Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AFMPaper P4 Dec 2010 exam was

Former userFormer user15y ago#61
Tried my best:
Q1 - I had a stab at but it was too long to complete
Q2 - Would have been ok but the information was so splattered over the page that I needed more time to finish it.
Q3 - I think was ok.
Q5 - Was a pointless question. It had nothing to do with anything... it was just a bull and bluff question.

Nothing to do with the fact that the world is in a financial meltdown - which I find strange for a financial paper. (Bob barely touched on it too) - But that's maybe because both he and Bob live in their own little world of academia and have zero clue as to the outside world.

Couldn't see anything on ethics.

Let's see how this goes.

With so many more people finding it 'ok', the passmark will go up.
Sshine0515y ago#62
I used to think that Shishir Malde was a light at the end of P4 tunnel, but now I realize that this is the most foolish idea I have ever had!
Anyway, merry Xmas to all!
Former userFormer user15y ago#63
Guys, if the exam panel marks our papers as they should, I do not believe that the pass rate would exceed ...20%,
Hope that criteria will be loosen, otherwise the nightmare will continue endlessly...
Former userFormer user15y ago#64
I think the question 3~5 are easy comparing with prior year, which makes the overall rating remain OK.
Ccamille15y ago#65
I really do hope they take our comments into consideration when marking this paper since a majority seems to think that the paper was a disaster...............the scenarios were too long and took lots of time to ready through.................also think the time is not enough to answer 4 questions, should have been 3.....................couldn't read though the questions to be able to understand what it was about just glimpse through and wrote answers....................think i should have done question 1 last as it took me more than half the exam time to do it and it was difficult to continue answering the other parts since they depended on calculations from the first part......................been suffering with a terrible headache since i did this exam.............know i have to resit in June 2011 or might just choose another option.
Ppeksun8315y ago#66
For Part 3 (a), I got the N(-d1) and got something like 420 put option contracts...and for part 3(b), I calculated the put option contract price as well..I hope I get a good mark for question 1-3 , as I didn't complete Question 4 , due to run out of time..
Former userFormer user15y ago#67
The questions were very long, it was difficult to complete all four questions in the 3 hours given.
Former userFormer user15y ago#68
I pray that the examiner would consider time issues during the marking process.
Former userFormer user15y ago#69
can someone tell me how to leave a comment about the exam on ACCA's website please.
Former userFormer user15y ago#70
This was decimation! Its a total cointoss if I get over the line of not, heres what I got, lemme know what ye think;

Started with q2 - APV at 10%, working capital made everything negative? The PV of the interest relief, the PV of the Govt grant, the PV of the lost tax releif due to reduced interest costs, the issue costs, a present NPV overall..but only because of the subsidisation. Re decision - invest but question the exit strategy - where is the 16kk coming from? Is it valid? Is the Govt grant for sure and certain for hte whole of hte life etc? Then typical APV assumptions re M&M - tax exhaustion, bankruptacy risks, agency issues yadda. Of the 25 marks, I think I might have got 20.

Next stop, q3. Delta hedge. Liek a previous poster said - something like 348 shares. I think it was ending in 0.1 anyways so slighlt underhedge. I said No. of call options to sell (i dont think this is correct tho) and a bit about the symmetrical and offsetting payments to make the portfolio indepenedent of the underlying. Threw in that delta changed constantly also as a caveat. OF the 13 marks I tried to come up with some points, probably made three for each so maybe 3*3. Of hte 20 I prob go (5+9) = 16. Total thus far, 36 baby!

Question 4, DTR and all that jazz. Sloppy as hell TBH. Got (-) cashflows after capex, it was ((net profit + 75% of after tax profits on sub 1) less the capex) and then (net profit + 75%(after tax proifts on sub 1 after markup of 40% on sub two's goods) + 75%(sub two's profits with the mark up) less the cap ex again). I forget to add the additional tax on repatriation to home country on both scenarios. Of the 14 I prob only got 4, lets make it 2. Second part re discussion - I said intutively there will be less cashflow as more of the co's profits are taxed in a higher country, this may be good for non-financial reasons re media/pr etc and it may motivate that sub2 to be more productive due to perofmrance measurement etc, i said transfer pricing and management overheads etc plus to move any group losses to thiscountry to work againts this higher tax. OF the 6 marks, i guess I got 4. That makes 6 out of 20 - not cool but the cum. is 42...baby!

