Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AAA*** P7 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin10y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P7 March 2016 Exam.

*** P7 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P7 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P7 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results

Post your comments about P7 exam below

Ffidget10y ago#31
@baljit1989 said: Q3 - Didn't have a clue for part A, literally just wrote money laundering in cash based businesses can affect revenue recognition. Probably got no marks on this. - Spoke about money laundering issues and that evidence would need to be obtained, if not then they need to speak with the audit committee or those charged with governance about it. If none of this was done a qualified opinion should be issued because it is not pervasive. - IAS 37 = provision didn't necessarily have to be recognised providing the auditors obtain sufficient and appropriate that it shouldn't i.e. written representations legal claim against them will not succeed. Also they should review the board minutes to see if the legal issue has been discussed. A qualified opinion should be issued if the provision evidence is not obtained. Q4 - Due to time issues could only attempt part A which was Intimidation and talking about how the guy didn't understand what auditors do and the partner should arrange a meeting to explain what they do Overall gutted as I could have done more but ran out of time and failed in Dec 2015, hope I pass this time but due to only attempting part A on q4 and no answer for part A on Q3, fear I have failed again.
Money Laundering was jumping out of Q3, although I think more related to part b, than part a. Wasn't too bad a question though. Q4 was, or should I say, "would've", been ok but for the time pressure. There was a hellova lot of ethical and professional issues that could've been picked up on in each of those scenarios - especially the first one. Just not enough time to adequately address them all.
MM439910y ago#32
Looking at these thoughts on Q1 i completely missed out IAS41 and mentioned something about risk that refurbishment costs are not capitalised in accordance with IAS16 Also re compliance risk i mentioned health and safety of employees in the event they were injured by the animals or insects Am i way off the mark here? I struggled to think of ROMM , just had a mind blank Not hopeful
MM439910y ago#33
Also did anyone make comments in relation to 'implied' options in the basis for opinion as insufficient info was available for provision and cash based payment to foreign bank?
Former userFormer user10y ago#34
@sami1986 said: Looking at these thoughts on Q1 i completely missed out IAS41 and mentioned something about risk that refurbishment costs are not capitalised in accordance with IAS16 Also re compliance risk i mentioned health and safety of employees in the event they were injured by the animals or insects Am i way off the mark here? I struggled to think of ROMM , just had a mind blank Not hopeful
.................................................................................. I struggled with Business risk. There were loads of financial statement (ROMM) risks but they only wanted four. I picked those where I was very sure of the standard and where I'm sure I had the materiality calculation mark in the bag. That gives you 4 marks out of 10 marks, before you do any hard work. I therefore chose the four with values attached to them and I don't have to write a paragraph to earn a mark. P7 is always time pressured and that tactic was given to use by our tutor on a revision program. Receivables - $38 million of receivables which were about $20 million (or about there) an increase of about 85 to 90%. Could be a sign of bad debts and therefore receivables balance over stated. IAS36 impairment requires the recoverable amount to be recognised not the money owed. I don't remember the total assets figure and PBX but $38 million was material. Unclaimed holiday plan The basis of calculation was too subjective and there was manual processses involved This increase errors inherent to such manual processes. 19.2 million was material and had also increased by 82% from last year which may further signify error or wrong basis used. Therefore liabilities overstated New stores bought $159 million (something like that) was material to total assets Classification was the risk If they are refitted and retained for business use - IAS16 PPE apply. If sold off for a profit, then IFRS5 - Non-current assets held for sale apply (or IAS 40) If not classifies properly, then Non-current assets are overstated. Reffittment cost. $8 million was material to profits but it was planned to be spend next year not this year. Therefore if a provision is made now, a cost will be recognised early leading to understatement of profits by $8 million. This does not qualify for a provision under IAS37 as their is no obligation to refitt the stores. They can avoid that cost by selling the stores off or use them the way they are. Cutt-off was important here. Was this expense for this year or next year?
