Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

General ACCA*** P1 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll ***

Oopentuition14y ago
Post your comments about June 2012 P1 exam.

?How did you do? What came up? How did this paper compare to previous exams?

Vote in our Instant Poll
*** P1 June 2012 Exam was … Comments and Instant Poll *** poll results
Dddnguyen14y ago#1
What a nightmare, i attempt only Q1, this is fourth time, .......................
Former userFormer user14y ago#2
you need to wait for another 2 hour
Former userFormer user14y ago#3
Q1: Rist Appetite, AAA model, Independence, Accountability, Mendelow and
Q2: Independence, risk committee and (forget)
Q3: Ethics
Q4: insider(family) and outsider(listed), Induction programme and unitary v two-tier
Ffaizan14y ago#4
It wasnt that bad I just gotta say Kaplan exam tips rock. They were very accurate. anyways Q2 was independence of NED, risk committee and risk mitigation difference for large and small companies.

I have a question in Q1 part C where they asked to asses internal controls you had to mention COSO framework right? and would i not get marks in Q4 part a as i didn't mention insider and outsider but explained corporate governance pretty well.
Former userFormer user14y ago#5
good paper but facing time management problem little bit
Former userFormer user14y ago#6
exam was OK. I don't know how reach prof marks in "breafing notes".. but just 4 marks... Maybe It could be necessary for my 46 ))

So, the end of summer exam session! Happy summer days! :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#7
@faizan said:
It wasnt that bad I just gotta say Kaplan exam tips rock. They were very accurate. anyways Q2 was independence of NED, risk committee and risk mitigation difference for large and small companies.

I have a question in Q1 part C where they asked to asses internal controls you had to mention COSO framework right? and would i not get marks in Q4 part a as i didn't mention insider and outsider but explained corporate governance pretty well.


Not sure if Q1 C was COSO or not. I cant remember the phrasing of the question but I described the objectives of an internal control system and then pointed out with examples for the study the risks that these objectives were under threat...underskilled staff etc...could very easily be wrong though
Ffaizan14y ago#8
@rhymenoceros said:
Not sure if Q1 C was COSO or not. I cant remember the phrasing of the question but I described the objectives of an internal control system and then pointed out with examples for the study the risks that these objectives were under threat...underskilled staff etc...could very easily be wrong though


I am confused about it too but before going to exam i was reading the revision kit in it the tutorial note said whenever you read a question which has "assess" or "review" internal control.. use the COSO framework to answer.
Aahoatran14y ago#9
It was a good paper. Requirements were clear, scenarios were easy to follow and understand. I wished the P5 paper was written this well.
Mmizsj14y ago#10
Revision lectures + Revised for two days before the exam, and it went well.. Just wait till exam results. Didn't attempt AAA model completely forgot but answered all the questions. Q1 Q2 and Q4 :)

Hope we all pass!
Former userFormer user14y ago#11
@faizan said:
I am confused about it too but before going to exam i was reading the revision kit in it the tutorial note said whenever you read a question which has "assess" or "review" internal control.. use the COSO framework to answer.


Good point but I think that's moreso if they have an internal control system in place already and you have to assess it and see if it's good. In this one I think you had to point out reasons why establishing internal controls would be difficult..which meant you needed the objectives of an internal control system and then to point out the reason from the narrative why this couldnt be met..ie assess the risks.
Former userFormer user14y ago#12
@ahoatran said:
It was a good paper. Requirements were clear, scenarios were easy to follow and understand. I wished the P5 paper was written this well.


also taken P1 and P5 like heaven and hell )
Ffaizan14y ago#13
@rhymenoceros said:
Good point but I think that's moreso if they have an internal control system in place already and you have to assess it and see if it's good. In this one I think you had to point out reasons why establishing internal controls would be difficult..which meant you needed the objectives of an internal control system and then to point out the reason from the narrative why this couldnt be met..ie assess the risks.


