Skip to contentSkip to search
Kaplan Publishing: Black Friday countdown

AA*** F8 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***

Oopentuition_teamAdmin10y ago

Please vote in our Instant Polls about the F8 March 2016 Exam.

*** F8 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** F8 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results *** F8 March 2016 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments *** poll results

Post your comments about F8 exam below

DDavid10y ago#31
@gianina said: @David1988 Q6 1. Orders are automatically input ->there is a risk that slow moving inventory might be ordered even if not really needed => hence they should be checked and then authorized 2. Suppliers are chosen automatically but there is no saying about an authorized list, hence they might order from expensive suppliers => increase in expenses. A list should be set up and reviewed regularly & updated. 3. No approval or checking of bank payments 4. Minimum order levels not updated for a long period 5. All PL employees had access to the master data file. The phrasing was confusing though: "access to the master file is restricted to the bla bla"...restricted... that word confused me a bit. 6. Goods not inspected at third party warehouses 7. Can't recall... Got few similar...anybody else recalls their answers?
Goods not inspected at third party was my last 1 I couldn't remember ha - We have very similar answers for this question - reassuring
RRana10y ago#32
yeaaah that phrasing was really weird I'm not sure I understood it right it said it was restricted to all employees? as in accessable to all employees?
GGia10y ago#33
@ Rana Don't recall the Q no. but the one with the fire (1) and inventory(2) i wrote: 1. Is not adjusting, just the inventory part should be written down at lower of cost and NRV 2. Adjusting - inventory should be written down to lower of cost and NRV. It was a material amount -> qualified opinion if not amended... The payable Q: I wrote that for the one with the difference in the reply there must be due to cash in transit or goods in transit(check the bank statement for payments, can't recall anything else :( ) The one that didn't reply send a reminder, ask the client if we can call the supplier. Not material amount compared to the profit before tax...if in total with the rest of uncorrected misstatements turns out to be material -> adjustments need to be done. Do not recalll what examples I gave for the test....
DDavid10y ago#34
@trebleo said: I don't usually like talking about exam answers, but there was one MCQ that I just thought was a trick question, the very first MCQ on the RIGHTS of auditors. I picked A, that the Auditors had the RIGHT to a general meeting only. It was tempting g to pick C, that the auditors had the RIGHT to a general meeting AND give an opinion. But I excluded the auditor giving an opinion as a RIGHT, because this is a DUTY. Just out of interest did anyone else pick A, because there may be a difference between RIGHT and DUTY of auditors?
I picked A also which I was fairly confident on - External auditors have a responsibility to provide an opinion and this is different to a right
TTobi10y ago#35
@david1988 said: I picked A also which I was fairly confident on - External auditors have a responsibility to provide an opinion and this is different to a right
Thanks David. That was a mean trick from the examiner.
GGia10y ago#36
Yeah Rana. I understand your frustration. I spent like 2 minutes trying to figure out what they meant by that, hence i recall even now the paragraph "access to the master file is restricted to all employees of the purchasing department". Then i said what the hell...they must mean that all the PD employees have access and nobody else...was worth a shot as i was running low on finding 7 deficiencies...those guys had some pretty darn good controls set up in place :P
DDavid10y ago#37
@gianina said: @ Rana Don't recall the Q no. but the one with the fire (1) and inventory(2) i wrote: 1. Is not adjusting, just the inventory part should be written down at lower of cost and NRV 2. Adjusting - inventory should be written down to lower of cost and NRV. It was a material amount -> qualified opinion if not amended... The payable Q: I wrote that for the one with the difference in the reply there must be due to cash in transit or goods in transit(check the bank statement for payments, can't recall anything else :( ) The one that didn't reply send a reminder, ask the client if we can call the supplier. Not material amount compared to the profit before tax...if in total with the rest of uncorrected misstatements turns out to be material -> adjustments need to be done. Do not recalll what examples I gave for the test....
I wrote carry out a detailed reconciliation between the supplier statement and the ledger, discuss the difference with management, if this an error at the supplier end no action required, if it was an error at our end we should amend the balance One not received I said at clients permission send another circulisation, potentially call them if required, carry out a reconciliation if this shows any differences.
RRana10y ago#38
oh I think I mentioned something about the fire being a non adjusting event and that it should just be disclosed in the financial statements. I was really confused cause it was material so I didn't know if I should write down the value of assets on the financial statements or not. I don't remember what I did about the inventory but I think I messed it up as well
RRana10y ago#39
