient material available that is not something you will know until you start researching but I would have thought for these two there would be sufficient
can i choose 2 food companies for topic 8 food sector with 90% same brands but huge difference in size e.g one company has 7bn of total assets and other company has 1.5bn of total assets..
I want to choose aerospace as my industry for the report. Can I choose Airbus and Boeing?
Trephena,
I am facing some issues if you could kindly help me with them.
1)Where can i find a detailed breakdown of the figures found in the the financial statements of the annual report.
2) The figure of cost reimbursement is being shown in the FS of marriott and this figure has been added in revenue and then the same is deducted as cost too.I'm not sure how to interpret this as this figure makes up 90% of the cost and revenue.
Cost Reimbursements: We recognize cost reimbursements from managed, franchised, and licensed properties when we incur the related reimbursable costs. These costs primarily consist of payroll and related expenses at managed properties where we are the employer and also include certain operational and administrative costs as provided for in our contracts with the owners. As these costs have no added markup, the revenue and related expense have no impact on either our operating or net income.
3) Also should i base my RAP on the US sector or the whole group and if i base it on the US sector alone so should I include the the whole group figures or just the US sector .The annual report contains figures of the whole marriott group.
Best Regards.
@usama somail - i don't understand how the brands are 90 %the same if they are manufacturers as brands are unique to companies though common to retailers. Or do you mean types of products? If both are manufacturers then yes you can use these in spite of size -ratios allow you to make comparisons and you can cover the size difference in the Limitations section.
@aynskyfighter -yes these would make good companies to compare as they both produce commercial airliners and compete head to head. ( Don't worry about the currencies being different as ratios obviate the need to translate currencies )
Hello Trephena,
First of all thank you so much for helping so many students like us. Really, I think you should be getting blessings from all around the world!
I have two questions regarding the companies I chose.
1. The main company has a revenue 3 times as much as its competitor and hence is a much bigger company, is this an issue?
2. The main company has approximately 1/5 of its revenue on property sales and 4/5 on hotels. I'm aware business on properties is not among the industry sectors for period 35. However considering that it is a minor sector of its main business (the main business being Hotels), can i continue with this company?
Thanks a lot
@nzeadall -apologies for the delay in responding
1. Just the usual mention of this in limitations for both of these factors .possibly also in places the size will have effected results e.g. economies of scale and larger companies can often dictate more favourable terms for themselves with suppliers (e.g. 60 -120 days payment terms whereas small companies will rarely get much of an extension beyond 30-45 days)'
2. Try to see if there is any segmental analysis for this. Depending on whether these are outright property sales you may need to consider how this element has affected the results. Often larger chains with resorts do 'time share' sales, which in terms of maintenance will incur similar costs to the rest but can be passed on as charges to the 'owners' . See what information is available as there may possibly be a special accounting treatment whereby with the actual sale of a time share a portion of the sale is held in reserves and only transferred as income to the income statement over the life of the time share.
Once again I must stress that my knowledge and experience of this industry mainly relates to personal social experience rather than having any actual experience of the hotel trader's financial working practices.
So you guys think I can compare AIRBUS with BOEING for November submissions? Plus, what if I compare different years of AIRBUS and BOEING and compare its performance?

