Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** P3 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin13y ago
Post your comments about P3 June 2013 exam. How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams? Vote in our Instant Poll *** P3 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments *** poll results
Nnevyana13y ago#61
I think here the point is the relevant and suppoeted discussion, not really the conclusion.
Former userFormer user13y ago#62
maximum 2 otherwise 1 mark for conclusion
Former userFormer user13y ago#63
<cite>@localmode said:</cite> what on earth did you good people write about Scenario Planning in the 1$ industry ?>??
Not completely sure about the scenario thing, but what i wrote here was regarding possible market changes - increase in economy in a couple of years which would mean decrease in revenue for 1$ sales; possible increased pressure from the other participants in the market; change in lease/rent terms; i proposed using expected value for at least 3 different scenarios (worst case, normal case and best case) considering number of possible buyers... I also wrote about the 6I's in the 3rd question, but not particularly insisted on them. I said stuff like the system should be interactive, accept reviews, finally would help customers with their low deposit capacity through JIT inventory and maybe EOQ. To my understanding, the system would be for final customers (so not the chemical wholesalers but the chemical "buyers"). I didn't much appreciate the case study, i thought it was difficult to follow the initiation-conduct-termination of project line; the ideas were coming and i just wrote them down. Wrote alot in part b about culture (with referance to how culture was at the core of implementation (McKinsey's 7S model - but didn't insist). Then went on to culture web, but with significant emphasis on Power and Control. All the best to you.
Former userFormer user13y ago#64
Where did Payroll, Legal advice and enhanced Web presence fall in Harmon's process strategy matrix?
Aanon13y ago#65
So much for studying the entire syllabus. Would've been a cakewalk if i practiced more project management questions, and i thought i did, just that this one was unique, so I wasted a lot of time.
Former userFormer user13y ago#66
For me question 1 problems and lesson learnt from project at initial, implemation and post stages 1b how understanding of cultural we and organ configuration (structure would have given ceo better opportunity to deal with problem and 1c stragetic lenses in term on midshire. Question 3 harmon matrix by co nesta to evaluate payroll , legal advise and enhancement of it for delivery tracking delivery 3b advantages of it to get and retain customer question 2a porter 5 forces and 2b used suitabilty, feasibilty and acceptability (not so sure about this one) overall exam was fairly easy
Kkristyna13y ago#67
Hello; just wanted to say that I thought it was quite a fair paper, really. The models that were required were quite easy - what I found hard was trying to relate them all to the scenarios. How do you know whether you are picking the right information... Anyway. For the CRM I used the customer identification, aquisition, retention and extension... Who knows what they wanted - it is always a surprise when one reads the official answers!! :-) Please may it be a pass!!!
Rrabia_shah13y ago#68
Q1 part (a)was abiout project management i build my answer around ....Leadership, team members, Communiation, resources required for the project....etc part (b) culture web..... Q2 Portor Five forces Q3, Harmon strategy proces.... Ithink paper was fair enough for well prepared student ...as i was not prepare enough for the paper ...hoping for 50....
Jjosian13y ago#69
Well good luck to all those who wrote this paper. Unfourtunately i could not get to write it.
Mmaxkay13y ago#70
anyone ever written a statement on exam day?
Former userFormer user13y ago#71
I dont Understand that many students misunderstood about the question... In LSBF notes it is clearly define the CRM AND E-CRM ..THE MODEL ADCOKS GUIDE TO CRM HAS TO BE PLACED AND 6 I 'S IS WRONG selection ,as they were nothing like marketing scenario in the question... see LSBF NOTES PAGE NO 140...CRM AND E-CRM ...
Former userFormer user13y ago#72
I am not sure about this one. I finished on time but not sure if I wrote enough quality answers. My main concern was the invigilation. They read the rules out but over ran past the exam start time and then appeared not to have said we could start reading. Some people had started but the rest of us had not. Then at the end of the exam they didn't give us the extra minute they missed at the beginning! Also we have been prevented from having food available during the exam which is good but squeaky shoes and a constant flurry of people going to the toilet is very distracting. Aren't they supposed to be sitting an exam too?
Former userFormer user13y ago#73
<cite>@clairemitch said:</cite> I was surprised to see project management appear as Q1, would have expected a section B question on that topic. Did anyone consider suggestions such as using a PID to outline project details, have an experienced project manager or ensure adequate controls are in place to review how the project was going? It wa tricky enough to relate it back to the scenario at times. I went for q4 leadership styles said that Sully was dispalying the tells features initially. Job enrichment.. Focused on empowering the staff by allowing them to make decisions, motivate them to do a good job for their own satisfaction. Then question 3, I said to outsource the legal advice as not the core business, same for payroll. Then focus on the web enhancement internally as this is where value is added. In Q1, I didnt use cultural web, explained how the CEO came from industrial machine buaucracy but the hospital was more professionak beaucracy with wide flat structure, not sure was that the correct approach required!
yes i did use PID and business case....
Nnevyana13y ago#74
I also related q1a to PID and business case, the initial phases of the project management.
484m 8113y ago#75
I found Q1 a struggle as part a covered such a vast area... The whole of project management. Q2 part A was fine using porter five forces, however not sure how to approach path B ... Scenarios!? I did SFA but know this is wrong. Q3 part A was good using Harmons strategic matrix. Felt 10 marks for CRM was a bit too much. Overall didn't find this a good paper, I felt well prepared but this paper wasn't a consistent style with past papers.
