Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** P3 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about December 2011 P3 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P3 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Cchukii14y ago#61
Hi guys, what was question 2 part a and b? what was the correct models or frameworks on both parts of the question?
Former userFormer user14y ago#62
@kabambi

2a) cultural web
b) Harmon strategic/process matrix
Cchukii14y ago#63
2a,i talked about the types of organisational culture(power culture,task culture,person culture and role culture)
2b, Used SAF. was out of time so got kind of confused.
Wil i be panalised for using these frameworks?
Vvictoriaaa14y ago#64
i used PEST and porter's diamond and financial evaluation(internal) for question 1a... it would be so much easier to answer using SWOT, but it didn't cross my mind.....
Former userFormer user14y ago#65
@kabambi said:
2a,i talked about the types of organisational culture(power culture,task culture,person culture and role culture)
2b, Used SAF. was out of time so got kind of confused.
Wil i be panalised for using these frameworks?

I did the same for 2a. I didn't see too much information necessary to apply cultural web (what were the symbols, the stories or rituals)? The case indicated a lot of facts which looked like consequence of power culture and functional (role culture) with little project management.
For 2 b I used the Harmon's process importance/complexity matrix

I didn't have time to write anything at 1b.. I pray for a 50..
For 2b
Hhalbesri14y ago#66
salam to all!
description of the questions is very well put by our friend tuanmuda.
As for me there is a lot to write while there is absolutely a time pressure.I wonder if there is any one who covered most of the points to be written withen the available short time.So except for the time pressure the exam could be considered not very hard.15 minute time is to short to read,annotate,plan etc I for one could not even get the time to read the whole question no 3.but tried to give a reasonable try for b. Any ways wish u all and myself the best.The magic 50!
Former userFormer user14y ago#67
First time i've felt time pressured in exam - just kept writing and writing and could not structure. How do they expect us to read , structure and write in that time - this does not make sense, the time only allows for reading and writing - but the scenarios are too long and for slow readers like myself, it's difficult!
Fingers crossed I pass - this was my first attempt and left work 2 years ago to try and pass all these exams so there is a lot at stake!
May the forces be with everyone!
Former userFormer user14y ago#68
"I think the paper examines the application of frameworks. SWOT is not a framework you’re just naming the words in the scenario. Again we are examined in application of models. "

This cannot be further from the truth, we are examined on our skills in analysising a business or situation. The models are purely a tool to aid this analysis, unless the specifically ask for a model to be used. Do you think the examiner will not give marks if someone used no model for the franchise question, yet used common sense and acumen to evaluate the scenario?
Former userFormer user14y ago#69
This examiner is really mean. You need to understand a scenario of 3 pages, and understand his questions (a read-between-the-lines style). This is not knowledge that is expected of us students, but a thorough analysis of the examiner, and his approaches. Plus remembering all the models is simply a stupid way to assess the students. I had the impression that ACCA was more professional in this stance - it should be more about knowledge and understanding, less about learning stuff by heart and writing VERY VERY fast!
ALACCA LOVER!!!14y ago#70
@shaunboro said:
"I think the paper examines the application of frameworks. SWOT is not a framework you’re just naming the words in the scenario. Again we are examined in application of models. "

This cannot be further from the truth, we are examined on our skills in analysising a business or situation. The models are purely a tool to aid this analysis, unless the specifically ask for a model to be used. Do you think the examiner will not give marks if someone used no model for the franchise question, yet used common sense and acumen to evaluate the scenario?


I think this is a very good comment- models are there to guide you to certain issues but as long as you cover these issues with a model format or without it you are fine. Its about analysising the scenario not remembering words.
ALACCA LOVER!!!14y ago#71
Although when i get results might think differently!! I have never run out of time before in a exam but did this time and felt really pressured and really struggled to format things well. Here hoping what you write you get rewarded for not if your structure is good!
Former userFormer user14y ago#72
I used SWOT analysis as a frame to my answer for the first question and used elements of PESTEL for opportunities and threats and financial analysis for strenghts and weaknesses. Didn't mention five forces or diamond model in part b but concentrated on benefits and disadvantages of aqusition and subsequent franchise.
Question 3 was asking about the details of the project last phase. I think that little knowledge and common sense shoudl be sufficient.
To be frank we could spend another two hours to properly analyse the questions and implement every suitable model. Hopefully, I will pass.
Former userFormer user14y ago#73
how severe will I be penalised if I just use SWOT to analyse 1a) ?

