Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AFM*** P4 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition15y ago
Please share here with community your comments about June 2011 P4 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P4 June 2011 Exam was … Post your comments here and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Ccporteus15y ago#31
Gosh that was hard work. I didn't feel totally prepared going in but wasn't expecting this level of time pressure. I really can't see how Q1 could be done in the time.

Fortunately did Q4 and Q5 first, so hope to pick up a few marks on those.

Ran out of time on 2c which was a shame as probably easier marks than some of Q1.

My valuation for the acquisition was less than the $20 million that they had in reserves! Not good, had to make an estimate of $30 million in order to progress with the debt part. Ah well I had a stab. Hopefully will get some marks for working out the cost of equity, WACC etc.
Yyousaadat15y ago#32
Q.1> WACC 11% for Fodder and WACC 9% for Combined firm..... that was lengthy calcution than rest of the requirments for not that much tough if one have basic knowledge of acquisition and Capital Structure matters.

Q.2> Main issue was Future Spot rate after 4 months which is tricky rest was normal calculation..........

Q.3.Duration calculation by using formula......

1+y/y (1+y)+t(c-y)/c(1+y)wholepower t - 1 + y

where
c=coupon rate
y=yield to maturity (Which is to be calculated)
t= time to maturity ( 5 yrs)

So easy 9 marks if u know the formula

Q.4 Pe=35 Pa=35.7 (PV of Cashflows) than discussion blah blah blah........
Former userFormer user15y ago#33
Pa was 48. Pe was 49
Bburaaq15y ago#34
I dont quite remember my values, but ya even my Pa and Pe were in 40s...I guess 43. something and 41. something million; value of option was I guess around 8 point something.

And question 2 was very easy, you just had to calculate the lockin rate. Subtract from the futures rate today's spot. This difference would have closed down in 5 months, and it was actually 0.0080. At the end of the 4th month (this is when you will be selling your $ receipt), your REMAINING difference would be 0.0080/5 which is equal to 0.0030 if I am not mistaken. Just deduct this from today's future's price and you will be get the lockin rate, which would be your effective rate of transaction at the end of the 4th month.

Forward was your best option though; it gave you the most receipts. Then part b wasn't tough once you knew on which rate to transact at (which was forward rate).

C seemed easy but I ran out of time. I left 30 maarkkssss and i KNEW the answers...I just wish they would give us like 30 mins more! Its humanly impossible to complete the paper AND get it right in such a tight time frame :'(
Bburaaq15y ago#35
And I am not sure, but I recall my cost of capital for Fodder was 10.5%. Anyone here agrees?

Of course, the cost of capital for the combined company would depend on your valuation of fodder, we had to weight the beta alpha according to market capitalization, then progress towards calculating the combined Beta equity, moving on to CAPM, and then moving on to WACC calculation, where we would be borrowing at 6.4% (combined company).
Former userFormer user15y ago#36
Anyone noticed that instead of a separate Investment Appraisal ques he brought Inv App in each of the first 4 qus??
I knew the acquisition ques would be tough so I did not try that first. I attempted in the following order:
Q4 - Real Options - Pe: PV of (7 + 7 + 35) is that right? Pa was the PV of +ve cash flows?
Q3 - I initially thought I did this ok but after reading the comments I realised I completely messed up the Currency Future part. I think I got confused with Int Rate futures lol And I didn't get a result for the hedge cause I wasn't seeing info to work out the Fut Spot and Fut Fut price.
Q1 - I worked out value for Fodder, value for combined but then nothing... I got kinda lost and at that point I realised I was running out of time so I moved onto next qus. So 15+ marks lost there....
Q3 - duration. I only had time enough to work out for Bond1 - I got 4.6 years?? Something like that. But I think I failed it overall.
So I dunno. The main question is, do I try again in December or move onto Audit?? ugh kill me now...
Ttrinistudent00115y ago#37
@authentichero said:
I am not going to pass, i am so tired of ACCA now.


P4 made me so demotivated for the last 3 sittings, the first time being my closest to a pass at 46 (Dec 09). I simply switched to P7 this sitting, it was time pressured but it wasnt so bad. I'm hoping to pass. I suggest if you have given up on ACCA altogether bcuz of P4....P7 is the way to go. Just saying...dont give up :)
Sslimshon15y ago#38
one word - horrible
Ooseidarko15y ago#39
Q2 spoilt my day. Got confused so messed up. It carried alot of weight together with q1. did not practiced enough on the futures & options otherwise things would have been ok. Lecture in op tuition was very helpful. I discovered open tuition so late. I don't know whether I will pass or not but a little bit confident than in the previous sitting.
Former userFormer user15y ago#40
Hi Everybody,
I thought this paper, by far, was the hardest I have sat. We were asked to do so much in the amount of time we had, and I am among many that didn't manage to finish...
Q1 - How much did you all get for the valuation? I think mine was around 40m and the value of the combimed company came out at something like 180m... Which seemed rediculously high!
For the bond question, I couldn't really remember what to do with it but that's the Q I ran out of time on and so only magnaged to calculate the yeild at 5%.
I found Q2 OK...
Q4, was OK doing the formula, but not sure I got the inputs right. I got 14 for Pe and about 28 for Pa, what did you all get?
I'm feeling pretty demotivated after that, but lets just enjoy the summer :)
Mmuneebnawaz9015y ago#41
try to show ur efforts in Compulsory questions and attempt complusory questions first . what our teachers says is that those who attempt compulsory question complete and well answered even with 15 to 20 marks left in other optional questions have more chances to get pass as compare to who leave question 1 i.e compulsory for the last moment and unanswered.
Former userFormer user15y ago#42
I really don't like this examiner he is showing off his analytical knowledge too much and use this opportunity to show off. His style is so lengthy and so unnecessarily detailed. The question 2 is so unfair that if you can't get (a) answered the rest will be shit.
Former userFormer user15y ago#43
I think in the question 2 Pa was the present value of the the cash inflow from period 3 to period 6 as the inflow was going to start from year 3. Pe was the first two years investment and the production cost that they are planning to delay.

