Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBRPaper P2 Dec 2010 exam was

NSnicky shaw15y ago#61
althought i entered the exam hall wit no confidence.The paper seemed ok.Wish i get atleast 50
Former userFormer user15y ago#62
what was question 3 about???

where company had not significant influence and majority shareholders were director of the same company which also had 19.9% holding, there were transaction between co's.. i defined it under IAS 24 as company were under common control of director who were also the directors of company which had 19.9%,,, iam lit bit sure that this question includes the discussion of ias 24 and ias 27 as well... not absolutely sure.....

POST COMMEnt over this question
Former userFormer user15y ago#63
what was question 3 about???

where company had not significant influence and majority shareholders were director of the same company which also had 19.9% holding, there were transaction between co’s.. i defined it under IAS 24 as company were under common control of director who were also the directors of company which had 19.9%,,, iam lit bit sure that this question includes the discussion of ias 24 and ias 27 as well… not absolutely sure…..

POST COMMEnt over this question
Former userFormer user15y ago#64
what was question 3 about???

where company had not significant influence and majority shareholders were director of the same company which also had 19.9% holding, there were transaction between co’s.. i defined it under IAS 24 as company were under common control of director who were also the directors of company which had 19.9%,,, iam lit bit sure that this question includes the discussion of ias 24 and ias 27 as well… not absolutely sure…..

POST COMMEnt over this question
Former userFormer user15y ago#65
Manair was definitely an Associate to be accounted for under IAS 28 as the board composition was 20% even though the voting powers were 19.9% in addition there were significant transactions between the two companies. The sale of computer software and also where consultants were sent over to advise Manair's Board. This proves that there was significvant influence due to the fact that there was the power by the company to assist in the financial and operating policies of Manair.
Aamanda778715y ago#66
@destiny said:
By the way the tips are helpful. Thanks to OpenTuition!


I didn't see Open Tuition tips...Just for Kaplan, BPP, LSBF. Where are those normally posted?
Aamanda778715y ago#67
How did you answer the last section of Q4, the 9 mark question?
Former userFormer user15y ago#68
I have not written much on the last part of the Q 4; completaly forgot UKGAAP, hoped to get back to it at the end but did not have time. I have answered well the first part which was worth 15 points, so decided it was worth taking risk.
Former userFormer user15y ago#69
Somebody asked about direct method; I think it is more useful in manufacturing industry as it is relevant to expenditure categorized by nature(labour, materials, etc) and not by function. I wrote that suppling natural recourses has not much to do with manufacturing, hence indirect method is more acceptable. Besides, I think sth as free cash flow, deriving from that method is often used as adjusted profit for more precise ROCE.On the other hand, indirect method is more flexible and subjective, giving more freedom in categorizing expenses. And as the scenario indicated the directors really needed" freedom of speech " to show a loan as an income! And to cover all angles, I wrote that it seemed they saw the contract as an asset while its obligations and benefits are in balance. But then again, I may be complately wrong!
Former userFormer user15y ago#70
P2 was never going to be easy, the syllabus is huge. Can't judge how it went, hope I did enough to get 50. Went to classes, prepared well, but don't feel too confident. At least we can all relax now... Good luck everyone, hope we all get good news in February! Merry Christmas
Former userFormer user15y ago#71
Open Tuition's predictions for Q1 and Q4 were spot on! It was a fair paper but I think I should have been more prepared. hoping for a 50 at the least. Thank you Open Tuition!
Former userFormer user15y ago#72
@sohailsaeed said:
I had made a mistake by writing with attempting the paper with blue pen. Is any body tell me is this mistake will have any impact on my marks / result


Don't worry too much about that. I did that for F8 Audit in June so i phoned up the ACCA and they told me that my paper will be marked manually and that i wont be penalised.I passed the paper with 60 %.

Its early days yet for the electronic marking/scanning system so i think they will be a bit lenient for now.
Nniraj36515y ago#73
Hi , I found Q.1 technical but try to cover all the points Q.2 was good everything on share based payments , Q.3 (b) and (C) was bit complicated . I think I done 50/50 let see .. Good luck P2 members
Former userFormer user15y ago#74
Nearly 65 marks for writing in p2 . I didn't expect that. but overall expecting to pass :))
Ttinker15y ago#75
i have a question regarding Q2:
not all of these part questions have been IFRS2 share based payments, or have they? opinions seem to differ a lot about that. some say that the two mini scenarios without employees (part a hedging, and part c? where they bought the machine) are not under IFRS2. Any ideas?
Former userFormer user15y ago#76
the paper was definately better than the June one. I found the cash flow rather daunting because of the complicated notes. Q2 & Q3 were so so.anyway,hope i managed a 50.
Former userFormer user15y ago#77
All questions are o.k. .
Cchansabue15y ago#78
The paper was fair. Cashflow statements had a difficult adjustments as expected. Hope i got a pass.
Hhotid15y ago#79
The paper was ok even though the complication itself specially the cash flow, when I've seen cash flow I was very excited, however, when i turned back the page the notes were bit complicated. Q2 was not sure so jumped to Q3 (part c was difficult) then i did not have any other option but to go to Q4 SME was not prepared for it but thought just to give a try on, part a then part B was ok

many thanks to open tuition which i would recommend to any one in particular for this paper it has every thing that you need even though if you have to pay for it is worthy than attending BPP or Caplan or what ever places.. Inever attended any classes, only used Open tuition and i hope did well on the exam even though some points haven't been very clear,

I wish every bodit the best of luck on Feb.
Ssyedmayaz15y ago#80
Well i just thot for a while what the students have dOne if Graham gave foreign, piece meal acq and complex structure(in detail) anyhow cashflow question 1 was easy compared to the trendz....
I left IAS-39 whole and just read ias-32 fortunately was saved...
Question 2 was tricky...but somehow managed to justify MY VIEW POINT....dont know what was the right answer...
Paper was fine as compared to past trendz....but am not hopeful that much...
Main thing is presence of mind and i am lacking
Former userFormer user15y ago#81
it was my 1st attempt, and an good p2 experience.....
hopefully......just pass expected
Former userFormer user15y ago#82
in manair...although 19.1 % holding but its advisory team had their influence over the 60% decission...i believe it should be considered as a subsidiary........
Former userFormer user15y ago#83
i got a difference of 23.5 which i stated as a "computational error" in notes
Former userFormer user15y ago#84
@Aimalacca: Manair a subsidiary? That reaquires control, not influence. Sure you don't mean associate?
Jjbeshw15y ago#85
Comparatively it was a easy question. Theory part was little bit complicated.
Yyannick15y ago#86
any one doing p2 for june 2011?
Former userFormer user15y ago#87
cashflow is much easier than the consolidated balance sheet for me,however still made some mistake.this is the second time i attempted it , really a disaster the first time, even made a big mistake about the group strusture.really hope i could pass it .