Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AFMJune 10 Exams POLL Paper P4 was Post your comments here

Oopentuition16y ago
Please share here with community your comments about P4 exam!

?Take our P4 exam survey
https://opentuition.com/articles/surveys/acca-paper-p4-june-2010-exam-survey/

Vote in our instant poll!
June 10 Exams POLL Paper P4 was Post your comments here poll results
Former userFormer user16y ago#31
Q2 was fully disaster! That was not expected to mix the different things not related ro each other in one question. Assume, assume, assume.... It seems that examiner try ti find more and more different synonym to each ordinary words that we see during preparation. Very hard to understand what exactly examiner wants to see in answer... Very confusing exam. Is was the worst exam in respect of clear question presentation in ACCA.
Former userFormer user16y ago#32
securitized certificates are something like collateral debt obligations?
Former userFormer user16y ago#33
@zigot14 said:
Q2's based on the latest tech article on option pricing.

Did anyone think that the annuity factor formuia in Q1 was wrong?


I think the idea was that the exam question wanted to incorporate growth of cashflow inside the annuity formula? I just used it anyway since it was given.

For question 2 did anyone use Gordon's growth model? eg. the Ke = 12.56% x (180/580)

question 2 was quite challenging.

i found the theory question surprisingly easy.
Ttrinistudent00116y ago#34
How did anyone who said it was easy handle Q2?
Ttrinistudent00116y ago#35
@ Studystudystudy......yes the securitized unrated certifcates were the in the first tranche......which accounted for 10% of the pool of funds, just as the question said. That would have been the first one to go in terms of the debt obligations.....they are like junk bonds etc. Tranche 2 which is mezzanine debt which accounted for 10% of the pool (B rated fixed rate loan notes). And the final one accounted for the difference. Well they said 95% of the pool were made into CDO's the balance prob stayed as normal debt.
Former userFormer user16y ago#36
its disaster for me too. i really confused with annuity formula in Q1, Q4 is very strange, i cant imagine any real situation of running a business with one section as coins and notes producing and other section manufacturing sweets for finance traders!!!!. Q5 was better but i lost all my time before i reach there. is examiner expecting us as a banking expert?. if u compare pass rate of P4 with all other papers, its handled by tough examiner.
Ttrinistudent00116y ago#37
Gordon's growth model didnt even cross my mind. Geez! Praying for 50 yes. I tired.
Ttokunboayoola16y ago#38
The issue with this paper was that there were areas that we have encountered but the way it was presented in the exa was totally different which actually gives e the jitters!
Q1 is akin to Q17 in BPP fuelitie but what happens to dep siince they are talking of 'annual surplus cash'?
Q2 option pricing but we have to deterine Pe on the basis of a coupon/ yield rate
Q3 Tranching has never been tested b4
Q4 Issues with deerger
Q5 Forex - netting
Well what can we do but pray for the best!!!
Former userFormer user16y ago#39
At the end of the day i don't think the exam was suited for accounting students. It was more of the investment paper, which does not make much sense as majority of ACCA qualified do not work in Investment banking... Hopefully new examiner will be better unless I miraculously passed today's exam...
Former userFormer user16y ago#40
This is what P4 is famous for .. You study, study, and study, but then, at the end its all part of dream !! What comes up in an exam is totally out of the blue !!

I believe , BOB RYAN always test our nerves !! How strong we are to face something NEW !! Thats the real test base of a professional accountant ..

Ofcourse , The examiner knew him self we all 've been studying forex, valuations and bla bla , why not testing and differentiating GEMS among us by examining something new ??

WELCOME TO P4 :)
Zzigot1416y ago#41
@studystudystudy said:
I think the idea was that the exam question wanted to incorporate growth of cashflow inside the annuity formula? I just used it anyway since it was given.

For question 2 did anyone use Gordon's growth model? eg. the Ke = 12.56% x (180/580)


Q1. Using the formula to find the annuity factor would result in a negative figure no?

