APMPaper P5 Dec 2010 exam was
yeah i agree buddy,. see from reading his article, its assumed you know the technical stuff, learning off lists doesnt cut it. you have to think outside the box, very p3 & p1...so could go either way for everyone!!
@ kc81 , yes, u can ace it or fail it !!
Q1 - i tried my answer to be as relevant to the scenario as possible, and imagine it in real life situation. monetaring or building CSF, never heard of them either. i thought monitoring are those which are external to the organisation and which FP needs to be constantly aware of (logic from monitoring) eg. the movie reviews, the holiday trends, vampire mania, etc. building i said is about building within the organisation. like having strong cost control, or any other factors that relate to improving operating performance.
part C i linked them all up, eg. movie ratings on the website etc
Q3 - EVA easy, op bal of working capital and interest after tax adjustment.
Discussion was very similar to examiner article.. at this point of the exam i start getting behind my schedule
Q2 - tried the ABC and traditional. not so sure whether ABC cost driver apportin was rught, but picked up on cost drivers and overheads costs being not in order etc. comment was logical based on the figures i got, so at least that should score a mark
Beyond budgeting, well it was 8-9marks, i have few good and lots of waffle too
Q5 - not bad, everything was ready calculated so pure analysis. a good subjec as well, corp failure
overall mark allocated to questions seem very random
Q1 - i tried my answer to be as relevant to the scenario as possible, and imagine it in real life situation. monetaring or building CSF, never heard of them either. i thought monitoring are those which are external to the organisation and which FP needs to be constantly aware of (logic from monitoring) eg. the movie reviews, the holiday trends, vampire mania, etc. building i said is about building within the organisation. like having strong cost control, or any other factors that relate to improving operating performance.
part C i linked them all up, eg. movie ratings on the website etc
Q3 - EVA easy, op bal of working capital and interest after tax adjustment.
Discussion was very similar to examiner article.. at this point of the exam i start getting behind my schedule
Q2 - tried the ABC and traditional. not so sure whether ABC cost driver apportin was rught, but picked up on cost drivers and overheads costs being not in order etc. comment was logical based on the figures i got, so at least that should score a mark
Beyond budgeting, well it was 8-9marks, i have few good and lots of waffle too
Q5 - not bad, everything was ready calculated so pure analysis. a good subjec as well, corp failure
overall mark allocated to questions seem very random
Why in these days suddenly question papers become so long and to much analysis in that short time. They decided to kill us by long question??????
I feel it was quite okay, not that bad...Although the first question was unexepected, it was rather difficult to come up with proper CSFs and KPIs for such a specific industry under time pressure. And 2a was a bit complicated, not sure I did it correctly. But I'm happy with the optional questions, I feel I made up for lost marks in the first two questions. Good luck to everyone with the results:)
I think paper was quite different from past sittings............but not a bad one...I think it was lot more easy to do if you understand th ewordings...
Q1 was based upon a previous article upon csfs and everything was there what examiner has asked....building monitoring csf as...
Q2 a was bit confusing what to do ....I ended up with low cost in abc so recoomended to lower the price so that benefit from future compititors.
b was beyond budgeting... so was nice...def..principles...drawbacks of traditional budgets ...and some realtions with scenario....
Q3 a VBM...measuring value of company by future cash flow.....value mindset...link with performance management..
b EVA very easy calculation EPS share price...but struggled to write more except two three points...
c) again linking eva to cash flow as eva has same logic as NPV and difference in traditional profil measures...
I did Q 5.was running out of time so wrote very few points on each parts although if enough time was there was a easy one....
overall marking should be easy as paper was different and was not as expected...
Q1 was based upon a previous article upon csfs and everything was there what examiner has asked....building monitoring csf as...
Q2 a was bit confusing what to do ....I ended up with low cost in abc so recoomended to lower the price so that benefit from future compititors.
b was beyond budgeting... so was nice...def..principles...drawbacks of traditional budgets ...and some realtions with scenario....
