Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBL*** P3 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about December 2011 P3 exam.
What came up? How did you do? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P3 December 2011 Exam was: Post your comments and vote in Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#31
i 4got to evaluate the franchise strategy after acquisition. Damn... probably gonna fail this time
Former userFormer user14y ago#32
People, I'm as well a slow reader.. didn't have any time to plan, just wrote whatever came to my mind and still did not manage to cover all topics.. 20 marks down just because of that!! should I say it's unfair? or I would be subjective?
Aandreas6114y ago#33
in question 1 i used strengths and weaknesses internally and pestel for the external part. Was this ok or it needed something else????
Former userFormer user14y ago#34
and I only use SWOT to analyse entire q1a
Former userFormer user14y ago#35
I found it very very time pressured. I used pestle for external and just SW for internal. Answered questions 1,2 and 4.
Former userFormer user14y ago#36
has anyone used porter diamond + 5 forces in 1?
Former userFormer user14y ago#37
has anyone used porter diamond + 5 forces in 1?
Former userFormer user14y ago#38
any suggested answer for business process part n culture?
Kkzzrd14y ago#39
Gosh i screwed big time by spending too much time on Q1a with SWOT Analysis and couldnt do much on b and c. For Q2 - Culture Web and Harmon Process/Strategy Matrix was ok but then i was left with 15 minutes to do Q3 which i scrambled like mad to write whatever that came to my mind but could attempt c at all!

Looks like i'm going to pray hard for a miracle!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#40
sorry I used porter diamond and 7p (marketing mix) in 1 (a) haha I laugh at myself :)
Sstasi14y ago#41
Guys:

Porter and PESTEL are both used to evaluate the external environment.

I used 9 M's Model to evaluate the internal but nobody else seems to have used this. Everyone else used SWOT. Oh well....Hoping for reasonable pass. :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#42
Porter 5 forces is external evaluation as PESTLE is so they shouldn't be used in conjunction especially when the question asked for internal and external.

I used porter diamond for external and marketing mix to evaluate internal environmental factors, I hope that it's ok at least to some extent

good luck ;)
Sskyxxx14y ago#43
PESTEL for macro environment, P5F for industry environment for GET. Did a table of the financial info and a few comments, then a bit of SWOT for the others bits such as the IT system and brand, although I didn't use SWOT as headings.

I don't honestly remember the franchise part in 1(b)? It asked about the strategy so I used a bit of PESTEL to compare the two countries, talked about the adv and disadv of acquisitions (brief) and mentioned the possibilities of strategic alliance to reduce the risks. Summarised with SFA criteria.

CSF and KPI seemed straightforward.

I did (2) a (3) afterward.

I agree that the main problem with P3 is time management, I actually finished 10 mins early so I think I may have been too brief in places.

Just hope the marker can read my writing - nowhere else do I have to write for three hours using a biro!

Good luck to everyone! x
Ssidrashahab14y ago#44
Q1/pestel for opportunities and threats, swot for strength and weaknesses, many strength and weaknesses comes from financial data.
SAF for acquisition and J s &W three acquisition test
core copetences , KPI.
Q3/ Q4/ all the article stuff from KEN GARETT.

anyways...........P3 diet was GIFT for P5 sufferers.....ALHAMDULILLAH
Former userFormer user14y ago#45
There were too many things to write...
Q1 a - used PESTEL and SWOT
Q1 b - Porter's Diamond, SFA
Q2 - cultural web
for b - Process Matrix
Had about 15 min for Q3
Former userFormer user14y ago#46
Did pestel, Porter diamond and swot for the 1st part.
Part B did some analytics and moved fiurther
Part c discussed issues related to KPI and CSF's,
Then did q4 part (a) on pricing where i discussed customer demand,pricing objective,understand revenue cost and demand relationship,pricing methods,competitors pricing and pricing strategies.
Come on q3 project and went blank. Waffled part a and joted points fro par B and c.

Really scared.... Need a magical 5o...God pleaseee help me out
Former userFormer user14y ago#47
Too many things to write yes but time management was mostly examined.
Q1: pestel, 5 forces, diamond, sfa, and waffle for csf's keeping in mind the franchise
Q3: project mgt very easy and c part was mostly brainstorming with a lot of IT involved
Q2: Harmon's rest can't remember

Hope I pass thank God
Former userFormer user14y ago#48
I know from an article the examiner hates doing a swot when not specifically asked. I avoided that!!!
Rrafay_ali14y ago#49
kiileo said 1 minute ago:

I know from an article the examiner hates doing a swot when not specifically asked. I avoided that!!!


