Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AFMJune 10 Exams POLL Paper P4 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about P4 exam!

?Take our P4 exam survey
https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-p4-june-2010-exam-survey/

Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper P4 was Post your comments here poll results
Former userFormer user16y ago#61
Up to now, i am wondering what is the rational behind the questions st by that man.People claim Bob is not good, this man is worst. We should all appreciate the fact that the devil you know is better than the angel you don't know. Does ACCA want to tell me that they do not have examination board that scrutinise all exams papers before we sit for the exams. Total waste of 6 months for nothing. ACCA must do something. Among the papers i am sitting for this is the paper i beleive i will destroy, based how i prepare for it looking the structure of all the past question. It was a hell.
Former userFormer user16y ago#62
Thought Q2 was a direct copy from the article... it was difficult........ but yeah only if i had studied things might have been different.
Zzigot1416y ago#63
@ace

Sorry i dont have any reference. My lecturer mentioned this in class. I would say he's quite reliable because he reads up on these weird stuff.
Former userFormer user16y ago#64
It would be interesting to know how many in the ''easy'' camp used BPP texts or FTC. I used BPP but it was full of mistakes and inconsistencies. Regarding the exams, I was able to calculate growth using the NOPAT and retention rate of 180/580. For the rest of the paper I kept wondering where in the study texts such securitised debt and stuff had being mentioned. I think we need a clear syllabus that details what we need to know and a study text written with ample examples on even the most obscure topics. On a whole I don't believe this paper was as bad as that of June 09 but it would be a miracle if I manage to scrape 30%. What I am thinking of doing is choosing a ''relatively'' easier paper like auditing for example and only sit P4 after I become an affiliate. Is this possible?
Former userFormer user16y ago#65
well da examinerhad taken ful revenge 4m us 4 da last attempt easuest ppr....i did my best n did all da kit but all of no use...BOSM model question's in kit is v v easy as compared to wahat is appeared in da exams....also zakkie ur rite abt da SECURITIZED CERTIFICATEs....never heard of it b4 ;( ....may GOD pass me ...not so hopful bt not so pessimist.
Kkwanh8516y ago#66
got dizzy when read the whole paper in the reading time, this was the 1st time i wasnt able to write anything down on the question paper!!!!
drank a glass of water and started with Q2, confidently made the report format and jumped towards the appendix and then just kept on doing workings in the appendix and giving its result on the report, forget the infinity formula so took out ke the right and did the BSOP model the correct way but i guess with wrong figures.
Q1 cant remember wat was it about so cant remember hw i handled it can someone give me a clue plz for the peace of my min?
Q5 the question that made me dizzy!!! it wasnt much of a difficult one after all :) actually found it to be the easiest one made 2 grids explaining the setting off arrangements without conversion in one and with conversion in the other. and well part b was easy couldnt find much of disadvantages in why confused head at that time though
Q3 WHAT THE HELL WAS THAT COULDNT EVEN UNDERSTAND WHAT THE HELL WAS HE TRYING TO SAY SKIPPPED that one
Q4 started with introduction and was i was trying to say, then went towards asking questions to identify the issues and then went on with short paras of discussions on the main point made.
Kkwanh8516y ago#67
oh just read about it in someones post oh ya Q1 was easy actually better then Q5 :)
Former userFormer user16y ago#68
I was confused with Q2; was not sure what do in exam in 50 mins; just rushed off; not hoping for the best; this paper is really making me ill.
Llapthu16y ago#69
I just read again the article about valuing the company using the BSM model but stil unable to figure out the exercise price which was indicated by the examiner is the value of a zero coupond bond. We were only told that it was a floating loan at a yield of 5% plus 3% premium. It is also the cost of debt? On Bob Ryan's article we know the coupon rate together with cost of debt so we can work out the PV of the debt.

I only read the article twice like with all the remaining articles before entering the exam and forgot most of it by the time going over the question. I wish there was at least one question in the revision kit asking the similar type of things so I could practice few times over and remember what to do in the exam.