I said to do a reconciliation too but didn't say discuss the difference, I think half my answers lacked necessary detail ?
@david1988 said: I wrote carry out a detailed reconciliation between the supplier statement and the ledger, discuss the difference with management, if this an error at the supplier end no action required, if it was an error at our end we should amend the balance One not received I said at clients permission send another circulisation, potentially call them if required, carry out a reconciliation if this shows any differences.
GGia10y ago#40
What was Q 5 about? Anybody recalls? Ohhh...from all the things i lost i miss my mind the most...
DDavid10y ago#41
Anyone else remember any of the other questions - What about the audit risk question. I put: - Repairs and upgrades - capital vs expenses - need to investigate - Sales increase - cut off - Share capital - Need to ensure it is correct in notes to financial statements - New audit client - This brings risk in itself so need experienced staff on audit - Can't remember last one of top of my head
DDavid10y ago#42
@gianina said: What was Q 5 about? Anybody recalls? Ohhh...from all the things i lost i miss my mind the most...
Was this not interim and final audit? Or was that earlier?
GGia10y ago#43
All right David1988. Q5 audit risk I wrote about: 1. New client -> higher the risk...talked about contacting the outgoing auditors, made a big speech about not accepting the job if the client doesn't allow them to contact the ex-auditors. 2. Repairs & upgrades-> FS might be wrong due to misstated expenses and NCA 3. Share @ a premium -> to allocate correctly the equity amounts 4. The client wanted to report high revenues or something like that -> auditor must remain alert and professional skepticism maintained throughout the audit 5. Hope i wrote five as i do not recall anything else...wait...was this the Q with the inventory count? if so, i think i mentioned something about the audit firm not being able to attend to all the 23 of the warehouses inventory count... Anybody got anything else?
DDavid10y ago#44
@gianina said: All right David1988. Q5 audit risk I wrote about: 1. New client -> higher the risk...talked about contacting the outgoing auditors, made a big speech about not accepting the job if the client doesn't allow them to contact the ex-auditors. 2. Repairs & upgrades-> FS might be wrong due to misstated expenses and NCA 3. Share @ a premium -> to allocate correctly the equity amounts 4. The client wanted to report high revenues or something like that -> auditor must remain alert and professional skepticism maintained throughout the audit 5. Hope i wrote five as i do not recall anything else... Anybody got anything else?
We pretty much have the same 4 answers - I never mentioned about accepting the audit as I assumed this audit had already been accepted - I defo put 5 but I am struggling with remembering the last one haha
Former userFormer user10y ago#45
Question 6 deficiences in purchase system – poor supplier affecting orders – Did not use this one – no approval of bank payments - Suggested segregation of duties to the clerk who input these and were then automatically approved. So kind of suggested the same as you, but not exactly. – minimum order levels not updated for 12 months - Noted the the orders were made 'below minimum order level, so suggested that it was re-assessed and implemented. – all PL staff had access to master file – errors could be made - Didn't spot this – automatic POs generated and not inspected for accuracy - Agree, suggested that orders were checked prior to leaving – directors authorise everything over $200 which seemed unreasonable - Agree, suggested the managers limit was increased as barely anything would be authorised by him and the director could then approve big impact items. Gia's answer of 'Goods not inspected at third party warehouses' - I Insisted that they were Recall that there was something about stock takes also :-/
GGia10y ago#46
@David1988 The interim audit...ahhh...the interim audit...who paid attention to the interim audit part? Not me... The interim audit Q was earlier. i think it was a 10 marker...but i might be terribly wrong. I probably made a fool out of myself but i gave my best shot with answering this Q: 1. Procedures: *observe/assess the client's controls *observe the employees during daily work *other bla bla like discussions with the management 2. How it helps with the final audit: *auditors can focus more on the high risk areas *they can test less data as the interim audit evidence is appropriate enough *again some other nonsense probably but i can't recall it....
RRana10y ago#47
lol i know I'm glad I wasn't the only one but I should've used some common sense there bc how could a system be inaccessible to ALL employees right? ? aw well I hope I pass that question! haha for real they had some great controls I was like well what deficiencies, examiner? ugh I really hope I pass =[
@gianina said: Yeah Rana. I understand your frustration. I spent like 2 minutes trying to figure out what they meant by that, hence i recall even now the paragraph "access to the master file is restricted to all employees of the purchasing department". Then i said what the hell...they must mean that all the PD employees have access and nobody else...was worth a shot as i was running low on finding 7 deficiencies...those guys had some pretty darn good controls set up in place :P
Former userFormer user10y ago#48
