AAA*** P7 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Q1 is crazy.
Agree
I think the optional questions were more crazy (INT). Plus, I spend so much time in Q1 that by the time I started Q2 I started panicking.
This exam is the hardest.
Not enough time....if you take the time to carefully read all the questions, not enough time to give quality answers
Hey John! What you doin here? ;)
i think new sessions in march and September are for students to fail and go back to old june and december sessions. march session was such a disaster so much asked so little time. wanted to write more but no time left. and way too difficult then last dec session. thank you so much examiner
The exam was very tough. I will definitely fail...
Did anyone notice in Q2 requirement "Examination Procedures..." (I believe he meant Audit Procedures) - must have been in a rush! :P
Overall predictable; the only issue I thought was time management... and too many standards; we've already been tested lots in F7 and P2.
Were there many people sitting exams in the uk centres guys? In comparison to dec and june?
I didnt find the exam that bad...unless im completely missing something. What does seem to be happining is the examiner breaking the requirements into smaller and smaller seperate segements.
Q 1 was
10 mks for id and explain business risks. How may do they expect 7/8?
10 mks for id and explain 4 risks of material misstatement
6mks on audit planning with an outsourced accounts receivable function
5 mks for 'what evidence would you expect to see...' for a payroll issue (two payrolls merged and accrued holidays not taken included twice for some staff when the payrolls merged.)
None of those are 'bad' requirements...but most people will have spent more than 18 mins on business risks and romm each. Hard to take a step back and say...thats just 20 marks. In the olden days you might be 'lucky' and get a 25mk business risks question ... But not anymore.
What has been disappointing is the lack of support for students during this march exam. It was quiet for the first sepetember exam but not a single exam tip or advance guide from anyone to help focus the last week or two of study.
Iirc
Q2 was a 3 part question (5/6 mks each on deferred tax/leases/post year end provisions(no sure about last one). + another requirement i forget.
The ethics question was 3 fairly normal ethics scenarios...the reporting question was 4 fairly normal modifiable scenarios. The amounts of the errors had already been determined here and the drs crs for the adjustments determined which was slightly unusual.
Not necessarily hard but a very broad canvas of issues.
Q1. a) What did you have for your business risks? I struggled to find them, but came up with compliance re keeping live animals as stock, insurance cover re vetinary services being offered, diversifying into own brand, purchase of 20 stores with no set out plan for them, 60 day credit facilities for customers and some others that I can't remember now.
b) Four significant risks of misstatement was easier: Revenue - healthcare plan annual revenue recognised on day one, receivables balance, provision for refitting shops, can't remember the other now.
Regprentice,
Maybe 5 business risks 2m each. What u guys putting down for the 20m risks?
Mine INT variant.
Thought Q2(a) was about utilised loss as DTA (only to the extend there's future taxable profit) + Leases (but didn't look like IAS 17, what's it about?) + Convertible bonds wholly recognised as liability (should split accounting).
Q2(b) 8m on audit CAPEX forecast.
As for Q5, although all scenarios containing misstatements, but only the first one will get a qualified opinion isn't it? If I remember correctly, all the rest didn't meet the materiality level. But I quite rush with my last Q so I'm not sure whether I see figures correctly. I wasn't confident when doing this Q 'coz most of them unmodified. Sad.
I was struggling with business risks too. I simply put down : compliance risk coz some unusual animals might be prihibited to be sold + reputation risk if unsold animal dead bodies not being managed correctly and being found out + purchase of 20 stores w/o proper plan + fully trained staffs can easily leave coz client no control on them + AR increased by 90% problem of handling them thus cash flow problem.
My risk of MM quite different : IFRS15, IAS41 (I was thinking about yearly remeasurement of consumable animals but I guess that's not correct..), IAS 38 (Risk of recognising internal generated brand as intangible assets, do u think this is reasonable?)
A hardest exam, particularly regarding time management. However, the scenarios in the questions were also very tough to extract the points for instance difficult to find business risks.e.t.c.
Very much difficult paper.
In last 40 minutes I do the almost 45 marks requirements
Very Very tough time mangement challenge
However, I hope that InshAllah I will pass.
I felt the P7 exam just didn't offer enough time to write a quality answer. I believe I answered most requirements but not in the detail that I would have liked to given that there was so much scope on question 1.
I am expecting a fail due to a potential lack of depth to most answers, as I have noticed that a common examiner complaint is the lack of depth to answers by candidates, but who can blame them when you are rushing from one question to the next.