This is my last paper so I did put a lot of time into study hoping I will be qualied after 8 long years but it might not happen now. I failed last time and I accepted it because I did not understand the subject. I thought I was well prepared this time but it looks like not.
Former userFormer user16y ago#70
I had studied old paper 2.4 years and years ago and I don't think portfolio theory was included in that syllabus nor was PT given in my P4 BPP and FTC books. I did look at some notes my friends gave me from paper f8 but I never really did practice for the PT question. When I got to Q3, time was short and I was thinking on picking Q3 and Q4 (Q4 looked easy) but decided against it and thankfully picked Q5, I had a good Q1, i think, but a bit messy. Q2 was a bit confusing. Here's what I did:
1) Free cashflows discounted to perpetuity with ke to derive Equity value of the predator.
2) Used current asset book values as excercise price. Used the free cashflows equity value + loan book value + 1.3333 time equity of the prey as the current price.
3) Gave option value as the premium and the 1.333 times equity + option value as the bid price.
Hope this was OK?!!!
Former userFormer user16y ago#71
Anyone remember? Does Q2 ask to calculate the value of combined company or the target only? I very confused.
Kkwanh8516y ago#72
@qing said:
Anyone remember? Does Q2 ask to calculate the value of combined company or the target only? I very confused.

it asked to value the company which was acquiring the other, and thats soo weird i also almost ended up doing the valuation for the company which was being acquired however its market value was already available as the per share market value was easily computable
bobby played his best for his last
Former userFormer user16y ago#73
Thanks Kwanh85.
I valued the target. T_T
Former userFormer user16y ago#74
i thought the examiner want us to value the target using BSOP and compare it with current mv, and decide how much premium to pay them.

i did not read the requirement carefully.
i donot think i will pass then.
Kkwanh8516y ago#75
@qing said:
i thought the examiner want us to value the target using BSOP and compare it with current mv, and decide how much premium to pay them.

i did not read the requirement carefully.
i donot think i will pass then.

cheer up dude the checkers r like ur best friends, if you look at the marking scheme you can even pass the papers if you dont even do one question the right way, like you mustev calculated the BSOP model correctly with wrong figures?? you will still get alot of marks for that
Former userFormer user16y ago#76
The examiner clearly has his own agenda. I've done virtually all the questions in the Kaplan exam kit and I could have studied for 100 years and I would get the same mark as I did do on the 10th.

That's the 4rd exam in a row he's ignored hedging with futures/options etc.

Finally he mentioned toxic assets... after having written an article 5 recessions ago.

The written question was irrelevant to almost everything.

All the people I spoke to after the exam came out saying... what on earth was that? I went for some of the baby marks - I didn't know what that meant so I wrote this.

And some of these people will undoubtedly pass.... (as has happened before)
But I guess the ACCA want those kinds of people to represent their organisation. People who come out of exams and don't know what they've just done.
You try asking someone who sat this paper last time what something means and very often, they won't have a clue. Yeah good exam Bob.

At least Bob's gone... we'll be singing.. "Ding dong the witch is dead" at his leaving parade.
Former userFormer user16y ago#77
@kwanh85 said:
it asked to value the company which was acquiring the other, and thats soo weird i also almost ended up doing the valuation for the company which was being acquired however its market value was already available as the per share market value was easily computable
bobby played his best for his last


It was required to value the combined entity, then subtract the value of the predator company and derive the maximum bid price for the target company. Then compare this price with the current fair value - derive max premium to be paid
Former userFormer user16y ago#78
@zigot14 said:
Q2's based on the latest tech article on option pricing.

Did anyone think that the annuity factor formuia in Q1 was wrong?


I also thought that the formula was incorrect. I'm sure that the formula given multiplied everything in the big square brackets by (1 + g), but it should have been by A, where A is the annuity in year 1.
Former userFormer user16y ago#79
@qing said:
Anyone remember? Does Q2 ask to calculate the value of combined company or the target only? I very confused.