Finally, to q1 , did the format report but was messy messy so maybe 1 of 4 marks, part 1 was write down the assets, pay off the employees redundancies (super-preferential treatment to the blue-collar proles!!) then I got lazy and said that the bank OD had a floating charge so nadda for the debtholders and zip for the equity holders - i prob got 2 of the 3 marks - hey, its a lazy assumption! Re restructuring, stick in the new "financed by" section, new share issues bring up the bank/cash and assumed no write down to NRV since the company contines. I also put in the additional profits (7% pa?) in perpiutuy at the new discount rate (12% minus the 2% mentioned) and added that to the assets on the ne wb/s. Of the 8 marks...I expect maybe 2. Re part three, MBO, same thing, halfed the assets, added the additional profit in perp. to it and stated my obious (simplistic) assumptions. I expect 1 mark there. The last 12, a good bit of risk/return preferences, yadda yadda re equity liek a call option, stuff liek how the directors want the co. to surive to avoid any fradulent trading investigations etc and went with MBO, not coz my (shoddy) calc.smind you but for ideas like managers would pay a bigger premium for (i) depsration to keep their jobz and (ii) winners curse bidding up, (iii) use the money to restructure the remaining sections (iv) good for the shareholders to split the co.s - greater clarity (v) use the revenues to delverage the remaining co.'s d/e - of the 12 I expect maybe 8 - that be 14 from 35 and brings my total to 56

...but who knows - have I made some msitake somewhere there? Let me know peeps.

Stay cool
Former userFormer user15y ago#71
@lesly-ann said:
can someone tell me how to leave a comment about the exam on ACCA's website please.


https://www.accaglobal.com/allnews/students/2010/NEWSQ4/News/3381129
Ppeksun8315y ago#73
@change said:
This was decimation! Its a total cointoss if I get over the line of not, heres what I got, lemme know what ye think;

Started with q2 - APV at 10%, working capital made everything negative? The PV of the interest relief, the PV of the Govt grant, the PV of the lost tax releif due to reduced interest costs, the issue costs, a present NPV overall..but only because of the subsidisation. Re decision - invest but question the exit strategy - where is the 16kk coming from? Is it valid? Is the Govt grant for sure and certain for hte whole of hte life etc? Then typical APV assumptions re M&M - tax exhaustion, bankruptacy risks, agency issues yadda. Of the 25 marks, I think I might have got 20.

Next stop, q3. Delta hedge. Liek a previous poster said - something like 348 shares. I think it was ending in 0.1 anyways so slighlt underhedge. I said No. of call options to sell (i dont think this is correct tho) and a bit about the symmetrical and offsetting payments to make the portfolio indepenedent of the underlying. Threw in that delta changed constantly also as a caveat. OF the 13 marks I tried to come up with some points, probably made three for each so maybe 3*3. Of hte 20 I prob go (5+9) = 16. Total thus far, 36 baby!

Question 4, DTR and all that jazz. Sloppy as hell TBH. Got (-) cashflows after capex, it was ((net profit + 75% of after tax profits on sub 1) less the capex) and then (net profit + 75%(after tax proifts on sub 1 after markup of 40% on sub two's goods) + 75%(sub two's profits with the mark up) less the cap ex again). I forget to add the additional tax on repatriation to home country on both scenarios. Of the 14 I prob only got 4, lets make it 2. Second part re discussion - I said intutively there will be less cashflow as more of the co's profits are taxed in a higher country, this may be good for non-financial reasons re media/pr etc and it may motivate that sub2 to be more productive due to perofmrance measurement etc, i said transfer pricing and management overheads etc plus to move any group losses to thiscountry to work againts this higher tax. OF the 6 marks, i guess I got 4. That makes 6 out of 20 - not cool but the cum. is 42...baby!