Q3 a VBM...measuring value of company by future cash flow.....value mindset...link with performance management..
b EVA very easy calculation EPS share price...but struggled to write more except two three points...
c) again linking eva to cash flow as eva has same logic as NPV and difference in traditional profil measures...
I did Q 5.was running out of time so wrote very few points on each parts although if enough time was there was a easy one....
overall marking should be easy as paper was different and was not as expected...
Completely out of left field this exam was. Where was my lovely budget comparison? I barely picked up my calculator - it was much too theoretical. It worries me when ppl say they had to ask for another answer booklet. Does that mean I didn't write enough?? And don't even talk about Q1... ugh! I felt like a, b & c was the same question - just phrased differently. lol
I actually liked Qus2 coming out of the exam but then someone said the mark-up was NOT on full cost, just the production cost? Arrgh! First P4 now this, why me?
I actually liked Qus2 coming out of the exam but then someone said the mark-up was NOT on full cost, just the production cost? Arrgh! First P4 now this, why me?
don't think this paper was fair at all! Fair enought he examiner said he would give more discursive questions - but to give discurisve question on parts of the paper which have no really length to them is pretty bad!
Where in P5 do CSF's/KPI's come up? Certainly not mentioned in open tuition lectures, and don't recall seeing them in BPP either. This is a question I would expect to find in a P3 paper - given that I sill have this to do then I had no idea what to write - panicked and wasted too much time! Unusual to have a whole question based on one part of theory - not like he "pilot question" at all in my opinion.
HORRIBLE! will be re-sitting next year!
Where in P5 do CSF's/KPI's come up? Certainly not mentioned in open tuition lectures, and don't recall seeing them in BPP either. This is a question I would expect to find in a P3 paper - given that I sill have this to do then I had no idea what to write - panicked and wasted too much time! Unusual to have a whole question based on one part of theory - not like he "pilot question" at all in my opinion.
HORRIBLE! will be re-sitting next year!
Everyone has a different style, I asled for 3booklets, mind u only used one page of the last booklet
Completely disgusted by the examiner why do this to us .....we practise past exam questions then find out exam nothing like anything we have done..
Worst p5 paper I have ever seen!!!! I have done all practice but nothing could prepare me for this.I am sure pass rate will be the low 30s . The questions were not worded properly so didn't understand what was wanted.
*****Third time writing this paper.....I hope I pass b cuz I am FREAKING FED UP.....didn't feel as bad as i felt after the 1st 2 times i wrote it...but i'm still not in the clear.....PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE LET ME PASS!!!!****
I think the paper is ok, compared to P4---loads of both computations and reports! The questions are not lengthy, but our answers are long. The questions are reasonabaly long so leave us enough time to thhink and write. The new examiner's sample question has stated and showed his new style for the paper--he expects we have analytical skill rather than computation.I have studied the text book too and still found going through the book is useful. Something(theories, models..) always comes across your mind during the exam. Anyway best luck for all of us
it was horrible. one of the worst papers I've seen and it was the last one for me.
Can the tutor make some comments on the answers so that we can judge our answers please?
Can the tutor make some comments on the answers so that we can judge our answers please?
It was interesting to note that exam made use of several articles in Student Accountant - on CSFs, Beyond Budgeting, Failure predictions models. The ABC latest article explained well together with the calculations the difference between the traditional and ABC approaches to allocate overheads, and the ABC exam question was set in that line.
The new examiner did not ask any extraordinary question. In fact, as a post - event analysis I can state that reading with understanding those articles alone contributed substantially to exam success.
As we should bear in mind the exam questions will always be not the ones we saw, it was important to learn the textbook along with question practice.
Yes, I was also surprised by the new style of paper overall. And aware very well that it is quite obvious where you score marks on calculations rather than on totally discursive questions ( As I saw my 2 mocks markings, I realised that even half of page writing does not guarantee you 1 mark).