Oh well, wait and find out in April, until then it's time to move on to P3 ready for Thursday - lets hope that is a little easier!! In answer to the above question re how many people were in your exam, my hall must have only had about 40 people in total and about 60% of them were sitting F8 rather than P7.
@tanlihtyng said: Thought Q2(a) was about utilised loss as DTA (only to the extend there's future taxable profit) + Leases (but didn't look like IAS 17, what's it about?) + Convertible bonds wholly recognised as liability (should split accounting)..i) The main thing I picked up on with the deferred tax, was the jurisdiction's rule that entitlement to carry forward expired when there was a significant change in trading, and seeing as revenue or profit before tax (can't remember which one it was) had increased by 62.5% on the prior year, I thought "significant" had to be clarified to see whether the deferred tax asset still qualified. ii) Convertible bond. I did ramble a bit about this. Left it til the very end of the exam as couldn't remember the treatment, but eventually went on about splitting it into equity and liability instead of just treating it as a liability. iii) The operating lease should be accounted for evenly over the period of it. So it was $270 that should've been recognised and not $150. Also, copy of lease agreement needed to verify that it was indeed an operating lease.
@Fidget said: i) ..I thought "significant" had to be clarified to see whether the deferred tax asset still qualified. … iii) The operating lease should be accounted for evenly over the period of it. So it was $270 that should've been recognised and not $150. Also, copy of lease agreement needed to verify that it was indeed an operating lease.For (i), yes I did write the same thing. For (iii), I focused on audit evidences such as lease contract has been inspected to verify leasing terms and payment arrangements, payments agreed to bank statement n invoices, and one more which I forgot. that time was just trying to get some marks, did think of matching concept but forgot about it after that. When I see 'lease', I was like what's is it inside IAS17 related to this, couldn't think of any
What did you come up with for the Capital Expenditure Review? Worth 8 marks that was, but I wasn't really sure what it was asking me to do.
Not a bad exam although agree with others it was time pressured, I answered about 90%.
Q1
Business risks were more difficult to pick out this time round, I wrote about importing issues, new brand name, expansion of business/GC, duplicated payroll records could be a risk of fraud.
Q2
Found this a lot harder and ran out of time, didn't do part b.
Q3
Risk of Fraud in auditing revenue - wrote about responsibilities and risk assessment.
Cash transfer - wrote about money laundering
Provision - it should be recognised
Q4
A nice question on ethics, followed identifying the threat, its significance and any safeguards so hoping to score well.
Very quiet in my exam.
With regards to the deferred tax asset I wrote that due to a change in business strategy, I.e rather than buying properties they were now going to construct them, the utilised tax losses should not be offset against future profits per the jurisdiction.
@tanlihtyng said: As for Q5, although all scenarios containing misstatements, but only the first one will get a qualified opinion isn't it? If I remember correctly, all the rest didn't meet the materiality level. But I quite rush with my last Q so I'm not sure whether I see figures correctly. I wasn't confident when doing this Q 'coz most of them unmodified. Sad.For me all were not material, even when aggregated together. So I said an unmodified report should be issued. I think we has 6 marks to comment on impact of audit opinion and report. With an unmodified opinion, i really did not know what to comment in order to achieved the marks. Any other comments regarding this?
I believe that there should also be a reasonable assurance that the company will generate future profits so as to offset against tax losses. So as a result, obtain perhaps a prospective financial statement and other forecasts in order to determine if future profit will be generated. Not sure if i got this right
I found the exam really time pressured and the level of content really difficult but managed to answer something on each part - though scoring marks is another thing altogether.
I had to read question 1 at least twice before the panic subsided and was able to assess a few business risks.
The risks identified were mainly around the foreign exchange, expansion, brand not performing as expected
Risks of MM - IAS 21 recognition, Receivables could be overstated, Revenue recognition with the health plan, and impairment of stores purchased
I have read a lot of comments and I think I misread the deferred tax question -I didn't think the business had changed significantly.
6 marks down the drain I guess :(
@Fidget said: Q1. b) Four significant risks of misstatement was easier: Revenue - healthcare plan annual revenue recognised on day one, receivables balance, provision for refitting shops, can't remember the other now.I included IAS for Agricultural where they state that living animals / plants should be valued at FV. Was that ok? I also added the risk that the stores could have been classified as held for sale as they intended to sell some of them, but this is wrong since the store need refurbishment and hence not available for immediate sale. Really, I was out of ideas and has to write down anything. Hm, for provision for refitting, am not sure if that is a constructive obligation, and hence provision should not be created.
