Post your comments about P3 June 2013 exam.
How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?
Vote in our Instant Poll

SBL*** P3 June 2013 Exam was.. Post your comments ***
disaster..... ever in p3 history.....
I would better watch inception than writing this paper......
For Q2 (b), I used Ansoff and BCG models as the examiner used the wording 'scenarios' for new market in Eurobia, I don't know whether it is correct or not...
And for Q3 I also used 6Is for CRM, but my time management is so poor that I just finished writing the headings of all 6Is and explain 3 out of the 6 :(
<cite>@bbegio said:</cite> Hello After failing P3 in December, let me tell you how I think this session was. I read many past P3 papers and can admit that this one was a very fair paper. Q1 asked for what it needed the failing strategic planning project described in the scenario to succeed, with some reference to the software implementation that the CEO wanted in place- 18 marks that could be achieved. I personally developed my answer around SMART. The following question offered another 18 marks for analysis of the current culture and organisation structure and how, if it was assessed before laying down the strategic plan described in the scenario, it woul have helped the CEO to achieve the strategy. 4 marks for presentations and 10 mars for strategies lenses. Q2 - Porter's 5 forces -15 marks. Very sweet the examiner. The other part asked for .... Ops, I don't remember anymore. Q3 - harmon's matrix - again, the examiner was very nice this time. 15 marks for three business processes to assess plus suggestion on action. Last bit, 10 marks, CMR. How its implementation could help the company in terms of acquisition and retention of customers. I felt totally lost last time. I argued that it was complex and very lengthy. I don't think there was any trick this time but in December, the paper was much harder, I just hated it. I hope this helps! Good luck you all! BB
what on earth did you good people write about Scenario Planning in the 1$ industry ?>??
Timing was a big issue today. I had not finished reading Q1 at the 15 minutes mark, let alone the options (chosen by reference to the question requirements not reading the scenarios).
Q.1. I began after an extra 10 mins to finish reading(!) and took too long. Part (a) seemed ok - structured (i) around the project stages and (ii) around cultural web (except no obvious symbols, more emphasis on power) and comparing config of org to what the CEO was used to. Did you decide it was a professional bureaucracy anyone??
Part (b) I had already overrun and with hindsight should've moved on to do a better job of the Section B questions but I had a quick stab, writing down ways in which the CEO intended strategy to come from design, experience and ideas but all were scuppered as he didn't go about it very well. Did anyone feel they knew what this part was after?
Q.2. I got something down for each of the 5 forces in part (a) and talked through modelling scenarios on range of assumptions for part (b) but I didn't even look at the financial information I now realise!! Did people conclude that it was a good strategy?
Q.3. I began with something like 20 mins of exam time left but I think my part (a) answer was strong. I positioned each of the strategies on the quadrant and explained the IT people should've focused their attentions on the web process not overcomplicating payroll to the extent people don't know what they're being rewarded for! I said to stick with outsourced legal as workload varies and not adding value. Part (b) I frantically scribbled a few things about CRM, then realised that the customers were industry-based not end users so usual incitements wouldn't sway them. Was in middle of trying to turn it around when time was up!
Overall not a disaster but could've done with more reading/thinking time. Hoping for a pass!
<cite>@jackbailey02 said:</cite> Thought the exam was okay, but theres definately been easier in recent times. Seemed for every standard mark on there though, there was a difficult mark. The strategy lenses and CRM i knew a little about. I have never even heard of scenario planing, never mind for 10% of the exam. I looked in my Kaplan complete text and its not in the index. For question one I thought it was a bit confusing. I just found ways the project didnt go well or should have been done differently and tried to put them into each category. Id have prefered project management to be in the choice questions. For 1b i used the cultural web. Couldnt find anything to say for symbols and structure was a push. For 1c i knew the strategy lenses followed rational planning, incrementalism etc I tried to say how these applied to MedShire. I did question 2. Standard 5 forced, Overall said the market was already crowded and these competitors wouldnt let the business just set up, plus they were all bigger, so it wasnt a good option. For part B i didnt have a clue. I guessed why planning scenarios would be good and their limitations. I also suggested ways that the company could move into the market. I also did question 3. The harmons matrix was a nice topic. I said outsource the payroll, bring the law in house make it a key process as its so important in the industry. I said automate the website tracking as it seems the IT dept could do it simply. For part B i couldnt remember much. I said the website could help interaction, send personalised emails etc. Overall as long as I have understood whats been asked and applied it well enough, 50% should be doable. Good luck to everyone else.legal advice had high complexity but low stg importance because those legal advices where requird by themself not by end customer so it shoud have been outsourced.. website had lowcompexity and high stg importance so itshould have been kept inhouse.. besides they had it expertise from the developmnt of complex payrol
I thought it was okay.