Hmm you could be right because i'm 50/50 on this as they did mention stuff related to control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information system and monitoring in the case study but you could be right.. thinkin about it. the note did say if the system is working well not about why its difficult to have internal controls. Maybe i'll lose marks in this :(

Did anyone write like this in Q1 part C about internal controls? COSO or what rhymenoceros used?
00500896714y ago#14
Wow, that was the easiest exam I have ever sat!

The SA article on internal controls & turnbull was really useful.

Hoping for really high marks on this one. Going to have a great summer now.
Former userFormer user14y ago#15
This was my first ACCA exam as I did a degree and got the exemptions. Not sure how I did, think I might be a marginal fail. The time restraints on the exams are really difficult. I answered everything but not to the depth I know I needed to due to time.

Hope COSO was not the system I should have used on Q1 or I will have lost that whole section of marks in C. A lot of the stuff I knew like the back of my hand didn't come up so I was a bit gutted but it could have gone worse. I think I did ok, but now reading all the comments getting a bit worried. Not much I can do now though but it's hard not to think about it.
00500896714y ago#16
I spoke about coso in question 2 during the role of the risk committee and its promotion of enterprise management risk
Former userFormer user14y ago#17
Q1. what about pressure group in Mendelow matrix? it's "keep satisfied" or "key player"?

high level of interest, but how fairly evaluate influence? I wrote that it's "keep satisfied" that can accumulate power and transfer to "key player"
Former userFormer user14y ago#18
RE COSO I think it depoends what people consider COSO to be.

The question asked about the purpose of internal controls I took this to mean
- Safeguard shareholders investments
- Ensure compliance with laws and regs
- Ensure efficiency and effectiveness of operations
- Ensure reliable internal and external reporting
- Manage risk not eliminate it
- Form basis of risk management framework.

I think the other COSO framework is the COSO cube which is a framework for risk management and only part of internal control.

Does anyone agree/disagree?
Wwillynwilson14y ago#19
The purposes of internal control were simply the "objectives" therefore...
Facilitate operations
Ensure compliance
Ensure effective external and internal reporting e.t.c

I hope that clears a few things up for people
Former userFormer user14y ago#20
@willynwilson

I agree with you
Former userFormer user14y ago#21
There was no need to use coso as you have to relate to the scenario to get marks and there was nothing in it that required coso framework however there were some clear things due to which it would be difficult to implement ics and that was what the question was asking
Jjoevassallo14y ago#22
The paper was ok..ish
I thought it had a lot of theory in it, hence the time management issue.
I managed to complete all, barely, except Q1 the briefing report... only did very small part of it.
Re Q1 Internal Controls I think it should refer to the objectives (i.e. purpose) so I am not sure if COSO review comes into it.
I also got a bit stuck with the application of AAA 7 step - although I laid all the 7 steps well but could a bit muddled up. The decision was obvious I thought - Pealand.
The problem I found was Q1 was too lenghty to read, contained a lot of information, I suppose to help you out but it all takes time.......
Vvictoriaaa14y ago#23
opentuition tips are rather accurate! :)
Former userFormer user14y ago#24
Q1 part 1 was indeed confusing. I did not refer to COSO either !
Wwillynwilson14y ago#25
I put down that the best decision was to invest in the least profitable investment "pealand" because their ethical statement and the pressure group seemed to be more important than the extra money.
Former userFormer user14y ago#26
@carl29 said:
What about the statement the company made about meeting ethical expectations towards employees in developing nations?

I went the other one, maximal returns for shareholders, higher risk but also provided a boost to the local community. Bribery was part of the local custom so although not acceptable by usual standards, could be regarded ok locally, and the benefits out weighed the risks

This also fed quite nicely into the internal control part



But then you completely dissatisfy the 3rd party WB whos Interest moved to High and high power on the mendelow framework means you would try to satify this external stakeholder.

Bribery while although may be legal in that country It would also be unethical as it is a yearly bribe that would result in the continuation of the brutal dictatorship. I went pealand
Hhelen42514y ago#27
I have covered 95% of syllabus, so it is pretty easy for me. I chose the question 1, 2 and question 4.

