Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

SBR*** P2 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin10y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the P2 June 2016 Exam.

*** P2 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P2 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** P2 June 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results

Post your comments about P2 exam below

NNaomi10y ago#1
What a paper! All my hardwork and learning. Damn!!
AArron10y ago#2
Ahhh, the long awaited cashflow :-/
Former userFormer user10y ago#3
Question 1: Group cashflow was tricky and there was no much adjustment regarding financing activities. que 3 was a disaster....couldnt think through on 3b that has to do with football contract..3a was on ias 23 borrowing cost..still nt bad que for was lease..exposure draft Ifrs cldnt really explain the shortfalls of ias 17 & but d treatment of the 2 lease taken by Anan under the Exposure draft..seems both lease are to be treated the same way. ...looking unto Allah for the best
Kkayheige10y ago#4
Hmmmm!
Tthuviacc10y ago#5
The hardest P2 ever!...............................
RRoy10y ago#6
Ok here are my 2 cents question one on cash flow and there was a disposal. the goodwill on disposal was 9 after impairment and this was required to be deducted from the opening goodwill in order to calculate the current years impairment there were lots of other issues such as acquiring of associates and disposal impacts on working capital nci etc overall i did 17 workings for question 1 and my cash answer was -18. the correct answer was -23 because that was the total decrease in cash over the year question 1b was a very subject answer. i mentioned that cash flow gives the users more information regarding the actual figure because profit is a subjective and estimated figure and cash flow statements enable users to analyse how the entity is capable of managing its short term debts. i also mentioned how integrated reporting can enhance usefulness of information and more disclosure and transparency is kind of preferred by investors 1c was inter company balance. it was a clear ethical issue because the loan by the parent basically was used to hide the overdraft question 4 on leases. i was prepared for this. so wrote as much as i could for the first 16 marks. i think i messed up in calculations though because i just recognized both of them as finance leases at their present value which was given in the question question 3. i did borrowing costs. part b was horrible and in part c there was related party issue but actually there was no issue because director in common is not a related party issue if the director does not have control and significant influence good luck guys :)
MMark10y ago#7
A complete disaster, Q1 cashflows I'm guessing most of you, like me briefly overviewed this topic not expecting it to come out, yes there are marks to pick up here and there but hard to get a good mark if you guys get my drift, to easy to get things wrong or leave out things. Q2 Horrible restructuring - but had no choice as hadn't read the article relating to the revised ED Leases........ Nice one! Question from me "what happens when you own 100% of two subs and decide to sell one sub to the other sub with a loan interest free", we could make a sketch out of this question, I mean you'll still own 100% as an indirect holding but how do you treat all the transactions? Q3 Required knowledge of revenue recognition and cost recognition, and another random question, you receive 3M to let an airplane line advertise their name on your stadium, how does that affect revaluation? Should this not be simply "Other income" 1 M each year? Must be missing something. Very disappointed with my performance on this exam and the examiners questions, Re sit in September here for sure.
EEllenor10y ago#8
Cashflow screwed me over also, oh well fingers crossed that most people did something to get them over the line!
Hhassan10y ago#9
I dont know how do they set paper,they should have some common sence that student can answer or not.i think no use of doing hard work.its suggested for examiner please think about student first before doing any question. It was possible to answer taking lot of time to think but not during exam condition.the paper was too tricky and some people they didnt attemp even since they diditnt understood part b. If this is continuous for future,i think acca will lost their big market.
AAdam10y ago#10
Nice long cashflow question. Yuck.
A1aftaab 139010y ago#11
This paper was very hard!!! I never came across such questions in both kaplan and bpp kit!!! I wonder if they got a team over there to check the setting of the paper. Question 3 was a complete mess specially part b. Why would examiner test us so much on ias when in nowadays accountant seek help from ias plus.
KKanke10y ago#12
Wat da f... was question 3 all about. After part a borrowing cost i had no clue wat the rest were i just wrote wat ever came to my head hoping 1 or 2 of the numerous tinz i wrote would b right. Cashflow jst ok. Question 3 disaster. Question 4 great. Exam result no clue.
Ssanjacs10y ago#13
For someone like me who a month ago used to break up in a cold sweat at the thought of P2, this wasn't as bad as I thought it would be. As at last month, I had already planned to just attend June sitting, knowing I was no where near passing it, but I'm slightly hopeful. I was prepared for cashflows... I had ranked them 1. Cashflows 2. SOFP 3. PnL and to be honest, PnL would have been a disaster for me as I never got round to mastering it. Already planned not to do number 4, so didn't even look at it. 2 and 3 ... you just had to get past all the waffle... and make some sense out of the nonsense. Time pressure is crazy... all that answer plan stuff just goes out of the window! I attempted all questions and I just hope I have done enough to get 50 marks as this was my last paper.
