AFMPaper P4 Dec 2010 exam was
Does anyone know how the marking process is done in AC CA. Let say upon marking a student's paper the 1st time they get 40%. Is this the final mark. Is there any moderation done?
I thought it was absolutely awful! I failed P4 in June 2010 and I think that was a walk in the park compared to this. I know I have definitely failed!
There was far too much reading! From memory, I think there was the same amount of reading as P2, but that was a 50 mark question!
I've decided that I am definitely not going to re-take this paper, I shall just choose another option. So frustrating as this is the only paper left for me to pass and then I am qualified.
There was far too much reading! From memory, I think there was the same amount of reading as P2, but that was a 50 mark question!
I've decided that I am definitely not going to re-take this paper, I shall just choose another option. So frustrating as this is the only paper left for me to pass and then I am qualified.
Did anyone get a dicont rate of 10% for question 2?
Also there was the option to sell teg business after the 4 years, does that mean the sale value had to be included as a cash flow item in year 4?
Then what was the best option for question 1. I choose reconstruct but that was maybe wrong.
Also there was the option to sell teg business after the 4 years, does that mean the sale value had to be included as a cash flow item in year 4?
Then what was the best option for question 1. I choose reconstruct but that was maybe wrong.
Q.2,Discount rate was 10% by MM with tax model i.e Keu
Q.1 a) easy marks just calculate receipts less payments there was no secured debt holders so the payment was going to unsecured debtors mostly.
Q.1b) required Free cash flow to firm
Q.1c) very confusing did lots of blunders :(
Q.1d) was depending on part c so it was so so
Q.2b) assumptions and suggestion .......... there were lots of assumptions like on subsidized loan risk free rate is used to find annuity factor since there is no B debt etc etc
Q.3a) Black Scholes find Call option than put call parity find put option price
then put option price was multiplied with no. of shares/ contract size of 100 .
Q.3b) basic knowledge
Q.4a)Lots of calculations again like before implementing T.E proposal group tax was calcuted then 75% was applied on after tax profit dividend capacity was found almost same calculation after implementing T.E proposal.
Q.4b) required some ethical and regulatory considerations of Transfer pricing.....
So overall was a gud technical paper but very lengthy not a 3hrs exam.
It was my first attempt and hopefully the last one :)
Q.1 a) easy marks just calculate receipts less payments there was no secured debt holders so the payment was going to unsecured debtors mostly.
Q.1b) required Free cash flow to firm
Q.1c) very confusing did lots of blunders :(
Q.1d) was depending on part c so it was so so
Q.2b) assumptions and suggestion .......... there were lots of assumptions like on subsidized loan risk free rate is used to find annuity factor since there is no B debt etc etc
Q.3a) Black Scholes find Call option than put call parity find put option price
then put option price was multiplied with no. of shares/ contract size of 100 .
Q.3b) basic knowledge
Q.4a)Lots of calculations again like before implementing T.E proposal group tax was calcuted then 75% was applied on after tax profit dividend capacity was found almost same calculation after implementing T.E proposal.
Q.4b) required some ethical and regulatory considerations of Transfer pricing.....
So overall was a gud technical paper but very lengthy not a 3hrs exam.
It was my first attempt and hopefully the last one :)
Q2 a) APV was used as both financial and business risk was changing as a result of that new project and PV of Interest income on subsidized loan and PV of tax saving due to interest payment both need to be calculated.
Oh my gosh, a horrible exam for me.
Q1 - maybe 10 marks, Q2 hopefully 17/25, Q5 10 marks and didn't even do the fourth question, simply ran out of time. Seems like a June resit for me, it's not possible to pass with 3 questions right? And clearly with the marks I've counted, I don't even have 50...
Q1 was a violation, the trick we've all been taught is to move on if you can't do part of a question, but given than the last part of Q1 (c 13 marks) required analysis from the earlier parts, it was very difficult to "ignore the earlier parts of the question" and move on? That's my opinion, what does everyone think? As a result I completely screwed up the timing, absolutely detestation. Worked hard and felt prepared, but exam performance simply does not reflect that....
Q1 - maybe 10 marks, Q2 hopefully 17/25, Q5 10 marks and didn't even do the fourth question, simply ran out of time. Seems like a June resit for me, it's not possible to pass with 3 questions right? And clearly with the marks I've counted, I don't even have 50...
Q1 was a violation, the trick we've all been taught is to move on if you can't do part of a question, but given than the last part of Q1 (c 13 marks) required analysis from the earlier parts, it was very difficult to "ignore the earlier parts of the question" and move on? That's my opinion, what does everyone think? As a result I completely screwed up the timing, absolutely detestation. Worked hard and felt prepared, but exam performance simply does not reflect that....
