AFM*** P4 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
P4 abit fair let me keep my fingers crossed
In q1.....I got less than 40million cash flow,From operating profit I add depreciation and then deduct all investments and lastly interest of 5% on bonds....than I add dividend received n deduct additional withholding tax ....total of above all divided by number of share...this is what I have done.
In currency option...I think we shld not exercise... But anyways I showd the calculation ...which seems quite odd (to be honest)......question 4 no idea how to get PA....I just divide npv with cost of capital n got call option of -3.86, question 2 was OK ...got Marginal +npv n than I calculated the financing impact...I ignored that interest treatment of long term loan,which say interest will b on balancing figure......Now guys...what u say, what are my chances :)
Was it a call option on dollars?
Yes it was a call option on dollar
Is it put option? Because is an option to sell euro receipt
Does anyone remember the questions and mark allocation for Q1?
For me q4 pa=15 pe=15 because npv=0 can anyone confirm these?
No call because the contract was quoted in dollars and we were buying dollars. Selling euro. Call option
HOw much mark will they deduct if i use put option?
I havr never encounter this kind of question in past year..this paper p4 is so tricky
which question u left unattempt?
I choose 2 and 4 as optional and so far i discovered myself make quite few mistake
I din even know how to do 2b
You are correct on that one , otherwise that poll is not a true representative of the actual facts.
Call option mate .
Yeah, it is a call option. Can't remember what I did in exam. Does anybody remember, the premiums given on the left were premiums for call or put?
a very time pressured paper really, i attempted question 1 2 and 4. question one was okay did the dividend capacity normally, calculated the lock in rate and chose call options and did the forward rate wrote down explanations fine i think. the discussion paper was a surprise though did it like a report but changed the title.
question 2 i thought the apv was a fair one but mistakenly forgot the fixed cost out and the government subsidy was a bit confusing.
question 4 no idea wat the Pa was just put zero and made an assumption but i read the article and wrote sound assumptions. gues 10 marks for assumptions.
b, had no idea what rho was just wrote about interest rate risk
c was general knowlege on world bank and IDA
hoping for a pass atleast in sha allah
Well,
in Q1
a) dividend capacity was approximately USD 24 mln.
b) i have used call option and bought futures (both June contracts), effective rate was 1.1605. Contract size 138. (receipt USD 17mln)
c) dividend growth was without project 6% and company value USD 536 mln, as I remember. With new project i got higher value, so new investment project should be undertaken.
Q2. Base case NPV - Discount cash flows using all-equity financed dis.rate (I have used given asset beta, no need of ungearing);
Financial side effect - 1. tax shield on debt 18*0.06*0.25, discounted by risk free rate -3.5%, years (2,3,4,5 - as tax is payable in the following year)
2. subsidy effect 8*0.08%*0.75 , discounted by risk free rate -3.5%, years (2,3,4,5 - as tax is payable in the following year)
3. tax shield on subsidy loan 8* (libor-0.08)%*0.25 ,discounted by risk free rate -3.5%, years (2,3,4,5 - as tax is payable in the following year)
Right issue- nothing
Issue costs - (18+8)/0.99*0.01=0.26
Q4.
Call option - P(e) - 15 mln, Pa - i assumed that npv of expansion of production would be 0+1.41(negative npv figure given), and undiscounted it using 12% to get to the 3rd year. Options rho is the measure of interest rate changes.
I chose put option as you need to see what are you selling or buying againt dollar
Every currency trades against dollar
But thn again im not too sure as contect size was given in dollars
Sorry, tax shield on debt was calculated on reducing loan balanace (4.5 mln payment each year)
@georgestpierre said: For me q4 pa=15 pe=15 because npv=0 can anyone confirm these?Yes! I used the same numbers as you!
Anyone remember the mark allocation for Q1, Q2 and Q4?
Q4 was 16, 5 and 4
Q2 was 18 and 7
Q1 was 6, 9, 14, 8, 9 and 4 professional marks
For Q4 i used 15m as both Pa and Pe as the NPV was zero. But discounted both down at 3 years at 12%....think I got 10.68m for both?
Q1 was definitely buy futures and call options. contract was quoted in $ and we were buying $ from an expected euro receipt.
Q2 for APV i used CAPM to find the pre finance discount rate using only asset beta. Got discount rate of 15% If I remember correctly??
Did any attempt Q3.Is simpler than Q 4.benefit of M&A and valuation us in Net Asset basis and simple cash flow!
Hi,
In Q1 did you have to calculate 2 years of cashflows or just one I thought it said at the top of the QS it was going to fund project by two years cash flows??
Thanks guys
Hello guys and hope best of luck with this exam.
March 2016 mark allocation for Q1, Q2 & Q4 was as follows:
Q1) (a) Purchasing Power Parity Theory & Economic Exposure - 6
b) (i) Dividend capacity calculation - 9
(ii) FX Hedging strategy - 14
(iii) Dividend pattern and if the project was adding value - 8
(iv) Discuss about methods of financing - 9
+4 professional marks
Q2) (a) Adjusted Present Value Calculation - 18
(b) Concerns of shareholders regarding financing structure - 7
Q4) (a) Black Scholes calculation of real (call) option to delay. Discussion of assumptions & issues - 16
(b) Rho factor explanation and the effect of change of interest rates have on this option (call) - 5
(c) Possible funding from World Bank and specifically from International Development Association - 4
i did and yes i agree it was reletively very simple easy and straight forward question. i got a value of 104m using net assets method around 110 something using members earning mathod and 150 using cashflow method.
how many of you had a marginally negative npv in question number 2? mine was -1.47 base case npv if i remember correctly. While after adding the financing side my APV came out to be around $7.4m something positive.
i was able to attempt on 74 marks exam. Q#1 really made it a nightmare of exam for me coz i attempted that question in the end and due to that i was not able to even attempt the part b's ii and iii hence 22 marks were unattended. Altough i am very certain that ques 2 and ques 3 which i attempted were brilliant. but i dont think i'll be able to pass by just attempting 74 marks exam no matter how good i performed in those 78 marks.
Discount rate is 12% using CAPM
Q4- Pa-15 and Pe-15 ????? Pv of CFs ?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

