Please vote in our Instant Polls and share your comments about the P2 Exam.
Please note, the ACCA have asked us not to allow posting comments before 5pm UK time.
However you can vote in our instant poll immediately (Reload this page and post comments after 5pm)

SBR*** P2 June 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
Q1 a Income Statement (35 marks)
What happy enough seeing this plenty of adjustment and gave you a chance to pick up some easy marks with the goodwill calculation. The adjustments for the Disposing of interest in entities I am sure will make or break this question in terms of marks for the most of people.
b
What on IFRS and fair value model, hard to get 9 marks out of that but argued about how they give you an option on ia 16,40 etc to use the cost model or FV model so it was unfair for them to say that. Also business combination is always done at FVNA so I guess that was fair enough.
c
Ethics, not a whole lot again for 6 marks. He was wrong to lie on the loan about the finance lease assuming that it was actually i Finance Lease(i made that assumption). Mentioned fidicuary duty to shareholder....good faith etc.
2.
a
Functional Currency of new company. I said it was Dinars because they invested all there money in Dinar bonds which is the primary economic enviroment of the entity.
b
Deferred Tax Charge, didn't FX this but just said the a deferred tax charge on OCI and provision on SOFP. They delibaretly mentioned Deferred tax charge as I initially thought it was a deductable as the carrying was lower than the tax base but just made it work. Also said why it wouldn't have resulted in one had they stuck with normal historcial cost. That was basically IAS 12
c
Goodwill calc wasn't huge issue for me
d
This wrecked my head and got me very worried. I discounted back to PV over the 2 years but ended higher than the original par amount of 50 million. Anyways I accounted for it and only copped the Interest part, especially as it said it was done at average rage so just took my PV of future c/f and multiplied it by 8%. Not sure I got it right but just praying to get 2 or 3
Q3
a
Talked about this company and various issue. recognize revenue, independence of the boards, construction costs, recognize the loan as they are the legal guarantor.
b
Didn't have a clue, but coped the brand bit and waffled about IAS 38 but i said the fees would have to expensed to pl as they were basically marketing fees and nothing to do with development of a brand.
c
IFRS 5 i think this was. Talked about all the rules....where it would be shown, profit goes to pl . How you remove the assets and liabilities and show them as Seperately on SOFP. That it was in 12 months also
d
Leased property wasn't it? mentioned something about Provision to return, contigent Liability for any costs. Capitalise the improvements and depreciate over the life and mentioned something about the roof and a assumption that it was part of the deal and hence brought it under ias 37 provision if it was already agreed he could charge them for it.
One thing was I was under massive pressure for time., i have to rush 2 and 3 and my writing was poor I think. Not enough time in that exam...but I got something down for everything thankfully.
Any views?, I spent ages on the PL and OCI and did it fully. I hope they take that into account the work I put into it!!!!
I thought 1b was asking about ifrs 13 fair value measurement?
Who attempted question4?
Section A was ok. Hopefully picked up some good marks.
I completely failed Section B - I did Q2, the Goodwill was ok and so was the functional currency. DT I had no idea and can't remember the other one was.
For some reason I answered Q4 and don't think I did well on that at all. I thought Q3 was very tough.
Oh well, onto P1 tomorrow.
not a good paper. specially adjustments :(
I ran out of time :(
Did q2&3
1a - IS and OCI
I think I got this wrong but I had N for 12 months, and O as a 6 month Sub, and 6 month 20% Associate?
1b - FV model?
1c Ethics and Leases
Adj:
Pension - financing costs (Expected return - unwinding cost), operating cost (service cost), Acturial loss to OCI?
Hedging loss I put through the OCI?
Was the PUP negative? That lost me!
2) Mixed Question
Deferred tax, Loan, ?, ?
3) Only had 20 mins left for this!! :0
4) Debt vs Equity?
Wasn't great for me :( will definitely be resitting in December!!
Q3 B.