On the face of it, it wasn't a bad paper but too much was expected for the time given. Question 1 was too involved for just 35 marks and too much reading was required overall. For the questions given the 15mins at the start wasn't enough so a lot of reading & re-reading was required when answering and that took up too much time.
Ideally, M&M was the most appropriate approach to find the cost of equity to discount cash flows for question 2 base case npv. But alternatively, you could find beta of the similar listed company using CAPM given the information provided, by making beta the subject of the equation: Ke = rf + B(rm-rf). Ungear this equity beta to find the asset beta which is then used to determine the new required return by equity holders for the project. You'll get the same 10%.
It was really hard, to long to read Q1, you just lose yourself there, like business analysis question , com` on people Q5 is P3 knowledge not P4, he better put something more convenient. I was so disappointed about , and still disappointed, i would prefer June paper , well, i guess just have to wait for result.
did question 2 and found be of haizum by capm as mm cant be used as no kd was given and mv and only par given no time so one cant use irr to find kd as 17 marks didnt worth it unless assumption that kd was risk free 4.5% got be 2.04 and then degeared it to get ba used again capm to find ke as base case only includes ke got 10 discount rate q 3 was simple required to calculate delta hedge to balanced portfolio numberofshares/n(-d1) by black scholes after finding value divide by 1000 contract size got the answer 358 contracts and an easy calculation and then fcfe dividend capacity just need to include sucsidiary posttax 75 in normal fcfe calculation and second one fcfe by including blocked being remitted and got cover 1.0 he can do alot of things like parallel loans royalities to avoide it withholding tax of 10 percent was a trick q1 do not ask as time of only 30 min left after all that
I rated the exam 'OK' even though I know I failed. But I knew I would fail even b4 I got to the exam - I just didn't know enough! The only reason I wrote it is because I paid for it so I figured I may as well check it out.
Anyway it seemed pretty do-able, if lengthy. I was so excited when I saw the Black Scholes option question as I love that part the syllabus. Anyway I hope June 2011 exam comes like this. I'll definitely be ready for it then! Best of luck to everyone.
Anyway it seemed pretty do-able, if lengthy. I was so excited when I saw the Black Scholes option question as I love that part the syllabus. Anyway I hope June 2011 exam comes like this. I'll definitely be ready for it then! Best of luck to everyone.
this sitting was much easier than the June sitting, hopefull y I pass, Too much calculations for the time though was extremely time pressured.
Q1 i know i definitely wrong many things... Q3 i calculate delta hedge n(-d1) , stated in exam , and use the number of shares divide to n(-d1) divided by contract size...am I right ? or i muz calculate put option ? so confuse....
The exam was a disaster. The scenarios were just unnecessarily long. I must have gone blind in the exam or something but for Q2 I just could not see the asset beta to ungear and to calculate the cost of equity for the base case NPV. I did not even get to do the Financing side effects part for the APV.
Q1 - It really was not extremely difficult but somebody need to tell this examiner that the questions are too long.
This examiner seems worse than Bob.
Q1 - It really was not extremely difficult but somebody need to tell this examiner that the questions are too long.
This examiner seems worse than Bob.
What happens if i only did net present value for question 2?
This is my third attempt and I am wondering now whether I should take P7 instead of P4. There is now way I can crack Q1. The information was so much that I couldn't analysed and figured out in time. I didn't realise that I should have used MM in Q2 instead of CAPM. That's why I was stuck because Rf(4.5%) is less than Rm (4%) so I could not get Be to ungear. Q3 & Q5 were OK but that is not enough to pass this paper.
that was not Rm that was riskpremium means Rm-Rf=4% can be solved by capm as well as mm but mm requires kd so assumtion need to be placed that kd is riskfree=4.5%
the apv calculation , i forget write the assumption about the issue cost assumed not tax allowable , if i do it not tax allowable is it wrong ?
ya q1 was a tricky 1.but the main mission should have been to do all questions ina commercial sence........i think it was overall ok even though i messed q1 a bit
Q1 takes a lot of my time, it is too long and a lot to do.That is why I put 20 mark question undone. But fairly the exam is to the standard not easy not difficult just neutral! But expect both good and bad 50-50 due to time pressure and unstablised personal situation!
I really wonder do i have deficit of inteligence :)
Exam seem very easy, but VERY tricky. So i think if you new all small trick you could do it very easly. However this tricks were not shown anywhere, and I had to use much comon sence. And when it is about ACCA, I dont like use of my own logic very much (usually it is wrong), and that why I am very scared about P4 results. However it doesnt matter.. there is a June.