But I do not think that by seeing different style of questions which were absolutely within the syllabus I have a right to claim the unfairness of the paper.
However I suspect that overall ratio of calculations to discussions has not been maintained on this paper, which according to LSBF free video lecture- out of total 120 marks available( 5 questions = 120 marks) average discussion marks = 74.7 and average computation marks = 45.3. If examiner's performance assessed on these KPIs, next time we shall definitely see more computations.
My colleagues - students, what do you think about the adherence to those PIs?
The new examiner did not ask any extraordinary question. In fact, as a post - event analysis I can state that reading with understanding those articles alone contributed substantially to exam success.
As we should bear in mind the exam questions will always be not the ones we saw, it was important to learn the textbook along with question practice.
Yes, I was also surprised by the new style of paper overall. And aware very well that it is quite obvious where you score marks on calculations rather than on totally discursive questions ( As I saw my 2 mocks markings, I realised that even half of page writing does not guarantee you 1 mark).
But I do not think that by seeing different style of questions which were absolutely within the syllabus I have a right to claim the unfairness of the paper.
However I suspect that overall ratio of calculations to discussions has not been maintained on this paper, which according to LSBF free video lecture- out of total 120 marks available( 5 questions = 120 marks) average discussion marks = 74.7 and average computation marks = 45.3. If examiner's performance assessed on these KPIs, next time we shall definitely see more computations.
My colleagues - students, what do you think about the adherence to those PIs?
I attended BPP taught course, revision course and their mystudy too but they did not help me much as I hadn't done F5. I was totally hopeless that I didn't even have the courage go through the revision kit hardly. But luckily I got the idea of downloading opentution's notes and I simply read the whole notes just the day before exam. To my surprise the exam sounded much easier than any of the previous questions and I try to attempt from BPP's kit. I didn't leave any part except the calc part of ABC. So I now have a some rays of hope. Thanks to opentution for the clear and easy notes which I could read like a story unlike BPP's horrible notes. I should also mention we were taught by the subject expert of BPP on the revision course with his high standard?!. One should re-think of joining BPP/Kaplan again as I don't their courses are value for money anymore!!!
REMEMBER IF YOU FELT THE EXAM WAS UNFAIR (I DEFINITELY DID!) THEN PLEASE LEAVE FEEDBACK WITH ACCA AS THEY WILL TAKE THIS INTO ACCOUNT WHEN MAKRING THE PAPER:
null[/url}
null[/url}
Didnt expect that at all...have been through the past papers as part of my exam prep and apreciate that this is a new examiner, but where was the continuity?? I really didnt like the style of the exam,far to wordy (im not the best writer in the world and time was totally against me) and some of the language use wasnt good. Not so much roll on February but roll on June for the re-take...
Screggle I totally agree with you. Guys we should all leave negative feedback to this exam and maybe hope for some curve grading. This is by far the worst approach to the syllabus I have seen from all ACCA papers. I read crap load of material and did all of the exam kit and i have as much chances to passing this exam as a person who did not prepare at all ( well maybe 5-10 points more). Leave your feedback [url==https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ4/News/3381129null[/url} ][/url]
I did leave a feedback to complain the damn P5 ! I also did a lot and thought I would have chance to pass it,now no confidence, not a little.
Very long and there is something out of the syllabus in the mandatory question ( not included in study text as well as my lecture notes ) i.e, "building" and "monitoring" CFSs (What are these terms?)
The calculation is oke, not hard, quite simple and easy to get mark
The calculation is oke, not hard, quite simple and easy to get mark
Paper was fairly ok........could attempt all the questions........Q1 was a bit tricky though........there were 3 questions tht had been taken out of technical articles......EVA, Z Score and dont remember the third one........
Overall, way better thn P4.......