Former userFormer user10y ago#35
Very time pressured. I made the mistake of leaving Q1 once I had run over the allotted time, at which point I had hardly started the question. Then I returned to it in a hurry, trying to think of business risks with what I could remember of the scenario - all I could remember was the rabbits. I thought of one risk now - which is customers could buy the bunny rabbits thinking they might do something funny and then returning them when they are not funny. Maybe the risk would be understatement of warranty provision - however do rabbits come with a warranty? The flip side is the risk that someone buys a rabbit that is funny and they put it on youtube and blame it on the pet shop. The risk would be to reputation and hence possible overstatement of inventory? Staff are well trained so they should be able to advise that rabbits are not supposed to be for human entertainment - although that will be a hard sell as most people won't understand. Also what packaging do the pets come in? If they are too snugly packed they might not survive unless they are a spider or something. What about the risk is that someone might buy reptile thinking it can do stuff which it can't - like change colour. Or they might buy one that does change colour and then return because it wasn't following the rules. Also the risk that some of the inventory may be consumed by some of the other inventory - you only need to type snakes into youtube to see what could go wrong here. I think of all this stuff now - something tells me I haven't passed.
MM439910y ago#36
Funniest post ive ever seen!
@stuartpearce said: Very time pressured. I made the mistake of leaving Q1 once I had run over the allotted time, at which point I had hardly started the question. Then I returned to it in a hurry, trying to think of business risks with what I could remember of the scenario - all I could remember was the rabbits. I thought of one risk now - which is customers could buy the bunny rabbits thinking they might do something funny and then returning them when they are not funny. Maybe the risk would be understatement of warranty provision - however do rabbits come with a warranty? The flip side is the risk that someone buys a rabbit that is funny and they put it on youtube and blame it on the pet shop. The risk would be to reputation and hence possible overstatement of inventory? Staff are well trained so they should be able to advise that rabbits are not supposed to be for human entertainment - although that will be a hard sell as most people won't understand. Also what packaging do the pets come in? If they are too snugly packed they might not survive unless they are a spider or something. What about the risk is that someone might buy reptile thinking it can do stuff which it can't - like change colour. Or they might buy one that does change colour and then return because it wasn't following the rules. Also the risk that some of the inventory may be consumed by some of the other inventory - you only need to type snakes into youtube to see what could go wrong here. I think of all this stuff now - something tells me I haven't passed.
Ffidget10y ago#37
@sami1986 said: Also did anyone make comments in relation to 'implied' options in the basis for opinion as insufficient info was available for provision and cash based payment to foreign bank?
oh I went the whole hog on those and suggested modified opinion individually but disclaimer in aggregate if unresolved by the time the audit report had to be produced.
BBaljit10y ago#38
@StuartPearce I felt quite bad about the exam until your post cheered me up :)
JJo10y ago#39
Hi did anyone do the ICAEW exam today for AA and FAR?
NNalini10y ago#40
audit procedures for capital expenditure?
Aaarthi10y ago#41
I found the paper to be quite tough! Not the usual accounting standards were examined this time! I found question 5 to be very different, though we have a sum based on that in the kit. But the anewer to it was no way close to the kit And we had to sit and think before starting any answer and this subject is no joke!
LLT10y ago#42
@bayigga said: On Deferred tax asset, I also concluded that the Asset should be recognised. It was a change in supply not change in the way the business in carried out. They sold(build) to themselves instead of using someone else. I didn't think a change of supplier providing exactly the same product you've been dealing in is a significant change in business. That's how I discussed it.
I first discussed the normal IAS12 treatment then brought in the local jurisdiction and wrote about understanding should have been obtained that such changes didn't constitute a 'significant change', else risk of DTA being overstated. I didn't conclude anything.
LLT10y ago#43
@demashi said: Q2 was crazy while Q3 & Q5 were fair enough. I learnt from the last exam to start with the optionals first - time is a factor.
What's your materiality for each item in Q5?
LLT10y ago#44
@sbeeharry said: For me all were not material, even when aggregated together. So I said an unmodified report should be issued. I think we has 6 marks to comment on impact of audit opinion and report. With an unmodified opinion, i really did not know what to comment in order to achieved the marks. Any other comments regarding this?