Anyone else remember any of the other questions – What about the audit risk question. I put: – Repairs and upgrades – capital vs expenses – need to investigate - Totally agree – Sales increase – cut off - I noted that the director's were keen to increase sales, so mentioned that they may be trying to achieve a bonus, so we should scrutinise the sales in March/April as a result of the jump. Should check that fictious sales were not created by tracing PO to GDN to invoice and also check for credit notes in the next year that effectively wipe these receipts off the books – Share capital – Need to ensure it is correct in notes to financial statements - Wrote the same (allocation), but felt uncomfortable with my knowledge here, particularly as it was the same as revenue/capital – New audit client – This brings risk in itself so need experienced staff on audit - EEK, missed they were new – Can’t remember last one of top of my head
DDavid10y ago#49
@gianina said: @David1988 The interim audit...ahhh...the interim audit...who paid attention to the interim audit part? Not me... The interim audit Q was earlier. i think it was a 10 marker...but i might be terribly wrong. I probably made a fool out of myself but i gave my best shot with answering this Q: 1. Procedures: *observe/assess the client's controls *observe the employees during daily work *other bla bla like discussions with the management 2. How it helps with the final audit: *auditors can focus more on the high risk areas *they can test less data as the interim audit evidence is appropriate enough *again some other nonsense probably but i can't recall it....
I said firstly the interim audit covers the first half of the year and assists with reducing the workload at the final audit. Procedures as follows: - Controls testing to ensure working effective - Document controls systems which can be used at final audit - Substantive testing on first half of the year can be done Effect on final audit part - If controls testing is showing effective controls then can be reduced providing system does not change - Substantive testing can focus more on the 2nd part of the year as first half done at interim - Only need further testing if significant errors or frauds were found at interim
GGia10y ago#50
@ccoda and everybody else Wasn't there supposed to be an inventory count somewhere? 23 warehouses....was it this with the audit risk? Cuz i remember writing something about this but don't know to which one...
Cclaudeverson10y ago#51
My MCQ answer: ADACDCDABDAB
GGia10y ago#52
Spot on David regarding the interim audit! So if i get like 2 marks that would be great!
DDavid10y ago#53
@gianina said: @ccoda and everybody else Wasn't there supposed to be an inventory count somewhere? 23 warehouses....was it this with the audit risk? Cuz i remember writing something about this but don't know to which one...
Yes that was my final audit risk. Thanks, that was annoying me ha. Third party were sending stock reports direct to head office - Said risk of undertstatement or overtstatement in stock and subsequently the balance sheet - I said attend the count, ensure instructions are given and followed and perform test counts
DDavid10y ago#54
@claudeverson said: My MCQ answer: ADACDCDABDAB
I got ADCCCCDBBDAD so a few different Anyone else remember their MCQs?
GGia10y ago#55
@david1988 said: Yes that was my final audit risk. Thanks, that was annoying me ha. Third party were sending stock reports direct to head office - Said risk of undertstatement or overtstatement in stock and subsequently the balance sheet - I said attend the count, ensure instructions are given and followed and perform test counts
I said they can't attend all the warehouses counts -> should have put risk of not gaining sufficient appropriate evidence but instead wrote inventory might be misstated significantly...o man....., they should sample the count, discuss with management to see which ones were with errors or mistakes in last years, and attend counts to the ones with material amounts, the ones with high risk of misstatements and held at third parties....
GGia10y ago#56
@david1988 said: I got ADCCCCDBBDAD so a few different Anyone else remember their MCQs?
Don't recall them at all...just remember seeing a lot of Cs one after another in some portion and was like...this can't be correct, then i was like...kehh..whateva...
Nnati198110y ago#57
the question was: if the fs should be amended because the manager disclosed and included the contingent receivable in the fs,and how will affect the audit report if he refuses to amend the receivables. so the effect on the report will be modified if he disagree to amend the fs, with a qualified opinion. if he agrees to the auditor to do amendments than an unmodified report will be issued. This is my opinion based on my understanding
DDavid10y ago#58
@nati1981 said: the question was: if the fs should be amended because the manager disclosed and included the contingent receivable in the fs,and how will affect the audit report if he refuses to amend the receivables. so the effect on the report will be modified if he disagree to amend the fs, with a qualified opinion. if he agrees to the auditor to do amendments than an unmodified report will be issued. This is my opinion based on my understanding
Yes you are right about it being qualified - It said in the question what would the opinion be if he does not agree to adjust the disclosure I am sure so only need to talk about the qualified part.
Nnati198110y ago#59
no, it said all the purchase staff had restriction on the master file
RRana10y ago#60
so they couldn't access it?
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.