Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

General ACCA*** P1 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about June 2012 P1 exam.

?How did you do? What came up? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P1 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll *** poll results
Former userFormer user14y ago#31
Did anyone else use Turnbull report for the internal control environment using control environment and procedures for a robust sound system? Hope I didn't read it wrong... I am so pleased it's all over!
00500896714y ago#32
@dancingtech said:
Did anyone else use Turnbull report for the internal control environment using control environment and procedures for a robust sound system? Hope I didn't read it wrong... I am so pleased it's all over!


I did. It was in the student articles so worthwhile bringing in as it provides the reasons for establishing internal controls. Think you always get marks for bringing those articles into your answers
Pprateshramjohn14y ago#33
@helen425 good stuff, but shouldn't WB be keep informed? They don't have power but rather the ability to get key players involved.
Nnimbostar14y ago#34
This is my first disaster paper. I only had three weeks to cover the syllabus and revision(whilst also working fulltime) due to other commitments and my other half doing dissertations and Uni. Didnt even finish question 1 and had very little knowledge with the rest of the questions. I will be sitting this paper again in December.

Good luck to everyone.
Former userFormer user14y ago#35
@nimbostar said:
This is my first disaster paper. I only had three weeks to cover the syllabus and revision(whilst also working fulltime) due to other commitments and my other half doing dissertations and Uni. Didnt even finish question 1 and had very little knowledge with the rest of the questions. I will be sitting this paper again in December.

Good luck to everyone.


I think you're not Julius Caesar :)
Nnimbostar14y ago#36
@glebks said:
I think you're not Julius Caesar :)


Yep, I lesson learnt I have to say, I think I shouldn't have written on this sitting and should have waited for December but I just wanted to try to my luck.
Former userFormer user14y ago#37
Overall not bad..So far I think COSO will not be appropriate for Qs 1.c..advantages of internal control can be described here..Pealand matches with the present ethical values and norms of Hayho and thus ethically can be selected..can hope for 50...
Jjoevassallo14y ago#38
Q1 (c) asked the general purpose of Internal Control - so I agree it is not to do with COSO review. Rather should be per COSO objectives or the ASB objectives.
Turnbull refer to the "sound internal control systems".
Former userFormer user14y ago#39
English is not my mother tonque, so these discursive questions are difficult for me to pass. Time constrains don´t help me at all, so I prefer "calculations" to the definitions and longer answers.
Reading took a lot of time, I lost some time, when I hesitated between the Q2,Q3 and Q4. Then I decided for Q3 and Q4.
I will have to improve my English to succed this paper.
What I really hate are definitions like "the general purpose of internal controls". I usually omitts some of them, even if they are obvious.

Did anyone choose Q3?
Former userFormer user14y ago#40
I put WB in keep informed square according to present situation..is it ok or not?
Llsoltobaeva14y ago#41
I thought the paper was hard in general but after reading you, guys, I think it's me that stupid not to perform well on the exam, lol.
I wrote all my thoughts and managed to answer all points in the Q1, Q2, Q3 BUT I didn't apply any theory to my asnwers except those that were clearly asked in the requirments. Is it ok? I think no.
Re internal controls - I don't know if they were asking for COSO, I just wrote the objectives of internal control - I know that pretty well since I took F8 recently :)

WB - I placed this pressure group to H/H key players quadrant. I think using mass media and political relations this group had a signifficant power to influence Hayho. imho.

Overall I wanna forget this paper untill august :) when the results are ready.

Have a nice summer! YAY!
Former userFormer user14y ago#42
@lsoltobaeva said:
I thought the paper was hard in general but after reading you, guys, I think it's me that stupid not to perform well on the exam, lol.
I wrote all my thoughts and managed to answer all points in the Q1, Q2, Q3 BUT I didn't apply any theory to my asnwers except those that were clearly asked in the requirments. Is it ok? I think no.
Re internal controls - I don't know if they were asking for COSO, I just wrote the objectives of internal control - I know that pretty well since I took F8 recently :)

WB - I placed this pressure group to H/H key players quadrant. I think using mass media and political relations this group had a signifficant power to influence Hayho. imho.

Overall I wanna forget this paper untill august :) when the results are ready.