The 4 items were: impairment, borrowing costs (75K), irrecoverable receivables (65K) and FVTPL equity. Did you remember the PBT? I can't remember how much was the error. $400K? It sort of started with "4". Did you divide it over the PBT? It should be above 5%. I'm not sure what's the % if you divide the asset value over TA, if you do this way maybe you will get an 'immaterial' materiality. But since the impact of impairment would be debited to SOCI, I chose PBT, because with a lower amount compared to TA, I'll definitely get a higher materiality figure. And yes, I find the 6% rather unreasonable.
LLT10y ago#45
@Fidget said: What did you come up with for the Capital Expenditure Review? Worth 8 marks that was, but I wasn't really sure what it was asking me to do.
I didn't have much time for it but I wrote about checking arithmetic accuracy of the forecast, getting info / working papers on how the 1mil (sold of an old building) being derived and how sure are they it won't turn out to be lower than 1mil, WR from management that they will be responsible for the forecast. I think that's all I put down, I got no time for it. :C
Ddemashi10y ago#46
they were immaterial except the impairment. On an individual level no impact on the opinion but if considered in aggregate, I proposed an adverse opinion.
JJo10y ago#47
Does anyone know where there is a forum for the ICAEW March 2016 exams?
Ttonymc10y ago#48
I put things like: -Check expected sales proceeds to estate agents packs or surveyors reports. - Review tender documents or quotes for the price of building the complex for completeness - seek advise from quantity surveyor as to expected cost - something about the cash balance. That's all the ones I can remember, I think I put about 10 down in the end may to be on the safe side!
Jjay1410y ago#49
@stuartpearce said: Very time pressured. I made the mistake of leaving Q1 once I had run over the allotted time, at which point I had hardly started the question. Then I returned to it in a hurry, trying to think of business risks with what I could remember of the scenario - all I could remember was the rabbits. I thought of one risk now - which is customers could buy the bunny rabbits thinking they might do something funny and then returning them when they are not funny. Maybe the risk would be understatement of warranty provision - however do rabbits come with a warranty? The flip side is the risk that someone buys a rabbit that is funny and they put it on youtube and blame it on the pet shop. The risk would be to reputation and hence possible overstatement of inventory? Staff are well trained so they should be able to advise that rabbits are not supposed to be for human entertainment - although that will be a hard sell as most people won't understand. Also what packaging do the pets come in? If they are too snugly packed they might not survive unless they are a spider or something. What about the risk is that someone might buy reptile thinking it can do stuff which it can't - like change colour. Or they might buy one that does change colour and then return because it wasn't following the rules. Also the risk that some of the inventory may be consumed by some of the other inventory - you only need to type snakes into youtube to see what could go wrong here. I think of all this stuff now - something tells me I haven't passed.
Oh my Gosh!! Stuart!!--I just thought about another risk!!--There is a risk that after reading your post, the examiner may pass everyone that took this March edition!! You are just too funny!..I havent laughed like this in such a long time!!- aLSO THERE IS A MORE SERIOUS RISK THAT YOU MAY BE IN THE WRONG BUSINESS ACTUALLY --(You may think about moving on to comedy!) Lool at you only need to type in snakes!!
Jjay1410y ago#50
I hope pq accountant can copy on your answer and publish it...its a classic!
RRebecca10y ago#51
Q5 absolutely threw me - it was material to the P&L but immaterial to the balance sheet - what would the audit opinion be? Would it be qualified as performance materiality is usually lower and there were too many adjustments not complied with? Overall the exam was OK but found extremely time pressured - I had practised in timed conditions and usually found it reasonable but I felt my answers were not as in-depth as I was constantly fighting the clock
Ssulmaan10y ago#52
I finished all questions, wrote 17 pages and still had 6 minutes to spare.
Jjames10y ago#53
Hard exam and the option questions were strange ie Q3 & Q5
Former userFormer user10y ago#54
@sami1986 said: Funniest post ive ever seen!
lol. This is the funniest post on this forum. I wrote the exam yesterday and I've not been particularly happy. This post made my day. I just refer to it anytime I want to laugh and it always leaves me in stitches. LMAO.