Finally, to q1 , did the format report but was messy messy so maybe 1 of 4 marks, part 1 was write down the assets, pay off the employees redundancies (super-preferential treatment to the blue-collar proles!!) then I got lazy and said that the bank OD had a floating charge so nadda for the debtholders and zip for the equity holders - i prob got 2 of the 3 marks - hey, its a lazy assumption! Re restructuring, stick in the new "financed by" section, new share issues bring up the bank/cash and assumed no write down to NRV since the company contines. I also put in the additional profits (7% pa?) in perpiutuy at the new discount rate (12% minus the 2% mentioned) and added that to the assets on the ne wb/s. Of the 8 marks...I expect maybe 2. Re part three, MBO, same thing, halfed the assets, added the additional profit in perp. to it and stated my obious (simplistic) assumptions. I expect 1 mark there. The last 12, a good bit of risk/return preferences, yadda yadda re equity liek a call option, stuff liek how the directors want the co. to surive to avoid any fradulent trading investigations etc and went with MBO, not coz my (shoddy) calc.smind you but for ideas like managers would pay a bigger premium for (i) depsration to keep their jobz and (ii) winners curse bidding up, (iii) use the money to restructure the remaining sections (iv) good for the shareholders to split the co.s - greater clarity (v) use the revenues to delverage the remaining co.'s d/e - of the 12 I expect maybe 8 - that be 14 from 35 and brings my total to 56

...but who knows - have I made some msitake somewhere there? Let me know peeps.

Stay cool


Part 2(a), I discounted at 10% cost of equity too..but positive Base case NPV. and then overall, it is positive APV. Part 3(a), however, I get 420 put option contracts, with delta N(-d1) of 0.4761. 420 = 200,000 / 1,000 x 0.4761.. and the put option premium is 0.29 each...I am not sure whether it is correct or not, but my classmate get the same answer. How do you get 348 contracts tho? Question 1 , I suggested that Proposal 2 is the most likely to be suggested, after all the restructuring result. Question 4 is a disaster, run out of time.
Ttrinistudent00115y ago#74
This is my third attempt at this paper, and I was honestly annoyed at the length and quality of information to be sorted through in each question. It was time consuming and difficult to put into logical order. This is the first time in my life I have ever been in a situation where I did not attempt every single question on an exam paper.

Q1 was similar to the question Evertalk. The only difference was the last part of the question.
I chose Q2, Q3 and Q4 and man, was that a disaster. I figured out the APV and stuff.....but I didnt have the time to assimilate all the other information. I am so so disappointed because I need to pass to finish this qualification. Failing these papers are pissing me off. Examiners please get a grip and set more realistically timed exams.
Former userFormer user15y ago#75
Hope examiner
Quote:
Shishir Malde and ACCA read our message.
Q1 is disaster.Q2&Q3is better.Time is running out of on Q4.
Probably, June 2011 again!
Former userFormer user15y ago#76
@peksun83 said:
Part 2(a), I discounted at 10% cost of equity too..but positive Base case NPV. and then overall, it is positive APV. Part 3(a), however, I get 420 put option contracts, with delta N(-d1) of 0.4761. 420 = 200,000 / 1,000 x 0.4761.. and the put option premium is 0.29 each...I am not sure whether it is correct or not, but my classmate get the same answer. How do you get 348 contracts tho? Question 1 , I suggested that Proposal 2 is the most likely to be suggested, after all the restructuring result. Question 4 is a disaster, run out of time.

Re delta hedge - i did more or less the same as you (no. of shares / (delta * multiplier)) so it must have been either I didn't add/subtract to 0.5 to my table reading (or you didnt?!) or I did something wrong at the BSOP calc.s. > i'm taking it from BSOP and didn't think we needed put call parity calcs, but some other poster mentioned it elsehwere. I think i'm def wrong about shorting calls tho - that was stupid of me! But hey, its worth 7 marks so prob got 4 anyways.