About the 3 Year contract,
I wrote that the signing bonus of $20,000 should be expensed out in the PL this year, as the contract has already been signed.
And for $50,000 annual payments, as the company is locked in the contract to pay given that the tennis player plays the specified tournaments, the 50k this year is current year's liability/contingent liability (contingent to the player attending the tournaments). and the remaining 100,000 (50k x 2) total for the next 2 years should be discounted down to present values and shown as non current liabilities/contingent on the SFP.
And for the 20% of tournament prize winnings, I said that no liability is created until she has actually won.
what say ?
Hi guys, I hope you all did well on the exam. For me the exam was managable, but only and I mean ONLY due to question 4 - the question was a pure gift from Heaven. However, the changes and computations that needed to be applied in Q1 were mean - it is not physicaly feasible to do all of that in given time, and for only 30 marks?!
What did you answer under b - the directors concern regarding fair value that it does not reflect fin. value of entity? I wrote generally about IFRS 13 and then that fv is basically determined by income approach which takes into consideration future cash flows... and that if asset and liabilities are fair valued than net asset of entity is fair valued as the difference of the two... I hope to get some marks there...
In addition, how did you do with Q2 under c, regarding foreign loan? It was a bit confusing for me...
"I thought 1b was asking about ifrs 13 fair value measurement?"
Yes it was about IFRS 13 Fair value, but I took it up as a question about the FV models more so that than actual FV as I think that has been asked recently before. Directors felt the IFRS were pushing the Fair Value model rather and as a result giving misleading company valuations etc.
I not saying I am right by any means but given the way the question was phrased I went into a ramble about FV models in the standards rather than quote level 1 2 3 thing.
toooooo diffffficult i am fail
"Q3 B.
About the 3 Year contract,
I wrote that the signing bonus of $20,000 should be expensed out in the PL this year, as the contract has already been signed.
And for $50,000 annual payments, as the company is locked in the contract to pay given that the tennis player plays the specified tournaments, the 50k this year is current year’s liability/contingent liability (contingent to the player attending the tournaments). and the remaining 100,000 (50k x 2) total for the next 2 years should be discounted down to present values and shown as non current liabilities/contingent on the SFP.
And for the 20% of tournament prize winnings, I said that no liability is created until she has actually won.
what say ?"
Damn forgot this was based over 3 years rather than one year and expensed it all rather than show a liability for 2 of the 3 years. GRRRRRR
"1a – IS and OCI
I think I got this wrong but I had N for 12 months, and O as a 6 month Sub, and 6 month 20% Associate?"
Did it give enough information to calculate profits on the new Associate.....Was O a 6 month Sub as I am pretty sure reading it was originally calculated in 2012 possibly?. Now the disposal I am not certain did that mean it was a 6 month Associate.? from 60% down to 40%
Ekkk
Are fair values in the standards not determined by the rules underpinning IFRS13? I interpreted it as write about IFRS 13 and throw in a little commentary about if its any good or not.
"Are fair values in the standards not determined by the rules underpinning IFRS13? I interpreted it as write about IFRS 13 and throw in a little commentary about if its any good or not."
Yep they are....but for 9 Marks it couldn't all be regarding regurgetating IFRS 13. The fact you he mentioning value of company must be talking about possible the FVNA under IFRS 3 that you have to use when calculating goodwill.
I am sure there will be plenty of marks for all approaches.
I did 6 month sub and 6 month associate too. It mentioned that they now have significant influence which suggested an associate.
Q2 I decided that the functional currency was dollars as they make payments in dollars and the parent controlled all investments etc and their base was dollars. Not sure if that's horribly wrong
Rest is a bit of a blur, I missed out the 7marks on part 3a as that was my weakest question and ran out of time. I have never not finished a paper until now!
Yes, attempted Q4. First parts were ok, talked about what debt and equity were and the different ways of classing these (FVTPL, FVTOCI, amortised cost etc). The last part was more tricky trying to classify the B shares. May have lost a few marks there.