Have a nice summer! YAY!


trust me, uvazhaemaya, ) it was the easiest P1 exam for last 2-3 yrs! look to P4,P5 requirments and you'll understand what hard is it )
Former userFormer user14y ago#43
@carl29

I agree to a certain extent. I went for J also (I am a bit worried that nobody else has)
Firstly I thought Pealand was too obvious for a professional exam.
Secondly, the ETHICAL issue I thought was "bribery" (there were other risks that would need to be assessed but for the purposes of the AAA model I chose the "bribery" issue.)

The options were:
1.Pay the bribe go with Jayland
2.Don't pay the bribe go with Jayland
3.Don't pay the bribe go with Pealand.

Mostly aligned was "dont pay bribe go with jayland" - (developing country support, just because hayho is operating in a different country doesn't mean that they have to lose their integrity, (integrity was obviously one of the IC challenges later on in the question)

Consequences are that Mr .popo will increase regulations on their operations, not get his bribe, support local workforce, help developing community, satisfy shareholders maximise profit objective, increase in exposure to risk( that will need to be dealt with in next question).?

Anyone do this too? I ve defo failed if nobody has???
Ffaizan14y ago#44
@supermom said:
@carl29

I agree to a certain extent. I went for J also (I am a bit worried that nobody else has)
Firstly I thought Pealand was too obvious for a professional exam.
Secondly, the ETHICAL issue I thought was "bribery" (there were other risks that would need to be assessed but for the purposes of the AAA model I chose the "bribery" issue.)

The options were:
1.Pay the bribe go with Jayland
2.Don't pay the bribe go with Jayland
3.Don't pay the bribe go with Pealand.

Mostly aligned was "dont pay bribe go with jayland" - (developing country support, just because hayho is operating in a different country doesn't mean that they have to lose their integrity, (integrity was obviously one of the IC challenges later on in the question)

Consequences are that Mr .popo will increase regulations on their operations, not get his bribe, support local workforce, help developing community, satisfy shareholders maximise profit objective, increase in exposure to risk( that will need to be dealt with in next question).?

Anyone do this too? I ve defo failed if nobody has???


I did mention that in the course of action in AAA but in the end I choose Pealand because this subject is about ethics and it would be wrong choosing a project that goes against the company's press statement and other ethical codes. whats the point in studying a subject on ethics then?

I guess i'm the only one that went with COSO (control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information system and monitoring) :( I'll lose marks in this I'm sure now.

I used the COSO because in the revision there was a similar question about internal control where this was used but the difference was in the case study of tht question internal control already existed and they asked for challenges to putting more internal controls. So I got confused.

Anyways what is done is done good luck to all! Hope we pass!!
Former userFormer user14y ago#45
what was in q.3 did any any one attempt that question?? i think it was about ethics :P (a) is about confliction of interest and polly shah career who failed and still promoted there is assessment about that why he is still in firm
(b) is about safegaurd it will not occure again in jojo
(c) i forget about it :D
guys who attempt this question please tell me what he wrote in it
Former userFormer user14y ago#46
I also chose question 3 although I do not have much ideas abt it :((.
3(c) performance measurement of individual directors
and assess how it is difficult to apply for the company situation
Former userFormer user14y ago#47
I personally thought this exam was quite straight forward, and it's my first time at a P paper!
I was surprised/glad nothing came up about Deontological/Teleological, Absolutism/Relativism, Kohlberg etc!
I answered questions 1, 2 and 4. I noticed each question generally had 2 requirements so I approached it by splitting out each requirement and answering them separately to ensure I answered what the question was asking.
Here's what I concluded....

Q1 (a) - Risk appetite - Made up of a company's risk capacity/risk attitude. I applied this to the question and said a risk averse co would invest in Pealand, but risk seeking would invest in Jayland etc
b) AAA Model - I concluded that Pealand was the only option. Yes it said Jayland would make higher profit (due to risk) but how long would it be before profit decreased and Hayho lost customers, shareholders and potential investors due to reputation risk. Also, the Jayland option was not only highly unethical but bribery is highly illegal, that was my conclusion. I guess if you went for Jayland you will still get the marks if you've given your reasons well.
c) This was asking for a summary of internal control objectives and then an application to Jayland. This could be answered using the last paragraph on page 1 and the comments the lady working for the company had observed working in Jayland.
d i) Definition of accountability was required and also a brief explanation of what the agency relationship is applying it to Hayho's directors and their investors Quack Bank.
ii) Mendelow's matrix - I defined the 4 scenario's that can occur and then stated that WB were currently high interest but low power meaning they needed to be kept informed. However, I stated they could gain power from the likes of Politicians/Media etc. The second requirement was how WB's opinion should be taken seriously - I discussed if they gained power they could affect strategy, their reputation and close links to media/Politicians etc could highly damage the reputation of Hayho, resulting in a drop in profits caused by customers not wanting to purchase from an unethical company and this then having a knock- on impact with shareholders/potential investors etc and may put the company into trouble!