Q1 - how did you caluculated returns at all? Actually for me it was problem MV of debt to caluculate (i didnt see data for that), so I decided to use book values for gearing (probably it is not correct, but I can get some marks). Parts b,c,d hmmm I wrote something ... and suggest option 2 . restructuring, as by my caluculation this one had only positive P&L, and biggest value (I used NPV and given cost of capital). I put it in format of report.
Q2 It seemed straightforward APV question.. hmmm but I am woried as most od NPV values were negative because of working capital... so it could be wrong... but I have calculations.. and I wrote assumptions and comments, and advice to sell it.
Q3 ... Black and Scholes, I calculated something... and commented an all 3 proposals,and used some knowledge from risk uncertantz article, like dilution, neutral risk positions etc.. however.. it doesnt have to be enough right?
Q4, I have just started, wrote DVM formulae, didnt have MV of share, so I tried via Noapat to calculate Value of company, and caluculated expected NPV for next year..
Hmm I have no Idea and feeling what I have done... just it is good feeling to have it behind me...I tried the best.
Exam seem very easy, but VERY tricky. So i think if you new all small trick you could do it very easly. However this tricks were not shown anywhere, and I had to use much comon sence. And when it is about ACCA, I dont like use of my own logic very much (usually it is wrong), and that why I am very scared about P4 results. However it doesnt matter.. there is a June.
Q1 - how did you caluculated returns at all? Actually for me it was problem MV of debt to caluculate (i didnt see data for that), so I decided to use book values for gearing (probably it is not correct, but I can get some marks). Parts b,c,d hmmm I wrote something ... and suggest option 2 . restructuring, as by my caluculation this one had only positive P&L, and biggest value (I used NPV and given cost of capital). I put it in format of report.
Q2 It seemed straightforward APV question.. hmmm but I am woried as most od NPV values were negative because of working capital... so it could be wrong... but I have calculations.. and I wrote assumptions and comments, and advice to sell it.
Q3 ... Black and Scholes, I calculated something... and commented an all 3 proposals,and used some knowledge from risk uncertantz article, like dilution, neutral risk positions etc.. however.. it doesnt have to be enough right?
Q4, I have just started, wrote DVM formulae, didnt have MV of share, so I tried via Noapat to calculate Value of company, and caluculated expected NPV for next year..
Hmm I have no Idea and feeling what I have done... just it is good feeling to have it behind me...I tried the best.
it was a real disaster ...i couldnt manage the time it was toooooooo lengthy what was he expecting from us ...this was tooo much ....really tensed about it
Any way the paper was made much strategic than the ussual technical one which i think the examaminer is doing good. Playing to get a pass.
I fully agree that the exam was 'disaster', especially Q1. Q2 was OK, but only the calculations took me appr. 40 min.. what about the writing part..?
It is too long to do. I even don't believe that examiner himself can do it for 3 hours. How can candicdate do? Crazy long in the comparison with the previous examinations. DIsaster!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
DISASTER.......was toooo long........too much analysis........did Q1 in the last n culdnt complete it.....lost almost 20 marks..........Q4 and Q5 were fairly done......
Most horrifying was Q1 MBO............didnt knw how to calculate the required finance...........
anyways....fingers crossed.........50/50 chance
Most horrifying was Q1 MBO............didnt knw how to calculate the required finance...........
anyways....fingers crossed.........50/50 chance
It was OK. provided u really know the basics. I used geared and ungeared approach to get the beta in Q2. and i think it is totally fine. and for Q3, i have to blame myself for the stupidity. i spotted managing share price risk, i and i read on the delta hedge also. but i did not do the delta hedge instead i wrote the co. need to SELL put options! Instead of BUY, i wrote SELL. i think i will not get much marks from the 7 marks. sigh. i pray for luck and then i could pass. :)
I felt the exam was impossible to finish in the allocated time.Left out atleast 20 marks in question 1.Everbody who feels the same should give their feedback on the ACCA website and hopefully we will be heard and this will be taken into consideration during the marking process.
I agree, I have left my feedback on acca site. Hopefully enough people do the same.
paper was not so techinical as previous attempts
around 40% was repeat
q1 was similar to bpp kit q 53 evertalk( june 03) and delta hedge was similar to q 78(uniglow) of bpp kit..
around 40% was repeat
q1 was similar to bpp kit q 53 evertalk( june 03) and delta hedge was similar to q 78(uniglow) of bpp kit..

