APM*** P5 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Think it was 14 marks
I got 11% for the WACC too, think I got that one right
Wacc : equity 12 x 75% = 9 % pre-tax debt 8% x 25% x (1 - 0.30) 1.4%
Tax rate 30%
I got the wacc to be 11%. Both EVA'S were negative. For Q1 I got 13.3% for the EV ROCE but my explanation for using EV went horribly wrong now that I'm reviewing. I am so nervous.
go relax, exam finish
Much better paper especially in terms of timing and examiner has probably understood the previous papers were a bit too long to finish within 180 mins.
1.
a) Performance Evaluation - 14 m
b) 2 Measures on Rev/ OP sqm - 8 m
c) RI to replace as main measure over Operating Profit Margin - 8 m
d) ROCE Calculation and suggestion of another techniques (New Store) - 8 m
e) Loyalty Programme/ IS Benefits - 8 m
f) Structure of Answer - 4 m
2.
a) BPR and 3 Initiative Evaluation - 14 m
b) Reward System Evaluation - 11 m
4.
a) EVA Calculations for B/G - 10 m
b) EVA for Divisional Performance - 7 m
c) Value Based Management - 8 m
With me I added lease expenses back because it is value adding...
The paper was fair, hope to get a pass!
Hey... I found wacc of 11% . I worked out exactly the way u di and iam sure it is correct
Accuarate.. with me I didn't adjust the cost of debt with the tax rate. I took it that since we were given the post tax cost of debt... we didnt have to adjust it
Do you remember the mark allocation for Q1?
4for 4ii) i said it was incorrect to use rev and profit per sq meter mainly because the small stores were located in densely populated areas where they were guarenteed high sales and the big stores were in the outer city areas where the population was small and they would get less sales per sq meter.
but i also calculated variences,,, i foung that the larger stores ( which had less rev and profit per sq meter) exceeded budgeted expectations by 2% but the smaller stores only exceeded by 1%
This mean that despite the fact that the larger stores had less revenue per sq meter they were doing better than the smaller stores..
using revenue and profit per sq meter would mean rewarding managers for effort which they really didnt make...
yay!!! my wacc was also 11% lol
You didn't read the questions properly...
agreed
Hi
For Q1 part D) i kno dat it had asked for ROCE calculation but i dont think so if it asked for any suggestion for measures?
Can you or anyone please confirm because i dont remember the suggestion part to this question.
Many thanks in advance
@rushzer said: Much better paper especially in terms of timing and examiner has probably understood the previous papers were a bit too long to finish within 180 mins. 1. a) Performance Evaluation - 14 m b) 2 Measures on Rev/ OP sqm - 8 m c) RI to replace as main measure over Operating Profit Margin - 8 m d) ROCE Calculation and suggestion of another techniques (New Store) - 8 m e) Loyalty Programme/ IS Benefits - 8 m f) Structure of Answer - 4 m 2. a) BPR and 3 Initiative Evaluation - 14 m b) Reward System Evaluation - 11 m 4. a) EVA Calculations for B/G - 10 m b) EVA for Divisional Performance - 7 m c) Value Based Management - 8 mHi For Q1 part D) i kno dat it had asked for ROCE calculation but i dont think so if it asked for any suggestion for measures? Can you or anyone please confirm because i dont remember the suggestion part to this question. Many thanks in advance
Guys, has anyone used Mckinsey 7s in evaluation of BPR? E.g. bpr effect on systems was ..., on staff-... and so on
what about the ROCE calculation, I think I have 33% which is above the target roce of 30%
@ raja
Hi,
the requirement was not to suggest alternative measures but to asses the use of expected ROCE as a tool for decision - making
@AmaraFofanah said: what about the ROCE calculation, I think I have 33% which is above the target roce of 30%I think you mean 13% was the target ROCE and I got for the Medium and High demand a higher ROCE, but for the Low demand, a lower value
I used 7s McKinsey in evaluation BPR as well.
EVA both negatives. No adjustments to CE.
@Alexandra said:
I think you mean 13% was the target ROCE and I got for the Medium and High demand a higher ROCE, but for the Low demand, a lower value.
Am sorry it was 13% the targeted ROCE I got 13.3% more than the target as we have to add all the three possible outcome.
Also the commentary for ROCE calculation was not required instead the examiner only requires comments on the use of expected values.
What was the possible answer for BPR question's part II ?
I applied Mckinsey 7s model to evaluate how BPR affected systems, staff, skills, etc., and in each area tried to propose new performance metrics or at least comment on possible issues, e.g. possible conflicts due to downgrade of supervisors
update: sorry, did not notice you asked about the 2 part. I did not do it due to lack of time, shame
Q1- part a- analysis of report that was gud alot to write but some of my friends forget to link it with boards problem of short-ism
Part 2 was little confussing so first i calculate both ratios and then disscuss it on both negative n positive way
Part 3 was also easy so i write alot
Part 4 i calculate Roce then make a chart of probabilties and compare it with targeted also comment
Part 5 was also easy i linked it with companys goals and write alot
Q4 part a- calculate but i got positive npv and calulation of wacc is not gud i thnk how ever i explain all exemptions
Part b was awsome
Part c was ok
Q3 time was only 20 min left so i didnt attempt this question that gud just main points :(
Yup i thnk its just to calculate roce for three probabilties available taking there revue divided by same capital employed
Then apply probabilties and compare with targeted
How did you guys calculate the expected ROCE?
I did it like this:
Multiplied each operating margin and revenue with their respective probabilities to calculate the expected values, then applied that expected margin to the revenue to calculate the operating profit. Then the usual calculation...of ROCE
Well yes, in the case it was mentioned that CEO is expecting comments to such measures.
Does anyone know when will be published the answers of the exam paper?
Thanks

