Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

FM*** F9 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments***

Oopentuition13y ago
Post your comments about December 2012 F9 exam.

Please vote in our Instant Poll
*** F9 December 2012 Exam *** Instant Poll and comments*** poll results



Please note:
Remember that you are studying for a professional qualification - do not make postings that are abusive or threatening.
Former userFormer user13y ago#61
@suganya25 said:
F9 was quite a demanding paper in terms of time management.
I feel that the paper was manageable esp the calculations but the theory portion was...no commends

Question one: Npv was $266, arr was 28% so proposed investment is financially acceptable. I accounted for the fixed cost too. Part c about interest rated and capital investment decision? No clue. Part d was on factors to formulate AR policy.

Question two: AR policy was net cost. Inventory was net benefit. Optimum cash was in miller Orr model.

Question three: wacc was 9% I din include overdraft, must we? Benefit of offering convertible debt to taking up bank loan, I touched on flexibility and redemption. It was from the company point of view. The last part on interest rate hedging, I mentioned smoothing and fra.

Question four: biz valuations, I got a little confused on
Code:
the
br model. It's the proportion of retained earnings right? I took the (pat minus div ) divide by pat to get the proportion and multipled that with the ke value given in ther question.to get the growth rate. Then I applied it into the normal dvm equation. Hope I'm right. Merits of the valuation mtd, I wrote abt the techniques used, their pros and cons, whatever I cld rmb fr today morning's last minute revising. Cost of debt, was irr mtd. Debt to equity ratio decreased to 13% so the company's gearing improved ie financial risk is lower.

Whatever I cld recall...
Hope to pass this paper, can't wait for my P-papers next sem :) ALL THE BEST GUYS :)

Q1 absolutely the same results
Q3 WACC 9,7. I didnt include o/t, but it was 15m and was worth to include it..
AR reduced to 41 days.. net benefit from providing discount 48050
Former userFormer user13y ago#62
@aataro003 said:
Q1 absolutely the same results
Q3 WACC 9,7. I didnt include o/t, but it was 15m and was worth to include it..
AR reduced to 41 days.. net benefit from providing discount 48050



Oops, so we gotta include o/d?
Yes AR reduced, savings on overdraft interest but the cost of interest allowed was higher than the savings on o/d interest resulting in a net cost..that was my answer, did I mess it up?
Former userFormer user13y ago#63
What abt the question on market value WACC vs book value WACC? What to answer?
VVipin13y ago#64
i think i really messed up q.no.1
fixed cost actually were fixed investment costs.
my taxable profit were wrong if it is fixed investment cost.

and again in ARR,
i considered time line starting from t0 to t4, so i took it as 5 years period. so i divided by 5.
i deduct depreciation to find avg profit.
to finfd avg capital, i included fixed investment cost .

can anyone comment on this.
if u remember .

from q.no.1 10 marks gone for sure.
Iijaz13y ago#65
what do u mean by fixed inv cost. did u show as capital exp in T0.
Iijaz13y ago#66
what do u mean by fixed inv cost. did u show as capital exp in T0.
Iijaz13y ago#67
what do u mean by fixed inv cost. did u show as capital exp in T0.
Former userFormer user13y ago#68
@vipin70 said:
i think i really messed up q.no.1
fixed cost actually were fixed investment costs.
my taxable profit were wrong if it is fixed investment cost.

and again in ARR,
i considered time line starting from t0 to t4, so i took it as 5 years period. so i divided by 5.
i deduct depreciation to find avg profit.
to finfd avg capital, i included fixed investment cost .

can anyone comment on this.
if u remember .

from q.no.1 10 marks gone for sure.


What I did was, I calculated the inflated contributions for both the house types and deducted it with inflated fixed cost. That was my taxable cashflow. I deducted the investment cost of $4m from yr0 and tax paid for yr2 to yr 5 and same for the tax claim. That gave me net cashflow which u discounted with the nominal rate to get
v. Arr was calculated with the taxable cashflow for the four years minus full depreciation of 4m to get total profit and divide by four years to get average profits. Avg investment was two million. Avg profit over avg investment multiply by 100 to get the arr which was higher than the hurdle rate.
Former userFormer user13y ago#69
am i right to use the real; cashflow and the real discount rate? overall i think the exam was very very lengthy!
Former userFormer user13y ago#70
@suganya25 said:
Oops, so we gotta include o/d?
Yes AR reduced, savings on overdraft interest but the cost of interest allowed was higher than the savings on o/d interest resulting in a net cost..that was my answer, did I mess it up?

