AA*** F8 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
@nati1981 said: no, it said all the purchase staff had restriction on the master fileMight be as you say...it seems you have a very good photogenic memory as you can quote so nicely from so many Qs of the exam. But none the less...how can nobody from purchases department have zero access to the file? not even the supervisor/manager? Anyhow.. When are the results out? Anybody knows?
@gianina said: Might be as you say...it seems you have a very good photogenic memory as you can quote so nicely from so many Qs of the exam. But none the less...how can nobody from purchases department have zero access to the file? not even the supervisor/manager? Anyhow.. When are the results out? Anybody knows?Access is restricted to the purchase staff - This means that only the purchasing staff can access the master file - so this was a deficiency due to errors as they can all make amendments.
Results are on 18 April 2016.
I met a chap re-sitting his F8 exam in September. He got 49% and was certain that he failed as a result of changing his multiple choice questions because he saw two continuations of the same letter i.e. C in this exam and changed them because he could not conceive of the examiner having the same letter over and over.
Moral of the story, only change it if you think it is wrong ;0) It is totally conceivable that the MCQ could have been AAABBBCCCDDD lol, albeit, that would freak me the 'beep' out
What about the 4 objectives of purchasing system
- I said no damaged goods are accepted due to checks in place
- No wrong quantities or types of goods are received due to matching to PO when received
- All invoices are approved which achieves objective of accuracy of supplier invoices
- Can't remember last one
@ccoda said: Results are on 18 April 2016. I met a chap re-sitting his F8 exam in September. He got 49% and was certain that he failed as a result of changing his multiple choice questions because he saw two continuations of the same letter i.e. C in this exam and changed them because he could not conceive of the examiner having the same letter over and over. Moral of the story, only change it if you think it is wrong ;0) It is totally conceivable that the MCQ could have been AAABBBCCCDDD lol, albeit, that would freak me the 'beep' outTotally agree. I had 4 Cs in a row in this exam but didn't cross my mind to start changing for the sole reason they are all the same haha.
@david1988 said: What about the 4 objectives of purchasing system - I said no damaged goods are accepted due to checks in place - No wrong quantities or types of goods are received due to matching to PO when received - All invoices are approved which achieves objective of accuracy of supplier invoices - Can't remember last oneRiiight...the control and its objective: 1. Goods checked for quality and orders - to accept only good quality purchases and only the co's orders 2. Authorization in place for purchases - to only purchase the needed goods, efficiency in the purchase system 3. Inventory update automatically - never to run out of inventory in order not to loose sales & customer goodwill 4. And i think there was something with matching invoices to GRNs and purchase orders but i do not recall properly ...
@gianina said: Riiight...the control and its objective: 1. Goods checked for quality and orders - to accept only good quality purchases and only the co's orders 2. Authorization in place for purchases - to only purchase the needed goods, efficiency in the purchase system 3. Inventory update automatically - never to run out of inventory in order not to loose sales & customer goodwill 4. And i think there was something with matching invoices to GRNs and purchase orders but i do not recall properly ...Both kind of on similar lines with this one then - Haven't seem many questions like this in past papers so had to take a good think before answering.
@gianina said: Riiight...the control and its objective: 1. Goods checked for quality and orders - to accept only good quality purchases and only the co's orders 2. Authorization in place for purchases - to only purchase the needed goods, efficiency in the purchase system 3. Inventory update automatically - never to run out of inventory in order not to loose sales & customer goodwill 4. And i think there was something with matching invoices to GRNs and purchase orders but i do not recall properly ...Agree - but for the 1st one I had that down as a deficiency - as they didn't check the quantity of goods vs the GRN/ PO But I guess it could be a control too!
The audit risks - I also said that as they were planning to pay a dividend that they needed to vouch back to the supporting evidence to ensure it was in the right cut off or cash overstated..?
For Q2 my memory is so blurry but I remember it asking whether the event required an adjustment to the financial statement, and what audit procedures would need to be done before adjusting..is that correct? Was quite tricky.
yes mine looked a lot like that.
All I seem to remember from MCQ was that
1.A(1 MARK) 2.A 3.A 4.B 5.B
6.C (1 MARK) 7.D 8.B (1 MARK) 9.B(1 MARK) 10.D
11.A 12.B
Anyone same??
My MCQ was that AADCCCDBADBD
Q1 5 corporate governance weaknesses (10M)
Q2 Materiality & performance materiality (5M) & PURPOSE & procedures carrying out during interim audit (3M) & impact on the final audit (2M)
Q3 Fire(40%NCA damaged & $25kinventory damaged but does not deliveries late to customer) & Inventory(defective goods $915K - $50K / $7.9M)
i. FS requires amendment? ii. audit procedures (10M)
Q4 5 Audit risk (10M)
Q5 SP for exception notes of payables and accrual (5M)
Audit procedures can be carried out using CAATs to payables and accrual (3M)
Benefits of audit software (3M)
somethg with lawsuits and impact on the audit report can't remember the marks allocation.