Q2. Yup i did this for g too.
Former userFormer user16y ago#42
I'll be glad to see the back of Bob Ryan and his considerable ego.
Former userFormer user16y ago#43
Question 2 was disaster...
My impression is that they just play the game "have you read the latest article? oh you have not??? than you fail"...
that is not professional way of examining...
Former userFormer user16y ago#44
I would like see those people who are saying the exam was easy?
how could its possible?
may be you guys should give us some advices !!
Former userFormer user16y ago#45
Surely it would be in ACCA PR interests to hit the 'easy' option several times on this survey so the exam doesn't look like the joke it was in relation to they syllabus!
Former userFormer user16y ago#46
Make that the syllabus
Former userFormer user16y ago#47
@zakkie13901 said:
does anyone know what the hell is securitized certificates and how to estimate its return?it's in Q3...

I didn't do that Q. I had a glance at it in the beginning and thoguht this is not my cup of tea. I did the other 2.
Ddongbula16y ago#48
I had spent so much time on my P4, but the result is devastating, I feel so miserable right now. How can we get it right?
Ttrinistudent00116y ago#49
dongbula, I know how you feel. I think thats everyone's sentiments except the ones who said it was an easy paper :) Its unfair, since Bob Ryan has been the examiner, people have been complaining about this paper. Well, hopefully, wee'll see better days
Ttrinistudent00116y ago#50
Well ace87, it seems that you will probably receive a prize for this paper, cuz it was a disaster for everyone else. Well thanks for at least being a light in the darkness.
Former userFormer user16y ago#51
would anyone remember the B for equity in Q2?
Former userFormer user16y ago#52
thanks a lot
Former userFormer user16y ago#53
Well I was hoping for a big foreign exchange or interest rate risk question but I feel like I wasted my time studying this whole section. Q1 was a bit weird but I think I managed most of it. BSOP in queston 2 was a surprise so I didn't do well on that part. Not feeling too confident but second time around for me so I'm really hoping for 50%.
Former userFormer user16y ago#54
ACCA is taking us for granted. They told us that they have changed the examiner and it was good news because Bob Ryan sets exams that are beyond P4. However, it seems ACCA fooled us. Bob Ryan is still setting P4 exams and the new examiner is just reviewing the paper. Isn't this fooling us? Go to ACCA website and see the examiners list. You will see that the current examiner has been put there just to review. ACCA is happy with Bo Ryan.
Former userFormer user16y ago#55
They were 2 article questions: Option pricing for q2 and Toxic Assets for q3.
I felt q3 was really nasty, with interest rate swap.
It wasnt a fair paper, as no core topics being tested.
Former userFormer user16y ago#56
What is more concerning is that the new examiner reviewed the paper for ‘reasonableness’ and obviously thought is was reasonable.
I don’t think we should get too excited about the December resit, yet, as they may think alike!
If I get more than 20 marks in the first 2 questions I’ll be amazed and suspicious about the marking scheme.
Former userFormer user16y ago#57
Totally didn't expect that none of the questions was my expertise. even Q2 business valuation plus option pricing was messy. Didn't even expect Q5 will be tested as well, didnt prepared for that!
Wasting my whole lots of effort working through kit's questions T.T
Zzigot1416y ago#58
@chipbanda said:
ACCA is taking us for granted. They told us that they have changed the examiner and it was good news because Bob Ryan sets exams that are beyond P4. However, it seems ACCA fooled us. Bob Ryan is still setting P4 exams and the new examiner is just reviewing the paper. Isn't this fooling us? Go to ACCA website and see the examiners list. You will see that the current examiner has been put there just to review. ACCA is happy with Bo Ryan.


ACCA papers are set 18 months beforehand i think. Hence, this sitting's paper was set by Bob Ryan because 18 months ago he was still the examiner. The new examiner is, well, new and he only reviewed the paper that was set by Bob Ryan way before he was appointed.
Ssummeryj16y ago#59
worked so hard for all topics. did read examner's articles but not very detailed. Never know half of questions came from them. Disaster !
Former userFormer user16y ago#60
complete disaster