APM*** P5 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
The exam was not that bad althogh as always time presured.
The first question was on divisional performance, quality if report, proposed new performance measures, expected RoCE and new information system
The secon question was on business process reingeneering and performance of reward system.
The third question was on ABC and ABB and their application to divisions of the company.
The forth question was on EVA but I did not chose it so I do not know the details of the question.
The questions were clear and to the point for the first time! I guess our collective complains in the last session really helped here.
The paper itself was ok but lengthy. Manage to complete 85% properly and the rest in rush..been scoring 48 since last few sessions. Hoping just to manage a 50 at least inshAllah.
Abm and vbn, eva, roce, is, report assessment
Thought is was an okay question but time was very much against me. With regards ROCE we had to calculate it but talk about the expected value use in decision making right? Also, in the EVA question what did everyone do to the ROCE. Did you add the operation deprecation into it?
Please God let me get 50!
The paper was ok in general! Lost a lot of time while picking question to answer. ? Did anyone notice got negative Eva in 4q for both of divisions? Also did you advice to implement abc for timber in 3?
As far as I remembered I got Eva around -20mln for both....I did not adjust capital employed since did not reveal any adjustment which refer to PY... Did you?
I did not adjust capital employed too. In question 1 have you discussed performance of the company or just performance report in part (i)?
To be fair to the examiner, this wasn't a bad paper, if I fail it'll be because I wasn't prepared enough or my answers were vague in places.
I felt the questions had a lot of reoccurring themes, ROCE mainly.
I got negative EVA but it was massive, think I did my wacc calculation wrong? I also saw a previous question where you got marks for stating assumptions, so I put that I assumed the tax in the accounts was the tax paid and that the capital already had the leases in it, as we were given no detail.
Q2 on BPR I thought was going to be a nightmare as my knowledge on the subject is sketchy, but the question seemed to guide you to an answer, at least that's what I hope!
I was scribbling to the last second as I did Q1 last as it was the one I felt most confident with. I usually hate Q1!
Real lack of models in this exam though which surprised me.
I did not adjust capital employed too. In question 1 have you discussed performance of the company or just performance report in part (i)?
@gvanca said: I did not adjust capital employed too. In question 1 have you discussed performance of the company or just performance report in part (i)?In 1a evaluation of performance report was required, not the performance of the company, so I discussed the report!
I too but I wanted to check if I was right. Thanks :)
Another question on EVA have you added back lease expense in NOPAT calculation?
i am praying i passed. i didnt get to finish Q4 part b or c and i didnt understand what parts ii and iii required for Q1. How did you guys answer part ii for Q1. i thought that revenue per sq metre didnt make sense.
Do we not add back the provision for bad debt becasue it was a movement throughout the year? Also didnt the OCE not have to factor in some depreciation for the operating leases?
I di believe that they really switched examinator and it was nut Alex Watt this time! Because questions did not seem so complicated as usual.
Although I understood that I remember nothing about value based management though I've read about it!
Praying for passing while Alex Watt is on vacation!:-)))
On the income statement side, operating lease charges should be added back.
I have just read this on ACCA technical article RELEVANT TO ACCA QUALIFICATION PAPER P5. So we were correct to add operating lease charge back
WACC 10.45 %
Green EVA positive around 24m, Blue negative around $35m
mostly due to revenue and cap empl figure diff as most adjutments similar for each co.
no r&d adjustment, Econ. Depn adj (12-10) x (1-25%)
Operating Lease add back (said depn incl adj for leases I think ?) couldn't decide if that needed adj as couldn't find a period of lease. so did not further adj.
Non cash add back
pretty much only opex not adjusted
No cap empl. opeing figure adjmts
Who remembered the all requirement of first question .
Found the exam quite tough to be honest
Yes, Of course, It was the evaluation of the performance report, not the performance of company.
Where did you find the capital employed figure for use in Q1?
I either missed it or I am being really stupid and couldn't work it out.
How many mark is attributed to the evaluation of the report?
To start with the exam was pretty fair this time around (comparing i sat last two attempts as well). Overall the exam went pretty decent except the EVA part (I messed the a part of that badly).
Q 1- A- 14 marks on evaluation of report - No NFPIS, Mission statement parts not taken into account, Not enough comprehensive financial measures such as liquidity, working capital and gearing ratios, Suggested that report should include a more comprehensive analysis along with NFPIS, measures addressed to specific parts of missions statement and other financial measures.
B- Op per Square meter and Revenue per square meter- Overall decent measures but they on their own not enough to present the part of mission statement " Using all our resources", Calculated both measures and briefly compared them, Suggested rivals or past year data should be given as well to compare and look for growth.
C- Residual Income Vs Roce/EPS- Encourages manager to look and build for future as the capitalized investments are taken account of, Good divisional measure compared to ROCE and EPS, ROCE can be manipulated by holding assets which are aged.
D- Calculated ROCE- Expected values of Revenues around 13.05M and Op margin around 4.9% smth, calculated ROCE and argued that it is not comprehensive enough measure for company to decide on new stores to be built, NPV should be used and Effects of new store on ROCE should be calculated.
E- Information systems- Customer Retention, Customer Loyalty, Increases knowledge base of the company regarding customers, Buying habits, Aggressive marketing and a more target based approach.
Attempted Q2 and Q4.
Q2 A- BPR- Changes to production lines, faster production, greater motivated workforce, autonomy, improved production lines and methods, employees having a feeling of their own (freedom), adaptability, savings on Supervisor costs, particular disadvantages could be quality compromised and inconsistency and behavior issues of machinists regarding how they see the change
B- Bonus on number of times sewn per week is outdated after BPR, suggested team bonus should be announced related to quality standards being in place, can use a grading system for Jackets produced, A bonus should be given to team over number of A (best) graded Jackets produced and a further bonus should be given to team who has most A graded quality jackets made without defects. Also argued briefly that supervisor cost savings could be used to increase hourly wages of machinists.
Q4- A - Calculated EVA- One was negative one was positive, added back lease payments, added back acc depreciation of 1 in each as i thought economic depreciation was 9 and 4 and in income statement 10 and 5 was deducted, added non cash expense, adjusted capital employed as well, Wacc was around 9-10 %.
B- Cant recall what this was about but wrote in favor of EVA being used as performance measure system against traditional methods.
C- Value adding activities vs non value adding activities, shifting management focus, addressing mission statement of maximizing shareholder wealth.
Hoping to scrap a 50 this time around and get done with exams!
How many mark is attributed to the evaluation of the report?
@mustapo said: How many mark is attributed to the evaluation of the report?There were 14 marks for Q1 part a- evaluation of report
Q1 clearly asked to evaluate performance of the report.
For the WACC I have found 12%*75%+ 8%*25%=11%
The ratio was debt / equity was 1/3 hence 25% and 75% ?
HI everyone.
Attempted Q4 and Q3.
In Q4 one EVA was positive ~7 and one negative ~(25). WACC was 11% (1/4*8%)+(3/4*12%). As far as I remember there was a post tax cost of debt of 8%.
In Q1 expected ROCE was 13.3.
Does anybody remember whether a calculation of current measures (rev and profit per metre) was required?
Hi Senya, web have the same calculation except that I had no positive EVA both were negative
I have found 13.33 % as well
For the revenue and operating profit per square metre it was unclear hence I have done the calculation
Got the same numbers too. Although i did invent NOPAT and CE on EVA and moved on to comment on the results so i could grab the interpretation Marks