MMike10y ago#14
Q1 was ok. I think we could pick up a lot of marks on simple staff, but there was also tricky parts -DTL, DBO, impairment. Q2 - dark side ))) restructuring, DTL. Q3 - mix, but not very comlex. IA, borrowing, RP - agree that non RP issue Q4 - ok, current standart bad, future good, capitalise both assets
LLorraine10y ago#15
Q1- cash flow I was ready for this and secretly hoped it could come out Did Q4 next as again I was ready for this but thing I picked up the wrong number for my asset part of the journal Really couldn't decide between Q2 or Q3 in the end I went with Q2 = disaster!! I read it over and over then panicked and I found it difficult to put pen to paper!! I wasn't even time pressured at this point!! Expecting no more than 5 marks on this questions so my pass relies on good answers to Q1 and Q4!!
RRyan10y ago#16
Hopefully second time lucky for me. Large parts of the exam were educated guesses. Personally, the SCF wasn’t too bad – there were maybe 10-15 marks available within the question itself. IMO you had to revise SCF and leases as they were tipped last time and didn’t show (but if you hadn’t have known – then it’s hard to predict). How Kaplan can tip something for almost certain in March (SCF), and then go with P+L in June after a no-show, is beyond me! And in my opinion, you cannot ignore the current issue questions. I hear people saying that they didn’t even bother to revise as its too much and they’d prefer to concentrate on just the standards … that’s just crazy as the EASY marks are in the current issues for sure!!! If you have to re-sit (like I did) – read the technical articles that haven’t been examined and just have knowledge of them. I’ve not looked at leases for 2 weeks and it was pretty easy to regurgitate. Here’s my breakdown: Q1) CSF with disposal of sub, tax, financial instrument and a Goodwill aspect. I’ve forgotten the rest. Working capital took a few minutes to work out with the disposal too. :-/ Q3) registration of football players (ias 16 – pretty sure that’s wrong) & registration fees / variable bonus (ias 37?) etc, naming rights (ias 38?) of a stadium and Borrowing Costs (ias 23) for the purchase of a stadium in respect of interest. However, the borrowing costs were not directly attributable to the stadium and had arisen due to other borrowing costs. It did also say that the entity would not have required additional borrowings if not for the construction? Q4) Leases IAS17, Leases IFRS 16 (right of use / > 12 months / non-material exempt such as printers), Application of IFRS 16 to the scenario. The other question looked really confusing. I’m guessing between 44-60 so fingers crossed. Oh and the UK Variant has about 2 sides of A4 that compares maybe a dozen features of differences between IFRS SMEs and the U.K. GAAP equivalent. It’s guaranteed 15 marks and you can literally revise it in a few hours. There’s only FOUR practice questions in the Kaplan revision book and 2 of them are 8 marks. If you’re struggling, I HUGELY advise doing the UK variant. It’s a guaranteed 15 marks that is probably easier than the ethics. Good luck everyone, here’s hoping as many of us pass as possible. It’s a truly disgusting exam!
DDanielle10y ago#17
I was gave the wrong exam variant in my sitting today by the invigilator and wasn't told until an hour and a half through through the exam when they realised they gave me the wrong one (so it was too late to change to the correct one). I should have been sitting p2 UK and instead sat the international version. It completely threw me off and now dont have much hope in passing anyway. Tip: double check your paper!
MZMaisam Zaidi10y ago#18
@lynnecart said: I'm with you on the cash flow - did loads of consol SoFPs, one cash flow weeks ago. Just - you'll get marks for the bits you did do. On Q3, I went with something along the lines of: - this is IAS16, PPE - you are allowed to revalue - carrying value can't be greater than recoverable amount - rec amount is higher of FV less costs to sell and value in use - what's value in use? - well I guess there must be a floor on that of $100m if someone's willing to give you that much to put a couple of stickers on it - get a market valuation and do a DCF of future net inflows attributable to the stadiums - if the results of both of those are lower than $100m, then you can probably revalue it to $100m? I've no idea if this is a load of baloney or not. I guess if they did go on to do the deal with the airline, then they'd debit cash $100m, credit the asset valuation $100m because you'd then be unable to let anyone else put their sticker on it for however long... The other bit wasn't nice either - the footballer contracts. I went with application of IAS 38. I thought it might be something to do with financial instruments but I've never understood how the theory of that stuff relates to reality so chose to ignore it. I chose to scrub Leases en masse from my prep - too time consuming - so def hadn't read the ED and was pleased in a way that it was a big question I could rule out straight away, rather than a little bit of one. Good luck everyone.
IAS 38 is not Financial Instruments. IAS 38 is Intangible Assets - IFRS 9 is Financial Instruments.
Dderek6666c10y ago#19
Stink paper but come to expect it from the ACCA. Was Q4 b) about type A and type B leases under IFRS 16?