Q1
- easy marks for layout, intro and conclusion
- I actually managed to find lots of business risks, expanding into new industry, animal welfare standards due to keeping living animals, going concern issues due to significant advertising and huge drop in cash balance, reliance on overseas manufacturer, credit offered to customers.
- ROMM were IAS 2, IFRS 15 annual plan revenue needs to be recognised over 12 months, IAS 37 provision for refitting and potential redundancies, Payroll error maybe materially overstating expenses and IAS 38 potentially capitalising brand name.
- Couldn't think of the impact on planning for the outsourcing of credit control, what did anyone else put?
Q2
- IAS 12 = Deferred tax asset treatment was correct as the company had now begun to post profits rather than losses, however the change in business strategy may have violated the restriction in place, so they shoudl enquire with management to see if they think it would and also reach out to the local jurisdictional body to see if it would
- IAS 17 Lease = discount needs to be spread out through period of entire lease, so expense in the year of $150k was understated as it should have been $270k. Need to see the lease agreement to verify lease term, payment and discount, also review board minutes to see if lease was discussed.
Both the Deferred tax asset and lease were material.
- Part B the examination procedures on Capital Expenditure, just explaining different types of audit procedures i.e. getting a breakdown of the costs and analysing for reasonableness and assessing the architects work using ISA 620. Also this had elements of prospective financial info as it involved forecasting so mentioned PFI
Q3
- Didn't have a clue for part A, literally just wrote money laundering in cash based businesses can affect revenue recognition. Probably got no marks on this.
- Spoke about money laundering issues and that evidence would need to be obtained, if not then they need to speak with the audit committee or those charged with governance about it. If none of this was done a qualified opinion should be issued because it is not pervasive.
- IAS 37 = provision didn't necessarily have to be recognised providing the auditors obtain sufficient and appropriate that it shouldn't i.e. written representations legal claim against them will not succeed. Also they should review the board minutes to see if the legal issue has been discussed. A qualified opinion should be issued if the provision evidence is not obtained.
Q4
- Due to time issues could only attempt part A which was Intimidation and talking about how the guy didn't understand what auditors do and the partner should arrange a meeting to explain what they do
Overall gutted as I could have done more but ran out of time and failed in Dec 2015, hope I pass this time but due to only attempting part A on q4 and no answer for part A on Q3, fear I have failed again.
Definitely tougher than December. In Q1, one could barely think about the business risk - the question itself gave non away. I mentioned Regulatory risks, Staff Risks, Compliance Risks, Reputational Risks. The Risk of MM were a bit straightforward with FX Risk (IAS 21), FV of livestock (IAS 41), Revenue recognition (IFRS 15) and Provision for restructuring (IAS 37) mentioned.
You can't be too sure in this kind of paper, just say a prayer and hope for the best.
Q2 was crazy while Q3 & Q5 were fair enough. I learnt from the last exam to start with the optionals first - time is a factor.
@sbeeharry said: I included IAS for Agricultural where they state that living animals / plants should be valued at FV. Was that ok? I also added the risk that the stores could have been classified as held for sale as they intended to sell some of them, but this is wrong since the store need refurbishment and hence not available for immediate sale. Really, I was out of ideas and has to write down anything. Hm, for provision for refitting, am not sure if that is a constructive obligation, and hence provision should not be created.I just had it down as a possible compliance risk due to keeping live animals as stock as part of the Business risks required. I passed over the idea that valuation of them might've been a significant risk of material misstatement because it hadn't been judged as significant in prior years so wasn't striking me as something that was suddenly a significant risk in the current year. I mentioned the held for sale thing too. The trouble with that was that the stores were purchased in the current year being audited, but no plan for them for 7 months which took that into the new financial year and it was unclear how many stores would be kept, and how many sold on. So it was hard to say what to do with differentiating between those kept, and capitalised, and those those kept as held for sale. That differentiation would help with calculating how much of a provision should be created for each of the $8m refit costs.
On Deferred tax asset, I also concluded that the Asset should be recognised. It was a change in supply not change in the way the business in carried out.
They sold(build) to themselves instead of using someone else.
I didn't think a change of supplier providing exactly the same product you've been dealing in is a significant change in business.
That's how I discussed it.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

