APMPaper P5 Dec 2010 exam was
The new examiner is indeed cool, one would enjoy writting this paper for the first time. this being the case, then i count myself thru with acca exams. alex keep it man. love you.
Hi All - lets do something positive and that will make a change by leaving all the comments that were mentioned on here to ACCA Feedback site
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ4/News/3381129
The only hope to pass is by letting ACCA know that the Exam was not well structured and hopefully they will take this into account when marking our answers.
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ4/News/3381129
The only hope to pass is by letting ACCA know that the Exam was not well structured and hopefully they will take this into account when marking our answers.
people who can pass this paper must with lots of commerical sense and good analysis skiils, otherwise it would be a disaster.
I was dissapointed to see the whole calculation part literally being wiped out. This paper should be renamed Business Analysis 2. I mean we did sit business analysis!! Why have a paper that is exactly like it. Does not make much sense. I will not call this a traditional management accounting paper.
Overall, i thought that the paper was fair but really lenghtly.....I had a bit of trouble Q2 and wasnt expecting so much written elements., anyways hoping for 50%
i guess a fair paper. You just need to go through the technical article to pass the paper as almost all the questions were covered in them. If only i concentrated more those, a pass would be guaranteed. Waiting for the result. hoping to make it!!
I think this was a fair paper...Good testing of theory and analysis skills. I definitely agree that it was quite a time constrained paper.
The key is rationing of time, and when time for a quest is expired..you MUST move onto the next quest...whether you would have liked to write more to complete your previous answer or not.
Anxiously awaiting results...keeping fingers crossed.
The key is rationing of time, and when time for a quest is expired..you MUST move onto the next quest...whether you would have liked to write more to complete your previous answer or not.
Anxiously awaiting results...keeping fingers crossed.
@timo1901 said:
Hi All - lets do something positive and that will make a change by leaving all the comments that were mentioned on here to ACCA Feedback site
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ4/News/3381129
The only hope to pass is by letting ACCA know that the Exam was not well structured and hopefully they will take this into account when marking our answers.
Well said Timo, lets let the ACCA know exactly how we feel about this, this exam was a joke. I have moved to Sydney where there are no ACCA classes so we have to study by going through the book and mainly using past exam questions, I may as well of stayed at home.
I know that everything that came up was on the syllabus but the lack of warning about how drastically different the exam would be is where i have a problem..
Hopefully they will review this but iv a feeling nothing will be done.
This infact is what I expected, the new man showed that he is not interested in the calculations. the only surprise was in question 1, though I still believe I scored more than half on it. The paper was fair, I dont think I will ever pass P5 if I didnt pass this one.
I thought this was a very fair paper and covered a number of areas.
I still don't know however what Value Based Management is and I think Q1 was a bit woolly but the optional questions were not that bad.
Can anyone remember what costings they got for the absorption costing v's the Activity Based Costing. I am sure I got £51k for the abc and £59k for the absorption incl the 45% mark up! Did anyone get similar and did you also get EVA as a good positive figure for both years??
Cheers and hopefully the results will be good in 10 weeks!
I still don't know however what Value Based Management is and I think Q1 was a bit woolly but the optional questions were not that bad.
Can anyone remember what costings they got for the absorption costing v's the Activity Based Costing. I am sure I got £51k for the abc and £59k for the absorption incl the 45% mark up! Did anyone get similar and did you also get EVA as a good positive figure for both years??
Cheers and hopefully the results will be good in 10 weeks!
Not a good paper for me at all. Though it brings no comfort to me, it gives some sense of relief to hear most of you say that Q1 was an unfair question and that it appears to be more P3. That was my feeling from the very beginning but eventually blamed myself that I was under prepared. I have not done P3 as yet but had started to look through the notes for next time around and remember seeing something on CSF. After my P5 exam, I went to opentuition notes and saw nothing on CSF. I then turned to BPP text and found only one sentence on CSF in the entire book (not the most recent text). Furthermore, I searched for the technical article that someone mentioned and could not find any. To have a full question on CSF for P5 (31 marks, the highest on the paper) is rediculous and unfair to us as students.
Hi Terryan! Hayes? Karoxa Londones aprum?