Some easy marks such as Culture, Strategic Lenses, Porter 5 forces & Harmon Process Strategy Matrix
However i found CRM & Scenario analysis tricky. Not seen any of these in past questions
Overall i think there was enough easy marks for for a pass. Main thing was i finished the paper and wrote enough for each part. So marks will be gotten even in the tough areas.
MY FACE WAS BETTER THAN THIS PAPER.......!!!
<cite>@jk0323 said:</cite> legal advice had high complexity but low stg importance because those legal advices where requird by themself not by end customer so it shoud have been outsourced.. website had lowcompexity and high stg importance so itshould have been kept inhouse.. besides they had it expertise from the developmnt of complex payrolSame, thats what i thought. It made no sense to bring it in-house with just one legal person. I emphasis the good work that they were enjoying with the outsourced team so no reason for chance. I think they tried to trick people by saying the legal part was of importance (not strategic importance). Either way, you will still get good marks for whatever you decide as long as it is explained well.
Strategic planning process is simply the three stages planning model suggested by JSW: strategic analysis/position, strategic choice and strategy into action.
Did anyone else notice that on question 2, that the company's revenue was stated as being 120 times the revenue of the whole market? 120 thousand million dollars (which I referred to as 120 billion) as opposed to almost a thousand million. At first, I thought it was a misprint but then it mentioned the supermarket's was 42500 million. A strange way of terming it which makes me think it was a little trick put in by the examiner...
<cite>@jk0323 said:</cite> legal advice had high complexity but low stg importance because those legal advices where requird by themself not by end customer so it shoud have been outsourced.. website had lowcompexity and high stg importance so itshould have been kept inhouse.. besides they had it expertise from the developmnt of complex payrolMy tutor said it does not matter what you say as long as you can back up your arguments with valid points. I though the legal thing is a big issue for the customers and it is becoming more important as more legislation is coming in all the time, if they do not get it right they may lose them or get penalties. Automating the website is keeping it in house - but it seemed to be a simple task since they could develop very complex stuff like payroll.
Am I the only one who chose Q3 & Q4 instead of Q2?
<cite>@dannyt1985 said:</cite> Did anyone else notice that on question 2, that the company's revenue was stated as being 120 times the revenue of the whole market? 120 thousand million dollars (which I referred to as 120 billion) as opposed to almost a thousand million. At first, I thought it was a misprint but then it mentioned the supermarket's was 42500 million. A strange way of terming it which makes me think it was a little trick put in by the examiner...I didnt see that. I read it as 120mill. The other companies are all around 300mill. So because we are much smaller, dont go into competition with them.
<cite>@ryzvonusef said:</cite> Am I the only one who chose Q3 & Q4 instead of Q2?No I didn't do q2 either. I thought part a was easy but didnt have a clue on part b so didn't want to throw marks away :-)
smaller but have cash reserves and can lease a lot of stores........... market for $1 stores was growing (higher sales every year)so I write it is good idea to expand. recession probably will affect those 3 existing companies.
difficult paper for me in general. spent a lot of time reading the questions...................
<cite>@dannyt1985 said:</cite> Did anyone else notice that on question 2, that the company's revenue was stated as being 120 times the revenue of the whole market? 120 thousand million dollars (which I referred to as 120 billion) as opposed to almost a thousand million. At first, I thought it was a misprint but then it mentioned the supermarket's was 42500 million. A strange way of terming it which makes me think it was a little trick put in by the examiner...I noticed that too and it put me off the balance. I am pretty sure that it was ACCA's misprint. I interpreted it how it was - dollar shops market less than 1% of company's revenue so not worth investing into, the supermarkets having much bigger turnover so in the scenarios in part b) take this into consideration. But I still think that it was a misprint.
Gosh . . . Is it me or paper really was weird? Did ok overall but my 2(b) and 3(b) lacked in content l8r more than half a page for each
for question 1...i did not use cultural web for my answer..but i manage to write something based on what i know..i will still be correct right?as long as my answers are sensible and logical and fit to what the question ask.
And question one was way too lengthy i only had 1 hour left to attempt the other 2 questions. I think for any one sitting this paper for the first time it was quite a difficult paper
Okay people just bare with me assessment of the exam.
First of all every answer can be correct if backed up with your own arguments and assumptions via the text so everyone will have different interpretations.
Q1(A)
Looked at this and was worried but actually the they gave 3 heading to work under. So i included stuff as cost in the end, not checking the spec, questioning the ethics of the doctors and also threatening them. Also smaller stuff like meeting missing personally and voting without all memebers there.