Sshamela1210y ago#20
If you studied you would have passed. This exam was not a difficult one. If i fail i would be very upset as i knew what to do but its the difficulty in relating it on paper. I did question 2 and 4 for the option sections. However, question two gave a bit of a struggle like Ratim just could not make up his mind as to what he really wanted to do with his accounting life.
JJael10y ago#21
For question 1,I not sure whether want to ignore profit before tax,loss on disposal and the income tax for discontinued group or not.. Overall,time pressure..only able to finish 75%..hope can get at least 50marks with a pass..(pray)
Hhammad10y ago#22
Paper was horrible, even examinar also don't know what he has made for us.... He want us to got qualified or become examinar...
LLily10y ago#23
Can‘t agree more, I did the past paper for cash flow statement scored 30+, but this one, maybe 10+. There must be something going wrong with the examiner. It is the first time I want to quit ACCA eventhough I only have two couses left.
MikeLittleMikeLittleTutor10y ago#24
Danielle, if by chance you read this, take my advice and write to ACCA immediately to tell them what has happened. Do not leave it until after the results are announced - do it now
DDanielle10y ago#25
Thanks Mike. I have now spoke to ACCA and they have told me to submit a mitigating circumstances form. I have done this now not sure though what the outcome will be. Thanks .Danielle
Former userFormer user10y ago#26
I have to agree with to the above comments too. Question 1 (a) and Question 3 (b) and (c) were disaster. Thank God, I managed to practice 1 CFS question from the last exam papers. However, only 1 question from the past exam papers from 2010 till now is available. In general circumstances, most of us can CSF correctly, but this particular question was very ambiguous. The aim of ACCA should be to prepare qualified accountants / consultants who can deal with most challenging and common circumstances, but it is impossible to know and remember everything. All consultants and accountants re-read standards and other explanatory papers. I don't think that more than 3% of ACCA students prepare CFS manually or work for football companies. I really don't understand the benefits of such vague questions. It seems that the examiner had a bad mood and he/she is keenly interested in the upcoming Europe football championship.
Former userFormer user10y ago#27
hi people, is that your first time for P2? I failed in December. Now I have very bad filling for this exam. Anyone in my situation? I have to say, I was good prepared.. not for 100% but to pass for sure :(
DDom10y ago#28
1) I was happy with any consolidation so the cashflow didn't bother me. There were a few complicated adjustments but I think there was enough there to get 20+ considering all the practice ones i did were 27+. I completely missed the pension adjustment but i managed to spot that profit before tax needed adjusting and also there was an unwinding of the payable discount. The disposal got me because i couldn't see the consideration or the NCI so i knew you had to work it out but couldn't figure out how, in the end i did a best guess and hopefully will pick up some method marks. 2) Looked at this and didn't even understand what i was being asked so skipped 3) a) Borrowing costs - fairly straight forward, capitalise using weighted average as it is general borrowings. Stop capitalising if construction stops. Then for the cal just work out the interest each month and total it up b) Player contracts was just Intangibles. Initially measure at cost plus all the fees, depreciate over the term of the contract. Fair value is hard to measure as each asset is unique. Contract extension was a change in accounting estimate (useful life) so capitlise any costs associated with this and depreciate over the new useful life. Selling is just recognising a gain/loss on carrying value. Injuries/removed from squad is impairment so i talked about impairment, again stated that FV may be difficult to reliably measure. c) Struggled with this one. I said that the naming rights were internall generated intangibles and therefore couldn't be recognised despite there being a valuation. I said that it could only be recognised if a sale took place. Mentioned that this was a related party. Not sure how much of it is right though 4) a) i) Explained the current treatment of leases and what makes it a finance lease. Criticised because operating leases meet the definition of an asset and liability and also it encourages manipulation as directors try and claim a finance lease is an operating lease aka off balance sheet financing a) ii) type a and type b leases. Type A is boradly a finance lease and Type B is broadly an operating lease. Recognise a right to buy asset and corresponding lease liabiltiy for both. Leases less than 12 months can still be expenses as per an operating lease. I also said that it addresses many of the criticisms of IAS 17. I didn't know much about the new system in too much detail so must have only picked up half marks. b) Struggled with the claissification of these as unsure on the new standard in great detail so just threw some calcualtions down for the lease liability using the amortised cos thing - only worth 7 marks so hopefully picked up a couple of method marks to bump my grade up. Fingers crossed i passed, I'm hoping that because this is generall viewed as a difficult paper that the marking may be a tad more generous.
Former userFormer user10y ago#29
I liked your answers, clever :) I wish I had answered like you
Former userFormer user10y ago#30
@dd92 said: 1) ... there was an unwinding of the payable discount... b) Player contracts was just Intangibles. ...
I don't remember that the question gave a discount rate for the pension plan. So I assumed that the net interest component was zero. But now it seems that in pension related questions finance costs must always be deducted from service costs. Why account for player contracts as intangibles, rather than inventories as the main business of the entity of question 2 were football teams (buy and sell players) and sports events?