@terryann1 said:
Not a good paper for me at all. Though it brings no comfort to me, it gives some sense of relief to hear most of you say that Q1 was an unfair question and that it appears to be more P3. That was my feeling from the very beginning but eventually blamed myself that I was under prepared. I have not done P3 as yet but had started to look through the notes for next time around and remember seeing something on CSF. After my P5 exam, I went to opentuition notes and saw nothing on CSF. I then turned to BPP text and found only one sentence on CSF in the entire book (not the most recent text). Furthermore, I searched for the technical article that someone mentioned and could not find any. To have a full question on CSF for P5 (31 marks, the highest on the paper) is rediculous and unfair to us as students.
No you not the only one to feel the exam was unfair, too long and a complete joke ! i get more angry when i see people saying that it was ok and the examiner is good !! i think they probably done P3 which I haven't yet thats y i struggled. Anyways please leave your feedback on ACCA website to get a better marking, hopefully!
Had not really focused too much study on this exam, as I will be sitting P2 on Tuesday and struggling to fit it all in.
I was hoping for more theory than calculations for P5 - as I did not have to sit F5 because I started studying for ACCA under the old syllabus, so was quite worried about calulations. I passed P3 last June and hoped this knowledge will help. Went into the exam thinking I had no chance, but am quietly hopeful now.
Good luck to everyone!
I was hoping for more theory than calculations for P5 - as I did not have to sit F5 because I started studying for ACCA under the old syllabus, so was quite worried about calulations. I passed P3 last June and hoped this knowledge will help. Went into the exam thinking I had no chance, but am quietly hopeful now.
Good luck to everyone!
I think the general problem is that most of us were ready for figure crunching but we were sadly disappointed. However, I found that last june's BPP mock question was one of those tested. For me, my greatest challenge was actually the q1, all the answers are so interwoven I just can't help but wonder if I had answered all the questions in one part?!! Otherwisr, it did seem like we were writing a P3 exam, KPI,CSF and emissions . . . God help us all !!!
Can't read all those complaining that paper was unfair and differs from past ones. You are studying on professional level to get membership in honourable professional oranization thus expected to be ready for all challenges othervise what kind of professionals you are? I also feel this paper to be lengthy and suppose that I've did mistake of principle in q2, but I am not blaming examiner as being responsible for it and hope to get pass mark on 22 Feb 2011.
The questions were fair but too demanding, time was therefore the problem.
can we get shane johnson back please? grrr~~~~~
The paper was so confusing, i did not know what the examiner wanted. i had to read several times. The paper was base on theory and not much calculations. too much writing. it was a hard paper but i try my best.
Since I have been doing ACCA this was the most difficult paper I wrote. It was my last paper to qualify....I will be preparing for June 2011 exams now.
definitely too lengthy! n those topics were examined which were kinda rare.. like VBM.
I THINK IT IS UNETHICAL AND DISHONEST WHEN YOU PREPARE SO HARD AND PEOPLE BRING PAPERS LIKE THIS BOMBER....NOT MUCH HOPE OF PASSING
UMAR
UMAR
The p5 paper was really hard and was very different . i personnally thing if Critical success factor or Enviromental Accounting or z score were very important topics then there should have been some articles abt them or anyone of the topics . This paper wasnt like the questions of the revision kit so wats the whole point of doing a revision kit when not even a single question or anything similar to those revision kit questions came in the exam.
The paper was too lenghty and theory oriented. I had prepared myself for the practical part. i believe most of us were shocked with the whole thoery part especially the first question it has neva been 100% theory there were always sum practical bitss.
I believe if the examiner had a different approach then it should have been mentioned sumwhere in the articles . For this session not a single topic related article was published for P5 . Over all i doubt this paper wud have a gud pass rate ...i reallly hope i get thru thou the chances luk really lesss...i wish everyone the very best.
The paper was too lenghty and theory oriented. I had prepared myself for the practical part. i believe most of us were shocked with the whole thoery part especially the first question it has neva been 100% theory there were always sum practical bitss.
I believe if the examiner had a different approach then it should have been mentioned sumwhere in the articles . For this session not a single topic related article was published for P5 . Over all i doubt this paper wud have a gud pass rate ...i reallly hope i get thru thou the chances luk really lesss...i wish everyone the very best.