Former userFormer user10y ago#55
@stuartpearce said: Very time pressured. I made the mistake of leaving Q1 once I had run over the allotted time, at which point I had hardly started the question. Then I returned to it in a hurry, trying to think of business risks with what I could remember of the scenario - all I could remember was the rabbits. I thought of one risk now - which is customers could buy the bunny rabbits thinking they might do something funny and then returning them when they are not funny. Maybe the risk would be understatement of warranty provision - however do rabbits come with a warranty? The flip side is the risk that someone buys a rabbit that is funny and they put it on youtube and blame it on the pet shop. The risk would be to reputation and hence possible overstatement of inventory? Staff are well trained so they should be able to advise that rabbits are not supposed to be for human entertainment - although that will be a hard sell as most people won't understand. Also what packaging do the pets come in? If they are too snugly packed they might not survive unless they are a spider or something. What about the risk is that someone might buy reptile thinking it can do stuff which it can't - like change colour. Or they might buy one that does change colour and then return because it wasn't following the rules. Also the risk that some of the inventory may be consumed by some of the other inventory - you only need to type snakes into youtube to see what could go wrong here. I think of all this stuff now - something tells me I haven't passed.</blockquote lol. This is the funniest post on this forum. I wrote the exam yesterday and I’ve not been particularly happy. This post made my day. I just refer to it anytime I want to laugh and it always leaves me in stitches. LMAO.
Jjay1410y ago#56
@ Samy and Ify..'im going to try and put it on my phone so once i stop at a red light i will read it and laugh!!..Better cure than a doctor..
Former userFormer user10y ago#57
@jodukwe said: @ Samy and Ify..'im going to try and put it on my phone so once i stop at a red light i will read it and laugh!!..Better cure than a doctor..
I wouldn't advise this as it would be a non-compliance risk. To safeguard against this maybe laugh at your phone after you have exited the vehicle and are safely indoors:-) Thank you @Jay14 for your very kind comments, thank you @Michael, @Baljit and @ifyujay for saying the post made you happy - I was the same as you after the exam so you have cheered me up too. I am a bit slow in digesting these exam questions - I find I only really get into the question when its too late, or I have already written something else. They say you should structure the answer in a professional way with the primary issues featured first and respond with the appropriate format. So maybe the bunny rabbits were a decoy. With this hindsight here is what I should have put: To: The Audit Partner From: The Audit Manager Subject: The Audit of that Pet Shop Thank you for your email. Correct me if I have misunderstood but in the background information you supplied it says that the group had £200m odd in cash and someone spanked £150m on some disused shops. The punchline is the directors are not sure what they are going to do with the shops. I have half a mind to request a meeting with the directors and bring a megaphone with me so that to shout to them 'THEN WHY DID YOU BUY THEM?' I think I know what's happened here. In the kerfuffle with the different animals, they've clearly lost the company credit card and it has found it's way into the hands of an imbecile who splashed out one fifty mil like it was nothing. Now the directors are trying to style it out like that was the plan all along. I wouldn't even spend £1.99 on an ice lolly unless I knew what I was going to do with it. And I certainly wouldn't trust these guys with an ice lolly. Even if we did trust them with ice lollies the worse case is a liquid asset - which is far from the case here. Who is going to buy 20 run down battered shops which need (£8m x 20) refix? Haven't they read the news about high streets shops losing out to online? Pity they don't sell rats as pets, otherwise they would be onto a gold mine. Then there's the issue with the staff holidays. They are running both a manual and a computerised system. These guys are too much. Any more financial tom foolery and they are all going to be taking one big holiday. I say we press control alt and delete with these people and send them a letter of resignation. Don't reply anymore of their emails and if we see them in a conference or something we can pretend we don't know them.
Former userFormer user10y ago#58
Here we go again . Hahahah.
SS10y ago#59
I attempted 80% of the exam paper as I ran out of time and couldn't attempt the final question of 20 marks. Does anyone know if anybody had passed p7 without attempts 20 mark question? Do I stand a chance to pass it, if so, how much? Comments are welcome!
Former userFormer user10y ago#60
@shakirbukhari said: I attempted 80% of the exam paper as I ran out of time and couldn't attempt the final question of 20 marks. Does anyone know if anybody had passed p7 without attempts 20 mark question? Do I stand a chance to pass it, if so, how much? Comments are welcome!
Still have, in Vietnam. Passed 55/65 attempted or 61/80. Goodluck for you :)
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.