Q1 was really time consuming. I dont know how can you perform both calculations in 17 marks question timezone. You cant leave it half way as you cant answer other bits without having to know how much is the value of the equity of the company to know how much debt finance will require to fund the purchase etc.

Q4 was alright as it was purely based on simple calculations with no much tricks except the currency swap part which required bit of thinking. I will appreciate if some videos are uploaded for the same. Unfortunately didnt have much time to organise the answer properly as Q1 and Q2 were time consuming.

I wanted to write so much for this question but again no time. Pointed out main issues and couple of ways to handle them. Couldnt write the directors remuneration because not much time left to read question second time and pick all the bits.

Overall, I am not sure about the result but any paper at professional level cant be easier than this one.

Good luck everybody!!!!
Former userFormer user15y ago#44
i dnt think so that paper was that difficult . although underperformed .. q2 -was straight forward if you have studied foreign currency hedging ... Q4 and Q5 were so easy .. Q1 was lengthy .. so i attempted it last .. theory was easy in question 1 so you could have gained easy marks there .. part a of q1 was very lengthy for the allocated marks .. but still passing marks could have been achieved at this part also .. for people doing question 1 first for them it would had been a challenge coz most problably they would had run overtime and then messing up in other questions to ..
Former userFormer user15y ago#45
The question 1 was a disaster

otherwise it was ok but spend too many time on quest 1 that could complete the paper :(
HHhamdy hafez15y ago#46
it's my second attempt, & I think there will be another one next DEC
Former userFormer user15y ago#47
The exam was fairly easy
Former userFormer user15y ago#48
Pe should be calculated as we calculate value of zero coupon debt.. i did in the same way.. discounted the outflows n found the terminal value at 2nd yr.. dont know whether it was right:s
Former userFormer user15y ago#49
I dont think one should try to 'complete' question straightaway.. it is rather impossible that u know every bit of every question.. i attempted question 1 firstly but only those parts which i can attempt in the short time possible.. its not about COMPLETINg the question. u have 100 marks all you have to do is to grab them by hook or by crook.. i learned this over my last 2 attempts.
Former userFormer user15y ago#50
Fu*&ing horrible

Ran out of time for Q1, could only answer part of Q2.

Q4 & Q5 not too bad but I seriously doubt that I scraped enough marks to pass.

Same time in 6 months then...............
Former userFormer user15y ago#51
The questions seemed doable at first, but lots of complicated details made exam very time pressured. I felt well prepared but did not know the whole syllabus inside out, which I think you need to know if you intend to pass! I managed to answer all of the questions but very poorly, due to time pressure. I agree the exams need to be challanging but this "style" of exam does not allow students like me to prove how hard they've worked. Very disappointed, I expect I will need to re-sit in Dec.
Former userFormer user15y ago#52
Q1 was technically not hard, but it needed a lot of time to calculate all differents parts and time consuming. Q2 was straight forward. Q4, Q5 was reasonable. all in all, it was much more reasonable than previous examiner's very hard technical questions.
Former userFormer user15y ago#53
I dont Know Why Examiner Consider us a Machine .......... ? Q1 Was too Much Lengthy ... is does not make any sense .... it was a Competition to Manage the Time Efficiently... Not a Paper Of Financial Management
Former userFormer user15y ago#54
shishir has made me speechless , i did what i could do in preparations but after coming out of the exam i was confused. The questions were time consuming , can ACCA have anather way of assessing people rather 3 hr papers.
people fail not that they dont know the things but because of time pressure.
Former userFormer user15y ago#55
shishir has made me speechless , i did what i could do in preparations but after coming out of the exam i was confused. The questions were time consuming , can ACCA have anather way of assessing people rather 3 hr papers.
people fail not that they dont know the things but because of time pressure.
Former userFormer user15y ago#56
Fairly Easy Exam.
Q.1 Fairly straightforward
Q.2 Fairly easy on the currency forex part
Q.4 again an easy one
Q.5 Reflection of P1.
Ssomewherelse15y ago#57
here is the link if anyone would like to give feedback about this exam. I think they consider the feeback before marking.

https://www.accaglobal.com/en/student/exam-feedback.html
Former userFormer user15y ago#58
Unless they reduce the pass rate to say 35% i am doomed. Mr Malde is clearly trying to complicate a course that is seemingly supposed to be enjoyable and beneficial to future finance professionals.
Former userFormer user15y ago#59
In one of the comments somebody said that Q1 required normal degear-regear exercise. Was it necessary? For what? Didn't it say that the combined beta was wheited average beta of the 2 firms?
Aazzuritta15y ago#60
it was my 3rd attempt to pass the paper. it is my final paper and i cannot manage to pass it. i believe that this was my last attempt i will change paper on december as i do not have any desire to read once more the same things!!!