Question 1: a) risk appetite and how does that affect the company's strategy?
b) Use AAA Ethical Model to analyse which investment option should Haygo company to adopt
Option 1: Invest in J country with potential risk: bribe issue,political risk ( unstable country) and less corporate governance requirement;
Option 2: stable country and government encourage outwards investment and comply with corporate governance;

General purpose of internal control and assess the difficulty to have sound control system in J country.
General purpose of internal control is :
- -to safeguard the company's assets and shareholders' investments
- - to ensure the completeness and accurateness of accounting records in place;
-- to prevent and detect of fraud
-- to effective running of the business
-- to ensure internal policies are carried out by the company

The difficulties to have a sound internal control in J country because of the following reasons:
-- cultures in J country does not support sound control system based on the scenrio;
- quality issues
- less skilled people especially people has less knowledge about accounting, thus it is difficult to produce the complete and accurate accounting records and it is difficult to meet the international accounting records;
-- Also it mentioned on the scario that it is difficult to safeguard assets

c) It is about the brief notes regarding meaning of accountability and agency relationship between the board of H and only one single investor of Quack Bank; and how the demands of WB (International pressure group) which concerns Human Right issue can affect the company's strategy? On the scenario, it says, WB can get a support using media, such as newpapers and TV and also get strong support from politician and trade organisation from all over the world. Therefore, WB is on High power / high interest category, based on Mendelow's Map, Management of Haygo has to take WB views into consideration due to WB's powerful position. Otherwise, it will adversely affect company's performance, it can cause potential reputation risk; erode the shareholders' confidence, and major shareholder (Quack Bank) may withdraw the investment and reduce the share price down; In addition, it will make the company to find diffculty to raise funds.

Q2. a) Meaning of independence and evaluate the Independence issue of NEDS
b) Role of Risk committee and critise the senior manager comments about the risk. In the case, senior manager says risk is useless and risk does not stop the risk etc. My main point is risk management system reduces the risk but does not eliminate the risk; risk management system helps the management to identify the risk and response the risk according and take action to monitor the risk;

C) why the largest organisation needs the risk management system than the small company? The similar question as Gluck and Goodman (Dec 08 ) part b. Factors affecting the need for internal audit and controls.

Q4. a) Compare general corporate arrangement between family memebers company and listed company? Why CEO in family business thinks the family control over time is being lost?
b) What are the benefits of induction programme to new NEDs and how CPD helps executive directors in Lumy family after family business floated on the stock market?
C) the distinguish between 2 tier board and unitary board, and some difficulties for Lumy family member to be fit in a unitary board?
Jjoevassallo14y ago#28
Q2 (a) - I thought the question was about describing Independence in the corporate governance conteext, i.e. independence from personal influence; independence of directors from operational involvement and independence from overt personal motivation because the compnay is run for the benefit of the owners/shareholders.
Wwillynwilson14y ago#29
@middeo said:
But then you completely dissatisfy the 3rd party WB whos Interest moved to High and high power on the mendelow framework means you would try to satify this external stakeholder.

How about the risk of the international media disclosing the bribe, therefore creating a reputation risk and also the fact that the bribe will show that the company is not complying with their corporate governance arrangements, and the fact that WB has the potential to be a significant key player, and can influence the public, politicians and the trade organisations.

There is no way the extra money was worth the risks.

Bribery while although may be legal in that country It would also be unethical as it is a yearly bribe that would result in the continuation of the brutal dictatorship. I went pealand
Mmaypen17214y ago#30
@helen425, well done and thanks. I did the same questions. However, I thought I did question 1 well on internal control objectives until then. Those were my points on internal control objectives (not COSO), but I didn't explain in depth my reasoning. I was conscious of my time management when I was revising past papers but still ran out of time. My answers will appear to the marker to be lacking in application - integrity :)

The overall exam was satisfactoy but very lengthy. In areas, the marks allocated were unfair for the work involved to achieve those marks. I'll either get 48% or 51% due to time management but not due to lack of ability to answer the questions. It's an improvement on the F9 exam. Today, I can offer feedback to friends, colleagues and relatives without crying :(

Cheers to the summer! Wishing one and all a great summer! And most of all, a great summer to Open Tuition tutors/admin. Thank you all!