Q1(B)
Paragram and cultural web here altho took me a while to figure out could not fill all the boxes via the text but tried. Big one was the power in the organisation. Second part and went on about the organisation being wide flat professional beurcracy and comparing public vs private sector. Also threw in a big of mintzberg to Harry i think was the strategic apex.
Q1(c)
lenses was okayish, clearly he was strategy by design, expierence a little bit when he had to back down from his assumption on healthcare when the doctors challenged him. Also no ideas imo.
2(a)
5 forces
b
I was dumbfound but i focused in on scenarios. Then i looked at the text and realised in my mind that is. So the country was in a recession but what about if the economy turned around scenario 1 and then i looked at the fact supermarket had not yet looked at price and when i say yet i used that as scenario 2 what if they did. Also just threw in the brand awarness with questionairre. Basically I thought he was asking you to think outside the box and would the investment be worthwhile if certain market conditions changed....after all it is 5 forces. Rivalry and bargaining power of customers.
3A
Harman, kept legal in house and outsourced payroll since they were crap at it. However any answer will do once backed up from the text
3b
CRM was tricky here as normal industry rules dont apply. Threw in a little market segemnation to acquire and also regarding retain emails on offers etc. That was tricky as general things simply would not apply so hard to get much on both.
Hopefully it went well anyways.....time was good for me but the case study was vast and if you panicked there you lose a lot of time. I always leave case study to last so my brain is working from the 2 smaller questions.
Best of luck folks
<cite>@flippy said:</cite> for question 1...i did not use cultural web for my answer..but i manage to write something based on what i know..i will still be correct right?as long as my answers are sensible and logical and fit to what the question ask.dont worry as long as you've adressed the issues you'll be fine . And what did you do about the configuration of culture in the same part?
Q1 had such technical information, quite lenghty and boring scenario... wayvard paragraphing led difficult to pick the points out... although the requirments were clear... spent alot of time picking up the points... performed quite ordinary in Q1 as i picked Qs 2 and 3 to start the paper with, hadnt had enough time to write much in 50 mins....
Q2 was five forces, found this was the easiest part of the paper and applied SFA Model and MCR in part (b) to evaluate the market attractivness...
Q3 was not difficult i got the legal expert to be outsourced as there wasnt such strategic importance seemed... I retained IT department in house as their importance was high with some improvments on.... payroll modification should be outsourced as the IT department would engage in the web site development... part (b) was CRM and made general points to aquire and retain the customers....
Overall it was not easy, really had plenty to write
Was A Disaster.
Q1 Was Very Weird.
Got my mind into a lock.
Freaked out.
q2a was fine
b Didnt Know much Scenario planning could take any form anyways argued that what would happen if potential barriers were put up resulting the company to exit the market after entering Not allowing success
q3a inhouse legal stuff, use automation for payroll and erp for website Erp to be devollped internally cause internal staff appear to be capable.
3b.Crm just wrote random ways of attaining and retainning customers :/
q1 was a major turn off.
if it would have been swot or strategic position pass would be guranteed.
*Sigh*
Yikes reading this only makes me realise how bad I f**ked up the first question!! Oh well atleast 5 forces and Harmon and Lenses were (hopefully) easy marks so hope I wrote enough bs on the rest of it to get by! Is it just me or was anyone else relating Q1 to AVB's spell at Chelsea? (The doctors being Frank Lampard and JT)
My feeling is that the exam was not much about business analysis :(
Too many general questions.
The way the questions were asked got me writing too much about theory, perhaps not enough application to the scenarios.
Q1: a i) Project Mangement Process issue
ii) Importantant to understand organization culture and configurations
b) Strategy as plan, idea and experiens
Q2: a) Porter 5 forces – oversea market
b) Analysis of managers views
Q3: a) Harmon Matrix
b) How CRM help to acquire and maintain customers
This was the first time I have sat P3 and I didn't think the paper was horrible. The examiner even told you what model to use for some of the questions, something I wasn't expecting. I stupidly got myself a little clouded by the doctor power structure which ended up dominating most of my Qu1 answer and I also struggled to get started (I just wanted to sound semi intelligent!). Pity, I had high hopes of passing this one first time and giving myself a bit of a much needed confidence boost.
The proof of the pudding will come in August.
Good luck everyone!!! :o)
Hi guys,
I have one question. I forgot to write conclusion in 2a question. I believe that I got the 5 forces alright and I am not sure how much points can examiner deduct for not reaching any conclusion? I listed some previous exam sessions and saw that the examiner did not reach conclusion in his answers.
If examiner does`t take more than 5 points for not reaching an conclusion, maybe I have some chance :)
Best regards and good luck everyone