Ggolamrahim13y ago#76
G
Ggolamrahim13y ago#77
Was the CEO the project manager or the project sponsor??
Llunix13y ago#78
<cite>@abgreat1 said:</cite> I dont Understand that many students misunderstood about the question... In LSBF notes it is clearly define the CRM AND E-CRM ..THE MODEL ADCOKS GUIDE TO CRM HAS TO BE PLACED AND 6 I 'S IS WRONG selection ,as they were nothing like marketing scenario in the question... see LSBF NOTES PAGE NO 140...CRM AND E-CRM ...
Not everyone studied at LSBF and other providers material did not focus on CRM much.
Former userFormer user13y ago#79
<cite>@golamrahim said:</cite> Was the CEO the project manager or the project sponsor??
I dont think it said. Maybe that was part of the problem, he was both?
Llunix13y ago#80
<cite>@golamrahim said:</cite> Was the CEO the project manager or the project sponsor??
I understand that he was the project manager.
Ssameed13y ago#81
One thing that took me totally off guard was project management in compulsory question . Never in my wildest dreams i thought that project management will be featured in 50 mark question
Llunix13y ago#82
<cite>@sameed said:</cite> One thing that took me totally off guard was project management in compulsory question . Never in my wildest dreams i thought that project management will be featured in 50 mark question
I also thought that it was somehow unbalanced, 40 marks for project management and culture :(
Llunix13y ago#83
<cite>@jackbailey02 said:</cite> I dont think it said. Maybe that was part of the problem, he was both?
You are right, he was both and that was part of the problem.
Former userFormer user13y ago#84
fantastic paper p3 this time it was much harder in dec12
Ppolldoll13y ago#85
I really hope the marking scheme for Q1 (a) (i) isn't weighted so that you had to distribute the project management criticisms evenly between the 3 phases of the project that they identified... I did make sure that I put a couple of things for each but way more for initiation phase as it was so clearly doomed from the start LOL! Why am I even thinking about this? Must get to bed now. P2 in the morning!
SAst. acey13y ago#86
My Q1 answer seemed weighted around the fact it was a NFP org. Particularly with the problems in the initiation phase with some of the things the CEO was suggesting and when relating the 3 lenses (design, experience and ideas) to MidShires. Did anyone else do the same??
Former userFormer user13y ago#87
AS PER MY THINKING, I WAS NOT EXPECTING 50 MARKS FROM PROJECT MANAGEMENT AND THATS THE REASON I MAY FACE TROUBLE THE OTHER PORTION WAS FAIR IN THAT CASE IF YOU HAVE GOOD APPROACH. LETS SEE AND HOPE FOR THE BEST DEAR ALL, PLEASE ALSO PRAY FOR MY MOTHER, SHE IS CANCER PATIENT AND IN SERIOUS CONDITION REGARDS, AHMED
Former userFormer user13y ago#88
Hello colleges, i hope we all smile at our result on the 8 August 2013 , because we all thought we did something right but the marker will tell us the right thing and i hope all of us to be happy that day. However, Q1 was a scenario one strategic planning mistakes , organisation culture and strategic lenses Q2. Porter's five forces and it and Qb. i cant remember that one Q3 Harmon 's Business process matrix and CRM of how to acquire and retain customer. therefore with the gentle effort of all of us , may God help us all and may we coincide with a market that will honestly give us of effort not otherwise.
Mmahadi13y ago#89
hi, I sat P3 4 times, I think this seesino is fair, i did the optional questions first ,then spent the remaining time in the case study, Q3 is the easiest for me with 15 marks on BP change using Harmon Matrix (the processes with each one worth 5 marks)+ 10 marks on CRM with its three stages(Acquisition, Retention & extension) approximately 3-4 marks for each stage of CRM Q2 15 marks on Porter's 5Forces(3 for each force analysis)+ 10 marks on Scenario planning(this is the only part I missed for time pressure) Q1 18 marks for criticizing the CEO's Approach for Project management in each project phase(initiation, conduct & termination) I suspect that 9 mistakes have to be documented & supported from the Case study(lack of formality, resources not committed to the project, poor strategic fitness, etc.) another 18 marks for culture & org. structural supporting the project failure(mintzberg is the best answer guide for this) 4 marks for professional skills 10 marks for strategy lenses I did Q3 well, Q2 p-a well, Q1 P-a(i) well, poorly did Q1 p-a(ii) & p-b, with a loss of ten marks of Q2p-b overall its a fair paper
Former userFormer user13y ago#90
Regarding Question 2 (NESTA, discount stores, market attractiveness) Did anyone else notice that the difference in revenue of NESTA compared with the combined sales of the discount stores was unusually large? Total revenue of NESTA was "$120,000 million" and the supermarket revenue was "$42,500 Million" as stated in the written portion. However, the combined 2012 Revenue of all 3 discount shops was only $930 million in the data. Such a big disparity. I mentioned that although the market may be attractive if it keeps growing, it might be rather small for NESTA to justify any substantial investment. I'm guessing the 120,000 million was not a typo was it? Did anyone else find this strange since NESTA was more than 100 times bigger by revenue than all 3 competitors combined? I don't see why they couldn't have written $1.2 Billion, or was this suppose to be a trick of some sort?