Q6 Control objectives for purchasing and payment (4M)
7 deficiencies on the above system (14M)
IS reports required - (2 professional marks)
Can ANYONE recall me back the lawsuits marks allocation?? i think this lawsuits questions separated to 3 parts rights? the last part was $2.6M receivables somethg regarding the accounting treatment - contingent assets. what's the first two parts? and their marks allocation?
@ntetema said: The paper F8 was demanding
@nataliejj said: Q5 SP for exception notes of payables and accrual (5M) Audit procedures can be carried out using CAATs to payables and accrual (3M) Benefits of audit software (3M) somethg with lawsuits and impact on the audit report can't remember the marks allocation. Can ANYONE recall me back the lawsuits marks allocation?? i think this lawsuits questions separated to 3 parts rights? the last part was $2.6M receivables somethg regarding the accounting treatment - contingent assets. what's the first two parts? and their marks allocation?The audit procedures for the faulty brakes in question 5c were five marks Then whether it should be modified with respect to receivables and this was for four marks.
@samirrules said: The audit procedures for the faulty brakes in question 5c were five marks Then whether it should be modified with respect to receivables and this was for four marks.Ohhh i got it...Thanks @samirrules!!!
@nataliejj said: Ohhh i got it...Thanks @samirrules!!!No problem, how did you find the exam?
..
Fernando you are right!. Provision of $2.6 million in litigation case was appropriate and should have been properly disclosed. But the treatment of receivable was not right.It should have been disclosed as contingent asset rather than receivable. Since the board refused to amend the statement so the modified opinion should have been made.
I was confused in Qualified or adverse opinion. was the receivable amount pervasive?
What was answer to the mcq: related to role of audit committee?
@samirrules said: No problem, how did you find the exam?I didn't manage to finish the whole paper...the materiality & performance materiality and deficiencies I didn't finish but I think overall is quite ok..mcq I think only question 12 am not sure what's the right answer as am abit panic at that time. I can't think what's the question already but I rmb my answer is B. How's your?
@nataliejj said: I didn't manage to finish the whole paper...the materiality & performance materiality and deficiencies I didn't finish but I think overall is quite ok..mcq I think only question 12 am not sure what's the right answer as am abit panic at that time. I can't think what's the question already but I rmb my answer is B. How's your?It's was okay in my opinion, I felt rushed in the last question but otherwise I was fine with respect to time, I am sure you will be okay. There were a few parts where I felt there was s few things I was repeating but otherwise it was okay. Are you planning to do another module in June? I am thinking at the moment whether I should do F7?
@amanpreetsaini said: Fernando you are right!. Provision of $2.6 million in litigation case was appropriate and should have been properly disclosed. But the treatment of receivable was not right.It should have been disclosed as contingent asset rather than receivable. Since the board refused to amend the statement so the modified opinion should have been made. I was confused in Qualified or adverse opinion. was the receivable amount pervasive?Was profit before tax not way bigger than 2.6 million though so as it would not be changing profit to loss, it would not be substantial amount and so it would be a qualified opinion.
@samirrules said: It's was okay in my opinion, I felt rushed in the last question but otherwise I was fine with respect to time, I am sure you will be okay. There were a few parts where I felt there was s few things I was repeating but otherwise it was okay. Are you planning to do another module in June? I am thinking at the moment whether I should do F7?Hmm....actually f8 is my last f paper...and am taking p1,4&6 this coming June...hopefully everything is fine...maybe I will defer p1 maybe not.. Still considering..
@nataliejj said: Hmm....actually f8 is my last f paper...and am taking p1,4&6 this coming June...hopefully everything is fine...maybe I will defer p1 maybe not.. Still considering..Wow that is pretty impresive, I feel like I can only do 1 paper every 3 months whilst working full time. Are you working full time as well as that is pretty impressive tbh. Good luck on whatever you decide to do.
@samirrules said: Wow that is pretty impresive, I feel like I can only do 1 paper every 3 months whilst working full time. Are you working full time as well as that is pretty impressive tbh. Good luck on whatever you decide to do.Well am full time student..haha..thank you and good luck to you too^^
was a fair exam, aiming for 80+
wish you all the best
well i think in MCQs the first was B the rest i dont remember and the events were first non-Adjusting Event but it was material and disclosure was to be made and the second was adjusting event so if the directors do not amend the F.S in that case the Report were Modified in both cases and Qualified opinion with Except for had to be given am i right??
What is considered "pervasive" in F8 exam? Becuase OT notes nor BPP Revision KIT provides any specific % which would be considered as the material misstatement being pervasive.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