Overall, way better thn P4.......
i wrote alot for the 1st question. hoping to get a pass by then. have not got time to finish the whole paper. but i did write for those parts that i know how to do. was not expect on full writing question on Q1. shocked to see ABC in Q2 for i read nothing on it! expect budgets but nothing of it came. expected Beyond Budgeting and it came but i am running out of time to write more.
Overall, the paper was harder than what i expect. too much writing, thinking and common sense. Imagine writing P4 and P5 in two consecutive days. my hand is still aching now.
I tried my best and hope to get a pass! :)
Overall, the paper was harder than what i expect. too much writing, thinking and common sense. Imagine writing P4 and P5 in two consecutive days. my hand is still aching now.
I tried my best and hope to get a pass! :)
@screggle said:
I'm pretty certain I've f***** this one right up! This paper was TOTALLY different from previous papers and I know if you have learnt everything then that shouldn't really be an issue but I'm sure the BPP taught course focus is driven by past papers and from my memeory we only really covered about a third of the paper.
I was hoping that most pepople felt the same so that the marking would be more lenient, but it appears that most people on here found it to be OK, so seems like there is a good chance of me faling.
I didnt feel it was an easy paper. the exam is way too long for the 3 hours and most of it was not from the syllabus. I do not understand how can people say it was ok and fair! Anyways please give ur feedback on ACCA website, may be the marking will be lean then.
Hi Guys - if you feel that the paper was way too lenghthy for the 3 hours limits and it was not covering the main topics in the syllabus then please fill in your feedback on ACCA website and provide your commments. Hopefully the marking will be lean and fair and may be we get a pass! Please ask everyone you know to do the same.
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ4/News/3381129
https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ4/News/3381129
Agree with comments above stating that very specific parts of the course are allocated large percentages in the exam. Wish I'd studied the ACCA articles more. When i think about all those past exam questions I did for nothing....
OMG... as I opened the paper I wished I could leave the exam room I even contemplated putting down my head and just not attempting at all.
I completed level 2 before the change in syllabus so I have no clue what F5 has in it... I know for a fact the BPP P5 text does not have much about ABC calculators, nor CSFs and PIs so I hope that my memory serves and creative writing succeeds.
Good luck for Feb 22nd
I completed level 2 before the change in syllabus so I have no clue what F5 has in it... I know for a fact the BPP P5 text does not have much about ABC calculators, nor CSFs and PIs so I hope that my memory serves and creative writing succeeds.
Good luck for Feb 22nd
The paper was so horrible, this examiner is cruel I'm telling u.... There is no way a person can ask so comfusing questions like this....Ohhh!!!!! ol Questions were so demanding 4 3 hours.....
I was surprised by the new style of paper overall. This paper was totally different and harder from previous papers. How hard I have tried for the calculations and practiced myself of the budgeted income statement also useless in this sitting. I aware there is less calculation whereby the new examiner has stated his thought in the examiner approach that more discursive question will be focused on. But cannot expected so much theories been tested. This is the style of the new examiner!
I tried my best and hope to get a pass!!
I tried my best and hope to get a pass!!
To be quite honest ACCA had to change the examinator for June 2011. Especially there are some changes to the topics within P5. They had to run proper pilot paper and give enough guidance to BPP/Kaplan to reflect the changes in their course notes and book's context.
I have tried to do my best, and hope for the best!
Good luck to all of us!!!
P.S. Also I left feedback on the ACCA website as mentioned above posts.
I have tried to do my best, and hope for the best!
Good luck to all of us!!!
P.S. Also I left feedback on the ACCA website as mentioned above posts.
It was terrible! I don't understand how ACCA, as an professional institution, can allow the form of the exams to be changed every time the examiner is changed?! Isn't acca the one who should determine the form of the exam and the questions, no matter who examiner is?! It is not professional to just say:"the new examiner style"!! So we are all little animals which can be so manipulated?
If this was not my last exam, I would given up, as acca really disappointed me....
great Christamas present!
If this was not my last exam, I would given up, as acca really disappointed me....
great Christamas present!