I think thats wrong/quote the article. Examiner doesnt HATE SWOT because Its part of the study guide. Infact SWOT seems to be the most effective model here in q1 (16 / 4 - 4each) as for all those who used PORTER PESTEL DIAMOND blah blah I think u guys just wasted a lot of time . I used SW and OT for internal and external and think managed well. I had trouble in 1b , but rest was good and hoping a pass.
Former userFormer user14y ago#50
So factors effecting the price, last question.. What did you all write..??
Former userFormer user14y ago#51
paper was very easy but bit lengthy ...did well hope to get v gud marks
Former userFormer user14y ago#52
Hi, can somebody please remind me of the exact question 1 (b) requirement ? I wrote a report on the 3 parts of strategic choice - basis of com, strategic direction & methodology. I did not use SAF unfortunately, did anybody else take my approach??
Former userFormer user14y ago#53
rafay ali

I think thats wrong/quote the article. Examiner doesnt HATE SWOT because Its part of the study guide. Infact SWOT seems to be the most effective model here in q1 (16 / 4 - 4each) as for all those who used PORTER PESTEL DIAMOND blah blah I think u guys just wasted a lot of time . I used SW and OT for internal and external and think managed well. I had trouble in 1b , but rest was good and hoping a pass.

I think the paper examines the application of frameworks. SWOT is not a framework you're just naming the words in the scenario. Again we are examined in application of models.
Rrafay_ali14y ago#54
@kiileo said:
rafay ali

I think thats wrong/quote the article. Examiner doesnt HATE SWOT because Its part of the study guide. Infact SWOT seems to be the most effective model here in q1 (16 / 4 - 4each) as for all those who used PORTER PESTEL DIAMOND blah blah I think u guys just wasted a lot of time . I used SW and OT for internal and external and think managed well. I had trouble in 1b , but rest was good and hoping a pass.

I think the paper examines the application of frameworks. SWOT is not a framework you're just naming the words in the scenario. Again we are examined in application of models.


what gives you the idea that swot is not a framework/model? the "WORDS" are infact an applicable tool for assessing env, as per the study guide. So is "SAF" AND and "TARA" (risk approach) etc. Anyhow I dont think we have to justify/agree on something amongst ourselves rather than convey it to the examiner. I just said using the models mentioned aren't a charismatic element in answers since it eats up alot of time and definitely ppl mostly mess up the application of such models (NAMING them isn't anything- unlike most candidates assume)
I just used a strategy to get that part done as quick as I could, as its given in marking scheme "1 valid point = 1 mark" thats all I need.
Hope all who deserve pass :)
Rrafay_ali14y ago#55
@macg said:
Hi, can somebody please remind me of the exact question 1 (b) requirement ? I wrote a report on the 3 parts of strategic choice - basis of com, strategic direction & methodology. I did not use SAF unfortunately, did anybody else take my approach??


It had two parts 1- acq 2- franchise. AND YES I DIDNT USE SAF either :( I couldnt even think of it . Just made a dumb report assessing about 6 points for acq, skipped franchise and concluded (ran out of time ) :( so yea this was my worst part of the paper rest was fine so hoping it wont become a curse for me ..
Former userFormer user14y ago#56
@saadain said:
So factors effecting the price, last question.. What did you all write..??

I wrote according to article written by Ken Garrett (Business Strategy and Pricing Feb 2011 article) Influence on price : mission objective,pricing objective, cost,competition, customer and control.
dont know im correct or not
Former userFormer user14y ago#57
I was under the impression that the acquisition and franchise Proposal was one strategy? Are people suggesting that each should be dealt with separately? Was the question not to assess gets strategy,which was to acquire and then franchise.
Former userFormer user14y ago#58
@bingonolan said:
I was under the impression that the acquisition and franchise Proposal was one strategy? Are people suggesting that each should be dealt with separately? Was the question not to assess gets strategy,which was to acquire and then franchise.


Yeah, that's what I thought as well. Those two were interdependent. Raziakstan or whatever the country's name was...would have given them the bid if they acquired the SOF....

Also, one question...did no one use the balance score card for internal analysis? Would I have been wrong to look at it from that angle? I mentioned the financial aspect with the workings and analysis, the customer perspective (talked about how they were happy with the advertisements and efficient and timely service etc), and the learning and innovation that GET brought about with its computerized systems...Please someone, tell me that is right!
Former userFormer user14y ago#59
in my opinion., SWOT is the best model to use to assess strategic position of the company. It evaluates internal strength and weakness and external opportunities and threats.
Sstasi14y ago#60
A SWOT analysis is regarded as a summary of all the models. The other models/ frameworks detail the specific areas in which the strength/ weakeness etc is found. Someone uploaded study notes in the documents section of forum some time ago and in it u will see that the models like P5F, PESTLE etc. are branches of SWOT. There's no problem in using SWOT just that your answer may not be as detailed as someone else who used PESTLE who would have individually considered and identified the effects of legislation, government, etc.

I think since the question said using models or frameworks then the requirement would be to use more than 1 model or framework.

Just my thoughts :)