@terryann1 said:
Not a good paper for me at all. Though it brings no comfort to me, it gives some sense of relief to hear most of you say that Q1 was an unfair question and that it appears to be more P3. That was my feeling from the very beginning but eventually blamed myself that I was under prepared. I have not done P3 as yet but had started to look through the notes for next time around and remember seeing something on CSF. After my P5 exam, I went to opentuition notes and saw nothing on CSF. I then turned to BPP text and found only one sentence on CSF in the entire book (not the most recent text). Furthermore, I searched for the technical article that someone mentioned and could not find any. To have a full question on CSF for P5 (31 marks, the highest on the paper) is rediculous and unfair to us as students.
Completely agree with terryann1: it is ridiculous and unfair to have a full 31-mark question based on one small paragraph in an article published in 2006 for the old sillabus. This is an exam. In my opinion an exam should test the most important and practical topics relevant to the qualification. Most of us work full time and struggle to find sufficient time for studies. ACCA appointed "official publishers" whose textbooks do not cover topics tested in the exam. To me it is unfair that we are expected not just to read and get familiar, but to memorise content of all technical articles to be able to asnwer to exam questions. Why then to appoint "official puiblishers"? Publish everything on ACCA website and we will know that we need to read what is on the website and not to waste time on rubbish textbooks and lectures. Ofr even state that there is no limit to tested material: anything relevant to "Advanced Performance Management" can be tested at the exam.
Btw, I downloaded the article on monitoring and building CFSs on Saturday, 11 December 2010 and the title said that it was "relevant to Professional Scheme Papers 3.4 and 3.5". If you open the article now you will notice that ACCA has already changed the title to "relevant to ACCA Qualification Papers P3 and P5". How does this sound for you? Is not it unfair?
Once again, ACCA examiners should understand that this is an exam and there should be some standards and the defined sillabus tested. Students, official publishers and tuitors should be aware of what will be tested to be able to prepare/teach for the exam. If an examiner is changed he/she should be informed about current sillabus taught/studied. To me, it should be made clear what models are tested in each particular question, just like standards tested in P2. Otherwise all of us are just playing a lottery.
question1 was a difficult q asked by the examiner as compared to other questions, paper p5, seems to be much more difficult as i expect... lets hope for the best...
Too much of theories and less calculations..I understand that P level is more to theories but this sitting is too much.It seems like taking P1 or P3 instead of P5. Time allocated for this paper is not enough and abit unfair for those who practiced the past year papers because is totally different from previous diets.the fact that theory questions being asked more this sitting, it has taken up alot of candidate's time in writing and analysing. Not fair at all for the candidates.Should bear in mind on the time that candidates have to answer the whole question paper.
@yuriyp said:
Can't read all those complaining that paper was unfair and differs from past ones. You are studying on professional level to get membership in honourable
professional oranization thus expected to be ready for all challenges othervise what kind of professionals you are? I also feel this paper to be lengthy and suppose that I've did mistake of principle in q2, but I am not blaming examiner as being responsible for it and hope to get pass mark on 22 Feb
Even if it was challenging there are key topics for p5 & we were expecting a questions on those key parts but none did appear... shld we say the paper was fair and a p level????
Guys - please fill in the feedback on ACCA website https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ4/News/3381129
for this paper or any other paper. Seriously they need to change their strategy and what they doing to us after studying so hard for months and paying all this money !
for this paper or any other paper. Seriously they need to change their strategy and what they doing to us after studying so hard for months and paying all this money !
This paper was really hard for me. I stopped thinking in the exam room and ended up messing up on simple calculations like EVA . Much as we are being tested to be professionals, the style of questions was really tricky. I was re-sitting this paper and truthfully speaking June exams were far much better. It's really disappointing with one paper to go. Anyway let's not give up guys, i hope June 11 exams will be fair.
For me,it's hard...im not expecting so many theory as what come out in the question. We are expecting more calculation on this. I dont know whether can pass or not..but,i really hope examiner more linean in examine the paper. I really hope that i pass this paper since it's my last paper...