Re question 2 APV, my results were susp. negative in fairness, that working capital was dragging the whole thing down so yours looks more lkely there. Kudos.

What did you do for the MBO/restructuring valuations tho? Would love to know how you tackled that?

Did you get anything done for q'4 at all? Surely you had a stab at it! Also, was gonna waffle q5 but i figured it would just take up way too much TIME!
Ppeksun8315y ago#77
@change said:
Re delta hedge - i did more or less the same as you (no. of shares / (delta * multiplier)) so it must have been either I didn't add/subtract to 0.5 to my table reading (or you didnt?!) or I did something wrong at the BSOP calc.s. > i'm taking it from BSOP and didn't think we needed put call parity calcs, but some other poster mentioned it elsehwere. I think i'm def wrong about shorting calls tho - that was stupid of me! But hey, its worth 7 marks so prob got 4 anyways.

Re question 2 APV, my results were susp. negative in fairness, that working capital was dragging the whole thing down so yours looks more lkely there. Kudos.

What did you do for the MBO/restructuring valuations tho? Would love to know how you tackled that?

Did you get anything done for q'4 at all? Surely you had a stab at it! Also, was gonna waffle q5 but i figured it would just take up way too much TIME!


For delta value (Q3(a), subtract from 0.5, because it is N(-d1) and it is a share put option.

Part 1(a), all the payable have equal claim over the net realisable value of the assets (as non going concern) and less the redundancy cost of 54m. shareholder get nothing.
2(a) Prepared the Financial position of the Doric Co. after the restructuring, with surplus of cash at bank of $20m, after the capital investment. and also prepared the income position. However, for the value of the company, I suppose to do FCF, which exclude the depreciation. I forgot to exclude the depreciation, but I still use this formula FCFx(1+g)/ke-g to get the value of the firm. Hope the examiner just penalise me 1 mark for this.
Q1(c) need additional fund of $152m..and again income position, just like Q1(b) above.

Q2(a) I guess I got the positive Base case NPV because of the realisation of the project for I guess $16m if I am not mistaken, and also the recovery of the working capital at the 4th years.

Q4 (a) I did some calculation up to the income of the subsidiary before the proposal by T.E, maybe get 3 or 4 marks only..


Later still need to attend P2 exam -.-
Ppeksun8315y ago#78
the P4 question is uploaded on acca website :-
https://www.accaglobal.com/pubs/students/acca/exams/p4/past_papers/p4/p4_2010_dec_q.pdf

can restructure the answer to check the mark..
Former userFormer user15y ago#79
It was my first time to sit the paper. its not what i had expected. The paper was too hard. Yes the expected topics such as risk mgt, Investment appraisal, business valuation were there, the main problem was about the way they were set.

Considering past papers set by Bob, i think the new examiner is once than Bob. But anyway they are completely different people. i still hope for that mark that will make me an affiliate God willing.

Wish all my colleagues the best. Lets wait for February when results come.
Former userFormer user15y ago#80
Q1 on restructuring. How is used the fact that the bondholders will contribute 90 mill cash?
Couldn't it be understood that they will purchase new bonds for 90 mill?
It probably meant that they will get new shares worth 270 mill paying only 90 mill. But from the text of it the first is also possible. Isnt't it?
Ppeksun8315y ago#81
@murat said:
Q1 on restructuring. How is used the fact that the bondholders will contribute 90 mill cash?
Couldn't it be understood that they will purchase new bonds for 90 mill?
It probably meant that they will get new shares worth 270 mill paying only 90 mill. But from the text of it the first is also possible. Isnt't it?


