SBR*** P2 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
the unwinding of the discount was for contingent consideration that had been discounted. The PV of the payable was 10million and you needed to unwind this one year so the payable was 11 million but they eventually only paid 7million so 4 million reduction in payables was non-cash.
The pension adjustment you were suppose to rework it and take into account the pension benefit paid out but i completely missed this.
The main business is not buying and selling players, the main business is putting on sporting events and earning revenue from crowds/competitions. To do this you buy assets, the asset is not the player but the contract for them to play for you and therefore intangible. I think i lost marks because i didn't explain why it was an intangible i just said that it was one and told them how to account for it.
edit: I suppose you could argue that some players are inventory because you buy them young, train them up and then sell them on for a profit but as long as you can apply a standard to this and justify the answer i see no reason why you wouldn't get some credit for it.
PART 3c was related to related parties. the two directors were in common and there was an issue of receiving funds. however i said it was not related party issue because having directors in common doesn't constitute that. however i recommended disclosures of that transaction
goodwill of disposal required calculation in cash flow statement. i calculated that and deducted it from opening goodwill to determine the current years impairment
as far as i can remember, i had large number of items under operating activities. then investing activities and then finally i had only 2 items under financing. one i was remember was the loan paid
34 voters mentioned that P2 was easy - can you please share with us how you study ?
Twisted figures, twisted wording, obscure reasoning questions and work to do for 4-5 hours instead of 3. Somebody might have great fun by humiliating students like this.
But for the other parties in the "game", there is nothing fun to waste 120 frustrating hours over 3 months, by night and during weekends, to learn for such a disaster and to fail the exam in such a manner.
Not to much lesson to take from this, only a tough attack to students’ psychological health and self esteem. Poor those who must accept such a situation, for getting a license to work to earning their livings….
looking to Allah's Mercy :) *fingers crossed*
Maybe you are right. I don't remember its main business now. Question 3 was selected only because of time constraint and it looked like about revenue and borrowing costs. Question 2 was almost 2 pages long.
As I know pension plan payment outs have no influence on CF. Only contributions paid to the plan are accounted as explained by Dec 2013 exam paper notes.
How the proceeds from the subsidiary disposal are correctly calculated? (1) Initial consideration - disposal loss or (2) NA dod + goodwill - NCI dod - disposal loss?
As the goodwill impairement of the disposed subsidiary was not included in the consolidated P&L no adjustment was required in the operating part of CF, except the goodwill of the disposed subsidary without impairement (c/f -b/f - disposed goodwill)?
According to new suggested IFRS explanations a 5 year lease for building (useful life 30 or 35 years) isn't booked as the asset by the lessee?
@smichail said: Twisted figures, twisted wording, obscure reasoning questions and work to do for 4-5 hours instead of 3. Somebody might have great fun by humiliating students like this. But for the other parties in the "game", there is nothing fun to waste 120 frustrating hours over 3 months, by night and during weekends, to learn for such a disaster and to fail the exam in such a manner. Not to much lesson to take from this, only a tough attack to students’ psychological health and self esteem. Poor those who must accept such a situation, for getting a license to work to earning their livings….I completely agree. I'm a Big Four senior getting no help with my exams (they're not even paying for my fees or giving me time off to study). These exams are an unforgivable cruelty. They don't test your knowledge as much as they test your ability to take a test through extraordinary handwritten time-pressured situations. It's as far from actual work as it gets. I've always wanted to, upon finishing the ACCA, pen an angry letter to the Examiner, but I've worried there might be repercussions.
