AFM*** P4 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Yes this is correct ... Pa=15 (asset value) and Pe=15 (Pv of +cfs) .... as NPV=0
Argh the more i think about it the mire i've found i've done wrong!
P4 was fair this time
i did q1,2 and 4
q4 was stright forward
Yes i did the same
Any information for Q3? No one chose it?
Hi guys. I used pa of 15 and pe of 13.99. Instead of using the zero npv i used the projected negative npv. Do I get some marks at least 50percent of the question or do I miss out on it entirely for using the wrong pe?? Pls help out
I did it wrong too but will only be a couple of marks in hindsight i think it should pa=16.01 because it took it from npv -1.01 to 0 with 15 investment meaning 16.01 must have come into the project. And pe=15 i think.
But hey ho as long as calculations are there they will allocate some marks. We will just lose those specifically for pe/pa which ever is wrong.
Question 1
I used March Future n March Call option..But people are saying June..
Do I get some marks at least 50percent of the question or do I miss out on it entirely for using the wrong month? Pls help out
I'm really worried.
Question 4. My Pa was 13.99 also...Lord I'm worried
I did Q3. It was merit and demerit of M&A.
Also valuation based on net asset basis and fcf The merit and demerit must be based on the scenario.
What were the answers if you remember? Only cash flow details were given with total assets and liabilities if I remember
Hi dear i have also written pa 13.99 its not a deadly sin only 1 or 2 marks will be deducted but if there is mistake in d1 answer then there will be 0 marks
.. dear i have attempted part b well but messed up in qs 1 can u tell what u written in qs 1 last part ...i have calculated div capacity and hedging in very bad presentation and didnt wrote enough on ans just did like rough work will this be accepted?
I also had 13.99 as Pa,,,let us wait and see.
I did in the same way as you))
Hi, mu guess is, you will make it . At least, to the best of my knowledge, you did better than me.
You actually brought me to light as to what I did not know was expected of me.
Well then, Good Luck on this coming 18th April, 2016!
Hi there, no worries, the marking scheme isn't quite like that. Just for one P/E ratio or any other figures, you will not be penalized wholly instead just the allocated mark.
The examiners would like to see your presentation and your understanding in tackling the particular scenario, thus you will still be rewarded with marks for your remaining answers although these figures isn't right in its own right.
No worries, my friend and Good Luck when the result is out this coming 18th April, 2016.
Hi there, Danielle and Ahmed Bashir are right; it is supposed to be a PUT option as it is a situation of hedging against the depreciation in the Euro currency in exchange for the US Dollar.
And therefore, should the Euro currency was to move against the company, it is able to ensure the minimum receipt in the US Dollar currency.
Yup, your friends are likely correct in saying that it should be the June contract but nevertheless, you could have done well in other questions perhaps enough to walk you through to a passing mark level.
Just keep your fingers crossed just like myself as I did a blunder too for cancelling out here and there and making it relatively difficult for the examiner to marking my answer script.
All I can say now is Good Luck to the people like who could have done better just to ensure we are able to secure that very important passing mark.
Yes, George, your right! It is about hedging against the depreciation in the Euro exchange rate against the US$ Dollar currency and therefore to hedge using the 'PUT' option - the right to sell at the predetermined fixed rate only if the exchange was to moved adversely - the option is to be exercised.
Good Luck!
There is something wrong there, Q1 receipt was around USD 23m, and the historical growth rate was 16.6 % without project. (Dividend grew from 10800 to around 20000). It was way higher than the project which had only 7%.
me too
Hi Danny,
You are receiving EUR 20m and hence you need to hedge against the strengthening of the USD. If the USD depreciates, you will receive much more EUR. If the dollar gets stronger, you will receive less. Thus, your only option is to buy a call, as you want to receive a guaranteed minimum amount.
Guys this a technical error.contract currency is $.expecting to receive Euro.Hence sell Euro ,buy $.since you buy contract currency and home is USA therefore it is buy june call options at strike price.
Exactly, at the end you get like USD 23m out of the EUR 20. And no need for a put as the more the USD depreciates, the more USD you will get from the EUR 20. The examples in BPP were always with contracts based on either GBP or EUR. That's why it was confusing to see 0.89 as strike, but it makes sense as the contracts were based in USD.
Well guys, my special to thanks to you as I am enlighten with the fact that I did badly as I was not aware about my gravely wrong interpretation especially in the area involving foreign exchange hedging.
I guess I have to start continuing practicing any questions that I can get hold on for this paper P4. I believe I will need to resit it as I did not only get this question so wrong but other
questions as well.
Thank you guys for sharing your thoughts particularly, Hans, for bringing up the matter in relation to hedging against foreign currency exchange.
Hi Hans,
Thank you for giving your share of thoughts and opinion.
It has helped me to understand that I have gotten the question wrongly thus not providing the right answer.
This least I know now - I best not waste time preparing for other papers as I will have to resit this paper P4.
Thank you once again and Good Luck to you when the result is out on 18th April, 2016.
In hedging in forward rate i divided 20m with higher forward rate and in future i multiplied locking rate with 20m..and in option chose the call option of june..in qs 1 last part i written than the shareholders will have cocern because the amount that will be rec from sale of inv is uncertain so some debt and equity should also be raised for financing.. in div capacity just calculated the amount like rough work.. anyone plz give ur comments regarding what ive done in qs 1..and will i get professional marks if used the report format in dicussiob paper?
Did u multiplied or divided with forward rate?
If we were to receive euro 20m we would hedge that amount so that if euro depreciate or dollar appreciates we would have to face loss, that's why we chose sell future and lock a rate so that uncertainty is beg dealt with and we would sell those euros at locked rate and also we would know today what proceeds in dollar we'll get!
So for future => Sell Euro Future
Nd for options => Put Option
Hi Noor,
My apology as the last time I thought it was a put option, but it is a call option.
Congratulations, you are likely right. So keep your fingers crossed.
Good Luck.
Hi Basher,
Now, I know that I have just so little knowledge and understanding about hedging against foreign currency exposure.
I need to do some homework now perhaps of what you have written thus far.
Thank you so much and Good Luck!
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