My take on it was that he wanted us to value the predator company before acquisition, then combined after. I thought that the point was that the predator company started off profitable and worth lots, then acquired another profitable company, but then because of the large amount of liabilities in the target company, the combined company could be perceived as being of little value if, say, net assets method used. It seems illogical that the combined value of two profitable companies should be less than the predator company alone. That brings in time value / near the money / Black-Scholes option valuing as being suitable - per examiners article.

Anyone agree, or am I way off the mark?!
Former userFormer user16y ago#80
THE PAPER WAS A DISASTER.
JUST HOPING TO PASS AS I DID MY LEVEL BEST
Former userFormer user16y ago#81
A challenging exam for this attempt, wishing all those out there the best on their results for putting in hard work as this exam could've raped anyone!

Q1 was awesome, would've been perfect had i ever thought Monte Carlo Simulation would show up anywhere in any p4 exam! :P

Q2 was good until i got the answer for the value of a firm from Black Scholes model, that was impossible to interpret as the combined value i was getting was less than the equity value of the first company using free cash flows!! and it was asking for how much premium to pay?! that was confusing, otherwise still pretty good.

Q3, i dont think i even read the question properly and was out of time.

Q4 didnt attempt, i hate theory

Q5. netting was soooo easy. calculate all the external transactions into one currency (say euro) and you should be getting a net receipt of around 6 billion. then calculate the total monies needed for group payments and receipts (note, payments and receipts are all amounts that need to be paid with money!) so you end up requiring somewhere over 20 or 30 billion (cant remember) and then subtract the 6 billion you will receive from others and thats your total requirement (guys i really think i nailed this one, but i can never say about p4!)!!!

does anybody ever remember advantages and disadvantages??
Former userFormer user16y ago#82
AND I SWEAR THAT ANNUITY FORMULA IS WRONG!!!!!!!!!!!

just calculate 2 or 3 years growth and discount seperately and use the formula, your answers should differ!

who is the new smarta** examiner??
Former userFormer user16y ago#83
zigot14
Regarding the anuity formula I also thought It was wrong but I was not so sure,I think there is something missing as the factor cannot be that much small
Nnicolat7716y ago#84
How disappointing. I feel like I may as well have not bothered revising at all as I would have been prepared for that as much as I was anyway. Qu 4 and 5 were fine but i struggled mainly with Q2 as it confused the hell out of me.

I think ACCA need to address this problem so people aren't wasting their time resitting this exam. What a nightmare.
AAnjan16y ago#85
section B questions were unexpected...i would not say it was difficult but as it was surprising it required more time to plan the right approach for answer..considering the exam time pressure it was challenging...particularly Q no.3 took my all reading and planning time and finally i decided not to answer it...so 15 minute was lost..and i started getting panic...so couldn't attempt to my ability..
Former userFormer user16y ago#86
I think the exam was unfair. It offered very limited choice for a student. Non core topics were tested. Yes we are suppose to know our f9 material but I did the old 2.4 financial management and I was never tested on Monte Carlo simulation. Section B offered very little choice. Q3 was an article but I was not expecting it cause the article was released many months ago. I think both lectures and students should complain to ACCA that the exam material does not correspond to what is being taught in class. They should mark us out 50 and not 100. They should select the best two questions answered. There should be moderation. Please all who found the paper a disaster, please complain to ACCA. Resiting cost a lot of money.
Former userFormer user16y ago#87
Good luck to you all, i failed P4 twice and decided to do tax this time round as P4 was still a Bob Ryan paper. Hopefully in December it will be a better paper for any of your that may need to retake, with more of the core topics covered in slightly easier to understand ways. I did find after a exam debrief that once i understood what the examiner was asking for the questions were ok, but it is very hard to do that under exam conditions and in 3 1/4 hrs.
Ssunnyfish200116y ago#88
I have prepared several hedges for exchange/interest rate for a long time, at last they are not tested at all!