Q1. Was perfectly doable. The depreciation/revaluation part in the A section was tricky though.
Q2. Ok apart from the deferred tax part. Hopefully got some marks by defining it and working the basic carrying value and TWDV out.
Wow that was tough! Q3 was toughest by far. Question 4 I did instead of 2 and i interpreted as applying the term "liability" to the 2 different share types. One set of shares had a contractual obligation to give out cash and the other was just an equity swap. I don't know about you guys but I'm confused by Q4?? the last 2 sittings have been weird and not at all about current issues.
The one that threw me was Q1 part b. The directors were on about "financial value" vs Fair Value. I thought financial value is the amount the company is worth in the market?? either way if people start valuing their companies any way then it will be open to manipulation right??
P2 is getting tougher no doubt, I'm hopeful to scrape through and never see it again!
The exam was difficult, but it is P2, so it is expected to be difficult!
I didn't mess up so bad that I am sure I will fail, but I am not sure I will pass either :( Maybe I will!
Let's hope for the best, I solved everything!
Maha
I'm also sure that Q3 part 1 was to do with a joint venture/associate, but i'm noticing now they aren't putting IFRS references to make it easier! The tennis player must have been recognised as an intangible as they do meet the criteria, and all the expenses will be expensed??
Difficult paper
This exam is a total failure for me. I've lost too much time on Q1 a. Option the subsidiary was sold on 1st Oct. So I consolidated it its results for 6 months and the rest I accounted it as Share of profit from associates. Not sure about the pension anyway. The question was asking about the expense through OCI so I adjusted with only the actuarial loss. And then the effective hedge which was a lost, not sure about that either. Anyway I moved it to OCI
For the rest of attempted questions (2 and 3), I had not much time left to complete them. So I am pretty sure I will sit this exam again in dec.
I had 6mths consolidation and 6mths associate too. Spoke about IFRS 13 for Q1.b as it said fair values. For Q2.a I said functional currency was dinars... Not sure if thats right? All capital was invested in dinars. It said daily operating expenses were in dollars but low value..
I calculated a deffered tax liability and if you used historic rate, it worked out as a deferred tax asset.
Tennis player initially expense as contract signed already but then a contingent liability..
Hoping for the best, p2 will always be tricky
what a paper!
q1) Question one was an p & l consolidation..
Am not sure about the goodwill... it was 15 then reduced by 3 (impairment) to 12 then revalued to "2 above the original value"
what was supposed to be done in this? I reversed the impairment previously realised.. got end goodwill figure of 17
q1b) to do with fair value.. i described the whole ifrs about what it says and explained that IFRS do not actually advovate for the use of fair value and gave an example of ias 38 in which intangible are not to be valued under FV if there have no active market.. hope to get some marks out of 9
q1c) ethics.. why hiding of finance lease is wrong..
q2a) asked about functional currency.. now facts first:-
- subsidiary was not independant
- profits were held by th parent (parents functional currency was dollars)
- the little expense it has was paid in dollars
true its capital was in dinars.. but i chose dollars as its functional currency. Is this right?
q2b to d) had other issues to do with foreign goodwill and foreign loan etc.. hope i got some marks
q3) overall was a proper killer..
a) to do with a property developer.. had some houses which he sells th rights to own to the general public.. I discussed IAS 16 IAS 40 and IAS 2. concluded should be treated as IAS 2 inventory since this is what the co deals with... God knows if I am right..
there was a revenue recognition aspect as well..
I felt really time pressured in this paper
Hope what i did will help me get a 50! Hope WE ALL PASS!
Now p1 tomorrow.. best of luck everyone!!!
Hat off to P2 examiner ...how he set the paper ,really appreciated .....P2 examiner is too brilliant and prove it that p2 is not an easy paper as some peoples expected
.
I got Profit after tax was 92.8 .... anybody also got this??
Q1 Subsidiary 1
Calculated FV adjustment for land and used this for my calculation of net assets at reporting which I calculated by simply adding current years profit.