They are not purchasing new bonds...they are converting their existing bonds into equity. Rather than lose more than half of their bond value (unable to recover), by contributing 90m in cash, they are able to convert it into equity, and being a majority shareholder with voting rights and participate in the company's profit.
Former userFormer user15y ago#82
Well the paper was too lengthy and required some thinking again. there was no time for this. Generally it looked a fair paper but ver comprehensive. Let the examiner not make the paper too lengthy given the technicalities involved in the ppaer itself. We should keep our fingers crossed
Former userFormer user15y ago#83
Well the paper was too lengthy and required some thinking again. there was no time for this. Generally it looked a fair paper but ver comprehensive. Let the examiner not make the paper too lengthy given the technicalities involved in the ppaer itself. We should keep our fingers crossed
Former userFormer user15y ago#84
Well the paper was too lengthy and required some thinking again. there was no time for this. Generally it looked a fair paper but ver comprehensive. Let the examiner not make the paper too lengthy given the technicalities involved in the ppaer itself. We should keep our fingers crossed
Former userFormer user15y ago#85
that paper was not fair . am dropping it if i fall. bye shishir malda
Former userFormer user15y ago#86
thought the paper was ok overall...

q1) was lengthy and terribly challenging. overall i thought he juz wanna see students make decisions and be confident in it after all, the explain consist of 16 out of 35 mark... (i chose option 3 anw... anyone made the same option??)

q2) never use MM haha .... got 10% nevertheless thought it was easy as it is fairly obvious the proposal will fail should the $16m pte deal falls through. Perhaps there are other issues i dinnot consider

q3) spent the 13 marks on trying to fit his article inside lolz! i think its my worst qtn since this qtn has the least direction given

q4) i attempted this question and thought it was a given..... however none of my friend tried it leaving me quite worried.... can anyone tell me how is it done ?? Basically i settled the TP first. Next I calculate the FCFE of the company before dividend before adding the 2 different method.

While this is my first attempt, i think its much better than Bob, given that when i tried his papers, i had quite alot of time but not the knowledge. The addition of a CIS seems to be similar to the questions set by the previous examiner before bob ryan. Pass me please!
EEsther15y ago#87
Well well,my second shot, I think this guy did a better job but just that the questions were too lenghty as noted by all, However a well prepared student could have gain the 50 mark.

Q1 reconstruction, talking about the different stakeholders great question just time consuming, hey I attempted the damm thing hoping i can score atleast 15 marks, that also depends on what i wrote, you know when you know something, God Lord father have mercy, that was our first question for our study school.

Q2. APV yeahhhhh, did not realise that q2 was APV only after q1 so i rushed it however i think i have 15 marks there too. oh I need 20 marks.

q3 Delta hedge oh no should have learnt it better, or i just not getting the real thing out of this delta hedge, anywyas i attempted it too.

q4 was some dividend scheme somethiong well i did not even read that question that is to tell you how much details

q5 joint ventures in a foreign country, scenario had so may thing to understand and in that time i wote something since under time pressure not sure . well i don't think i will get 10 marks each for the last 2 question but i tried my best and i think it will be unfair to the examiner if i said the paper was hard OH no compared to lats no no. I was lost in the jungle, didn't know where to turn, but thia time i had something to write

So in conculding i think the pass mark this time around will be commendable, but i also think he will mark the paper hard.

All i looking for is 50 Sir. Thank you
EEsther15y ago#88
@jewel said:
The questions were reasonably fine, except some bits, but it was simply impossibe due to the time!!!! I lost plenty of time reading the questions and had really no time left to answer them although I knew how to do most of it!!!


I would say the same thing too, you are so right
I really would like to know what a person has to do to pass this exam!
It´s the worst exam I´ve ever taken!!! I won´t get more than 40 marks, so June 2011 for sure!
Aadnanjavaid15y ago#89
section A was very time consuming. First question was too long and 2nd have lot of calculationsssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss.
HHhamdy hafez15y ago#90
@zheqin said:
Hope examiner
Quote:
Shishir Malde and ACCA read our message.
Q1 is disaster.Q2&Q3is better.Time is running out of on Q4.
Probably, June 2010 again!

for me I think it will be June 2011 again

any way thanks a lot for Opentuition staff
also thanks for all P4 group (really we share together every thinag that we need for the exam, but may Allah save uss)

for those who prepare them self for P4 June 2011 exam, kindly count me on your group
let us take a rest