regardless of whether it is the correct model to be used or not

the examiner asked for frameworkS or modelS
Former userFormer user14y ago#74
@tzxsean said:
how severe will I be penalised if I just use SWOT to analyse 1a) ?

regardless of whether it is the correct model to be used or not

the examiner asked for frameworkS or modelS


You will be fine mate, the plural is just acknowledging the fact that a few models could be used. Its the meat of what your answer which will get you that marks, not SWOT or PESTEL etc headings. I used SWOT, but to do that I had to suggest factors which are covered in PESTEL. As long as you analysed, the tool you use is irrelevant. I often think the tool is there mostly for people without decent analytical skills (me included), as the headings are simply gateways to getting your idea down.

I am hoping for a pass, answered all questions sensibly enough but perhaps lacking in detail. I studied hard, so I know that I will not be letting myself down in that regard and if I need a resit its not through lack of effort.
Rrafay_ali14y ago#75
@tzxsean said:
how severe will I be penalised if I just use SWOT to analyse 1a) ?



PLEASE!! like the comment above tells, try to understand that what the examiner means is for you to "APPLY" your knowledge . It totally based on your choice as long as its valid and relevant!
I cant believe you passed all these papers and at p3 ur thinking PENALIZE. Geez! theres NO negative marking AT ALL in the whole of ACCA at any paper / examination level!! WOW you must have had quite a hard time expecting passes then :) haha .

regardless of whether it is the correct model to be used or not

the examiner asked for frameworkS or modelS
Rrafay_ali14y ago#76
Shaunboro said
I am hoping for a pass, answered all questions sensibly enough but perhaps lacking in detail. I studied hard, so I know that I will not be letting myself down in that regard and if I need a resit its not through lack of effort.


You sir, just did a synopsis of my feelings after the paper.
Former userFormer user14y ago#77
OMG!! who are these ppl examiner hates SWOT say no to SWOT..it is a framework which was enough alone to answer 1a although it was expected from the candidates to use a combination of a few models giving equal weight to both internal(SW) and external environment(OT)
Anyways guys what the hell was 1b all about although any sane person will go with SAF and so i was no exception i couldn't really understood what exactly was required.did it asked about the proposed strategy to be used to acquire SOFR which was a forward integration for GEt and then to use it for franchising after the acquisition?
Former userFormer user14y ago#78
the penalty means what is the maximum mark I can get out of 20 ....

isn't it works like penalty since din't follow to instructions?

of course there is no negative marking
Former userFormer user14y ago#79
The Exam Quesiton is too long but Easy and Straightforward, not let the student have sufficient time to answer in short period , i think it is difficult than Diet June 2011 and Dec 2010.

Only 25 Min to answer Q3. I hope i could pass , I study hard and already prepare over 3 Months. I already fail in diet June 2010 , dont want fail again. it is my last paper! the chance to pass i think 50% vs 50%


Overall , This Exam Question is too long , little discrimination to those who both read and write slowly , the force should be emphasied on student 's analysis competence, rather than Exam Machine
Former userFormer user14y ago#80
Also , i miss franchise portion , due to time is too rush, i just answer the franchisee could spread portion of risk , but the management no oversea franchise experience, and system need to modified to intergrate the relationship Franchor and Franchiee and control , and franchiee could bear some significant investment outlay when get with high gearing ratio
Former userFormer user14y ago#81
i agree it is a 5 hour paper which u have to do in 3 hours i mean what the hell if a person knows it all and is competent then why the hell he has to fail just because of time pressures
Former userFormer user14y ago#82
3 hours is a very very irrelevant with this kinds of questions! the case was very long... agreed with syed faizan.. it should have been a 5 hour paper... i felt like only a few minutes spent in the exam hall.... hopefully we all can pass... insya Allah..
Mmahadi14y ago#83
LOl, it's Okay, but time pressure is a big problem, I left 12 marks without answer, however for Q1 A I used "M" Model to analyse the Internal & Porter 5 Forces For External, the others are same of majority's base