I used this information in reference to the 8% sale. I needed the net assets at disposal and goodwill. Therefore I had to calculate goodwill at this stage and apply 8% that the NCI would I erase by. Compare that to the consideration received.
I applied NCI% at year end * sub1 pat and put this figure in profit attributable to NCI
Sub2
60% sub becomes 20% associate 6/12months
Had to calculate goodwill and impairment and put this to COS and then calculated gain or loss on disposal. Most of the figures were given except goodwill ie Net assets at disposal, FV of NCI at disposal
Consolidate 6 month as a subsidiary. And PAT Associate *20% *6/12
Also share of NCI profit attributable: 40%*PAT * 6//12
Intercoy trading- reduce revenue and COS 12
PURP : (8/12)*2 but I can't remember if I added when I should have subtracted as the PURP was actually loss
Pension- current and past cost added to admin
Options- long but April 13 treated as 1/3 years and 4/7 directors
April 14 treated as 2/3 yrs and 3/7 there difference between equity of the two yrs treated as expense and added to admin.
Add cash flow hedge back to finance cost and show loss in OCI
Finally talked about FV definition and level and then talked about uses of FV in standards eg financial assets and impairment review
FC if correct then operating lease is form of off-balance sheet finance and explained why FD wants to show as operating ie reduces gearing etc then talked about ethics and fair view etc
As per what I understand (also read it in the lsbf kit) is that when it comes to Cons. Income Statement, the markers are very generous, even if your working is around halfway there, you get half of the allocated marks for that.
This is what Martin wrote about marking the working of the Impairment & reversal of PPE in Ashanti, which had a working worth 4 marks :
Close 4/4
Not Bad 3/4
Had a go 2/4
So if you have done all the workings and put your numbers in here and there, you can expect to score good in the first 35.
"As per what I understand (also read it in the lsbf kit) is that when it comes to Cons. Income Statement, the markers are very generous, even if your working is around halfway there, you get half of the allocated marks for that.
This is what Martin wrote about marking the working of the Impairment & reversal of PPE in Ashanti, which had a working worth 4 marks :
Close 4/4
Not Bad 3/4
Had a go 2/4
So if you have done all the workings and put your numbers in here and there, you can expect to score good in the first 35."
I hope you are right Martin....
In all honesty, the paper was soft compared to some of the horrific past questions I was attempting before the exam. I spent so much time dealing with complex questions I got to question 1 and forgot a lot of basic consolidation skills, so many points I made on my question paper but ran out of time to write in answer booklet.
Hopefully did enough
I did Q2 and Q3
Q2A) functional currency is....
But noted that the subsidiary is not autonomous and it's operation cost was dollars. The parent dictates investment decision and there concluded the subs functional currency is actually dollars... Anybody disagree???
B) goodwill calculated in dinar but had to convert p cost of investment into dinars. Calculate fx in goodwill and NCI and group exch diff and mentioned this can be recycled.
C) talk about DT = all TD except goodwill
TD: CV - Tax base
Convert the PPE at historical rate and then charge depn which differed to the capital allowance due to difference in uel for tax purpose. I got a taxable difference * tax rate
D) foreign loan- this was tough but translated the loan at historical rate less the payment of interest at average. Balance due in dinar converted at closing and the difference in USD put to FX gain in P&L
Q3) A) talk about investment property and inventory because housing is sold in normal course of business and then talk about impairment. Finally talk about revenue recognition
B) was abit quick in thinking intangibles was being tested so definition of intangible and recognition criteria. Said it did not meet recognition requirements and should expense. On second thought perhaps provision/contingent liability was being tested???
C) head office- what is a lease, indicator of FL accounting for FL and OP l . Concluded that the contract looks like a finance lease
D) talk about held for sale and calculated carrying value but could not Finnish in comparing to what the item was being sold for etc and wanted to see if there were events after reporting aspect but not enough time
What's your thoughts folks?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