Q 4) a) Firstly I discussed the differences between a family company and a listed company - eg size, difference in agency costs, large co - having to adhere to Stock Market Corp Gov codes, difference in stakeholders, differenct conflicts, Large co being propfit seeking but small family co run to satisfy customers and maintain reputation etc The second requirement was CEO assumption that family control will be lost if they were floated - I just linked this to the question.
b) 2 requirements - benefits of induction for NED'S and CPD for current execs - could use common sense for this eg - to give NED'S feel for company- culture, to help them build staff relations, so they are aware of co strategy/objectives etc
c) 2 requirements - distinguish between unitary and 2 tier board - question made it clear the difference eg unitary - made up of execs/NED'S 2 tier - Op board - control day-to-day activities, Supervisory - make decisions and may include Op Board in certain decisions. 2nd requirement - Difficulties of Lum family to accept unitary board - relate to question ie already conflict as family want to maintain values/culture and NED'S already unhappy about these and other common sense answers ie dillution of their family control etc

Q2 - I rushed this a bit due to a time constraint!!
a) 2 requirements - discussion of independance - I just waffled and talked mainly about making decisions objectively and free from any bias or influences and mainly discussed this in the context on NED'S. 2nd requirement - Can't remember this part!!
b) 2 requirements - Role of risk commitee - straight forward enough- review int controls, risk policy, risk appetite, monitor risks, ensure communication re risk is cascaded throughout the company etc 2nd requirement - criticise snr mgrs comments - just picked out a few of his comments and criticised them, kind of ran out of time.

I'm just hoping I've passed, I feel like I gave it a good go, could of just done with 10 more minutes really but all in all looking at the last few P1 Papers set, I thought it was very reasonable! Good Luck!
Bbenjamincozoemena14y ago#48
If I combine all d points raised by u guyz on this forum, then I think I did perfectly well in this paper and should expect a comfortable pass...however, COSO was not suppose 2 be d answer 4 d IC systems, F8 is of help here, and then in the mendelow's law, WB should be 'kept informed' they only have high influence and low power (having political, human right, etc, connection is not enough 2 have high power, else WB should directly stop d decision of Hayho as they r already against it if they really have high power. 4 AAA, d decision was 2 execute d project in pealand (coz they comply with ethical standard. The only challenge I had was the issue with 'brief note'. I found it hard not 2 make it look like a memo. How am I expected 2 write 2 somebody without addressing him...Pls Examiner must understand my courtesy (I know 4 marks is @ stake here).
Jjoevassallo14y ago#49
@frankie184 said:
I personally thought this exam was quite straight forward, and it's my first time at a P paper!
I was surprised/glad nothing came up about Deontological/Teleological, Absolutism/Relativism, Kohlberg etc!
I answered questions 1, 2 and 4. I noticed each question generally had 2 requirements so I approached it by splitting out each requirement and answering them separately to ensure I answered what the question was asking.
Here's what I concluded....

Q1 (a) - Risk appetite - Made up of a company's risk capacity/risk attitude. I applied this to the question and said a risk averse co would invest in Pealand, but risk seeking would invest in Jayland etc
b) AAA Model - I concluded that Pealand was the only option. Yes it said Jayland would make higher profit (due to risk) but how long would it be before profit decreased and Hayho lost customers, shareholders and potential investors due to reputation risk. Also, the Jayland option was not only highly unethical but bribery is highly illegal, that was my conclusion. I guess if you went for Jayland you will still get the marks if you've given your reasons well.
c) This was asking for a summary of internal control objectives and then an application to Jayland. This could be answered using the last paragraph on page 1 and the comments the lady working for the company had observed working in Jayland.
d i) Definition of accountability was required and also a brief explanation of what the agency relationship is applying it to Hayho's directors and their investors Quack Bank.
ii) Mendelow's matrix - I defined the 4 scenario's that can occur and then stated that WB were currently high interest but low power meaning they needed to be kept informed. However, I stated they could gain power from the likes of Politicians/Media etc. The second requirement was how WB's opinion should be taken seriously - I discussed if they gained power they could affect strategy, their reputation and close links to media/Politicians etc could highly damage the reputation of Hayho, resulting in a drop in profits caused by customers not wanting to purchase from an unethical company and this then having a knock- on impact with shareholders/potential investors etc and may put the company into trouble!

