AA*** F8 June 2014 Exam was.. Instant Poll and comments ***
You are right, Mo. I was taking F5 also. That was harder.
sorry think u are making a mistake Question 2 didn't have anything to do with audit risks,it asked about Vale for money audits and sampling
I am releived to have finished this paper. My fingers are crossed. Time management was my biggest issue.
I will pass it... help me lord!!! :-D
i like reading thru these comments, they always give me a smile things like the examiner's gift to us ..lol..
all in all i think this paper was fair and i really expect to pass. got in exam room late just before they started writing so didnt have reading time, but as soon as i saw qn 1 about payroll i started smiling. thanks Open tuition for your tips, they helped me much.
i managed to attempt all questions apart from qn 5 (a) which i think was 4 marks.
am sure its a pass for me, and hope you guys all pass.
crazy exam in my opinion!
time contraints were a big issue but the corporate governance question was a blessing!!
lets hope for the best and a big THANK YOU to mr GROMIT for improving my concepts regarding going concern and hope that will be enough!
@rositca "I write that if the assumption is appropriate-modified opinion with emphasis of matter paragraph after the opinion paragraph"
This is not correct. If the auditor agrees that company is a going concern, then an unmodified opinion is given with an emphasis of matter paragraph.
Let's just hope that F9 is as good as this or even better. I hope that the theory is just good. Very scared about F9
1) Was about a hotel and how employees record overtime worked. The question asked you to identify audit risks, name tests of control and substantive tests. Substantive tests for tax.
2a) define the 3 Es (value for money audit)
2b or 2c) sampling: explain the need and what it is
3) Company selling 24 month contracts. Are receivables overstated? Identify risks and recommendations.
4) Corporate overnance issues: identify issues and make recommendations (appointing close friend, remuneration determined by finance director, no board training, no audit committee).
5) Company with lots of going concern issues. Identify issues (major competitor, loss of employees, supplier difficulties, cashflow issues, litigation), procedures to look for going concern issues, etc State impact on audit opinion when auditor agrees with going concern but there's material uncertainty (unmodifed opinion but emphasis of matter paragraph).
Can't finished my paper done 60% had write extra for Q1 which leads to lack of time at the end.
Know each and everything asked But can't perform well. Is it possible that i can Get 50 out of 60.. ? Seems impossible to me :(
Somewhere there was a company using a continuous inventory count. Some questions related to that, including tests.
My life (as an international student in UK with student visa) literally depends on this paper for the time being and I didn't do well. :(
Time management was a struggle to me. No time to pause and think and plan the answers.
Ok I totally read the going concern question wrong sh*t!!!!! I understood it as what are the six possible indicators that company is not a going concern to be that the company will survive..I took it as a double negative so!!! Oooops.....how many marks was that worth? And what are the 3 es for the value for money audit...I didnt know that either!! Best of luck to the F9'ers tomorrow lets pray it was as good as this paper was!!!
It was an ok exam. I had time issue also didnt answer a few questions. I hope what i did will allow me a pass.
@tbm13 i think if i remember well, the auditors believed it was a going concern but with material uncertainity. my understanding was that the issue at hand was material enough so i thought it was best to modify the report but i may be wrong.
somehow i think it was meant to be an emphasis of matter.
just read some references and it was meant to be an emphasis of matter para. how many marks was that part again??
Damaged good are audit risk as they mean that valuation of inventory is overstated.
6 indicators not going corncern (not surviving) like loss of major customer, staffs etc, that's 6 marks.
Part (d) emphasis of matter (directors agree to put disclosure on going corner) that's 3 marks
@flyshine, am sure i got the indicators, atleast am only loosing 3 marks, posibly will get 1.5 marks for some wording lol
Q5 If the mater of going concern was disclosed appropriately - unmodified opinion with emphasis of mater, if not disclosed appropriately - qualified opinion
Did someone also write audit risk relating to recording of the revenue- the contracts were for 24 months- so the revenue potentially should be divided over the period- or I tollay misunderstood something?
3 Es (value for money): economy, efficiency, effectiveness.
I would like to thank you guys, the open tuition team, for the free lectures and the educated guess exam tips. I used Kaplan as well, but your material simply makes much more sense and is so much easier to digest for me. Cheers lads and best regards from Zagreb.
Ave: yes, I think wrong revenue recognition is a risk in this case.
Thank you :)
Did anyone highlight the employees wages being adjusted each year because of inflation as an issue? Can't remember what the exact question was. Also with Audit risks the the inventory overstatement the 2 week in transit, could you argue cut off not being accurate? With the overtime control weakness did everyone just say gets managers approval for overtime so no unauthorised wGes will be paid etc. think they only issues I could think about my paper. Got all finished bar 5a the substantive test in inventory.
paper goes well as 7 extra Minutes was given due to energy failure ... and i did not stop mean while also.. so 14 minutes to complete last 7 marks.. helped by God Indeed !! ... Yahoooooo !!! ... :D
Hope to pass this time, as i won't be comfortable for resitting the f8 paper for dec 2014 (or onwards) as it will have a different format and structure than all previous papers.
I think it was a fair paper. All topics were topics I studied for but as usual time mgmt was a factor. I know I handled q4-corporate governance fairly well, but you never know with ACCA examiners where F8 is concerned. Hope to pass of course. Wish everyone the best of luck!
This was an ok exam. Too much information to write in 3 hours. I attempted all questions I hope what I wrote was enough to give me a pass this time. Last time I thought I would definitely pass and I only got 40%. I am keeping my fingers cross this time around. I am positive tho.
Topic lockedNew replies are closed.