@tashkent said: Maybe you are right. I don't remember its main business now. Question 3 was selected only because of time constraint and it looked like about revenue and borrowing costs. Question 2 was almost 2 pages long. As I know pension plan payment outs have no influence on CF. Only contributions paid to the plan are accounted as explained by Dec 2013 exam paper notes. How the proceeds from the subsidiary disposal are correctly calculated? (1) Initial consideration - disposal loss or (2) NA dod + goodwill - NCI dod - disposal loss? As the goodwill impairement of the disposed subsidiary was not included in the consolidated P&L no adjustment was required in the operating part of CF, except the goodwill of the disposed subsidary without impairement (c/f -b/f - disposed goodwill)? According to new suggested IFRS explanations a 5 year lease for building (useful life 30 or 35 years) isn't booked as the asset by the lessee?agreed question 2 looked too long, i think it would have taken me too long to understand what the question was asking me. I had like 2 mins spare at the end of the exam so out of curiosity went to have a proper look at question 2 and still drew a blank. I can't remember what the pensions adjustment now but there's something niggling me and i feel like i've missed a step. I ignored the bit that said the plan paid out £xmillion as i assumed it was a red herring but i feel like i was meant to do something with this.
@anakh said: hi people, is that your first time for P2? I failed in December. Now I have very bad filling for this exam. Anyone in my situation? I have to say, I was good prepared.. not for 100% but to pass for sure :(Hi Anakh, I am in the same situation as you. I failed in Sept exam and this is my 2nd try. I spent lots of time on P2. That is why I feel so angry. By the way, I passed P7 in December which I spent 20% time of the time I spent on P2. Guess P2 examiner is intend to convert P2 to the most difficult paper of ACCA.
Lily, what's calms me a little bit, is that I am not alone ... :) disaster ! but I have a little hope, maybe we can pass this time , who knows :)
Ah really rubbish - 6th time or something - lost count!
Thought I was doing the Kaplan study kit question pretty okay. Thought I the knowledge okay maybe about 75%. But the paper always leaves me stumped..
Struggle to know what the question wants and it's hard to commit to writing about anything if you think the topic might be something else.Felt like I maybe should have explained the obvious a bit more.
Does anyone know what remember what all the question 2 sections were?
a) Reorganisation
b)??
c)??
Just read Farai's post
pretty much guessed reorganisation - and left the JO/JV question although I know how to account for both - couldn't work it into answer
@niknak said: Ah really rubbish - 6th time or something - lost count! Thought I was doing the Kaplan study kit question pretty okay. Thought I the knowledge okay maybe about 75%. But the paper always leaves me stumped.. Struggle to know what the question wants and it's hard to commit to writing about anything if you think the topic might be something else.Felt like I maybe should have explained the obvious a bit more. Does anyone know what remember what all the question 2 sections were? a) Reorganisation b)?? c)??b) Deferred tax asset on AHFS disposal. c) Joint venture accounting before and after purchase of entire vehicle
@b1989 said: Just incase anyone is interested, Q3b footballer contracts and disposals https://www.danielgeey.com/football-amortisation-chelseas-50m-luiz-profit/ Q3c, FFP and Related party transactions in relation to PSG and Man City https://www.danielgeey.com/financial-fair-play-and-psg/ Pretty interesting to be fair. Still a ruthless exam!Wow! Did you see those before or after the exam?
Long awaited cash flow...it wasn't really that bad.
December 2015?????? i really can't understand why the examiner had to be so cruel to us.
Cash flow caught me off guard, why oh why did they have to bring it..
The P2 paper of this sitting was set with an intension of failing us . it was to hard , I ended up forging answers from out of space
what a savage paper. Have been perfectly comfortable with ACCA papers until now. In 3 hours you have no time to think, and boy did I have to think!
Football players contracts?
Could it be because KPMG recently released a valuation of European football clubs with Barcelona and Manchester United being the most valued?
Exam was not so terrible....except for question 2. However i hoped for cashflow as well coz it is the easiest of all the consolidation but...somehow lost focus with this huge paragraphs. So unfortunately with having to read and reread those long paragraphs i was unable to do much in this section.....
ACCA are understandably making the questions harder given things change but making the questions LONGER for the same period of time is just cruel. Yes you take time to disect the question and plan yoyr answers....but by the this is done the time has ran out and no time for writing......... So the average person either freeze seeing the length of the question, read slow, write slow, or just falls straight into writing trying to beat the clock all of which is detrimental to a pass or a fail.