I will try to memorise the structure of my unswer

Current rec days
365*2465/15m=60 days

Revised receivables days
(0.5*30)+(0.3*45)+(0.2*60)=41

Current receivables=2465

Revised = 15m*41/365=1684

Saving on interest= 2465-1684 * 0.06 (o/d int)=46860

Cost of discount= 15m*0.5*0.01=0.075

did i miss smth?
Iijaz13y ago#71
agree with suganya25. thats what i did. deducted inflated f/cost from contribution.
Dd01945213y ago#72
I showed the fixed inv costs as a fixed cost in years 1-4 and I inflated them By 2% per year, I have a feeling it should be more complicated than that cause the question was worth 12 marks.
Former userFormer user13y ago#73
LOL )) i missed up rounding )))
U are right )) damn it
Former userFormer user13y ago#74
I wouldn't comment on that my NPV was negative some how. my ARR was wrong so again no comment on q1
Dd01945213y ago#75
Was the MV of bonds £114
Former userFormer user13y ago#76
@d019452 said:
Was the MV of bonds £114

Q4 Mv of bonds, I got 111.2 (
Former userFormer user13y ago#77
@rinrawee1 said:
I wouldn't comment on that my NPV was negative some how. my ARR was wrong so again no comment on q1


I think the comment should be given base on your own answer, even the calculation is wrong, you still get marks on the comment...
Former userFormer user13y ago#78
@d019452 said:
Was the MV of bonds £114

what q was that?
Dd01945213y ago#79
I think the MV of the bonds was q4 but not sure
Former userFormer user13y ago#80
its was very easy paper..
NPV +250,000
ARR 28%
WACC 9.3%
other all calculations was very easy and theoretical portion was also bit easy...
Ssalahuddin8813y ago#81
hi there ! my npv is 881positive i included fixed cost..wacc comes 6.1% while arr 30.23% which is not rite ..mv of bond was the same 25m,,as it is in the question..becoz no value were given there,,,,overall paper was average..working capital q were excellent,,,,,,
Dd01945213y ago#82
Company valuations in q4 I got i 160k, ii approx 90k, iii approx 161k iiii approx 233k. From what I recall there were 2 questions that had a written on interest rates and what could happen, which I thought was very strange?
Dd01945213y ago#83
I got 28% arr. q4 The debt/equity ratio for book value was over 30% and MV was about 19% I think. For he WACC I got 9% including the overdraft and 9.6% not including the overdraft. The MV of bond I think I got 111.14.
VVipin13y ago#84
@d019452 said:
I showed the fixed inv costs as a fixed cost in years 1-4 and I inflated them By 2% per year, I have a feeling it should be more complicated than that cause the question was worth 12 marks.

all of included fixed cost to find taxable profit, i also did same. but only now my brain worked , it is wrong. that fixed cost were fixed investment costs. when i calculated for ARR , i took it.
qn clearly says that fixed cost for roads, utilities, which is commonly used in the site.
Iijaz13y ago#85
@d019452 said:
Company valuations in q4 I got i 160k, ii approx 90k, iii approx 161k iiii approx 233k. From what I recall there were 2 questions that had a written on interest rates and what could happen, which I thought was very strange?
thats what i got. Alhamdollilah.
Mmarky12313y ago#86
Hi people.

I thought I had prepared well for this exam but I cant help but think Ive made a total disaster on it!

Q1 - My best question. NPV - I know Ive made a silly mistake - I think Ive discounted at 9% but Im pretty confident with the rest of my calculations. I think my NPV was about 540k positive?

Q2. - I think I made a decent enough effort and my savings were I think 11,700?? I think I did pretty ok theory too.

Q3 - Disaster! - I didnt complete the first part of the question - my mind just went blank :( Hoping to pull a few marks back on the theory.

Q4 - I thought was very hard - some parts I think I did ok, others ???!! - Again hoping I pull marks back on the theory.

Overall - exam was a lot harder than I expected. This was my first attempt at F9. Speaking to people before and after exam I get the general feeling that F9 is a popular resit!!

I did my best - heres hoping for 50 marks! - If not - June 13 here I come!!

Now for a break....

Merry Christmas everyone!
VVipin13y ago#87
@d019452 said:
I got 28% arr. q4 The debt/equity ratio for book value was over 30% and MV was about 19% I think. For he WACC I got 9% including the overdraft and 9.6% not including the overdraft. The MV of bond I think I got 111.14.

i got same except that arr i made mistake
VVipin13y ago#88
anyone remember net benefit if cash discounting is chosen??
i think i got around 14k net benefit.
VVipin13y ago#89
last question,
i didnt prepare for theory explanation.
relative merits on different bussiness valuations (8 mark). i consider it gone though i wrote my own theory.

how to mitigate interest risk. i explained it very poorly. around 5 marks gone.

q.no.1 10 marks gone.
approx 25 marks gone already. easy qn, but small small mistakes marks gone already.
Former userFormer user13y ago#90
can believe i calculated average capital by dividing by 4...i can c y my arr was wrong
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.