Q 4) a) Firstly I discussed the differences between a family company and a listed company - eg size, difference in agency costs, large co - having to adhere to Stock Market Corp Gov codes, difference in stakeholders, differenct conflicts, Large co being propfit seeking but small family co run to satisfy customers and maintain reputation etc The second requirement was CEO assumption that family control will be lost if they were floated - I just linked this to the question.
b) 2 requirements - benefits of induction for NED'S and CPD for current execs - could use common sense for this eg - to give NED'S feel for company- culture, to help them build staff relations, so they are aware of co strategy/objectives etc
c) 2 requirements - distinguish between unitary and 2 tier board - question made it clear the difference eg unitary - made up of execs/NED'S 2 tier - Op board - control day-to-day activities, Supervisory - make decisions and may include Op Board in certain decisions. 2nd requirement - Difficulties of Lum family to accept unitary board - relate to question ie already conflict as family want to maintain values/culture and NED'S already unhappy about these and other common sense answers ie dillution of their family control etc

Q2 - I rushed this a bit due to a time constraint!!
a) 2 requirements - discussion of independance - I just waffled and talked mainly about making decisions objectively and free from any bias or influences and mainly discussed this in the context on NED'S. 2nd requirement - Can't remember this part!!
b) 2 requirements - Role of risk commitee - straight forward enough- review int controls, risk policy, risk appetite, monitor risks, ensure communication re risk is cascaded throughout the company etc 2nd requirement - criticise snr mgrs comments - just picked out a few of his comments and criticised them, kind of ran out of time.

I'm just hoping I've passed, I feel like I gave it a good go, could of just done with 10 more minutes really but all in all looking at the last few P1 Papers set, I thought it was very reasonable! Good Luck!


Having carefully read your answers I am sure you would obtain a pass mark.
Some of my answers were similar to yours, though must admit some questions I waffled on a bit and maybe got a bit out of track, like risk committee, corporate governance family/outsiders etc.
My disappointment was time - I left Q1 the briefing notes till the end and ran out of time, although I only had time to do the heading, and explain the first part on accountability and a bit about Mendelow framework... but ran out of time when I came to explain the 4 scenarios. Shame because I knew the answer and same like Agency relationship..... but time was crucial to me.
Hope for a marginal pass. Good luck to all.
KKDS14y ago#50
Well, I must thank O/T for their notes and tips as I did not follow any classes and was my first attempt.

As someone quoted, F8 did help a lot and also as for Q1 many points could be taken from the scenario itself too. You do have to extract points from the scenario and always have to refer to the given scenario. Am i correct? That's what I have gathered from previous lecturers and going through the student article.

Anyway hope for the best and good luck to all.
Pprateshramjohn14y ago#51
https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/acca/global/PDF-students/acca/p1/exampapers/P1/P1_2012_jun_q.pdf
Former userFormer user14y ago#52
Hey just a quick query about question 2 c...risk mitigation in larger and smaller companies. what angle did people go with on this one? I cant find any notes on it anywhere.

I went with the angle that it's important in both but it can be more important in larger companies due to more of a headcount, complexity of transactions...that sort of thing. Does this make sense or am I completely off the mark?
Ffaizan14y ago#53
@rhymenoceros said:
Hey just a quick query about question 2 c...risk mitigation in larger and smaller companies. what angle did people go with on this one? I cant find any notes on it anywhere.

I went with the angle that it's important in both but it can be more important in larger companies due to more of a headcount, complexity of transactions...that sort of thing. Does this make sense or am I completely off the mark?


I went with the same but stated it's more important with large companies as the transaction amounts are higher, affect of transaction are bigger, etc.

What you wrote sounds write. You're not completely off the mark.
Former userFormer user14y ago#54
P1 was fair compared to the past papers I have seen. Qtn 1, got all the answers from the scenario. Mendlow...I put the pressure group in "keep informed" box coz they had high level of interest and low power but explained more about it.
The criteria for performance measure, I used -linked to strategy, individual contribution, acceptable to shareholders, flexibility and difficult to distort. I don't knw whether I used the right stuff. did any one do this number?