I attempted question 3 first coz i could have done 2 out of the 3 though with the pressure of time the professionsl points is out the window plus alot of the information disappears from your mind.
Question 2 I read twice and though i got the gist of the topics covered I am yet to understand the scenario. I tried question 4 coz i remembered something about leasing and ifrs 16 but completely blanked out when i came to write about the new proposal which means there was no way i could have done part B lol or continue with Part Ai.
All in all paper was passable but the horrendous paragraphs, amount of information to gather and grasp as well as put down on paper after gathering and completing ones thought....impact grately on ones ability during exam which is in no way a true reflection on ones ability.
Alot of people are exam experts but in real life thats a different kettle of fish...
This was my first attempt and I went in their with a mind set of just gaining the exam experience. Though I was still hoping to get the boderline 50 I am also wont be surprised that there will be a September sitting for me.
ACCA seems to be just concerned with making money........and the markers well.. .
Fingers crossed and best of luck to all.
Danielle I advise that you contact ACCA immediately on this issue.
Absolute Disaster! The wording of the exam is not clear, so frustrating! This will be the first time I will have failed an ACCA exam. I have completed the online exam feedback questionnaire which ACCA emailed to me and complained about it. It happened to my colleague last year doing top level CIMA and all the students complained as lots of peolpe failed.
All the papers were remarked and a number of people who had failed then passed.
Fingers crossed for us all!
Madpierro.. basically my thoughts exactly, practice papers went well at home but sitting in the exam read through scenarios 2 or 3 times, tried to answer then had to re-read..
Obviously at this level we aren't going to be given simple 1 line questions.. but these exams are too much the other way... you pretty much have to find the questions yourself.
Also as always the model answers don't really give us a do-able example of how to answer.
Anyone I know who passed this exam only ever got 50-52 even the passers struggle! Not that they care! ?
Could have so got 5 marks for the joint operation question but really thought there was some query I didn't understand in the question, whereas my friend just wrote what the knew of how to account for joint arrangements.
Would have got me 35 instead of the predicted 30 yay! ?
Q1: I just did whatever adjustments I could, I know I missed a load, I got the proforma done, I was out by 100 in end.
Part B: I explained indirect and direct method and waffled about the benefits integrated reporting would bring to users of FS.
Part C: I waffled about the directors window dressing the bank overdraft to avoid there loan covenants penalties, and mentioned there ethical Responsibilities.
Q2: part A: had no idea what they were asking, I said that if the parent opened another company then the parent would become a sub to the new parent, had no idea was making it up.
Part B: can't rem but don't think I wrote anything.
Part C: I talked about diff between joint arrangement and joint venture, and said it was a joint venture because there was a special purpose vehicle.
Q4: part A: waffled about IAS 17 risks and rewards and off balance sheet financing.
Part B: Mentioned IFRS 16, single lessee accounting model, control over risks and rewards.
Part C: type a and type b leases, not sure if I mixed them up or explained them very well but tried to explain them as best I could, had no real idea of the accounting treatments so just guessed them.
Overall I did a lot of waffling, I filled out the recent survey and complained about vague questions, tricky examiner language, and no real connect to past exam papers. If they are changing the direction of the course then fine but I don't see why we should be the guinea pigs.
I'm definitely repeating in Sept??
Anyone think that the CF will present itself again for the re sits???
Hard to know now, since so many people giving out about the cashflow maybe he will test another? you couldn't rule it out, going by order the SOCI is now due, very hard to predict it, now he has done cashflow maybe he reverts back to his favoured SOFP ?
The players contract are intangible assets. They generate income through the services offered by the players. The entity owns the rights to the players. Please study the Financials of Football clubs, you will understand better
ACCA has released the sample answers for June 2016 diet. Go check at https://www.accaglobal.com/uk/en/student/exam-support-resources/professional-exams-study-resources/p2/past-exam-papers/international-stream.html
yea - i put none of that .. slight optimism turns to utter despair! :(
The Answers are even more of a disaster!!!! September here I come... please bring a CF again in Q1 :)

